Re: [DAY 8] Talking Heads Mafia (RYM #90)
Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2015 8:45 pm
Sun's up people. Get cracking.
Murder, Mayhem, and Mafia
https://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/
I still can't get over this post. If Strawhenge truly felt that MacDougall was a "scum buddy" to 3J and Motel Room, then why did he not place his vote on Mac? By referring to Mac as "scum buddy", this means Strawhenge must've thought Mac was "scum". Yet he refused to make a difference between Mac or Diiny in the lynch. I dun git it.Strawhenge wrote:Jay, keej, it's quite noble that you're trying to save your scumbuddy right now, but I'm not buying it.
Have you offered an opinion on Russtifinko?Matt F wrote:Psssst motel room, the following is what I consider "tunneling", not what I'm goin' after you and 3J for...
I still can't get over this post. If Strawhenge truly felt that MacDougall was a "scum buddy" to 3J and Motel Room, then why did he not place his vote on Mac? By referring to Mac as "scum buddy", this means Strawhenge must've thought Mac was "scum". Yet he refused to make a difference between Mac or Diiny in the lynch. I dun git it.Strawhenge wrote:Jay, keej, it's quite noble that you're trying to save your scumbuddy right now, but I'm not buying it.
I am happy with a 3J lynch today, which is where the thread will prolly go, but I'd also like Strawhenge, motel room, and Floyd to be on the chopping block, as well.
Fixed*Matt F wrote:Yes, I've had him marked as "anti-Mafia" since he was the 8th and final vote on Long Con during Day 2. Yes it's possible to bus teamies, but considering how important Long Con's role was, and considering Russ' vote was the essential nail in the coffin, I have a hard time seeing him as bad.
However, I have decided to dedicate this day to straight scum huntin', so I will ISO Russ now!!
He's too busy staring at the sun. He's so high he's off the poll.Matt F wrote:What up Choutas', why the sunglasses? Hard for you to see?
Deal with it meme.Matt F wrote:Fixed*Matt F wrote:Yes, I've had him marked as "anti-Mafia" since he was the 8th and final vote on Long Con during Day 2. Yes it's possible to bus teamies, but considering how important Long Con's role was, and considering Russ' vote was the essential nail in the coffin, I have a hard time seeing him as bad.
However, I have decided to dedicate this day to straight scum huntin', so I will ISO Russ now!!
What up Choutas', why the sunglasses? Hard for you to see?
Matt, thanks for bringing some attention to motel room. I think my point about him being ok with lynching civs yesterday was largely ignored, with the seaside stuff going on.Matt F wrote:You could just quote it, and then put your answers in blue. Then we know where the convo's been and where it's currently at.motel room wrote:holy shit I'm not touching that monster post any more. I'll pull out your red and reply and you'll just have to remember what I'm replying to. Cos damn some of that still isnt actually questions.
Anyway, I'm out. I'll be back in the morning to continue our discussion.
What does everyone in the thread think about 3J and Motel room voting together 5 out of 7 day phases, dissuading players from voting MacDougall during Day 6, and bandwagoning a civilian Day 7?
Wait, wait, wait. So disregarding everything I've done this game and all 139 pages of content, I'm bad because one baddie voted for me on Day 1 but another one didn't?? I fail to see the merit of this.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Black Rock replaced AceofSpaces. This was one of AceofSpaces' only two posts of the game before he subbed out, in which he followed a known teammate's suspicion to vote Russti, being the second vote on him and about an hour before the deadline.AceofSpaces wrote:I am putting a vote onto Russ, based on what MacDougall said. I really don't have the time to catch up fully and form a solid opinion right now. Voting for Russ is the best I can do.
I asked Mac if he wanted to lynch Russti, who had quickly gained four votes, and was looking like a decent lynch candidate (trailing birdwithteeth 4-7). Instead, Mac left his vote on the less popular reywas (now RadicalFuzz).
These things considered, I think Russtifinko is mafia.
This seems....tunnelly.Epignosis wrote:Russ was my Day 1 suspect, and he never left that list.Matt F wrote:You think motel room is clean or you just like these two better?Epignosis wrote:If I had two lynches as of this moment, they'd go to 3J and Russ.
"Tunnelly?"Russtifinko wrote:Wait, wait, wait. So disregarding everything I've done this game and all 139 pages of content, I'm bad because one baddie voted for me on Day 1 but another one didn't?? I fail to see the merit of this.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Black Rock replaced AceofSpaces. This was one of AceofSpaces' only two posts of the game before he subbed out, in which he followed a known teammate's suspicion to vote Russti, being the second vote on him and about an hour before the deadline.AceofSpaces wrote:I am putting a vote onto Russ, based on what MacDougall said. I really don't have the time to catch up fully and form a solid opinion right now. Voting for Russ is the best I can do.
I asked Mac if he wanted to lynch Russti, who had quickly gained four votes, and was looking like a decent lynch candidate (trailing birdwithteeth 4-7). Instead, Mac left his vote on the less popular reywas (now RadicalFuzz).
These things considered, I think Russtifinko is mafia.
This seems....tunnelly.Epignosis wrote:Russ was my Day 1 suspect, and he never left that list.Matt F wrote:You think motel room is clean or you just like these two better?Epignosis wrote:If I had two lynches as of this moment, they'd go to 3J and Russ.
If either of you have a case to bring, please, let's have it out in the open. I'm happy to defend myself if need be, and I have nothing to hide.. I don't like these mentions and insinuations with nothing behind them, though. They've led to too many bad lynches, just because someone's name is out there a lot.
Do you want me to drop a bomb? OK here it goes.Matt F wrote:Who are your top suspects Choutas?
Do you speak English?Choutas wrote:Do you want me to drop a bomb? OK here it goes.Matt F wrote:Who are your top suspects Choutas?
1,2,3
You ask me who's the scummiest and murderous
Who tried to kill whom? Who was supposed to be slain.
Y'all had it all before you, game has been generous.
The SK has been killing only RYMers, simple and plain.
Could he be a RYMer? JJJ feelin' it. He tried to kill me callin' it.
Hey Floyd baby you have me money on being scummy(Modified from O'DB)
BarelyEpignosis wrote:Do you speak English?Choutas wrote:Do you want me to drop a bomb? OK here it goes.Matt F wrote:Who are your top suspects Choutas?
1,2,3
You ask me who's the scummiest and murderous
Who tried to kill whom? Who was supposed to be slain.
Y'all had it all before you, game has been generous.
The SK has been killing only RYMers, simple and plain.
Could he be a RYMer? JJJ feelin' it. He tried to kill me callin' it.
Hey Floyd baby you have me money on being scummy(Modified from O'DB)
I'm on your lynch list for my Dusk 0 vote.Matt F wrote:Thanks, J. Whenever you get back, assuming these were the only five lynch candidates tomorrow, who would you pick? (or if you're strongly against all of them, let me know)
motel room
Metal Marsh
Epignosis
TheFloyd
Strawhenge
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:It's also possible you're the bad guy and you're turning the two-for-one special into a three-for-one (if motel room is town).![]()
Unfortunately, my total whack out theories prevent my really good theories from getting any traction, cuz I guess peeps think I'm crazy haha. Remember, it wasn't until Ricochet and others started looking at Mac differently before he was lynched.
However, I will point out, earlier in the game I suspected Mac of being an LC teamie for their discussion on the Nothing but Flowers role, I even asked Mac if I was wrong and he simply said "Yes" (which I wasn't)
and
In an ISO of Black Rock, I suspected her and Long Con of being teamies because of her "I believe BC was in the lead" comment after I was curious who was in the lead, BC or LC, during the late Llama train Day 2.
So I get it right sometimes
So ISO me now since I've been on your mafia lynch list for my Dusk 0 vote.Matt F wrote:Yes, I've had him marked as "anti-Mafia" since he was the 8th and final vote on Long Con during Day 2. Yes it's possible to bus teamies, but considering how important Long Con's role was, and considering Russ' vote was the essential nail in the coffin, I have a hard time seeing him as bad.
However, I have decided this day to straight scum huntin', so I will ISO Russ now!!
Well it's guaranteed he wasn't roleblocked if his name's off the poll.Epignosis wrote:He's too busy staring at the sun. He's so high he's off the poll.Matt F wrote:What up Choutas', why the sunglasses? Hard for you to see?
WHO wasn't roleblocked?Metalmarsh89 wrote:Well it's guaranteed he wasn't roleblocked if his name's off the poll.Epignosis wrote:He's too busy staring at the sun. He's so high he's off the poll.Matt F wrote:What up Choutas', why the sunglasses? Hard for you to see?
Doesn't rule him out as bad of course.
There are three roleblockers in this game. Two of them are dead. The other one picks two players, and removes one from the poll while roleblocking the other. So Choutas could not possibly have been roleblocked, whatever his power might be. This might have nothing to do with the same player surviving both nightkills, but it's true nonetheless.Epignosis wrote:WHO wasn't roleblocked?Metalmarsh89 wrote:Well it's guaranteed he wasn't roleblocked if his name's off the poll.Epignosis wrote:He's too busy staring at the sun. He's so high he's off the poll.Matt F wrote:What up Choutas', why the sunglasses? Hard for you to see?
Doesn't rule him out as bad of course.
Explain.Epignosis wrote:Voting MetalMarsh89.
I'm just waiting on you to fall asleep after everyone piles on.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Explain.Epignosis wrote:Voting MetalMarsh89.
I think you're the SK though.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Also, I hate you.
Funny, because I thought Mac was onto something about you.Epignosis wrote:I think you're the SK though.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Also, I hate you.
motel room wrote:Nah you should quote it cos I don't like you dropping into the thread after no content and trying to drum up shit without context.Russtifinko wrote:To be more precise: esplain the part where you think JJJ will flip town, but you're happy to remove the doubt by lynching him. I recall Mac saying something very similar, I think about Sorsha. (Would quote, but have you seen that dude's post history?)
I'm not sure how I can further explain it. I think JJJ may be town and made the same mistaken judgement on mac as I did. I'm not confident enough to fight his lynch and can see benefit from him as a lynch contender being removed from further chatter. He has even said the same thing himself. Why is me thinking this so suspicious to you, specifically?
Fine. Found it. Not sure why you felt the need to have me do that. (It's near the top of page 9 of his post history, btw.)MacDougall wrote:I think we really have to lynch sorsha. I feel like it's the key to breaking the game open today. She either flips scum and leaves behind a tasty breadcrumb trail, or flips town and leaves behind a tasty breadcrumb trail. Trusting Golden again seems like a nice way to get another townie killed. We've got a scum dead inside the first four days in a large game. We can afford a tactical lynch. Sorsha is a good lynch candidate for up front scum play as well as being the best possible lynch from a tactical perspective. Short of someone saying "I am scum" my vote won't be changing today.
That's good. Keep going with that.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Funny, because I thought Mac was onto something about you.Epignosis wrote:I think you're the SK though.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Also, I hate you.
I agree! I thought of them as a triumvirate too. RIP Roxy and fingers.RadicalFuzz wrote:What's with this Roxy-splints-BR triangle all getting modkilled in one night? Spooky stuff.
motel room wrote: Yeah no thats what I mean:
So back to this other thing, if seaside was isolating those three players (jjj, diiny, espers) because of voting shenanigans he saw, on Day 4, that actually would indicate they were more likely to be town? - threw in a comma
But yeah, aside from the Day being clarified, am I correct or misunderstanding?
This totally happened to me. You are slowly winning me back to thinking you're sane, though. Slowly.Matt F wrote:Unfortunately, my total whack out theories prevent my really good theories from getting any traction, cuz I guess peeps think I'm crazy haha. Remember, it wasn't until Ricochet and others started looking at Mac differently before he was lynched.
However, I will point out, earlier in the game I suspected Mac of being an LC teamie for their discussion on the Nothing but Flowers role, I even asked Mac if I was wrong and he simply said "Yes" (which I wasn't)
and
In an ISO of Black Rock, I suspected her and Long Con of being teamies because of her "I believe BC was in the lead" comment after I was curious who was in the lead, BC or LC, during the late Llama train Day 2.
So I get it right sometimes
You're an intelligent man Epignosis. A civilian was lynched yesterday; why would you vote for someone you think to be the serial killer today?Epignosis wrote:I think you're the SK though.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Also, I hate you.
I love it when someone feels they need to say this.Russtifinko wrote:, and I have nothing to hide..
I thought seaside was a possible mafia member. If you'll recall, I read through his posts and brought him up for discussion yesterday.Epignosis wrote:That's good. Keep going with that.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Funny, because I thought Mac was onto something about you.Epignosis wrote:I think you're the SK though.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Also, I hate you.
You have a fluidity about your posts. "I'm voting seaside, but going to 3J if it doesn't work out." Bobbing and weaving. Going with the current. Now you're voting Russ. You don't sound bad. You sound cereal. Like Frosted Flakes.
A body has to go some time.Metalmarsh89 wrote:You're an intelligent man Epignosis. A civilian was lynched yesterday; why would you vote for someone you think to be the serial killer today?Epignosis wrote:I think you're the SK though.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Also, I hate you.
Or is that your real plan?
Are you sure you're not the PSK?Epignosis wrote:No. I think MacDougall is a co-conspirator with Long Con. I don't think serial killers can be caught in the first half of a game outside of luck, so I don't bother hunting them until Mafia are eliminated.
Second half. Second half.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Oh really?
Are you sure you're not the PSK?Epignosis wrote:No. I think MacDougall is a co-conspirator with Long Con. I don't think serial killers can be caught in the first half of a game outside of luck, so I don't bother hunting them until Mafia are eliminated.
Explain please.Strawhenge wrote:He's either Life During Wartime or Psycho Killer. Vote him immediately.
Mafia isn't eliminated.Epignosis wrote:Second half. Second half.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Oh really?
Are you sure you're not the PSK?Epignosis wrote:No. I think MacDougall is a co-conspirator with Long Con. I don't think serial killers can be caught in the first half of a game outside of luck, so I don't bother hunting them until Mafia are eliminated.
Never said you've been going after me (although you have lightly, on and off).Epignosis wrote:"Tunnelly?"
Name the last time I voted you.
Name the last time I questioned you.
Name the last time I went after you.
You're about to all three wishes.
Great. Yes I knew what you were referring to, what I objected to was you coming in out of nowhere and pretending to be certain about something. Going and actually doing it now seems like busywork but ok do you see the difference between what I'm suggesting and what Mac was suggesting? Mac thinks lynching Sorsha will leave behind all these clues he's super eager to get into, I'm suggesting lynching JJJ crosses him off the list the end. No more bickering about whether he's scum or town or what because look it's happening again today "JJJ should still be on the table for a lynch", "what do we think about JJJ?" over and over.Russtifinko wrote:motel room wrote:Nah you should quote it cos I don't like you dropping into the thread after no content and trying to drum up shit without context.Russtifinko wrote:To be more precise: esplain the part where you think JJJ will flip town, but you're happy to remove the doubt by lynching him. I recall Mac saying something very similar, I think about Sorsha. (Would quote, but have you seen that dude's post history?)
I'm not sure how I can further explain it. I think JJJ may be town and made the same mistaken judgement on mac as I did. I'm not confident enough to fight his lynch and can see benefit from him as a lynch contender being removed from further chatter. He has even said the same thing himself. Why is me thinking this so suspicious to you, specifically?Fine. Found it. Not sure why you felt the need to have me do that. (It's near the top of page 9 of his post history, btw.)MacDougall wrote:I think we really have to lynch sorsha. I feel like it's the key to breaking the game open today. She either flips scum and leaves behind a tasty breadcrumb trail, or flips town and leaves behind a tasty breadcrumb trail. Trusting Golden again seems like a nice way to get another townie killed. We've got a scum dead inside the first four days in a large game. We can afford a tactical lynch. Sorsha is a good lynch candidate for up front scum play as well as being the best possible lynch from a tactical perspective. Short of someone saying "I am scum" my vote won't be changing today.
This response is terrible imo. You're really debating the point that Mac expressed a willingness to vote Sorsha even if she was civ? It's right there in the thread! And then you say I'm "trying to drum up shit" when, again, Mac's point was well documented as a major point of suspicion that Day.
Finally, you double down on your "JJJ is civ, but we should still lynch him anyway" idea. It's this simple: lynching civs is NOT worth it. We're losing! Someone (Rico?) said we have 4 days to get at least one baddie, or game over. Wasting one of those days lynching someone you think is good should be repulsive to you. At least Mac made up some bullshit about wanting info! You don't even say we'd get anything out of JJJ being lynched. You want someone you say is civvie to die so that we can stop discussing him as a potential lynch candidate??? The POINT of the game is to discuss people as potential lynch candidates!
I am overreacting, or is this the least civ mindset all game? I'm down to vote motel room again, with Matt this time. I'm more sure about him than JJJ.
I don't give a shit about what is and isn't a NO U. And here you are misrepresenting again what I said. I didn't go after you because you said "deliberately." I went after you because you said "deliberately misinterpreted," when I didn't do that.Russtifinko wrote:Never said you've been going after me (although you have lightly, on and off).Epignosis wrote:"Tunnelly?"
Name the last time I voted you.
Name the last time I questioned you.
Name the last time I went after you.
You're about to all three wishes.
tunnelly (tə' nə lē): lacking a sufficiently broad focus; being so set in an outdated mindset as to preclude assimilation of new information
You're on me because I said "deliberately" on Day 1. Which by the way is a NO U, since it was in response to me going after you that Day. You seem very concerned with the word-mincing.
Linki: Hmmm, how surprising the motel room suddenly agrees with Epi and MM that I look bad, now that my suspicion of him is gaining traction. Oh, wait, check that, it's not.
Double Linki: Strawhenge, what? Haha, you can't just hop into the thread, tell us to vote someone, and reasonably expect us to follow without giving us a reason why. What is going on with people? Is your reason "info dumping"? Because Choutas tried that yesterday, and it was a major factor in a civ being lynched.
He may be bobbing and weaving, but I think you are as well. I don't get why you have all of a sudden backed away form JJJ. Can you explain?Epignosis wrote:That's good. Keep going with that.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Funny, because I thought Mac was onto something about you.Epignosis wrote:I think you're the SK though.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Also, I hate you.
You have a fluidity about your posts. "I'm voting seaside, but going to 3J if it doesn't work out." Bobbing and weaving. Going with the current. Now you're voting Russ. You don't sound bad. You sound cereal. Like Frosted Flakes.
If you want to accuse me, you must use evidence from the thread that everyone can see.Strawhenge wrote:If I answer the question about 'info dumping,' is that info dumping?
I'm not trying to dodge anything.Elohcin wrote:He may be bobbing and weaving, but I think you are as well. I don't get why you have all of a sudden backed away form JJJ. Can you explain?Epignosis wrote:That's good. Keep going with that.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Funny, because I thought Mac was onto something about you.Epignosis wrote:I think you're the SK though.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Also, I hate you.
You have a fluidity about your posts. "I'm voting seaside, but going to 3J if it doesn't work out." Bobbing and weaving. Going with the current. Now you're voting Russ. You don't sound bad. You sound cereal. Like Frosted Flakes.
which indicates I could completely lynch 3J, but I'm not sure.Epignosis wrote:If I had two lynches as of this moment, they'd go to 3J and Russ.