Re: Mafia: A World Reborn Game Thread - Day 14
Posted: Wed Dec 09, 2015 9:42 pm
Lorab, your continuous
isn't making me feel better about you. You having to defend yourself is sounding more like an excuse not to go case-building.

Murder, Mayhem, and Mafia
https://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/
That is not what I said. I currently believe Tranq is circle. I don't think he's your teammate. But I think he's on the other team. So, yeah, I'd consider voting a circle suspect.S~V~S wrote:So none of your Circle suspects, Draco, for instance? With only 8 people left you only find 2 people suspicious?
Because it makes more sense that a baddie Tranq would make a deal with someone he believes to be bad than a civ Tranq would.S~V~S wrote:Lower level suspects? There are 8 people left,including yourself.
Why doyou think Tranq is circle?
I thought I saw her online.Dom wrote:FS, did you know you would survive that NK?
And forgot to answer the first part. Yes, there are 8 people. There are a few I mostly trust, in addition to myself, who I have on my civ list. I'm assuming probably 3, but maybe 4 baddies depending on recruitment. 2 of you strike me as at the top of my list as suspicious. The others I don't have a solid thing on, just pings, or lack of reason to trust, and (as I have now said several times), I haven't had time to reread them to see if that makes me feel different about the level of my feelings about them.S~V~S wrote:Lower level suspects? There are 8 people left,including yourself.
Why doyou think Tranq is circle?
I don't think she necessarily realized he was circle when she made the deal. But I know she is true to her word and think she would keep to it, even if she regretted it.Sorsha wrote:SVS's mission is to kill all the circle members for killing MM. Why would she make a deal with one?
You ARE wrong. And I forgive you.S~V~S wrote:There are only 8 people, you can't be more specific?
I feel like I am being kind of an asshole, so I am going to walk away for a bit. But conventional wisdom has been saying there are 2 circle members left; any ideas there?
If I am wrong and you are NOT circle i am sorry. But killing MM who hurt noone except a probable serial killer has mama bear-ed me more than I would have thought.
Assuming SVS was the last of her kind, at this specific point, I think I would probably choose to lynch LoRab. Who came next would depend on if LoRab is actually bad or not (and if there is more than one baddie at that point) but Tranq, you, and probably Dom would be the options on the table for me. If SVS was not bad or the last cabal, I'd probably lynch Tranq next.Draconus wrote:Golden and Sorsha, I'm sure you're right about SVS. Hypothetical: After lynching her, who would you vote for, and in what order (assuming there are 2 or 3 baddies left)?
I amdead serious about MM. And same question to you as Draco asked; if you lynch me & Tranq, which one or two people do you also think are also bad? There are 3 or 4 left.If you are right about me (and you are not) and Tranq, who would you try to lynch next?LoRab wrote:I don't think she necessarily realized he was circle when she made the deal. But I know she is true to her word and think she would keep to it, even if she regretted it.Sorsha wrote:SVS's mission is to kill all the circle members for killing MM. Why would she make a deal with one?
Also, she could be lying about her mission to kill all the circle members.
You ARE wrong. And I forgive you.S~V~S wrote:There are only 8 people, you can't be more specific?
I feel like I am being kind of an asshole, so I am going to walk away for a bit. But conventional wisdom has been saying there are 2 circle members left; any ideas there?
If I am wrong and you are NOT circle i am sorry. But killing MM who hurt noone except a probable serial killer has mama bear-ed me more than I would have thought.
And it's not that hard to look at the list of players and take off the list of names of people I suspect to some degree or other and see who is left. I don't need to name civs.
And, as I've said a few times, I don't know who are the baddies. I agree that there are likely 2 circle and 1 Witherdeath. But with the possibility of recruitment, or being wrong on numbers, then I accept that there could be a 4th baddie. Hence why I said that there are probably 3, but there could be 4.
There are 2 of you that I feel pretty sure are bad (you and Tranq). I know I am good. The others are question marks to me, the ones I've named with pings, and the others penciled in as civs.
I feel the same as I did here:Draconus wrote:Golden and Sorsha, I'm sure you're right about SVS. Hypothetical: After lynching her, who would you vote for, and in what order (assuming there are 2 or 3 baddies left)?
I want SVS lynched today because I think she is cabal. Unfortunately things have happened and if I keep my vote on svs today it could mean I'm a goner here too so I'll be moving my vote to LoRab. I'm not happy about this.Sorsha wrote:Tranq might be completely right about Dom and LoRab being Circle. The problem with your case Tranq is that if we save svs for "last" and she's not actually the last Cabal. Civs lose.
I'm fine with lynching Dom or LoRab tomorrow after we find out if svs is the last Cabal.
Why do you feel that confident that I'm bad?Golden wrote:Assuming SVS was the last of her kind, at this specific point, I think I would probably choose to lynch LoRab. Who came next would depend on if LoRab is actually bad or not (and if there is more than one baddie at that point) but Tranq, you, and probably Dom would be the options on the table for me. If SVS was not bad or the last cabal, I'd probably lynch Tranq next.Draconus wrote:Golden and Sorsha, I'm sure you're right about SVS. Hypothetical: After lynching her, who would you vote for, and in what order (assuming there are 2 or 3 baddies left)?
Yes, she is.S~V~S wrote:She isn't.
I don't. I'm only confident about one person. That's why I'm pushing for the outcome we can be sure of instead of the one we can't.LoRab wrote:Why do you feel that confident that I'm bad?Golden wrote:Assuming SVS was the last of her kind, at this specific point, I think I would probably choose to lynch LoRab. Who came next would depend on if LoRab is actually bad or not (and if there is more than one baddie at that point) but Tranq, you, and probably Dom would be the options on the table for me. If SVS was not bad or the last cabal, I'd probably lynch Tranq next.Draconus wrote:Golden and Sorsha, I'm sure you're right about SVS. Hypothetical: After lynching her, who would you vote for, and in what order (assuming there are 2 or 3 baddies left)?
Sorsha wrote:I feel the same as I did here:Draconus wrote:Golden and Sorsha, I'm sure you're right about SVS. Hypothetical: After lynching her, who would you vote for, and in what order (assuming there are 2 or 3 baddies left)?
I want SVS lynched today because I think she is cabal. Unfortunately things have happened and if I keep my vote on svs today it could mean I'm a goner here too so I'll be moving my vote to LoRab. I'm not happy about this.Sorsha wrote:Tranq might be completely right about Dom and LoRab being Circle. The problem with your case Tranq is that if we save svs for "last" and she's not actually the last Cabal. Civs lose.
I'm fine with lynching Dom or LoRab tomorrow after we find out if svs is the last Cabal.
Linki: *feeds SVS's raccoon some cookies and pats it on the head nicely*
S~V~S wrote:I amdead serious about MM. And same question to you as Draco asked; if you lynch me & Tranq, which one or two people do you also think are also bad? There are 3 or 4 left.If you are right about me (and you are not) and Tranq, who would you try to lynch next?LoRab wrote:I don't think she necessarily realized he was circle when she made the deal. But I know she is true to her word and think she would keep to it, even if she regretted it.Sorsha wrote:SVS's mission is to kill all the circle members for killing MM. Why would she make a deal with one?
Also, she could be lying about her mission to kill all the circle members.
You ARE wrong. And I forgive you.S~V~S wrote:There are only 8 people, you can't be more specific?
I feel like I am being kind of an asshole, so I am going to walk away for a bit. But conventional wisdom has been saying there are 2 circle members left; any ideas there?
If I am wrong and you are NOT circle i am sorry. But killing MM who hurt noone except a probable serial killer has mama bear-ed me more than I would have thought.
And it's not that hard to look at the list of players and take off the list of names of people I suspect to some degree or other and see who is left. I don't need to name civs.
And, as I've said a few times, I don't know who are the baddies. I agree that there are likely 2 circle and 1 Witherdeath. But with the possibility of recruitment, or being wrong on numbers, then I accept that there could be a 4th baddie. Hence why I said that there are probably 3, but there could be 4.
There are 2 of you that I feel pretty sure are bad (you and Tranq). I know I am good. The others are question marks to me, the ones I've named with pings, and the others penciled in as civs.
Can you say the actual names of the people you suspect? Directly? Without a lot of qualifiers & other text?
Now really, I have to bake cookies and shit.
Did you miss these Lorab? The consensus is that there are 3 or 4 baddies. If you are correct about me (uou aren't) and Tranq (no clue) who will you be gping after next?S~V~S wrote:So who besides me & Tranq is bad then?
Just... it makes me uneasy.Sorsha wrote:What Dom
The people I have listed are the people I suspect. Why are you pretending that I haven't named others?S~V~S wrote:So who besides me & Tranq is bad then?
I'm not happy eitherDom wrote:Just... it makes me uneasy.Sorsha wrote:What Dom
I get that. But it's frustrating because I don't want to be lynched and because I want the civs to win and I know that lynching a civ (me) will be a bad thing. And I can relate on focusing efforts.Golden wrote:I don't. I'm only confident about one person. That's why I'm pushing for the outcome we can be sure of instead of the one we can't.LoRab wrote:Why do you feel that confident that I'm bad?Golden wrote:Assuming SVS was the last of her kind, at this specific point, I think I would probably choose to lynch LoRab. Who came next would depend on if LoRab is actually bad or not (and if there is more than one baddie at that point) but Tranq, you, and probably Dom would be the options on the table for me. If SVS was not bad or the last cabal, I'd probably lynch Tranq next.Draconus wrote:Golden and Sorsha, I'm sure you're right about SVS. Hypothetical: After lynching her, who would you vote for, and in what order (assuming there are 2 or 3 baddies left)?
But Draconus asked me what would be next based just on where things are at now. It is really very contingent on what the deal is with SVS. And in reality, it will depend on things like more isos etc... I haven't read back on you at all, because today the time I have had spare has been focussed on figuring out what I think about the tranq/SVS situation. I focussed my efforts that way because of how sure I am that one of them tried to kill splints.
You are working a lot harder to evade say one one name than it would take to actually say it.LoRab wrote:The people I have listed are the people I suspect. Why are you pretending that I haven't named others?S~V~S wrote:So who besides me & Tranq is bad then?
Why is it so important to you for me to make a list?S~V~S wrote:You are working a lot harder to evade say one one name than it would take to actually say it.LoRab wrote:The people I have listed are the people I suspect. Why are you pretending that I haven't named others?S~V~S wrote:So who besides me & Tranq is bad then?
Like I said, without the text etc., just a name. If Tranq & I are gone and the game is not over, who else do you suspect? And you have to know Sorsha is right; I would not make a deal with the Circle.
So you refuse to name anyone else? Really? You keep saying you mentioned them in posts, but you won't just reiterate it clearly for me?LoRab wrote:Why is it so important to you for me to make a list?S~V~S wrote:You are working a lot harder to evade say one one name than it would take to actually say it.LoRab wrote:The people I have listed are the people I suspect. Why are you pretending that I haven't named others?S~V~S wrote:So who besides me & Tranq is bad then?
Like I said, without the text etc., just a name. If Tranq & I are gone and the game is not over, who else do you suspect? And you have to know Sorsha is right; I would not make a deal with the Circle.
And, as I said, I don't know when you and Tranq made a deal, if you knew/believed that he was circle at the time, or if you are being honest.
No, I'm worried that you have an ulterior motive and will somehow benefit from me naming names.S~V~S wrote:So you refuse to name anyone else? Really? You keep saying you mentioned them in posts, but you won't just reiterate it clearly for me?LoRab wrote:Why is it so important to you for me to make a list?S~V~S wrote:You are working a lot harder to evade say one one name than it would take to actually say it.LoRab wrote:The people I have listed are the people I suspect. Why are you pretending that I haven't named others?S~V~S wrote:So who besides me & Tranq is bad then?
Like I said, without the text etc., just a name. If Tranq & I are gone and the game is not over, who else do you suspect? And you have to know Sorsha is right; I would not make a deal with the Circle.
And, as I said, I don't know when you and Tranq made a deal, if you knew/believed that he was circle at the time, or if you are being honest.
You worried to piss off the civs by accusing them?
And you can believe this, 100%. I would not be making deals with him if I thought he killed my partner who he did not need dead to win. Nope. I have nothing to make deals about, of course, but trust me, i would be denouncing him to the skies if Ithought he was Circle.
I am pretty sure I am going to die today, and regardless of what my role flips as, none of you will believe it. So it does not matter much to me. I need to go to bed, I wake up at 5 AMI will find out then if I lived.
I've told you everything. :/LoRab wrote:@Dom: Were you planning to vote? Because your lack of vote is making me paranoid.
Yes, but your lack of voting has made me uneasy.Dom wrote:I've told you everything. :/LoRab wrote:@Dom: Were you planning to vote? Because your lack of vote is making me paranoid.
Draconus wrote:Also, it appears the dead have risen
Metalmarsh89 wrote:It's a rezzvolution!a2thezebra wrote:Mafia: A Rezz Reborn
timmer wrote:Yay! Deadie party!![]()
![]()
![]()
The dead live onDrWilgy wrote:We rize... For the rezz will be ours...anybody?
He has said he trusts me, I have given him a good degree of trust, but it's a close vote and he hasn't voted and I'm in the lead. What about the wording makes you uneasy?Draconus wrote:Golden, does this ^^ wording make you uneasy?
It makes me think that you only need 1, if any, more vote on SVS to survive.LoRab wrote:He has said he trusts me, I have given him a good degree of trust, but it's a close vote and he hasn't voted and I'm in the lead. What about the wording makes you uneasy?Draconus wrote:Golden, does this ^^ wording make you uneasy?
linkitis: @Dom: What does that mean?
LoRab wrote:He has said he trusts me, I have given him a good degree of trust, but it's a close vote and he hasn't voted and I'm in the lead. What about the wording makes you uneasy?Draconus wrote:Golden, does this ^^ wording make you uneasy?
linkitis: @Dom: What does that mean?
lolwatLoRab wrote:I currently believe Tranq is circle.