Battlestar Galactica Mafia - GAME OVER

#4201

I've said it about 5 times already, you guys should definitely look into Bea, DrWilgy, Glorfindel and Sig!

They have NOT claimed Cylon, they have NOT voted for Nutella on D2 lynch poll, they have voted for Nerolunar on D3!

#4202

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:How's everyone else feeling right now?
I'm not overwhelmed at all.
Yeah, well that's probably because you're one of the twelve players I want to lynch.

Or it's because I'm acting accordingly given the direction this game is going.

#4203

I absolutely support a sig lynch. The other three I'm not so sure.

#4204

Long Con wrote:You can't imagine how frustrating it is to be accused of knowing what's going on with you and your Mystery Crew, but I have nothing to do with it. WHY do you all think that? Some sort of clue? Uh, it couldn't be someone intentionally misleading you maybe??? I don't know, I'm friggin blind here.

I'm starting to wonder about this. The other person I expected to go after you for this, didn't. So now I don't know what is going on with that. Yes, I'm being intentionally vague but it had a lot to do with my suspicion of you so now.

I guess I'll look at who agree'd with me that didn't know what I knew also.

SVS and JJJ come to mind right now but that's only if I accept the fact you are town and there is no way in hell I'm listening to anyone who calls anyone confirmed town in this game.

LoRab is a guarantee'd lynch so I want a cw. Marmot gave a good one in D'Faraday. He's produced literally 8 posts in this game and like 3 of them say anything worth a damn. It's day 4. He needs to produce or be lynched. I'd like something to be gained from this day so.

Vote: D'Faraday

#4205

Zeebs - this encylopedia of yours... Did it specifically say "town" besides LC or human? There is a difference my dear. And in this game, it's a deadly difference.

LINKI - Polo I agree to all three. But I think since we already know about LoRab she's probably the best bet for today. They would all be good back ups, though. As is DF, IMO. (Thanks MM) I'm not saying anything more about LC if y'all are going to ignore it so I would say they are the next best options, IMO. For me it's Sig, Wigly, Bea, Glor

#4206

Ok, make that 14 players I wanted to lynch.

Linki: Lol, as much as I'd love to just flow with the game, I feel somewhat responsible since I've earned the President's good graces. I'd rather just lynch Cain, but it's not really viable to pick out a single role among such a large group. Thus, I guess we can keep lynching Cylons and hope that we accidentally run into a Cain lynch.

What's your POA zebra?

#4207

ObscureAllure wrote:
Long Con wrote:
ObscureAllure wrote:
Matt wrote:
ObscureAllure wrote:Because if they are a townie WE LOSE THE TOWNIE.
How do you feel about bad Cylons having a lynch save at LYLO?
I already said like four times that I think everyone (except for me) should say the dastardly phrase so that all bad cylons loose their amnesty.
So, you don't accept anyone else using your excuse for not saying it?

Because only one person has my role and the conditions of my role DUH.
Then why aren't you concerned with the others who wont say it? Don't you find it suspicious?

Epignosis wrote:
Long Con wrote:
ObscureAllure wrote:Because if they are a townie WE LOSE THE TOWNIE.
No human would avoid saying the phrase. I don't believe that some players somehow are not allowed to say it. Epignosis, do you believe that some humans are not allowed to say the phrase?
I don't.
I don't (care.) I have my reason. Just because you don't understand my reason doesn't make me a bad guy. I've voiced support of you Epi since you were lynched and I was one of the first if not the first person to say that .... ugh let me phrase this very very carefully.... Some toasters burn toast and some toasters just give it a light crispness. I was one of the first to point at both LoRab and Nutella. I agree that Sig, Bea, and Wigly are probably mafia. And I am telling you that Lynching LC is a very, very good idea.
This, much more than your refusal to make the statement, makes me believe you must be a Cylon.
Wait do you think I'm a cylon or a mafia? Make up your mind.
I'm quite sure I haven't shown any indecisiveness about this, but you may substitute the word "Cylon" in for "mafia" anywhere I have used the latter. It's really weak to try and attack/rebut based on this non-issue.

I am literally a cylon hunting machine. Just let me be about the damn species claim, please?? I'm not changing my mind regardless of what y'all say or do. Now either let me keep sussing out the bad guys like I've done all game or lynch me because we're going to keep talking in circles about this if not. I'm not saying it.
Not saying it tonight, not saying it unless I get lynched, or not saying it ever?
Not saying it unless the outcome outweighs the punishment I will receive. As of this moment, you and your cronies threatening to lynch me isn't a bad enough outcome to outweigh the punishment.
Your last so-called punishment was posting in Smilies. What makes you think that saying it would result in a fate worse than dying and losing the game.

Hmm...

Host: Do players need to be alive to claim their Win Condition?

LC - I love that you're trying to swing it my way and turn it against me when you know why I can't say it. You, above all others, know why I can't say it. You can't be mad at me for just being who the Golden God made me. I was born this way.
I'm sorry, OA, but you are a frakking loon. You can't imagine how frustrating it is to be accused of knowing what's going on with you and your Mystery Crew, but I have nothing to do with it. WHY do you all think that? Some sort of clue? Uh, it couldn't be someone intentionally misleading you maybe??? I don't know, I'm friggin blind here.
I can't help it if you picked the wrong one. That was your fault, not mine. Next time choose more wisely. (I'm not saying anything more than that. You're lucky you're even getting that. I just think I know what's about to happen and if it does, I want some evidence on record. lol)

I haven't "picked" anything. I have no idea what the frak you're talking about.

Long Con wrote:
ObscureAllure wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:I can't promise that. LC is confirmed town.
Since when? When did this happen? Show me the post? Show me some evidence? Because I've got evidence that says he isn't.
No, actually, you don't.

Possibility A: You're lying.

Possibility B: You are, for some reason, claiming an info role, and you have been fooled somehow.
Uh uh! No sir! Do not shift that on to me! I am NOT an info role at all. Again, it was YOUR action, not mine.

I want you to take this in the spirit of a friendly game and true frustration: YOU FUCKING CRAZY BITCH, I DIDN'T DO ANYTHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

And I want to reiterate that I'm thrilled that you are playing again, and I hope you stick around, and I consider you a friend.

I just had no other way to express that at this point. Stop it, I am not involved in whatever the hell is going on with you and Matt and Silver and whoever else in any way. Get it through your head and stop wilfully being such a dupe!

#4208

I mentioned 4 people, not 3, OA.

#4209

Sorry for the quote error there.... I think it's still understandable, let me know if I need to repost that.

#4210

ObscureAllure wrote:Zeebs - this encylopedia of yours... Did it specifically say "town" besides LC or human? There is a difference my dear. And in this game, it's a deadly difference.

I thought you said you were tired of discussing it.

#4211

a2thezebra wrote:
ObscureAllure wrote:Zeebs - this encylopedia of yours... Did it specifically say "town" besides LC or human? There is a difference my dear. And in this game, it's a deadly difference.
I thought you said you were tired of discussing it.

Trying to get you to see the giant ass clues I dropped for you, darling.

#4212

I sense some directed angst in Long Con's posts. This is a new development.

#4213

Giant-ass clues or giant ass-clues?

#4214

Polo wrote:I've said it about 5 times already, you guys should definitely look into Bea, DrWilgy, Glorfindel and Sig!

They have NOT claimed Cylon, they have NOT voted for Nutella on D2 lynch poll, they have voted for Nerolunar on D3!

In this order of most suspicious to least:

Dr. Wilgy I'd be willing to look into more. He hasn't done much since he replaced IAWY who didn't do much. At this stage in the game the low content posters should be looked at. I have no idea on sig, he's null to me. Glorfindel and Bea have had some townie looking posts but their voting history sucks I agree. So in order of most to least suspicious in this group is Wilgy, Sig, Glorfindel, Bea.

#4215

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Ok, make that 14 players I wanted to lynch.

Linki: Lol, as much as I'd love to just flow with the game, I feel somewhat responsible since I've earned the President's good graces. I'd rather just lynch Cain, but it's not really viable to pick out a single role among such a large group. Thus, I guess we can keep lynching Cylons and hope that we accidentally run into a Cain lynch.

What's your POA zebra?

Person of Amnesty?
Pizza of Alligators?
Prerogative of Agents?
Pandas of Amarillo?
Pain of Alienhood?
Pennies of Adam?

#4216

ObscureAllure wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
ObscureAllure wrote:Zeebs - this encylopedia of yours... Did it specifically say "town" besides LC or human? There is a difference my dear. And in this game, it's a deadly difference.
I thought you said you were tired of discussing it.
Trying to get you to see the giant ass clues I dropped for you, darling.

I don't do clues.

#4217

a2thezebra wrote:
Long Con wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
ObscureAllure wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:I can't promise that. LC is confirmed town.
Since when? When did this happen? Show me the post? Show me some evidence? Because I've got evidence that says he isn't.
Considering that my opinion that he is confirmed town is encyclopedic fact and your opinion that he is not confirmed town is contradictory of a ton of in-thread evidence pointing to the contrary, I think it is you who should feel some obligation to present evidence.

I mean, everyone knows at this point that he's confirmed town.
As if I don't have enough complete crap to deal with. Why???
Why are you mad about this? If anyone should be spreading the Good News, it's you.

What is your angle here? I'm done with dealing with this, if other players want to do the right thing and deal with your crap harshly, they have my blessing. I don't need this in addition to the piles of crap that are being thrown at me.

#4218

How anyone could suspect Wilgy more than sig at this point in the game is beyond me.

linki -

#4219

Sorry Polo, I said all four at the bottom of that post, just typing too fast.

LC: Honestly, it's a pleasure. I forgot how good you are. As much as I want to in game strangle you, still love ya, bud. <3
LC: I said I ain't got time fo you no mo! Hide yo wife, hide yo kids! Now on to other things...

Where the heck is DF anyway. Has he been this quiet in other games here recently? I don't remember hi ever being this quiet back in the day.

#4220

a2thezebra wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:Ok, make that 14 players I wanted to lynch.

Linki: Lol, as much as I'd love to just flow with the game, I feel somewhat responsible since I've earned the President's good graces. I'd rather just lynch Cain, but it's not really viable to pick out a single role among such a large group. Thus, I guess we can keep lynching Cylons and hope that we accidentally run into a Cain lynch.

What's your POA zebra?
Person of Amnesty?
Pizza of Alligators?
Prerogative of Agents?
Pandas of Amarillo?
Pain of Alienhood?
Pennies of Adam?

Penis of Art

Or Plan of Attack

#4221

Polo wrote:Giant-ass clues or giant ass-clues?

I agree with this post 100%.

#4222

Polo Obscure Allure

#4223

Polo wrote:Polo Obscure Allure

#4224

I may be too gullible, but I'm inclined to believe that, out of all Cylons, the only one who'd absolutely refuse to claim Cylon (unless it's necessary to avoid a lynch) would be Cavil due to his being so vital to the mafia.

#4225

Polo wrote:I may be too gullible, but I'm inclined to believe that, out of all Cylons, the only one who'd absolutely refuse to claim Cylon (unless it's necessary to avoid a lynch) would be Cavil due to his being so vital to the mafia.

Oh, we can make him claim alright.

This is where ass-clues will be most useful.

#4226

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:... there are people who are resistant or absolutely refusing the Anti-Amnesty plan (bea, ObscureAllure, Ricochet, Long Con, others I can't name off the top of my head)...
Excuse me?
You're excused.

But I should clarify that to are/were, not just players who are currently opposing it.

That's fair, I did originally oppose it because I thought it was flawed, and I wanted to stick to my anti-Cylon guns for fun alone. When it was clarified that the flaw I presented didn't exist, I was not opposed. I'm not a mindless supporter, sorry.

ObscureAllure wrote:Zeebs - this encylopedia of yours... Did it specifically say "town" besides LC or human? There is a difference my dear. And in this game, it's a deadly difference.

LINKI - Polo I agree to all three. But I think since we already know about LoRab she's probably the best bet for today. They would all be good back ups, though. As is DF, IMO. (Thanks MM) I'm not saying anything more about LC if y'all are going to ignore it so I would say they are the next best options, IMO. For me it's Sig, Wigly, Bea, Glor

At least I'm not ignoring you, OA. Which is more than some have given me.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:I sense some directed angst in Long Con's posts. This is a new development.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Polo wrote:I may be too gullible, but I'm inclined to believe that, out of all Cylons, the only one who'd absolutely refuse to claim Cylon (unless it's necessary to avoid a lynch) would be Cavil due to his being so vital to the mafia.
Oh, we can make him claim alright.

This is where ass-clues will be most useful.

I did a literal and unintentional LOL.

#4227

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:Ok, make that 14 players I wanted to lynch.

Linki: Lol, as much as I'd love to just flow with the game, I feel somewhat responsible since I've earned the President's good graces. I'd rather just lynch Cain, but it's not really viable to pick out a single role among such a large group. Thus, I guess we can keep lynching Cylons and hope that we accidentally run into a Cain lynch.

What's your POA zebra?
Person of Amnesty?
Pizza of Alligators?
Prerogative of Agents?
Pandas of Amarillo?
Pain of Alienhood?
Pennies of Adam?
Penis of Art

Or Plan of Attack

Same thing really.

#4228

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Polo wrote:I may be too gullible, but I'm inclined to believe that, out of all Cylons, the only one who'd absolutely refuse to claim Cylon (unless it's necessary to avoid a lynch) would be Cavil due to his being so vital to the mafia.
Oh, we can make him claim alright.

This is where ass-clues will be most useful.

I see your point. Everyone needs to claim mafia and, by asscluesion, the ones who claim it last could be Cavil, right?

#4229

No, a mass claim would help mafia more than hurt them.

#4230

a2thezebra wrote:Same thing really.

Excellent plan of attack.

Polo, I did what Long Con just did to that post of yours.

#4231

a2thezebra wrote:No, a mass claim would help mafia more than hurt them.

No, I think a massclaim would t-rump any other strategy.

#4232

a2thezebra wrote:No, a mass claim would help mafia more than hurt them.

Over 13 people have already claimed Cylon. What do you suggest doing now?

The only way we can kill mafia and Cylons is through lynches. If they claim right before being lynched, the next person in the poll dies. If the second most voted person is human, he'll die, whether mafia or not, and statistically, there are more civ humans than mafia humans.

We need to kill Cylons because Cavil is amongst them. If the Cylons haven't claimed already, they'll be immune and we will take another day to lynch them.

If everyone claims, lynching Cavil will be easier. Capisce?

#4233

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:No, a mass claim would help mafia more than hurt them.
No, I think a massclaim would t-rump any other strategy.

My strategy is that we hunt mafia and try to lynch them until they're all dead, t-rump that.

#4234

Polo wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:No, a mass claim would help mafia more than hurt them.
Over 13 people have already claimed Cylon. What do you suggest doing now?

The only way we can kill mafia and Cylons is through lynches. If they claim right before being lynched, the next person in the poll dies. If the second most voted person is human, he'll die, whether mafia or not, and statistically, there are more civ humans than mafia humans.

We need to kill Cylons because Cavil is amongst them. If the Cylons haven't claimed already, they'll be immune and we will take another day to lynch them.

If everyone claims, lynching Cavil will be easier. Capisce?

Lynching Cavil will be easier...except we'll all be dead by the time we get to him. Cupeesh?

#4235

a2thezebra wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:No, a mass claim would help mafia more than hurt them.
No, I think a massclaim would t-rump any other strategy.
My strategy is that we hunt mafia and try to lynch them until they're all dead, t-rump that.

I would, butt I don't know which roles are mafia, while I have a better idea which ones are Cylon.

As long as the Lorab lynch doesn't turn into a train wrec tummorrow.

#4236

Why are you so sure of that, Zebra?

@Admiral Goldama: I propose a law to replace every single mention of the word Cylon in this thread to Colon.

#4237

Polo wrote:Why are you so sure of that, Zebra?

@Admiral Goldama: I propose a law to replace every single mention of the word Cylon in this thread to Colon.

EBWOP

#4238

Polo wrote:Why are you so sure of that, Zebra?

If you want in-thread evidence, check out how much support this proposition has been getting. Don't you think that if it actually helped town that there would be a hell of a lot more opposition?

#4239

I advise you not to google which piece of anatomy is most close in spelling to 'toaster'

#4240

It's the same kind of uneasy feeling I get when everyone's down to lynch person X. Even if I suspect person X myself, the fact that there's little to no opposition to person X's lynch indicates to me that person X is in fact not bad, unless they're confirmed (like actually confirmed) bad or something.

#4241

Golden wrote:I advise you not to google which piece of anatomy is most close in spelling to 'toaster'

I just met her!

#4242

Cavil for sure. You caught me. Let me give you more of my team mates while I'm at it.

Golden:

Is it a colored waffle?!?

#4243

We're not talking about blue waffles, right? Let's not talk about that.

#4244

Golden wrote:I advise you not to google which piece of anatomy is most close in spelling to 'toaster'

This image is work-safe and family-friendly.

Spoiler: show

#4245

What do you know, that's a fake disease. At least I didn't fall for it as a councilwoman.

#4246

Golden wrote:I advise you not to google which piece of anatomy is most close in spelling to 'toaster'

This image is work-safe and family-friendly and actually an image!!!.

Spoiler: show

#4247

Awesome, I love asters!

Spoiler: show

#4248

You found no resurrection ship at E6

#4249

sig wrote:@HOST was no kill submitted or was the nightkill blocked? Also when did the Marmot law start working? Would it have blocked last nights kill?

Almost done school for the year so bear with me here.

Laws operate from the start of the day phase on which they are introduced, although if it possible for someone to contravene one before it is posted on that day, then they will not be found to be in breach.

#4250

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Who be you lynching today?