Murder, Mayhem, and Mafia
https://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/
idk like i would be very surprised if this is a scum post112 wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 1:05 pm
yer damn right
i'm soooooooooo mafia
seriously can't believe you guy haven't chopped me yet i'm the most obvious mafia that ever mafia'd
you guys are too good
when i flip scum, which i undoubtedly will, i hope you celebrate the astounding achievement in brain power that led to my ejection
i'm gonna flip the darkest shade of red
"Heads I win, tails you lose."NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 2:39 pm Hally is sorta kinda almost claiming a way to survive in a game with mod-confirmed only three PRs and two flipped town PRs
Do you guys think town has three PRs? Do you think Hally claims a way to survive if she’s doesn’t have it? Do you think if she does have it she ever doesn’t use it if she’s mafia?
By far the safest play today is to TK Hally, if she’s mafia it makes sure she dies, if she’s town we don’t actually lose anything.
Bad takeNANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 2:39 pm By far the safest play today is to TK Hally, if she’s mafia it makes sure she dies, if she’s town we don’t actually lose anything.
idk if this is a correct take but i think it’s a towny oneArete wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:02 pm
take:
we're a few hours from EoD and no one cares about the wagons, like, at all
take 2: if Mafia is being wagoned and Hally is not a wolf then the Mafia are close enough to winning that someone would ?probably? care (somewhat complicated due to the RNG aspect of who dies from the extra LC poison)
additional bonus take: if a wolf was on the LC wagon (so, Epi, Poison, Nanook, Hally) they would care especially much about keeping Wilgy alive because they can't guarantee their own survival to the poison effect but they can guarantee Wilgy's survival (n.b. the only living off-wagon players were Wilgy, Ash, and 112)
from this I'm concluding that the threadstate points strongly to Wilgy being town, and more weakly to 112 being town (that one is sketchier because 112 technically isn't top wagon, so Mafia would only need to maintain the status quo to avoid a wolf elim)
(***possible exception: if Hally is a wolf they're less likely to try to push agenda today due to the thing where they're dying)
'Arete is that just Dadv but with more words' yes but I don't think I'm wrong
the issue I'm having is that I don't really find the players-not-being-wagoned to be especially wolfy
Epi isn't a current wagon and is getting a pass for no clear reason so that could maybe be a hit? but I'm not, like, confident of that
I just don't really think Wilgy is a hit right now
It's a bunch of words that say nothing.Hally wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:05 pmidk if this is a correct take but i think it’s a towny oneArete wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:02 pm
take:
we're a few hours from EoD and no one cares about the wagons, like, at all
take 2: if Mafia is being wagoned and Hally is not a wolf then the Mafia are close enough to winning that someone would ?probably? care (somewhat complicated due to the RNG aspect of who dies from the extra LC poison)
additional bonus take: if a wolf was on the LC wagon (so, Epi, Poison, Nanook, Hally) they would care especially much about keeping Wilgy alive because they can't guarantee their own survival to the poison effect but they can guarantee Wilgy's survival (n.b. the only living off-wagon players were Wilgy, Ash, and 112)
from this I'm concluding that the threadstate points strongly to Wilgy being town, and more weakly to 112 being town (that one is sketchier because 112 technically isn't top wagon, so Mafia would only need to maintain the status quo to avoid a wolf elim)
(***possible exception: if Hally is a wolf they're less likely to try to push agenda today due to the thing where they're dying)
'Arete is that just Dadv but with more words' yes but I don't think I'm wrong
the issue I'm having is that I don't really find the players-not-being-wagoned to be especially wolfy
Epi isn't a current wagon and is getting a pass for no clear reason so that could maybe be a hit? but I'm not, like, confident of that
I just don't really think Wilgy is a hit right now
How is that hard to fake as scum?Hally wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 1:47 pmidk like i would be very surprised if this is a scum post112 wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 1:05 pm
yer damn right
i'm soooooooooo mafia
seriously can't believe you guy haven't chopped me yet i'm the most obvious mafia that ever mafia'd
you guys are too good
when i flip scum, which i undoubtedly will, i hope you celebrate the astounding achievement in brain power that led to my ejection
i'm gonna flip the darkest shade of red
and 112’s posting generally looks like “i know im gonna flip town and am laughing at everyone” which is pretty hard to fake as scum. like she’s clowning on us because we have the audacity to think she wouldn’t be town
that's ... what even is that interpretation of my sentenceEpignosis wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:27 pmIt's a bunch of words that say nothing.Hally wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:05 pmidk if this is a correct take but i think it’s a towny oneArete wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:02 pm
take:
we're a few hours from EoD and no one cares about the wagons, like, at all
take 2: if Mafia is being wagoned and Hally is not a wolf then the Mafia are close enough to winning that someone would ?probably? care (somewhat complicated due to the RNG aspect of who dies from the extra LC poison)
additional bonus take: if a wolf was on the LC wagon (so, Epi, Poison, Nanook, Hally) they would care especially much about keeping Wilgy alive because they can't guarantee their own survival to the poison effect but they can guarantee Wilgy's survival (n.b. the only living off-wagon players were Wilgy, Ash, and 112)
from this I'm concluding that the threadstate points strongly to Wilgy being town, and more weakly to 112 being town (that one is sketchier because 112 technically isn't top wagon, so Mafia would only need to maintain the status quo to avoid a wolf elim)
(***possible exception: if Hally is a wolf they're less likely to try to push agenda today due to the thing where they're dying)
'Arete is that just Dadv but with more words' yes but I don't think I'm wrong
the issue I'm having is that I don't really find the players-not-being-wagoned to be especially wolfy
Epi isn't a current wagon and is getting a pass for no clear reason so that could maybe be a hit? but I'm not, like, confident of that
I just don't really think Wilgy is a hit right now
"I don't think Wilgy is a hit right now."
So just when would Wilgy be a hit?
[VOTE: Arete] aubergine
I’ve only seen her town game (g9). She’s seemed completely in line with that and independently appeared towny to me, but I admit to doing a bit of sheeping as well that she couldn’t play this game as wolf.
Native English speaker?Arete wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:32 pm like, I have trouble seeing how a reasonable native speaker of English* would interpret my sentence like that
and it kinda feels like you picked out a random line from my post and completely ignored my actual argument so that you could vote me and have a reason other than OMGUS
because the reason you're presenting does not make sense
*I don't know if you're a native English speaker, if you're not then I'm sorry and I'm not trying to insult you
yes, but it shows a lot of thought. even if the conclusion os not that extraordinary, the process used to get there looks townyEpignosis wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:27 pmIt's a bunch of words that say nothing.Hally wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:05 pmidk if this is a correct take but i think it’s a towny oneArete wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:02 pm
take:
we're a few hours from EoD and no one cares about the wagons, like, at all
take 2: if Mafia is being wagoned and Hally is not a wolf then the Mafia are close enough to winning that someone would ?probably? care (somewhat complicated due to the RNG aspect of who dies from the extra LC poison)
additional bonus take: if a wolf was on the LC wagon (so, Epi, Poison, Nanook, Hally) they would care especially much about keeping Wilgy alive because they can't guarantee their own survival to the poison effect but they can guarantee Wilgy's survival (n.b. the only living off-wagon players were Wilgy, Ash, and 112)
from this I'm concluding that the threadstate points strongly to Wilgy being town, and more weakly to 112 being town (that one is sketchier because 112 technically isn't top wagon, so Mafia would only need to maintain the status quo to avoid a wolf elim)
(***possible exception: if Hally is a wolf they're less likely to try to push agenda today due to the thing where they're dying)
'Arete is that just Dadv but with more words' yes but I don't think I'm wrong
the issue I'm having is that I don't really find the players-not-being-wagoned to be especially wolfy
Epi isn't a current wagon and is getting a pass for no clear reason so that could maybe be a hit? but I'm not, like, confident of that
I just don't really think Wilgy is a hit right now
"I don't think Wilgy is a hit right now."
So just when would Wilgy be a hit?
[VOTE: Arete] aubergine
Ok, soEpignosis wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:38 pmNative English speaker?Arete wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:32 pm like, I have trouble seeing how a reasonable native speaker of English* would interpret my sentence like that
and it kinda feels like you picked out a random line from my post and completely ignored my actual argument so that you could vote me and have a reason other than OMGUS
because the reason you're presenting does not make sense
*I don't know if you're a native English speaker, if you're not then I'm sorry and I'm not trying to insult you
I'll do you one better.
I'm an English teacher.
So so so how to improve grammar, sir?Epignosis wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:38 pmNative English speaker?Arete wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:32 pm like, I have trouble seeing how a reasonable native speaker of English* would interpret my sentence like that
and it kinda feels like you picked out a random line from my post and completely ignored my actual argument so that you could vote me and have a reason other than OMGUS
because the reason you're presenting does not make sense
*I don't know if you're a native English speaker, if you're not then I'm sorry and I'm not trying to insult you
I'll do you one better.
I'm an English teacher.
ok just ignore me thenAsh Lael wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:27 pmHow is that hard to fake as scum?Hally wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 1:47 pmidk like i would be very surprised if this is a scum post112 wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 1:05 pm
yer damn right
i'm soooooooooo mafia
seriously can't believe you guy haven't chopped me yet i'm the most obvious mafia that ever mafia'd
you guys are too good
when i flip scum, which i undoubtedly will, i hope you celebrate the astounding achievement in brain power that led to my ejection
i'm gonna flip the darkest shade of red
and 112’s posting generally looks like “i know im gonna flip town and am laughing at everyone” which is pretty hard to fake as scum. like she’s clowning on us because we have the audacity to think she wouldn’t be town
“Haha I’m town and you people are going to look so stupid” is, like, the easiest genre of post for a caught wolf to make.
What’s difficult is “here’s why one of these supposedly locktown people actually isn’t”, which a PoE’d villager can do without much trouble if they have good reason to think the PoE is wrong. But it’s hard for a wolf because they can see all the good reasons for townclearing people are indeed good reasons.
So far I’ve seen nothing like that from 112.
then presumably you should have been able to use context clues to figure out that my sentence was narrating my present state of mind rather than implying Wilgy's alignment would be different depending on when we flipped him!Epignosis wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:38 pmArete wrote: ↑Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:32 pm like, I have trouble seeing how a reasonable native speaker of English* would interpret my sentence like that
and it kinda feels like you picked out a random line from my post and completely ignored my actual argument so that you could vote me and have a reason other than OMGUS
because the reason you're presenting does not make sense
*I don't know if you're a native English speaker, if you're not then I'm sorry and I'm not trying to insult you
Native English speaker?
I'll do you one better.
I'm an English teacher.