Re: Re: Occultism Mafia - Day 4
Posted: Wed Jul 16, 2014 7:23 pm
Also, I'm still missing six votes with 20 minutes to go. Come on, guys.
I agree with SVS, BWT has been super blendy to me this whole game. He fits the profile of an inactive baddie, and neither him nor Keterman has even voted this game. 10 minutes to go, not sold on Nutella, going to go with BWT.S~V~S wrote:These are my question marks (I feel pretty good about everyone else):
BWT
Dom
Eloh
Hedge
MM
Nutella
Vomps
Of those, leaning civ:
Eloh
Hedge
That leaves:
BWT: As blendy as the person he replaced
Dom: Comes back from being sick; Boogs dies. This would be a nice set up as well, though.
MM: Not loving the drive by
Nutella: No clue; but I really hate MMs vote
Vomps: Love the participation, but the game related content kinda blendy
I am leaning towards MM or BWT most
Did he do some not-very-nice things?thellama73 wrote:Oh, and since it's annoying when hosts are too cryptic about these sorts of things, I will go ahead and tell you that yes, you have to kill Abramelin. Someone like that just can't be allowed to live.
Let's just say that power corrupts.birdwithteeth11 wrote:Did he do some not-very-nice things?thellama73 wrote:Oh, and since it's annoying when hosts are too cryptic about these sorts of things, I will go ahead and tell you that yes, you have to kill Abramelin. Someone like that just can't be allowed to live.
So, can we assume his "operation" has been completed? My first guess is that he had something to do with our old pal Chronozon rising from where ever it is that things rise from. Can we assume that Abramelin's "operation" summoned Chronozon?Abramelin the Mage - Author of one of the most powerful and rigorous works of Western Magic, detailing an intense operation to commune with one's Holy Guardian Angel and learn great magical secrets. Takes a few days to complete his operation, but if he makes it he becomes super powerful. *secrets*
Okay, Chrono was pleased after Nutella was lynched, and subsequently the whole baddie team being destroyed. I'd guess that this wasn't a coincidence. If Chrono is connected to Abramelin, maybe he had to eliminate the baddie team first before he could gain powers, and really become a threat to the civvies.thellama73 wrote:
Chronozon, with a satisfied smirk, has receded into the realm from whence he came.
I'm sorry for not explaining before. It was just a strong hunch. I hope don't think too badly of it now.nijuukyugou wrote:What I am suspicious of is MM's vote for nutella with no explanation, and I've been suspicious of replacements since they well, replaced the inactive players. That is where my vote is going today.
The mafia has been eliminated. You're just after the indie now.Metalmarsh89 wrote: llama, if the mafia is eliminated, will it be declared in the game thread?
I dunno. I mean, I guess it's possible. I know Crowley's role didn't mention any powers specifically, but that Chornozon (or however it's spelled) wasn't mentioned in any of the roles. So I guess by that theory, there could be other baddie secrets we aren't aware of. I just don't think it's likely that someone gets recruited by Day 4. Usually, recruitments take a bit longer than that from what I've seen in games.Elohcin wrote:Bye NutellaThanks for counting my vote Llama!
After I get the kids to bed I am going to do some rereading of the roles as well as players posts. Does anyone think Abramelin could have been recruited to the baddie team? If so, my distancing comment could still be relevant.
I dunno if I agree. There are so many civvie players, I have a hard time seeing Abramelin aligned with them, even at the beginning.insertnamehere wrote:I really don't know who to look at. I'd assume that Abramelin was civvie-neutral before he had his little "operation", and possibly had to get the baddies out in order to make himself stronger.
I can see it INH's way. It still makes for a balanced game IMO even if Abram needed to get the baddies out to gain his power. However, I wouldn't call it civvie-neutral. I would call it a last-man-standing role. He needs everyone gone to win but only gains his powers once the baddies are gone. If we weren't so good at getting the baddies this quickly, it would have taken him longer to gain his powers or we may have even lynched him before he was able to gain his powers.Metalmarsh89 wrote:I dunno if I agree. There are so many civvie players, I have a hard time seeing Abramelin aligned with them, even at the beginning.insertnamehere wrote:I really don't know who to look at. I'd assume that Abramelin was civvie-neutral before he had his little "operation", and possibly had to get the baddies out in order to make himself stronger.
Linki: thanks llama.
Metalmarsh89 wrote:I'm sorry for not explaining before. It was just a strong hunch. I hope don't think too badly of it now.nijuukyugou wrote:What I am suspicious of is MM's vote for nutella with no explanation, and I've been suspicious of replacements since they well, replaced the inactive players. That is where my vote is going today.
No.S~V~S wrote:
I certainly did say that, then she became involved. And with only one baddie left, I felt what Mongoose was saying had some merit.
You find that people changing their minds makes them bad?
Didn't we try this with Epig?S~V~S wrote:I just searched MMs posts for "Nutella" and there were only 2 mentions, both today. After this post, the nutella vote surprised me.
The other post was the vote where he voted for her.Metalmarsh89 wrote:There's only one mafia left. Who is nutella distancing from? As far as I know, distancing is something that baddies teammates do.Elohcin wrote:As for who I am voting for today, it is between Mongoose and Nutella. I have explained my suspicions of them both and Nutella's most recent post seems like distancing to me.
Niju, what do you think of Mongoose? You had said before the MP lynch that his case on her seemed sound and then you voted MP. What was your reasoning there?
I just want to fill everyone in on my condition:S~V~S wrote: BWT: As blendy as the person he replaced
Dom: Comes back from being sick; Boogs dies. This would be a nice set up as well, though.
MM: Not loving the drive by
Nutella: No clue; but I really hate MMs vote
Vomps: Love the participation, but the game related content kinda blendy
I am leaning towards MM or BWT most
Sherry, do you think there's a reason Mr. Name wants to be your bff this game?S~V~S wrote:Yeah, I concur. Doing the same.
and we are agreeing too much, lol. The sky is gonna fall down or something :lol:
Who is "us"?birdwithteeth11 wrote:Well, you're welcome. You can thank us later. :P BIH Nutella!
So given that the game isn't over yet, my guess is that we still have other roles we need dead to finish the game. Abramelin is the only person I see with secrets, so my first guess would be that it's him. Anybody agree or disagree there?
Linki: It's okay. You're forgiven, since we know you're not evil. :P
Should we tell Dom that there's only one "baddie" left, or just let him continue to think that there are teammates? It's kind of funny.Dom wrote:Sherry, do you think there's a reason Mr. Name wants to be your bff this game?S~V~S wrote:Yeah, I concur. Doing the same.
and we are agreeing too much, lol. The sky is gonna fall down or something :lol:Who is "us"?birdwithteeth11 wrote:Well, you're welcome. You can thank us later. :P BIH Nutella!
So given that the game isn't over yet, my guess is that we still have other roles we need dead to finish the game. Abramelin is the only person I see with secrets, so my first guess would be that it's him. Anybody agree or disagree there?
Linki: It's okay. You're forgiven, since we know you're not evil. :P
So sorry for missing the vote this evening. I probably would have voted MM again though, so ya'll did better without me.insertnamehere wrote:BIH Nutella!
Let's get down to it, we're now looking for a rogue indie type character.
So, can we assume his "operation" has been completed? My first guess is that he had something to do with our old pal Chronozon rising from where ever it is that things rise from. Can we assume that Abramelin's "operation" summoned Chronozon?Abramelin the Mage - Author of one of the most powerful and rigorous works of Western Magic, detailing an intense operation to commune with one's Holy Guardian Angel and learn great magical secrets. Takes a few days to complete his operation, but if he makes it he becomes super powerful. *secrets*
Okay, Chrono was pleased after Nutella was lynched, and subsequently the whole baddie team being destroyed. I'd guess that this wasn't a coincidence. If Chrono is connected to Abramelin, maybe he had to eliminate the baddie team first before he could gain powers, and really become a threat to the civvies.thellama73 wrote:
Chronozon, with a satisfied smirk, has receded into the realm from whence he came.
Or, alternatively, he was offered a choice to either join the civvies or the baddies once he completed his "operation". I don't see Abe joining the baddies willingly, though. (No offense to AP or Nutella.) I doubt that he has been recruited.
I really don't know who to look at. I'd assume that Abramelin was civvie-neutral before he had his little "operation", and possibly had to get the baddies out in order to make himself stronger.
This means that looking for people not wanting to catch baddies could end up being fruitless. As far as we know, he's a lone wolf, so no looking for connections either.
We're going to have start back at square one for this.
As to Abramelin, I agree that he's likely a lone wolf and a review is in order.Mafia:
Team Power: Each night, they can attempt to evoke a demon to do their bidding.
Mongoose wrote:I am not faking
I wish that you were baking
Cakes and pies for me
Two problems with that, if they can summon a demon every night, then why haven't we seen a little message each day saying "Joan Rivers has risen from the depths of hell to haunt you all!" or something similar to that.Hedgeowl wrote:
As to Chronozon, I am pretty sure he was summoned by the baddie team. See below.
As to Abramelin, I agree that he's likely a lone wolf and a review is in order.Mafia:
Team Power: Each night, they can attempt to evoke a demon to do their bidding.
Ha ha haDom wrote:No.S~V~S wrote:
I certainly did say that, then she became involved. And with only one baddie left, I felt what Mongoose was saying had some merit.
You find that people changing their minds makes them bad?
Given the results, of the lynch, I think that I was wrong though.
Glad you are doing better, hopefully totally back to normal soon.Dom wrote:
I just want to fill everyone in on my condition:
I am feeling better. I am on some pretty heavy medication, and it's screwing with me a bit. I have a few more days of it, and if my ears are not back to normal, I have to go back and hope for the best. :/
I do.Dom wrote:Sherry, do you think there's a reason Mr. Name wants to be your bff this game?
Thank you for your well wishesS~V~S wrote:I do.Dom wrote:Sherry, do you think there's a reason Mr. Name wants to be your bff this game?
Should I explain to you why I post every word I post or should I post things and let the response to influence my thinking? Should I explain to you why you don't need a comma after the word "left" or should I let you use punctuation incorrectly?insertnamehere wrote:Should we tell Dom that there's only one "baddie" left, or just let him continue to think that there are teammates? It's kind of funny.Dom wrote:Sherry, do you think there's a reason Mr. Name wants to be your bff this game?S~V~S wrote:Yeah, I concur. Doing the same.
and we are agreeing too much, lol. The sky is gonna fall down or something :lol:Who is "us"?birdwithteeth11 wrote:Well, you're welcome. You can thank us later. :P BIH Nutella!
So given that the game isn't over yet, my guess is that we still have other roles we need dead to finish the game. Abramelin is the only person I see with secrets, so my first guess would be that it's him. Anybody agree or disagree there?
Linki: It's okay. You're forgiven, since we know you're not evil. :P
Nope, SVS is my teammate in the super-secret second mafia no one knows about. And we would've gotten away with it too, if it wasn't for you meddling kids!Dom wrote:Thank you for your well wishesS~V~S wrote:I do.Dom wrote:Sherry, do you think there's a reason Mr. Name wants to be your bff this game?
Anyway, do you think that reason is civvie-related?
OK, let me try to understand this post. From what I can grasp, and correct me if I'm wrong, you are upset about me asking questions about your posts. This is mafia. Asking questions about people's posts is more or less the whole game.Dom wrote: Should I explain to you why I post every word I post or should I post things and let the response to influence my thinking? Should I explain to you why you don't need a comma after the word "left" or should I let you use punctuation incorrectly?
Oh, are we doing grammar lessons now? Let's take a look at what you said literally a sentence earlier.Dom wrote:Should I explain to you why you don't need a comma after the word "left" or should I let you use punctuation incorrectly?
I meant the people who voted for Nutella. That line probably should have be in sarcastic orange, in retrospect. Because I was trying to make a joke.Dom wrote:Who is "us"?birdwithteeth11 wrote:Well, you're welcome. You can thank us later. :P BIH Nutella!
So given that the game isn't over yet, my guess is that we still have other roles we need dead to finish the game. Abramelin is the only person I see with secrets, so my first guess would be that it's him. Anybody agree or disagree there?
Linki: It's okay. You're forgiven, since we know you're not evil. :P
I think that's why I have a hard time reading Dom sometimes. In most games, he comes across to me this way at at least one point in time. And that's the impression I'm getting from him now.insertnamehere wrote: Moving on, I'm not getting a LMS indie type of vibe from Dom, but more of a cold, confused, and angry civvie. We should just wait until the drugs wear off, and then hear what he has to say in a hopefully more coherent manner.
thellama73 wrote:I have received all the PMs I expect to. Does anyone object if I end the night a little early? I will be at a baseball game tomorrow night, so the day period will last 48 hours.
This sounds fake.thellama73 wrote:I have received all the PMs I expect to. Does anyone object if I end the night a little early? I will be at a baseball game tomorrow night, so the day period will last 48 hours.
I do what I can from beyond the grave.S~V~S wrote:That sucks Blooper
Welcome Back MP![]()
OK, how would we even go about finding this person? A smart indy plays like a civ as long as possible. Maybe a reread of blooper, to see who she had an eye on might be useful. She was a fairly odd kill choice IMO, so it could be something she said.
Also, as always, LOVE your graphics, Blooper