Re: Harry Stephen Keeler [DAY 10]
Posted: Thu Apr 16, 2015 9:06 pm
Voted DF also.
Murder, Mayhem, and Mafia
https://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/
Black Rock wrote:I got nothing from the Elo lynch and that's the truth. You are assuming a lot here Dom, just to paint me bad. I am telling you the truth, you just don't care.Dom wrote:Elohcin
10
rabbit8 (7), Dom (9), Long Con (10), Elohcin (11), juliets (12), Black Rock (13), Bullzeye (14), S~V~S (15), Bass_the_Clever (16), birdwithteeth11 (17)
You are #5 of Elo voters-- excluding Elo.
Eloh had up to 6 items.
birdwithteeth11
5
Black Rock (12), Bass_the_Clever (13), juliets (14), Turnip Head (15), rabbit8 (16)
You were the 1st BWT voter.
I doubt you only have one item.
How are you feeling about BR?juliets wrote:I'm in agreement with the Faraday votes and will join them. He has to be bad or something is off on my spreadsheet (and I don't think anything is).
Confirmed.DFaraday wrote:*Sigh*
Since the only people left to vote are one of my suspects, someone who is MIA, and someone who can't be counted on to vote any particular way, I'm clearly not going to be able to tie this up. I'll just go with Bass, because why not.
*Votes Bass*
What would you rather have me do, Dom? The only way I can tie this is if BR, Canuck, and Vomp all vote the same way as me, which wouldn't happen if I voted for any of them. That's if they all even turn up to vote.Dom wrote:Confirmed.DFaraday wrote:*Sigh*
Since the only people left to vote are one of my suspects, someone who is MIA, and someone who can't be counted on to vote any particular way, I'm clearly not going to be able to tie this up. I'll just go with Bass, because why not.
*Votes Bass*
I believe her that she only has 1 item. I think it's very probable that she didn't get something from the Eloh lynch. Do we know how the items are doled out? Like is it first as stolen to last stolen? Or best to worst? Maybe llama will answer this. It adds to my belief if it is best to worst as I got something basically worthless which would make it not hard to believe she got nothing.Dom wrote:How are you feeling about BR?juliets wrote:I'm in agreement with the Faraday votes and will join them. He has to be bad or something is off on my spreadsheet (and I don't think anything is).
Juuliets, then who has the items if BR does not?juliets wrote:I believe her that she only has 1 item. I think it's very probable that she didn't get something from the Eloh lynch. Do we know how the items are doled out? Like is it first as stolen to last stolen? Or best to worst? Maybe llama will answer this. It adds to my belief if it is best to worst as I got something basically worthless which would make it not hard to believe she got nothing.Dom wrote:How are you feeling about BR?juliets wrote:I'm in agreement with the Faraday votes and will join them. He has to be bad or something is off on my spreadsheet (and I don't think anything is).
I've thought a lot about the Bullz info and I think she got bad info. If she were bad she could have said f*** it, i think the info is wrong and jumped on the Bullz vote. But she didn't - she continued to believe the info and voted accordingly.
I just don't see her as bad.
llama: when doling out items to people who lynch a suspect, do you dole them out in the order they came to that person or do you judge the quality and dole them out best to worst?
They are distributed via a system known only to myself and certain trusted confidants, who shall remain unnamed for security purposes.juliets wrote: llama: when doling out items to people who lynch a suspect, do you dole them out in the order they came to that person or do you judge the quality and dole them out best to worst?
Thank you, Vomp. I kind of hope Vomp wins, he's the only one of you all who's making sense this game.Vompatti wrote:I'm voting for Bass k
I don't know Dom.Dom wrote:Juuliets, then who has the items if BR does not?juliets wrote:I believe her that she only has 1 item. I think it's very probable that she didn't get something from the Eloh lynch. Do we know how the items are doled out? Like is it first as stolen to last stolen? Or best to worst? Maybe llama will answer this. It adds to my belief if it is best to worst as I got something basically worthless which would make it not hard to believe she got nothing.Dom wrote:How are you feeling about BR?juliets wrote:I'm in agreement with the Faraday votes and will join them. He has to be bad or something is off on my spreadsheet (and I don't think anything is).
I've thought a lot about the Bullz info and I think she got bad info. If she were bad she could have said f*** it, i think the info is wrong and jumped on the Bullz vote. But she didn't - she continued to believe the info and voted accordingly.
I just don't see her as bad.
llama: when doling out items to people who lynch a suspect, do you dole them out in the order they came to that person or do you judge the quality and dole them out best to worst?
Do you think baddies or civvies are more likely to have a plethora of items?juliets wrote:I don't know Dom.Dom wrote:Juuliets, then who has the items if BR does not?juliets wrote:I believe her that she only has 1 item. I think it's very probable that she didn't get something from the Eloh lynch. Do we know how the items are doled out? Like is it first as stolen to last stolen? Or best to worst? Maybe llama will answer this. It adds to my belief if it is best to worst as I got something basically worthless which would make it not hard to believe she got nothing.Dom wrote:How are you feeling about BR?juliets wrote:I'm in agreement with the Faraday votes and will join them. He has to be bad or something is off on my spreadsheet (and I don't think anything is).
I've thought a lot about the Bullz info and I think she got bad info. If she were bad she could have said f*** it, i think the info is wrong and jumped on the Bullz vote. But she didn't - she continued to believe the info and voted accordingly.
I just don't see her as bad.
llama: when doling out items to people who lynch a suspect, do you dole them out in the order they came to that person or do you judge the quality and dole them out best to worst?
So voting a civ this game makes sense?DFaraday wrote:Thank you, Vomp. I kind of hope Vomp wins, he's the only one of you all who's making sense this game.Vompatti wrote:I'm voting for Bass k
That I don't know either though I don't have someone penciled in for one of the stealer roles on the civ side and then of course there are two missing baddies. I could have the roles penciled in wrong in which case I would say a baddie has them.Dom wrote:Do you think baddies or civvies are more likely to have a plethora of items?juliets wrote:I don't know Dom.Dom wrote:Juuliets, then who has the items if BR does not?juliets wrote:I believe her that she only has 1 item. I think it's very probable that she didn't get something from the Eloh lynch. Do we know how the items are doled out? Like is it first as stolen to last stolen? Or best to worst? Maybe llama will answer this. It adds to my belief if it is best to worst as I got something basically worthless which would make it not hard to believe she got nothing.Dom wrote:How are you feeling about BR?juliets wrote:I'm in agreement with the Faraday votes and will join them. He has to be bad or something is off on my spreadsheet (and I don't think anything is).
I've thought a lot about the Bullz info and I think she got bad info. If she were bad she could have said f*** it, i think the info is wrong and jumped on the Bullz vote. But she didn't - she continued to believe the info and voted accordingly.
I just don't see her as bad.
llama: when doling out items to people who lynch a suspect, do you dole them out in the order they came to that person or do you judge the quality and dole them out best to worst?
He would be the one with the items yes, unless the stealers have been steadily stealing from him. I need to think about this because I can see Dom's point but also see the points about Vomps. I agree though we should talk about it before we do anything. Thinking though we shouldn't talk tonight about it but game day tomorrow after the NK has passed. I'm paranoid this late in the game.S~V~S wrote:And then there was one
And it's the Millionaire. So that means we should talk about it before we vote if at all possible. Dom seems pretty sure on BR~ his reason seems related to items. The Millionaire has been doing the killing, so would be the one with the items. Coincidence?
Both Bullz & DF did the wide eyed, "Who Vomps? But Epi voted him to tie" deal. Unless that was an advance misdirection. It is something I have done myself in games, so it is a possibility. But the last time I recall Vomps blatantly saying stuff like, "RIP *insertdeadbaddienamehere* " was when he was bad. Or having linear conversations on topic. So I am confuzzled about what to do tomorrow.
Ok, I see your point. I just cant talk about it right now. i have to make dinner.S~V~S wrote:I am thinking we SHOULD talk about it in the night. So ideas don't die with anyone. Someone is gonna die tonight, but if we talk it out before that, it won't have been in vain. Maybe it will be me, I will be OK with that. There is only one baddie left, the civs can pull it out of the bag.
But we need to be on top of it.
I agree.DFaraday wrote:Thank you, Vomp. I kind of hope Vomp wins, he's the only one of you all who's making sense this game.Vompatti wrote:I'm voting for Bass k
I was confused, thinking the lynch was today. Doing too many things at once. We have plenty of time for BR to come into the thread.S~V~S wrote:Night is 2 more hours, then we have day. Not make it in what way?
I think I made that obvious.Dom wrote:I want to know what item BR says she has.
Black Rock wrote:S~V~S wrote:Black Rock appears to be vouching for you.
Vouching is the wrong word. I received an item from a recent lynch. It allows me to get some BTSC conversation. In this conversation it seems two baddies are talking about pushing the lynch towards Bullz. They seemed joyous about it. Unless I'm being tricked it makes me think Bullz is not a baddie.