[TREE MAFIA] Mafia Chat Thread

#51

Fantastic result. Mac, Epi and J all hate each other.

#52

I fail to change my vote and mac's parting words are to J calling him scum. I look worse after today but I think I can fight out another one.

#53

Diiny wrote:Fantastic result. Mac, Epi and J all hate each other.

Indeed, and we have many viable lynch options going forward. I could actually foresee a scenario in which none of us get lynched until LYLO or even at all, for that matter... but we'll see. Fingers crossed, but if one or two of us has to go, that's no problem.

With that said, we need to make sure to keep on watch, because the game can change quickly. So far you both have performed excellently.

#54

Alright, so let's discuss potential Night 2 kill targets. This could be a game changer, so I want to make sure we kill the right guy. What are your thoughts?

#55

JJJ defending motel room, WEW.

Mac saying I'm good? YEAH. toned it down this game day phase played pretty good I thought, was very happy to read that.

#56

Diiny wrote:JJJ defending motel room, WEW.

Mac saying I'm good? YEAH. toned it down this game day phase played pretty good I thought, was very happy to read that.

Those were both huge victories. I was nervous about JJJ conducting the ISOs, but it worked out. Props.

#57

I think it's fair to say there's no doc, btw.

We're not killing any of those three. Mac J and Epi are off the list.

linki: yeha I'm gonna fight him a bit over my iso because tbh there genuinely is some stuff he missed

#58

FYI my activity during Day 3 will suck, since it will end the evening before my big final exam, so I'll be in major crunch time. I'll see what I can do though (and I always inevitably get pulled into playing more than I should).

#59

Zeb is an option, but she will suffer because of her really weird vote. what was up with that? I feel like she defended wilgo all game

#60

Diiny wrote:I think it's fair to say there's no doc, btw.

We're not killing any of those three. Mac J and Epi are off the list.

linki: yeha I'm gonna fight him a bit over my iso because tbh there genuinely is some stuff he missed

I agree; I'd be surprised if there was a doctor at this point. Glad we went with the Sorsha N1 kill; it was worth the risk.

Agreed with Mac, JJJ, and Epi being off the list. That leaves a2thezebra, DFaraday, FZ., and TheFloyd73.

I'd lean toward keeping FZ. around; I think she is lynch worthy. She can be scary when she is on point, but she's definitely off the mark so far this game, and it's worked in our favor. I could consider any of the other three, I think. Need to mull over it.

Sounds good, go for it.

#61

Diiny wrote:Zeb is an option, but she will suffer because of her really weird vote. what was up with that? I feel like she defended wilgo all game

I was thinking that too, and that way I wouldn't have to come up with reasons to suspect her, probably after conducting an ISO.

You're right though that she could be a potential lynchee, especially after that vote.

#62

I should get back to studying. I'll pop back on either in a few hours or sometime tomorrow. Let me know what you think of those four options (pros/cons, maybe?), and I'll think on it as well. Curious what motel room thinks too.

#63

FZ is lynch worthy, yes.

This is great, for the first time I don't think there's anyone who isn't beneficial to keep around

#64

Let's withhold the NK.

I'm claiming doc.

LET'S DO IT.

I PROTECTED MAC DAY 1 BECAUSE HIS POST LYNCH VOTES SWUNG ME TO THINKING HE WAS GONNA GET TARGETED

#65

...my total visible post count goes up when I post here. Can eagle eyes folks tell I'm posting in an invisible thread?

#66

Oh no, it doesn't ignore that

#67

Diiny wrote:Oh no, it doesn't ignore that

Nope, MP accounted for that already.

#68

Slept on it and now I am actually considering JJJ. I reckon it'll make Epi look bad enough to be lynchabl, and then when mac goes for that lynch he'll look worse. Only other option for me is zeb.

#69

Diiny wrote:Let's withhold the NK.

I'm claiming doc.

LET'S DO IT.

I PROTECTED MAC DAY 1 BECAUSE HIS POST LYNCH VOTES SWUNG ME TO THINKING HE WAS GONNA GET TARGETED

An intriguing gambit, but it doesn't seem necessary, especially since:

1) You got some town cred over the past Day
2) Even if you get lynched tomorrow (or soon), your lynch will reflect badly upon certain players that aren't us (such as zebra for reading you as heavy scum but voting elsewhere Day 2, etc.).

#70

Diiny wrote:Slept on it and now I am actually considering JJJ. I reckon it'll make Epi look bad enough to be lynchabl, and then when mac goes for that lynch he'll look worse. Only other option for me is zeb.

JJJ is a possible choice, but I feel as though he may be lynchable, especially since he's one of the most easily-tinfoiled players in the whole game.

Call me crazy, but I'm actually leaning towards DFaraday. Why?

1) Completely untraceable, maximizes tinfoiling against JJJ, Floyd, Epi, zebra, and Mac, who are all going after each other. Doesn't discredit Epi's or Mac's theories one way or the other.
2) Although he's been a low contributor, I don't feel as though keeping him around gives us someone with easily lynchable status in the foreseeable cycle or two. Mac tried to get some momentum going that way, but I think he actually has a lesser chance of actually being lynched going into Day 3 than many other players in the game right now because so many theories are going around. I also don't know if players would want to lynch him during LYLO.
3) Solves the problem of MM having to replace him.

I realize it's a riskier NK, and not killing JJJ or some other master player could potentially backfire, but I think it still is the most attractive option for us given those facts. Thoughts? I'm not 100% sold, so I'm still considering Floyd, JJJ, and even zebra (though I think I lean least towards her of the four), but I'm definitely leaning this way for now.

I have to leave now, and I'll be at a party, but I'll make sure to sneak on my phone at some point super quickly just to make sure one of us has submitted a kill.

#71

hey you guys sorry i legit havent been around. Always busy on the weekends.

I was thinking killing zebra would be a good idea too. Zebra is in a place right now it seems where she can either fuel or shoot down thw tinfoily theories being thrown around and i think the rest can fuel them themselves, so to avoid her shooting them down...

Happy with a DFaraday kill too I guess, wouldnt be bad. Up to you guys I wont be around til Monday (my time).

The only way I'd be into that doctor gambit Diiny, and its cool if you want to, is if you didnt claim straight away. Save it for when needed. I really dont see a real doctor sticking their neck out like that when theres no reason to. Unless Im missing something, im skimming here

#72

No yeah I just want to have that ace in the hole. I'll obviously only claim when the real doc would reasonably

#73

I'm fine with killing zebra too if you all want. Which should we go with?

#74

But yeah faraday's a good idea actually, fresh golden subbing in could ruin everything.

#75

Sig, on the other hand, we could probably deal with. I mean that with no disrespect, but golden's a damn good player.

#76

Any kind of replacement would be a risk, but yeah, it could definitely be a different level of intensity based on who subs in. I still am leaning DF especially because I think it'll maximize the tinfoiling all around.

You alright with making it final?

#77

Yes, let's give Zeb hell for her vote.

#78

Diiny wrote:Yes, let's give Zeb hell for her vote.

MM, we would like to kill DFaraday.

#79

MovingPictures07 wrote:
Diiny wrote:Yes, let's give Zeb hell for her vote.

MM, we would like to kill DFaraday.

Thank yew.

#80

It is now Day 3, this thread will be locked until nighttime.

#81

Mafia chat is open now. :O

#82

lol Diiny, I thought you were gonna leave your vote off and let the coin flip decide for a couple mins there. Imagine that shit

#83

I've never had as much fun as winding up zebra.

I'm looking worse and worse, though. Super relieved to see Epi question zeb though.

I'm thinking zeb, quite honestly. Probably biased as fuck but fifty fifty wifom on me is probably better than my current situation. Interested to see what you all have to say.

linki: was considering it lol

#84

I've never had as much fun as winding up zebra.

I'm looking worse and worse, though. Super relieved to see Epi question zeb though.

I'm thinking zeb, quite honestly. Probably biased as fuck but fifty fifty wifom on me is probably better than my current situation. Interested to see what you all have to say.

linki: was considering it lol

#85

motel room wrote:lol Diiny, I thought you were gonna leave your vote off and let the coin flip decide for a couple mins there. Imagine that shit

Actually, I was going to roll a d6 if it came to it. :P

#86

Im gonna slightly reverse my view on you tomorrow, pretty sure, cos i think you voted late on JJJ cos you genuinely thought he was town and didnt like making him the lynch even at your own possible death even kept defending him til the end? (but you cant point that out, someone else - me probs - has to i reckon) Making my main push Floyd ultimately..

I reckon kill Mac cos he'd be dangerous at lylo and will be resetting his reads right now. No one actually seems to be listening to zebra and if Floyd votes you tomorrow thats 4 in a row, thats bullshit, floyd is scum.

but its easy for me to say that, youre the one feeling the heat and mate you're doing a killer job of it

Anyway that's how i see it atm. We've got a day to think.

#87

Yeah, definitely gonna mull it over. Thanks for the support...

It'd probably be good if you brought up those points, but if zebra pushes me on that point about me not wanting to vote until the deadline I'll probably end up making at least some of those arguments myself. It's kinda funny how nobody's listening to her, though they might tomorrow. I'm deliberately trying to get her sounding flustered and I think it's working. Mac's kinda gone quiet recently but I agree that he's a big threat at lylo.

You've been playing a damn good game yourself. You sound genuine and that's something I'm finding hard to emulate this game since my shoddy start. I really think we can win this.

Is it lylo tomorrow? I STILL have the doc claim up my sleeve, dude.

#88

If it is lylo tomorrow and floyd instavotes me as per usual despite votes being unchangable, would it prove I'm scum if three votes don't pretty quickly come crashing down on me?

#89

And is it as simple as Jay said? If a townie votes for another townie, is it OGRE?

#90

yeah if you've got your back to the wall go ahead and use the reasons especially if im not around. Gotta stay fluid

Its just that I see the people who were wrong about JJJ coming back with fresh new committed reads (potentially hurting us) as opposed to ppl with existing reads they haven't been able to pull the trigger on probably doubting them now but ehhh 50-50 you know. Lets keep doubt in the game. Mac and Epi should be reassessing but Epi at least has his Floyd read to think on. Sig, not sure. I might be dumb though, happy with whatever.

yep LYLO tomorrow...

#91

Diiny wrote:If it is lylo tomorrow and floyd instavotes me as per usual despite votes being unchangable, would it prove I'm scum if three votes don't pretty quickly come crashing down on me?

hmm maybe. Not all "scum" will be around at the same time. lets see what happens.

MM will the votes be locked tomorrow like usual?

#92

Basically my thinking is that if I get voted for and it's clear I'm scum because scum aren't instaflinging on their votes to quickly claim victory, bus ASAP. Don't be shy to point this out.

#93

Diiny wrote:s it lylo tomorrow? I STILL have the doc claim up my sleeve, dude.

who did you protect all nights? Why not sorsha night 1?

#94

Diiny wrote:Basically my thinking is that if I get voted for and it's clear I'm scum because scum aren't instaflinging on their votes to quickly claim victory, bus ASAP. Don't be shy to point this out.

yeah man

#95

Votes won't be locked tomorrow, not with a chance at a failed nightkill today and/or tomorrow night.

So even if you enter Night 4 with 6 players left in the game and the mafia team intact, mafia might not be 100% guaranteed to win, even if it's almost certain.

#96

Mac night 1 because his misdirections got me. I'll think about the others. I'm probably not going to use it, but it'd be really funny if I did.

linkis: awh. I guess I should be happy because floyd can't seal my fate instantly. I think we can pull through, though. Nip this in the bud.

#97

yeah it's probably better this way anyway, dunno.

Cool keep it up your sleeve

#98

I know I'm spewing a lot of shit right now but it's been in my head for a while and I need to get it out

Zebra and I have discussed this entire amount of bullshit without once resorting to questioning what the point in her moving to wilgy was; it can't have been to protect FZ because that was already the case with her vote which was already on me. If she ever asked why I'd say it was because she didn't want to catch too much flak for advocating my lynch and watching me flip town by her hand at that stage in the game. You can say it's because we're teammates, though, and she was trying to save me. That this entire dumb argument is a big masterful distraction. I don't know if that makes sense. Don't read this

#99

i feel really bad for JJJ vouching for me

#100

Poor Jay. Isn't this like the first time he's ever been lynched as town not on Day 1?

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous