Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 6]
Posted: Thu Mar 03, 2016 2:18 am
We're 2 for 2 with lurker lynches, let's kill Floyd.
i already explained that to you earlier, i legitimately felt offended by what you said to meDom wrote:Sprit why did you attempt to discredit me by saying I was rude and mean (a tactic already tried in this game against me)?
as i just read what Mac said "we're 2 for 2" on the lurkers. so, Floyd is my go to.Dom wrote:RIP Scotty.
Sprit, who do you think should be lynched today?
I'd feel a lot better about you if you had thoughts on literally anything other than lynching inactives.sprityo wrote:as i just read what Mac said "we're 2 for 2" on the lurkers. so, Floyd is my go to.Dom wrote:RIP Scotty.
Sprit, who do you think should be lynched today?
look the best part is, once we get through with them, my turn is coming, since yknow i have relatively low posts coupled with mild suspicion from some people for, idk? me being me?
well of course not, but then again, maybe im just being lazy againTurnip Head wrote:Have you already won the game?
I feel ok about Glorfindel, like thats his style. I could be wrong and he may have me fooled, but he reminds me of Star Wars mafia where he felt just slightly ruffled by people suggesting he was bad when he wasn't in a similar way to what he has done here.Turnip Head wrote:I wanna say a sabie teammate might have thrown in the towel at some point but I feel pretty good about all the sabie votes. What do we think of Glofy's vote for MM? He did that thing again where he brings a case forth and votes for it all in the same breath after spending the rest of the day not talking about his reads.
He was bad in Star Wars.Golden wrote:I feel ok about Glorfindel, like thats his style. I could be wrong and he may have me fooled, but he reminds me of Star Wars mafia where he felt just slightly ruffled by people suggesting he was bad when he wasn't in a similar way to what he has done here.Turnip Head wrote:I wanna say a sabie teammate might have thrown in the towel at some point but I feel pretty good about all the sabie votes. What do we think of Glofy's vote for MM? He did that thing again where he brings a case forth and votes for it all in the same breath after spending the rest of the day not talking about his reads.
Oh this sounds fun. Do I get to pick the player?sprityo wrote:tell you what TH, you've got me interested, ill provide you the best possible read for a single person i can, even though ive kept zero personal notes on anyone
Oh, I forgot he was bad. Well then, consider my suspicion of Glorfindel reignited.Turnip Head wrote:He was bad in Star Wars.Golden wrote:I feel ok about Glorfindel, like thats his style. I could be wrong and he may have me fooled, but he reminds me of Star Wars mafia where he felt just slightly ruffled by people suggesting he was bad when he wasn't in a similar way to what he has done here.Turnip Head wrote:I wanna say a sabie teammate might have thrown in the towel at some point but I feel pretty good about all the sabie votes. What do we think of Glofy's vote for MM? He did that thing again where he brings a case forth and votes for it all in the same breath after spending the rest of the day not talking about his reads.Check out his posts in Pikmin for what a civ Glorfindel could look like.
I've been asking people for days to look at Glorfy's ISO in Pikmin. IMO it is nothing like what we're seeing here.Golden wrote:Oh, I forgot he was bad. Well then, consider my suspicion of Glorfindel reignited.Turnip Head wrote:He was bad in Star Wars.Golden wrote:I feel ok about Glorfindel, like thats his style. I could be wrong and he may have me fooled, but he reminds me of Star Wars mafia where he felt just slightly ruffled by people suggesting he was bad when he wasn't in a similar way to what he has done here.Turnip Head wrote:I wanna say a sabie teammate might have thrown in the towel at some point but I feel pretty good about all the sabie votes. What do we think of Glofy's vote for MM? He did that thing again where he brings a case forth and votes for it all in the same breath after spending the rest of the day not talking about his reads.Check out his posts in Pikmin for what a civ Glorfindel could look like.
I still feel worse right now about SVS and sprit, though.
This is something I wanted to talk about. Seems Typh asked this question behind the scenes. Why would a civilian care what the answer to this question is, and why wouldn't they just ask it in the thread?Typhoony wrote:The Penguin can choose where the info will be sent to btw.
Cue typh is Penguin posts.
Lol. What? It's not like I gave anything away, I thought this was already heavily implied "knowledge" already in the thread?Turnip Head wrote:Matt... wtf
I just don't know what your aim is. I think you'd be more successful if you didn't play solely on your own terms. We're all trying to figure out the game together and you're off in la la land.Matt wrote:Lol. What? It's not like I gave anything away, I thought this was already heavily implied "knowledge" already in the thread?Turnip Head wrote:Matt... wtf
So you think MP is good to go then?
I mean, no offense meant, but I haven't even found time to do the isos I'd like to in THIS thread.Turnip Head wrote:I've been asking people for days to look at Glorfy's ISO in Pikmin. IMO it is nothing like what we're seeing here.Golden wrote:Oh, I forgot he was bad. Well then, consider my suspicion of Glorfindel reignited.Turnip Head wrote:He was bad in Star Wars.Golden wrote:I feel ok about Glorfindel, like thats his style. I could be wrong and he may have me fooled, but he reminds me of Star Wars mafia where he felt just slightly ruffled by people suggesting he was bad when he wasn't in a similar way to what he has done here.Turnip Head wrote:I wanna say a sabie teammate might have thrown in the towel at some point but I feel pretty good about all the sabie votes. What do we think of Glofy's vote for MM? He did that thing again where he brings a case forth and votes for it all in the same breath after spending the rest of the day not talking about his reads.Check out his posts in Pikmin for what a civ Glorfindel could look like.
I still feel worse right now about SVS and sprit, though.
Or... the Penguin sent info to Typh, and it was someone who is not his mortal enemy?Turnip Head wrote:This is something I wanted to talk about. Seems Typh asked this question behind the scenes. Why would a civilian care what the answer to this question is, and why wouldn't they just ask it in the thread?Typhoony wrote:The Penguin can choose where the info will be sent to btw.
Cue typh is Penguin posts.
Can someone please go back to Day 4 in their Delorean and bring Matt back.Matt wrote:RIP Scotty
Question for anyone/everyone - Are you personally under the impression that MP is Wonder Boy?
I'm not saying there aren't good answers, I just wanna see what Typh has to say. I have no read on him.Golden wrote:Or... the Penguin sent info to Typh, and it was someone who is not his mortal enemy?Turnip Head wrote:This is something I wanted to talk about. Seems Typh asked this question behind the scenes. Why would a civilian care what the answer to this question is, and why wouldn't they just ask it in the thread?Typhoony wrote:The Penguin can choose where the info will be sent to btw.
Cue typh is Penguin posts.
Sorry. I would have kept it to myself if it didn't seem like your point was directed at everyone.Turnip Head wrote:I'm not saying there aren't good answers, I just wanna see what Typh has to say. I have no read on him.Golden wrote:Or... the Penguin sent info to Typh, and it was someone who is not his mortal enemy?Turnip Head wrote:This is something I wanted to talk about. Seems Typh asked this question behind the scenes. Why would a civilian care what the answer to this question is, and why wouldn't they just ask it in the thread?Typhoony wrote:The Penguin can choose where the info will be sent to btw.
Cue typh is Penguin posts.
Lol no worries. I did word it like it was an open discussion. But I'm mainly looking for Typh's input. It just seemed like a weird little thing.Golden wrote:That sounded way more passive than I meant it to.
Maybe I missed it, but why doesn't anyone think Wilgy could be Robin?Turnip Head wrote:I just don't know what your aim is. I think you'd be more successful if you didn't play solely on your own terms. We're all trying to figure out the game together and you're off in la la land.Matt wrote:Lol. What? It's not like I gave anything away, I thought this was already heavily implied "knowledge" already in the thread?Turnip Head wrote:Matt... wtf
So you think MP is good to go then?
Try an ISO of MP. It could be the 15 posts where he basically says 'I'm not saying I'm Robin, I'm just demonstrating why you should exclude all other possibilities, and demonstrating how I've set it up so that I could prove I was Robin (even though I'm not saying I was Robin) since a very long time ago, when I stopped Scotty from dying and learned his role (but I'm not saying I was Robin)'Matt wrote:Maybe I missed it, but why doesn't anyone think Wilgy could be Robin?
Unlike some of you, I have a full time job and other commitments that mean I can't spend every waking minute here. I do my best to contribute to this game and again, unlike some of you I am uncomfortable lynching a fellow player without some semblance of a case against them. I'd like to think that especailly as we get deeper into these games I prefer to substantiate my lynch with a case based on at least some kind of loose logic and to do so takes time. You may not have seen this from me because I think this is a personal best for me reaching Day 6 in one of your games but like it or not, it's how I roll.Turnip Head wrote:I wanna say a sabie teammate might have thrown in the towel at some point but I feel pretty good about all the sabie votes. What do we think of Glofy's vote for MM? He did that thing again where he brings a case forth and votes for it all in the same breath after spending the rest of the day not talking about his reads.
When you felt discredited by me, that was not okay.sprityo wrote:i already explained that to you earlier, i legitimately felt offended by what you said to meDom wrote:Sprit why did you attempt to discredit me by saying I was rude and mean (a tactic already tried in this game against me)?
Epi would have a field day with this.sprityo wrote:quite honestly turnip, im just so freakin lazy. like i'd have to sit down out of my 4 hours i get to personal time out of the week to actually build a case on someone, and im just a terrible player for it, dont get me wrong, i could do it but like, i dont really need to in this game anymore? i mean cause ~reasons to be revealed upon death~
When did you get so judgmental? When did your politeness turn into a sour attitude about working? I student teach, have two jobs, take two classes, and have a social life. I post here too. It does not make me better than any one else who posts here. So, this lashing out is very suspect to me.Glorfindel wrote:Unlike some of you, I have a full time job and other commitments that mean I can't spend every waking minute here. I do my best to contribute to this game and again, unlike some of you I am uncomfortable lynching a fellow player without some semblance of a case against them. I'd like to think that especailly as we get deeper into these games I prefer to substantiate my lynch with a case based on at least some kind of loose logic and to do so takes time. You may not have seen this from me because I think this is a personal best for me reaching Day 6 in one of your games but like it or not, it's how I roll.Turnip Head wrote:I wanna say a sabie teammate might have thrown in the towel at some point but I feel pretty good about all the sabie votes. What do we think of Glofy's vote for MM? He did that thing again where he brings a case forth and votes for it all in the same breath after spending the rest of the day not talking about his reads.
How ironic after you said this earlier in the game my friend...Golden wrote:Oh, I forgot he was bad. Well then, consider my suspicion of Glorfindel reignited.Turnip Head wrote:He was bad in Star Wars.Golden wrote:I feel ok about Glorfindel, like thats his style. I could be wrong and he may have me fooled, but he reminds me of Star Wars mafia where he felt just slightly ruffled by people suggesting he was bad when he wasn't in a similar way to what he has done here.Turnip Head wrote:I wanna say a sabie teammate might have thrown in the towel at some point but I feel pretty good about all the sabie votes. What do we think of Glofy's vote for MM? He did that thing again where he brings a case forth and votes for it all in the same breath after spending the rest of the day not talking about his reads.Check out his posts in Pikmin for what a civ Glorfindel could look like.
I still feel worse right now about SVS and sprit, though.
Let me tell you, your credibility with me (as an individual, unrelated to this game) has taken a serious blow as a consequence of this. Let me tell you what this says to me. It says that like other players here, you're always going to support the more experienced players here over someone newer like me. The fact is, it's easier to dismiss the arguments of a newer player over those to whom you've had a lot of game exposure. That much is undeniable and you do so at your peril. I am convinced of the veracity of my argument from the last Day phase and intend to pursue that case for the remainder of this Day phase unless I can be convinced otherwise.Golden wrote:@glorf - You and sprit are new, and so is nerolunar, but I don't think any of you are being suspected for being new. Nero was correctly identified as bad. You were (perhaps erroneously) taking votes for your apparent Two Face claim, which you've since defended against and don't seem on the block today.
Sprit is playing his second game here, and some people have identified he is playing differently.
Putting that aside, I think almost any new player normally gets a small period of grace (one or two games) and then goes through a rough patch where they get incorrectly lynched because people think they have now got a handle on what kind of player they are and see them 'playing differently'. It certainly happened to me. Your point is fair in that sense...
Happy to do my best to get your name right.sprityo wrote:Mac has a point though in what loran just quoted, to have a wagon on me after having no previous momentum/suspicion, would look incredibly terrible on the people who voted me
Okay not "incredibly terrible" but "scummy."
I think this is a good idea.DharmaHelper wrote:It's mad late and I promise I'll do the legwork of this at some point but check this shit out:
I bet if we cross reference the list of players who voted to go to locations other than the ones sabie went to with the list of say, Mac or Sprityo or w/e voter, we will end up with a pretty meaty case for her teammate(s).
Even if the result includes me. I know it's not me that's bad, though. Looking at the fuller list there's a lot of overlap in our choices over time--I'd be interested in seeing a fuller picture of the overlap of choices between players.DharmaHelper wrote:Turns out that was a short list.
LoRab
Matt
SVS
I agree on sprityo. I disagree on me.MacDougall wrote:Let's lynch spirityo as well
And lorab. Especially lorab.
You, probably more than anyone, knows how much I hate getting in trouble with MP. But OK.Dom wrote:If we're talking about SVS, I think we should talk about whether or not her emotional lashing out over Mac's role claim indicates she is bad. She voted for Mac right before he claimed. She might be lashing out as a reaction of now potentially looking bad. I know SVS HATES role claims (so do I, and their use in this game does not look to be stopping), but she was a bit manipulative with her posts.
http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 33#p237533
http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 38#p237538
These two posts are what I'm talking about.
Now, this is not NEARLY has manipulative or guilt trip inducing as posts in A World Reborn (I'm thinking of the sad bear post), so I'm not nearly as convinced. What do we think of this?
If I had to pick who might be Sabie's teammate(s) between LoRab and SVS, I'd say maybe SVS. Between those two and Matt? I'm not liking Matt these days. I think Glorfindel is acting very bad and sprit is bad too.
So you don't have the "lynching me is not lynching mafia" primary reason to fight back?S~V~S wrote:You, probably more than anyone, knows how much I hate getting in trouble with MP. But OK.Dom wrote:If we're talking about SVS, I think we should talk about whether or not her emotional lashing out over Mac's role claim indicates she is bad. She voted for Mac right before he claimed. She might be lashing out as a reaction of now potentially looking bad. I know SVS HATES role claims (so do I, and their use in this game does not look to be stopping), but she was a bit manipulative with her posts.
http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 33#p237533
http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 38#p237538
These two posts are what I'm talking about.
Now, this is not NEARLY has manipulative or guilt trip inducing as posts in A World Reborn (I'm thinking of the sad bear post), so I'm not nearly as convinced. What do we think of this?
If I had to pick who might be Sabie's teammate(s) between LoRab and SVS, I'd say maybe SVS. Between those two and Matt? I'm not liking Matt these days. I think Glorfindel is acting very bad and sprit is bad too.
Go ahead and lynch me. I won't fight back. I have no reason to.
I won't take any beer, but I'll gladly bring my own wine.MacDougall wrote:Hey Dom, I'm just bout to settle down and scum hunt some, want to share some chips and beers?
That isn't what I said and not the post I referenced.S~V~S wrote:You, probably more than anyone, knows how much I hate getting in trouble with MP. But OK.Dom wrote:If we're talking about SVS, I think we should talk about whether or not her emotional lashing out over Mac's role claim indicates she is bad. She voted for Mac right before he claimed. She might be lashing out as a reaction of now potentially looking bad. I know SVS HATES role claims (so do I, and their use in this game does not look to be stopping), but she was a bit manipulative with her posts.
http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 33#p237533
http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 38#p237538
These two posts are what I'm talking about.
Now, this is not NEARLY has manipulative or guilt trip inducing as posts in A World Reborn (I'm thinking of the sad bear post), so I'm not nearly as convinced. What do we think of this?
If I had to pick who might be Sabie's teammate(s) between LoRab and SVS, I'd say maybe SVS. Between those two and Matt? I'm not liking Matt these days. I think Glorfindel is acting very bad and sprit is bad too.
Go ahead and lynch me. I won't fight back. I have no reason to.
I am not, but this is a game and yet another game where I argue with people over what my emotional reactions mean does not appeal to me at this time.MacDougall wrote:So you don't have the "lynching me is not lynching mafia" primary reason to fight back?S~V~S wrote:You, probably more than anyone, knows how much I hate getting in trouble with MP. But OK.Dom wrote:If we're talking about SVS, I think we should talk about whether or not her emotional lashing out over Mac's role claim indicates she is bad. She voted for Mac right before he claimed. She might be lashing out as a reaction of now potentially looking bad. I know SVS HATES role claims (so do I, and their use in this game does not look to be stopping), but she was a bit manipulative with her posts.
http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 33#p237533
http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 38#p237538
These two posts are what I'm talking about.
Now, this is not NEARLY has manipulative or guilt trip inducing as posts in A World Reborn (I'm thinking of the sad bear post), so I'm not nearly as convinced. What do we think of this?
If I had to pick who might be Sabie's teammate(s) between LoRab and SVS, I'd say maybe SVS. Between those two and Matt? I'm not liking Matt these days. I think Glorfindel is acting very bad and sprit is bad too.
Go ahead and lynch me. I won't fight back. I have no reason to.