Case against Novaselinever
In this
Essay case i will go through all 16 of novas' current posts are identify why he's bad.
I've broken up posts by times posted. Theyre all grouped in that they were made within a short time of eachother if theyre within the lines.
------------------------------------------------------
Post 1: Day 0 fluff, does not participate in Day 0 discussion. Already setting a pattern of being absent and not interacting. Everyone waved this off in Megaman, but in reality Novas still read the thread and laid low until I (one of the only players to suspect them) had died. And SUDDENLY he appeared to have "returned."
--------------------------------------------------------
Post 2:
novaselinenever wrote: ↑Fri Oct 19, 2018 1:38 pm
Elohcin wrote: ↑Fri Oct 19, 2018 9:57 am
Lunalee wrote: ↑Fri Oct 19, 2018 8:42 am
[VOTE:
MacDougall] aubergine
because he hasn't shown up yet, so why not?
And what if he ia civ? That's a stupid reason to vote him so soon. Give the guy a chance and go after someone you think is bad. Unless you are bad and are just trying to get rid of people you think could be civ. Maybe that's it
It's just a vote though, and the only one on him.
Over-reacting much?
Here he downplays Eloh's question to lunalee. Paints her in a bad light. No offering of a better opinion or solution. There was no reason to bring up the concept of it just being one vote. That didnt relate to what Eloh was saying at all. How I interpretted what eloh said was "that's a bad reason to vote him (and so soon into the day)" and that lunalee "should do some actual hunting."
So what novas did was not constructive, it served no purpose really other than to put out words into the thread and paint someone else who he probably feels is an easy target, as bad.
Post 3: no content
Post 4:
novaselinenever wrote: ↑Fri Oct 19, 2018 1:43 pm
sprityo wrote: ↑Fri Oct 19, 2018 12:16 pm
My poor unfortunate soul voted for none other than the Head of Turnips
As an aside for mechanics involving the flamethrower, If there is a tie in the lynch poll i choose one of the people tied
or i just burn whoever i want.
I really need you guys to sell me on some lynches here
How about you sell us on some lynches?
If you're intending on using the flamethrower in a democratic way (following the lynch poll), then this game shouldn't be any different of any other game where you would be trying to get the person you believe is bad lynched.
I had replied to this already but let me re-address it now. Novas asks me to give a reason to lynch someone else. Which is not how that works as DH is currently doing in a more practical sense. Our job as the people not with the flamethrower is to SELL THE EXECUTIONER on who to lynch. If we dont do that, then they can just do whatever they want. Now as DDL and TH have both pointed out, that isnt an excuse to have said executioner avoid discussion altogether. (my bad, oh well, go cry about it). The underlined is false because I never intended to use it democratically and didnt say as such. To wrap it up, this is lazy prompting without actually doing work themselves.
( I had my ultimatum laid out for everyone to see. And I was going to be judge jury and executioner in line with those rules. I want to state again, if im campaigning for someone to be lynched, why would i need to say it when I would be the one to just kill them anyways? This is why i left my choice in the lynch up to participation and numbers. )
Post 5: Votes Elohcin with no justification.
Post 6: Says "DH is good" with no justification.
------------------------------------------------
Post 7: Eloh asks Novas why he voted her (I would too because he didnt give a reason). To which Novas responds "I quoted something else from you earlier in a separate post that you have to go find and then figure out yourself what I'm thinking" essentially. He's referring to Post 2. Which boils down to he thinks Eloh is" Overreacting" to Lunalee's vote. There was nothing over-reacting about Eloh's post and it was just a lazy vote so that he would be safe from being burned. Lazy playing, no reasoning, expecting others to do the work for him. This guy is bad.
Post 8: Disagrees with TH suggesting Luna vs Eloh is town v town with a dismissive "nah." again nothing to back it up, just a straight up no. There is no reasoning behind most anything this guy says and it's all negative talk.
-----------------------------------------------
Post 9: asks for the flamethrower, disappears again
-----------------------------------------
Post 10: Answers my question of "who was vote #4 for me on Day 0" with "I voted you because of" The townslip theory DH put out at the very beginning of the day. Again, not his own idea but doesnt even reference DH as the one who originally said it. Trying to make it sound like he did work, when none was done. The vote for me however would appear true. [this sentence has been redacted for later use]
--------------------------------------
Post 11:
novaselinenever wrote: ↑Sat Oct 20, 2018 9:54 pm
Calling dibs on casing Elohcin.
Post 12:
more tunneling eloh because????????????? No one else shares this tunnel vision this guy has. I seriously hope his whole suspicion isn't built off of what he perceives as "overreacting." That would be Yikes.
Post 13:
Post 14:
novaselinenever wrote: ↑Sat Oct 20, 2018 9:57 pm
This is nice and all, but what if someone came in late and every one he suspects as already been cased? That's not cool.
"This is nice, but here's how it's not" AKA More shade throwing. The whole point of the exercise is obvious, be active, make a case, and make it good. If you dont read the thread, then it sucks for you. Again, nothing this guy has said has been positive, only dismissal
Post 15: Asks DH if DH is participating. The purpose of the whole exercise is to build a case, i'm bring up what i put earlier, there's no point in the executioner to build a case when they can just kill they person they suspect most anyways. THE EXERCISE IS FOR SELLING A LYNCH TO THEM.
Post 16:
novaselinenever wrote: ↑Sat Oct 20, 2018 10:06 pm
Hmm all right that's cool. I guess I'm one of the lucky ones. Already placed my vote, I'll substantiate later when I come back.
No back talk finally? impressive. "i guess i'm lucky" being that he placed his vote on someone he thinks will be an easy case and disappears yet again. Who knows if he'll actually make a case since someone who doesnt even make a case will have priority over him to be lynched. Unless im mistaken in this?[mention]DharmaHelper[/mention]
DharmaHelper wrote: ↑Sat Oct 20, 2018 10:31 pm
Anyway herein is the ranking for how I'll decide who to torch
- If someone presents a very compelling case against someone else
- If someone refuses to participate in the exercise
- If someone refuses to participate in the game.
-----------------------------------------
Nova is coasting through the game with no effort put forth and should be criticized for that. Nothing he has done has benefited anyone, He doesnt have a solid suspicion and literally just threw out a random town read. If he doesnt start actively trying to help the town, and stop being so negative. I can only assume he's mafia and dragging down the town morale. Sound familiar to anyone? Check MegaMan Mafia under user: DharmaHelper and user: novaselinever
Like always I'm open to discussion, replies, etc. In this instance it will only prove to strengthen my case, so bring it on.