The Syndicate

Quin wrote: That's because he's bad. Anybody else would've wondered enough about a cryptic as fuck post to ask if they were in his position.

You know those people on Facebook who annoyingly post brief teasers with no information content specifically so people will ask them to elaborate? (e.g. "Worst day ever") I don't respond to those people.

thellama73 wrote:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:WIFOM time!

I have never attacked someone with the rage a ferocity I've displayed against Long Con as a bad guy in my life. When I lose my mind with baddie hatred I am a civilian. This is a trait Golden and I largely share, I believe.

Yes, that's a good point, and one of my main sticking points about you. Absent the Long Con fight, I think your gameplay would be textbook active baddie, but you kind of went out on a limb there, which seems civ.

What else in my post history strikes you as textbook active baddie?

Quin wrote:

Sorsha wrote:I think Quin and jj could both be bad so I could put my vote on either of them.

Put it on 3J and maybe I won't kill you tonight.

But if I put it on you you'll be lynched and won't be able to kill me anyway

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

thellama73 wrote:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:WIFOM time!

I have never attacked someone with the rage a ferocity I've displayed against Long Con as a bad guy in my life. When I lose my mind with baddie hatred I am a civilian. This is a trait Golden and I largely share, I believe.

Yes, that's a good point, and one of my main sticking points about you. Absent the Long Con fight, I think your gameplay would be textbook active baddie, but you kind of went out on a limb there, which seems civ.

What else in my post history strikes you as textbook active baddie?

Very friendly, trying to make the other players feel good. You've been complimentary to me almost to the point of buddying. It could just be you genuinely being nice (and you are a nice guy), but my point is that it would be a smart way to play if you were bad. Everyone likes you, everyone sees you contributing. A good way to stay in the game a long time. The Long Con thing is out of character for that strategy though.

Sorsha wrote:

Quin wrote:

Sorsha wrote:I think Quin and jj could both be bad so I could put my vote on either of them.

Put it on 3J and maybe I won't kill you tonight.

But if I put it on you you'll be lynched and won't be able to kill me anyway

I've been thwarted

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Epignosis, how does a counter-wagon on Jay sound?

Interesting enough for you?

Linki:

I have already rendered my vote, so I do not feel right endorsing the lynch of someone else. If I had wanted 3J out, I would have voted him.

I really just want your read on him.

You said earlier you were going to operate under the assumption that Jay, llama, Quin, and Long Con were civilian and go from there. Your read of Quin changed; what of the others?

I adopted that perspective from a blend of experience and laziness. When I gained a precise understanding of what Quin was doing, he immediately went into the shit pile. He has placed llama in an indefensible position. Maybe llama is bad and Quin has information on him. I don't know. If that's the case, then I would say Quin handled it badly.

I have no reason to say any of them are good. I would say all of their Day 1 votes look bad, but that's circumstantial this early. They are all having at each other with wanton stubbornness. None of that on its own is enough for my condemnation.

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:WIFOM time!

I have never attacked someone with the rage a ferocity I've displayed against Long Con as a bad guy in my life. When I lose my mind with baddie hatred I am a civilian. This is a trait Golden and I largely share, I believe.

I'll remember next time I'm mafia to exhibit a particular trait of my civilian game and remind everyone of it.

I voted jjj

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

thellama73 wrote:I'm increasingly willing to believe that 3J has been playing a super-helpful, positive baddie game. Not sold on it, but increasingly willing to believe it.

What does this say to you about Quin, who hates my guts?

He didn't suspect you until after the theory of a roleblock came out and that he was the killer. That sort of timing doesn't benefit my read of you.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

thellama73 wrote:I'm increasingly willing to believe that 3J has been playing a super-helpful, positive baddie game. Not sold on it, but increasingly willing to believe it.

What does this say to you about Quin, who hates my guts?

He didn't suspect you until after the theory of a roleblock came out and that he was the killer. That sort of timing doesn't benefit my read of you.

This is wrong. I started to suspect him after he posted his initial feel-good/bad reads on Day 0.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

thellama73 wrote:I'm increasingly willing to believe that 3J has been playing a super-helpful, positive baddie game. Not sold on it, but increasingly willing to believe it.

What does this say to you about Quin, who hates my guts?

He didn't suspect you until after the theory of a roleblock came out and that he was the killer. That sort of timing doesn't benefit my read of you.

I don't understand what you're saying.

Just voted Quin.

thellama73 wrote:

Quin wrote: That's because he's bad. Anybody else would've wondered enough about a cryptic as fuck post to ask if they were in his position.

You know those people on Facebook who annoyingly post brief teasers with no information content specifically so people will ask them to elaborate? (e.g. "Worst day ever") I don't respond to those people.

Me neither.

Also because I'm not on Facebook.

I have come to believe that JJJ is definitely bad. Voted JJJ.

Anyone else considering a vote on JJJ? I don't want to force a tie.

Quin wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

thellama73 wrote:I'm increasingly willing to believe that 3J has been playing a super-helpful, positive baddie game. Not sold on it, but increasingly willing to believe it.

What does this say to you about Quin, who hates my guts?

He didn't suspect you until after the theory of a roleblock came out and that he was the killer. That sort of timing doesn't benefit my read of you.

This is wrong. I started to suspect him after he posted his initial feel-good/bad reads on Day 0.

No, you chatted with him on Day 0, questioned him on Day 1, projected your feelings on him, agree with him about llama, bantered with him, didn't include him in your reads when asked, and finally asked if he was llama's teammate on Day 2.

Sorry, but I don't buy it. You didn't "suspect" Jay until it was an extension of a suspicion of llama.

Any "tie" you perceive is likely to be not a tie, due to a +2 voter and a -1 voter.

Made wrote:Anyone else considering a vote on JJJ? I don't want to force a tie.

It doesn't matter. If you suspect him you should put a vote on him. If not, do it anyway.

In case I kick the bucket, I implore everyone to at least look back at my reads, and my rage against LC, with my role in mind. I think this game might be relatively simple to solve. Cool it with the tinfoil and reassess the game from a calm place.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Quin wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

thellama73 wrote:I'm increasingly willing to believe that 3J has been playing a super-helpful, positive baddie game. Not sold on it, but increasingly willing to believe it.

What does this say to you about Quin, who hates my guts?

He didn't suspect you until after the theory of a roleblock came out and that he was the killer. That sort of timing doesn't benefit my read of you.

This is wrong. I started to suspect him after he posted his initial feel-good/bad reads on Day 0.

No, you chatted with him on Day 0, questioned him on Day 1, projected your feelings on him, agree with him about llama, bantered with him, didn't include him in your reads when asked, and finally asked if he was llama's teammate on Day 2.

Sorry, but I don't buy it. You didn't "suspect" Jay until it was an extension of a suspicion of llama.

Would you believe me if I told you I was hiding my explicit read on him until I had something more substantial to work with?

@Quin, nope! Not at all.

Voting JJJ

I think Vompatti is bad

Metalmarsh89 wrote:@Quin, nope! Not at all.

-shakes fist-

Looks like Marmot gets to be the tie breaker. Which way will he choose? He seems to think both Quin and JJJ are bad. I urge him to vote Quin.

@Scotty: Vompatti is always bad.

Quin wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Quin wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

thellama73 wrote:I'm increasingly willing to believe that 3J has been playing a super-helpful, positive baddie game. Not sold on it, but increasingly willing to believe it.

What does this say to you about Quin, who hates my guts?

He didn't suspect you until after the theory of a roleblock came out and that he was the killer. That sort of timing doesn't benefit my read of you.

This is wrong. I started to suspect him after he posted his initial feel-good/bad reads on Day 0.

No, you chatted with him on Day 0, questioned him on Day 1, projected your feelings on him, agree with him about llama, bantered with him, didn't include him in your reads when asked, and finally asked if he was llama's teammate on Day 2.

Sorry, but I don't buy it. You didn't "suspect" Jay until it was an extension of a suspicion of llama.

Would you believe me if I told you I was hiding my explicit read on him until I had something more substantial to work with?

I don't see why you would do that. Put a knife to his throat and make him talk if you think he's bad. Don't wait for something substantial. Make something substantial. Instead you used your time and energy having at it with llama.

Hey llama, Sorsha's here too.

But I love me a good tie-breaker.

Sorsha already voted.

The epitome of evil incarnate: Long Con

Don't lynch, dummies: Epi, Boom, Sorsha, Marmot, niju

Looks okay to me: llama

Either bad or civilian lost in a tunnel: Quin

Yuck: Wilgy

Low posters: don't be merciful to them

Epignosis wrote:

Quin wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Quin wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

thellama73 wrote:I'm increasingly willing to believe that 3J has been playing a super-helpful, positive baddie game. Not sold on it, but increasingly willing to believe it.

What does this say to you about Quin, who hates my guts?

He didn't suspect you until after the theory of a roleblock came out and that he was the killer. That sort of timing doesn't benefit my read of you.

This is wrong. I started to suspect him after he posted his initial feel-good/bad reads on Day 0.

No, you chatted with him on Day 0, questioned him on Day 1, projected your feelings on him, agree with him about llama, bantered with him, didn't include him in your reads when asked, and finally asked if he was llama's teammate on Day 2.

Sorry, but I don't buy it. You didn't "suspect" Jay until it was an extension of a suspicion of llama.

Would you believe me if I told you I was hiding my explicit read on him until I had something more substantial to work with?

I don't see why you would do that. Put a knife to his throat and make him talk if you think he's bad. Don't wait for something substantial. Make something substantial. Instead you used your time and energy having at it with llama.

Well llama's bad too, so it wasn't a waste of my time and energy.

I put my thoughts into the thread. It's not hard to infer a read from it.

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:The epitome of evil incarnate: Long Con

Don't lynch, dummies: Epi, Boom, Sorsha, Marmot, niju

Looks okay to me: llama

Either bad or civilian lost in a tunnel: Quin

Yuck: Wilgy

Low posters: don't be merciful to them

I agree with this post 100% minus Long Con, so 90% I guess.

thellama73 wrote:Sorsha already voted.

Oh man, pressure's on.

I'll likely vote Quin. I think he's more likely to be mafia than Jay.

Friendly reminder not to trust Boomslang simply because he was the target of the night kill.

I get mislynched so rarely. Oddly therapeutic if it happens. Like a much needed vacation. Good luck civs, I'm still rooting for you.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

thellama73 wrote:Sorsha already voted.

Oh man, pressure's on.

I'll likely vote Quin. I think he's more likely to be mafia than Jay.

I think you should reconsider.

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:I get mislynched so rarely. Oddly therapeutic if it happens. Like a much needed vacation. Good luck civs, I'm still rooting for you.

You're not even dead yet

Could go either way. I'm enjoying the suspense.

Forgot he's playing: Scotty

Quin wrote:I'm enjoying the suspense.

Me too!

Will MM miss the vote I wonder? Less than a minute left.

Will A Person throw a wrench into the poll? Find out next time.

thellama73 wrote:Will MM miss the vote I wonder? Less than a minute left.

Nah, that would ruin my beautiful voting record.

Also, voted Quin.

I hope I've got the vote manipulators on my side

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

thellama73 wrote:Will MM miss the vote I wonder? Less than a minute left.

Nah, that would ruin my beautiful voting record.

You live dangerously, my friend. I like it.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

thellama73 wrote:Sorsha already voted.

Oh man, pressure's on.

I'll likely vote Quin. I think he's more likely to be mafia than Jay.

Quin may be bad, but JJJ is for sure bad. I'd go that way if I were you.

twiddles thumbs

Might make cheese toast. What's in store for everyone else's day?

9pm here... watching A Series of Unfortunate Events. Rye and coke.

Miller in a dinky 8 ounce can. Con artists.