Re: Mafia Misplay Mafia
Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2022 11:33 pm
i am going to vote hk because esooa did
*sip* agreedSabiplz wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 8:35 pmHe was obvtown after he dropped the gimmickEsooa wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 8:28 pmJack wasn't obvious town lolhollowkatt wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 8:26 pmShould have been the D1. Should have been the D2 (if you want to protect thread health. We got Mac so that's good and it's fine that I didn't go). Should have been the D3 but instead you all killed Obvs Town Jack.risiinq- wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 8:21 pm i mean, hk, i really wished we just resolved u d3
i felt so bad after i saw the jack flip
i acknowledge that because of my misplay i will need to be resolved as well since me alive is -ev, and i really dont have the energy to convince people, for a while, that i'm town, to escape death, before just getting suspected again
so we go down together and then they can start doing the serious wolfhunting, since honestly i think finding the last wolf is gonna be hard, or the last two if you arent wolf - since they're both very deep
Now, I am all out of fucks and it's too late to "resolve" the D1 wagons. If you think I am a wolf fine, vote for me. If your argument is "we really need to resolve HK" let me remind you that we're currently at 9 alive, 7-2
killing me today is 6-2, NK is 5-2. That means you need to hit a wolf tomorrow, and I don't think that you will, or D5 is lylo and I'm betting big on town losing this game.
You had your chance to "resolve", now you have to hunt a wolf and I'm not it and haven't been since basically the middle of D1. Nanook was tunneled and frankly bad at reading. Don't also be bad at reading.
I was actually thinking exactly the same thing earlier lol, especially the bolded. I don't really think it's both of them because I'm p sure HK is a wolf but one of those two being a wolf with HK makes the most sense for the OW nk1. So yea, don't rly think it's this exactly but rly towny thought from you. What do you think of HK?Neon wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 1:27 am Like okay Mac was the bait when it became obvious he was going over
Santy is power woofing
Lily is going deep
Santy built a vest of kevlar and pockets Riis but is able to keep safe and the focus is still on Riis. Lily has Esooa pocketed.
Santys behavior completely changes when it becomes obvious Mac is gonna flip at some point suddenly Santy is invested building cases pushing those cases very loudly forward. Insisting that the Mac pelt belongs where it does not. Shading me but never actually pushing me forward.
Lily is disengaged but present but one thing I noticed was the complete discrepancy in the treatment of HKs blow up vs Macs afair. Lily has been pretty safe all game.
Your post earlier about just voting HK cause I was I was ehh on is part of it. I thought the stuff yesterday about not really caring and wanting anyone dead was alright but today it kinda feels like the same even though we killed a town yesterday
It's the same as before. Jack/hk/ris had a wolf. Now it's hk/ris. I will vote with consensus cuz I'm none the wiser of which is the wolf.Esooa wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 1:57 amYour post earlier about just voting HK cause I was I was ehh on is part of it. I thought the stuff yesterday about not really caring and wanting anyone dead was alright but today it kinda feels like the same even though we killed a town yesterday
Maybe more of what you're thinking rn would be nice
You don't have any thoughts as to which?Lilypetal wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 1:58 amIt's the same as before. Jack/hk/ris had a wolf. Now it's hk/ris. I will vote with consensus cuz I'm none the wiser of which is the wolf.Esooa wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 1:57 amYour post earlier about just voting HK cause I was I was ehh on is part of it. I thought the stuff yesterday about not really caring and wanting anyone dead was alright but today it kinda feels like the same even though we killed a town yesterday
Maybe more of what you're thinking rn would be nice
Like the way this is posted felt a little off to me is all. You were wanting to discuss the Nanook NK, which is valid ofc, and I did, I think it means HK is very likely wolf just on it's own. But after I post that, you don't really think HK is a wolf or you agreed with it, or post anything else about the NK to engage, just say you're sheeping
Probs hk over snow? Lots of worlds buzzing in my mind. Harkens back to the thought that day 2 was w/w and they'd just try to go deeper with whoever lived. Also In a santy w world snow is town.Esooa wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 1:59 amYou don't have any thoughts as to which?Lilypetal wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 1:58 amIt's the same as before. Jack/hk/ris had a wolf. Now it's hk/ris. I will vote with consensus cuz I'm none the wiser of which is the wolf.Esooa wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 1:57 amYour post earlier about just voting HK cause I was I was ehh on is part of it. I thought the stuff yesterday about not really caring and wanting anyone dead was alright but today it kinda feels like the same even though we killed a town yesterday
Maybe more of what you're thinking rn would be nice
Do you think that "off" is a disengaged/disinterested lily or a wolf lily? The answer is obvious imoEsooa wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 2:01 amLike the way this is posted felt a little off to me is all. You were wanting to discuss the Nanook NK, which is valid ofc, and I did, I think it means HK is very likely wolf just on it's own. But after I post that, you don't really think HK is a wolf or you agreed with it, or post anything else about the NK to engage, just say you're sheeping
Lilypetal wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 2:02 amDo you think that "off" is a disengaged/disinterested lily or a wolf lily? The answer is obvious imoEsooa wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 2:01 amLike the way this is posted felt a little off to me is all. You were wanting to discuss the Nanook NK, which is valid ofc, and I did, I think it means HK is very likely wolf just on it's own. But after I post that, you don't really think HK is a wolf or you agreed with it, or post anything else about the NK to engage, just say you're sheeping
That's fineEsooa wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 2:04 amLilypetal wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 2:02 amDo you think that "off" is a disengaged/disinterested lily or a wolf lily? The answer is obvious imoEsooa wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 2:01 amLike the way this is posted felt a little off to me is all. You were wanting to discuss the Nanook NK, which is valid ofc, and I did, I think it means HK is very likely wolf just on it's own. But after I post that, you don't really think HK is a wolf or you agreed with it, or post anything else about the NK to engage, just say you're sheeping![]()
I think it could be wolf, it's at least worth mentioning
ok if it isn't hk or snow then who is it? do you think the kills actually point to hk or is it just the best option you have to choose from that you're hoping makes sense?Esooa wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 8:18 pmand obviously snow does that nk insteadhollowkatt wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 8:14 pmserious question:
do you really, really really think I kill Achro AND Nanook in this game?
Achro has seen my wolf game, he found me in ONE post in our champs qualifier. ONE post. It took literally everything I had to keep him off my back on D1 and then I killed him N1.
Nanook has seen my wolf game, was consistently on me all game long, did NOT have the thread pull to actually get me over the line. Why do I kill him and solidify that read?
I keep him alive, keep him impotent, keep him focused on me, not looking for a partner, not allowing others to go through his posts looking for my partners.
It never ever makes sense for me to be a wolf just by NKA
Yes I think it points to HK and that he's a wolf, idc the rest of itPorscha wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 2:05 amok if it isn't hk or snow then who is it? do you think the kills actually point to hk or is it just the best option you have to choose from that you're hoping makes sense?Esooa wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 8:18 pmand obviously snow does that nk insteadhollowkatt wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 8:14 pmserious question:
do you really, really really think I kill Achro AND Nanook in this game?
Achro has seen my wolf game, he found me in ONE post in our champs qualifier. ONE post. It took literally everything I had to keep him off my back on D1 and then I killed him N1.
Nanook has seen my wolf game, was consistently on me all game long, did NOT have the thread pull to actually get me over the line. Why do I kill him and solidify that read?
I keep him alive, keep him impotent, keep him focused on me, not looking for a partner, not allowing others to go through his posts looking for my partners.
It never ever makes sense for me to be a wolf just by NKA
I wasn't serious with it just figured I'd join in on the I'd never kill Achro posting
If HK is town then Nanook is contributing to killing a town and not doing much of anything else, and then is ML'able himself. I don't see how Nanook is the wolf teams highest priority in that world ever
nah don't give me that kind of attitude I really don't believe yourisiinq- wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 8:32 pmhe was not likely town to me at all. sorry if i had a bad read.Porscha wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 8:31 pmHe was likely town. Jack ONLY went over because snow came back and criedEsooa wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 8:28 pmJack wasn't obvious town lolhollowkatt wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 8:26 pmShould have been the D1. Should have been the D2 (if you want to protect thread health. We got Mac so that's good and it's fine that I didn't go). Should have been the D3 but instead you all killed Obvs Town Jack.risiinq- wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 8:21 pm i mean, hk, i really wished we just resolved u d3
i felt so bad after i saw the jack flip
i acknowledge that because of my misplay i will need to be resolved as well since me alive is -ev, and i really dont have the energy to convince people, for a while, that i'm town, to escape death, before just getting suspected again
so we go down together and then they can start doing the serious wolfhunting, since honestly i think finding the last wolf is gonna be hard, or the last two if you arent wolf - since they're both very deep
Now, I am all out of fucks and it's too late to "resolve" the D1 wagons. If you think I am a wolf fine, vote for me. If your argument is "we really need to resolve HK" let me remind you that we're currently at 9 alive, 7-2
killing me today is 6-2, NK is 5-2. That means you need to hit a wolf tomorrow, and I don't think that you will, or D5 is lylo and I'm betting big on town losing this game.
You had your chance to "resolve", now you have to hunt a wolf and I'm not it and haven't been since basically the middle of D1. Nanook was tunneled and frankly bad at reading. Don't also be bad at reading.
that's a yolk and a half ma'amLilypetal wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 2:11 am I think the problem is that especially with the jack flip Nanook should've been the most consensus town in the game outside of Sabi who wolves clearly don't want to kill. The nanook kill just makes sense out of context as well. Like idk would nanook be MLed? Maybe people swing to a SR when HK flips V but idk. Nanook is a good player and I don't see who else dies
this is a bold take. continue
we killed a wolf and then we killed the guy who was more town than at least 3 other players being talked about in a day with no conversation until the last hour of the day
Nanook is almost always ML'able IMO unless he like obviously kills a wolf just cause he's easy to say he's a wolf when he doesn't post much/isn't very transparentLilypetal wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 2:11 am I think the problem is that especially with the jack flip Nanook should've been the most consensus town in the game outside of Sabi who wolves clearly don't want to kill. The nanook kill just makes sense out of context as well. Like idk would nanook be MLed? Maybe people swing to a SR when HK flips V but idk. Nanook is a good player and I don't see who else dies
This is a stretch. Jack was playing townier but had reasons to do so as either alignment. I literally flipped a coin for who I was gonna vote though so I'm part of the problem
i'm probably just salty that I let some ne'er do wells convince me against my better judgmentLilypetal wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 2:15 amThis is a stretch. Jack was playing townier but had reasons to do so as either alignment. I literally flipped a coin for who I was gonna vote though so I'm part of the problem
I guess but he was generally being consensus townread last day phase and I think we all understood the lack of agenda in his HK push. Feel like every other slot in the game can also be manipulated just as much ig. You're probs right though and we just had 2 wolves caught day 2Esooa wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 2:15 amNanook is almost always ML'able IMO unless he like obviously kills a wolf just cause he's easy to say he's a wolf when he doesn't post much/isn't very transparentLilypetal wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 2:11 am I think the problem is that especially with the jack flip Nanook should've been the most consensus town in the game outside of Sabi who wolves clearly don't want to kill. The nanook kill just makes sense out of context as well. Like idk would nanook be MLed? Maybe people swing to a SR when HK flips V but idk. Nanook is a good player and I don't see who else dies![]()
definitely more so than Sabi for example, and like I said he wasn't really contributing much to this game that wasn't saying HK was a wolf, if wolves don't care about that why do they care to kill him
deep wolf reasons. you're welcomesantygrass wrote: ↑Sun Sep 18, 2022 2:16 am I am town and the personality switch ks just bonkers to note. How I go from 'Oh I am being sussed' and think that is a good plan to rise my WIM alot to bury the wolf who was in a better position than me, rather than the opposite?
Idt that view makes much sense.
Anyways still havent read much lily I will sheep you find me a wolf