Page 15 of 16

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:49 pm
by Epignosis
I want to mention this post from sign-ups
thellama73 wrote:I'm going to go ahead and predict that the baddies get crushed in this game. I hope I am not among their number.
and add "Neener neener neener." :p

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:51 pm
by Golden
Ricochet wrote:4/6 = 66.66%

God damnit, Golden is the devil incarnate. :|
I admit that right now I have the best winning percentage on RM except for those people who have won 1/1 games.

This will never last, though, Rico. Ultimately, I think you are the more driven player :) so I'll enjoy it while I can, and hand the throne over to you when it is time.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:51 pm
by Elohcin
Mafia -
Dragon D. Luffy
Epignosis
Golden
spacedaisy

Civilians -
Black Rock
Splints
G-Man
Hedge
MetalMarsh
Missing Person
Niju
Rico
Roxy
Llama
Timmer
Turnip Head

Day 1
Missing Votes: Hedge, Missing Person, Turnip Head

Night 1
Anonymous Votes:
Black Rock - Hedgeowl
Splints -
G-Man - Timmer
Hedge -
MetalMarsh - Roxy
Missing Person - Roxy
Niju - Spacedaisy
Rico - Timmer
Roxy - Epi
Llama - Golden
Timmer - Roxy

Question: Is a member of the Mafia was wearing a bow tie? Answer: Yes (DDL)

Night Kill: Ricochet

Day 2
Missing Votes: Black Rock, fingersplints, Hedgeowl, Metalmarsh, Missing Person, Niju, timmer

Night 2
Anonymous Votes:
Black Rock -
Splints - G-Man
G-Man - Epignosis
Hedge -
MetalMarsh - llama
Missing Person -
Niju -
Roxy - G-Man
Llama - G-Man
Timmer -

G-Man was killed. No question was asked.

Night Kill:
G-Man


Day 3
Missing Votes: Hedgeowl, Missing Person, Roxy, spacedaisy

Night 3
Anonymous Votes:
Black Rock - MetalMarsh
Splints -
Hedge -
MetalMarsh - Timmer
Missing Person -
Niju - MetalMarsh
Roxy - Epignosis
Llama - Epignosis
Timmer - MetalMarsh

Question: Is a member of the mafia wearing sunglasses? Answer: Yes. (Golden)

Night Kill:
fingersplints

Day 4

Missing Votes: Hedgeowl, Missing Person

Night 4
Anonymous Votes:
Black Rock -
Hedge -
MetalMarsh - Epi
Niju - Epi
Roxy - Epi
Llama - Roxy
Timmer -

Epi was a member of mafia. No question was asked.

Night Kill:
Roxy

Day 5
Missing Votes: Hedgeowl, timmer

Night 5
Anonymous Votes:
Black Rock -
Hedge -
MetalMarsh -
Niju - Epi
Timmer -

No question as Epi got the most votes for the second time and he is mafia.

Night Kill:
Black Rock

Day 6
Missing Votes: Hedgeowl

**Missing Votes -
- Green = 1 missed vote
- Orange = 2 missed votes
- Purple = 3 or more missed votes and participation score is affected.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:54 pm
by Golden
timmer wrote:After all that... no absentee baddie. I sniffed out Golden on my look back at the Day 1 lynch, but I never saw Epignosis at all.

Nice job, guys!! A well-deserved win!
You really did.

I wanted to NK you last night, because I sensed you would come back and be all over me, but we went with BR because you had been more absent.

And I thought TS had a little more faith in me - I never got a question :(

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:54 pm
by nijuukyugou
K going back to "never trusting anyone again, ever" :P

Good game!

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:55 pm
by Dragon D. Luffy
I TOLD YOU GUYS. I TOLD THE GODAMN TIE WAS GONNA BE MY DOWNFALL :omg:

We shouldn't have killed Ricochet on D1.

Well, I'm not complaining, we won. :beer:

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:56 pm
by Ricochet
Golden wrote:
Ricochet wrote:4/6 = 66.66%

God damnit, Golden is the devil incarnate. :|
I admit that right now I have the best winning percentage on RM except for those people who have won 1/1 games.

This will never last, though, Rico. Ultimately, I think you are the more driven player :) so I'll enjoy it while I can, and hand the throne over to you when it is time.
What's RM? You're still second best behind Nevinera here, if I recall correctly.

And hand me what throne? I'm at 50 now. FIF-TY. And plummeting. :pout:

linki: well, at least my one time nominee was civ. I actually trusted voting timmer back then, despite his switcheroo vote on Spacedaisy catching my eye a bit. I didn't trust almost anyone else enough to earn my vote.

linki#2: yeah, why did you kill me? :sniff: massive WIFOM aside, that is.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:57 pm
by nijuukyugou
Ahh, I missed my Blooper :D

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:57 pm
by Epignosis
nijuukyugou wrote:K going back to "never trusting anyone again, ever" :P

Good game!
Hey! Tanks for dem questions. :feb:

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:57 pm
by Golden
Lol DDL! That's hilarious.

Also, you guys would have been right about killing Roxy night one :D

We were trying to kill the people we thought most likely to get the question. Looks like we nabbed G-Man at the right time. And it's funny that MM's question basically led him straight to 'timmer or golden' at the end there.

linki Ooops, TS, not RM.

And 7/11 = 63.6%. I'm ahead of Nevinera!

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:58 pm
by Ricochet
Night 4
Anonymous Votes:
Black Rock -
Hedge -
MetalMarsh - Epi
Niju - Epi
Roxy - Epi
Llama - Roxy
Timmer -

Epi was a member of mafia. No question was asked.

woow

Night 5
Anonymous Votes:
Black Rock -
Hedge -
MetalMarsh -
Niju - Epi
Timmer -

WOOOOW the fail is strong in here


linki: Bastardo! Well, congrats.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:58 pm
by Epignosis
Dragon D. Luffy wrote:I TOLD YOU GUYS. I TOLD THE GODAMN TIE WAS GONNA BE MY DOWNFALL :omg:

We shouldn't have killed Ricochet on D1.

Well, I'm not complaining, we won. :beer:
:haha:

We were in a to-do over that tie.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:59 pm
by Golden
@Rico - we killed you because we thought you were probably a big long term threat, and because we thought people might vote for you to get the question on night one.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:00 pm
by Ricochet
I didn't catch any hints at the questioning, until Eloh said one would be allowed mention if he was chosen to question or such and MM & Epi started doing that, but I had a feeling the questioning ability didn't work too well.

linki: Well, as long as I gave you a shiver with my Spacedaisy read, I'm ok with that. :slick: I sucked at the rest, just as usual.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:01 pm
by Dragon D. Luffy
@Rico: you were pretty active on night 1, building big posts against llama and all, so we assumed you were a likely receiver of the question. We decided pretty much every kill in the game based on that.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:01 pm
by thellama73
I told you Golden was Mafia! I'm really surprised about Epi though.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:02 pm
by Epignosis
Dragon D. Luffy wrote:@Rico: you were pretty active on night 1, building big posts against llama and all, so we assumed you were a likely receiver of the question. We decided pretty much every kill in the game based on that.
Correct. And it was only happenstance that all of them suspected llama right before they died. So I used that to make llama look bad.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:02 pm
by Dragon D. Luffy
Also lol at MM having the info to take down Golden but never doing it because timmer was alive.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:03 pm
by Epignosis
thellama73 wrote:I told you Golden was Mafia! I'm really surprised about Epi though.
Dude, you had us feeling RUINED. We thought you had info on Golden the entire time, and we strove to lynch you anyway, knowing we would have to deal with the fallout.

Then you posted that you never got a question and we were like, "OH THANK GOD."

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:04 pm
by Ricochet
Dragon D. Luffy wrote:@Rico: you were pretty active on night 1, building big posts against llama and all, so we assumed you were a likely receiver of the question. We decided pretty much every kill in the game based on that.
yeah, never again

well, inadvertedly, all your kills were huge WIFOMs one after the another

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:04 pm
by Golden
thellama73 wrote:I told you Golden was Mafia! I'm really surprised about Epi though.
And I told you I expected you to be lynched, and you got every other vote lol!

The day one vote - I honestly didn't keep it to save DDL, and it was only after I'd cast it that I realised how bad it looked. I really thought it would come back to bite me.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:05 pm
by Golden
Epignosis wrote:
thellama73 wrote:I told you Golden was Mafia! I'm really surprised about Epi though.
Dude, you had us feeling RUINED. We thought you had info on Golden the entire time, and we strove to lynch you anyway, knowing we would have to deal with the fallout.

Then you posted that you never got a question and we were like, "OH THANK GOD."
Oh yeah, I was gearing up for showing why it was that you hadn't got a question. Thanks for making that easier.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:06 pm
by thellama73
Epignosis wrote:
thellama73 wrote:I told you Golden was Mafia! I'm really surprised about Epi though.
Dude, you had us feeling RUINED. We thought you had info on Golden the entire time, and we strove to lynch you anyway, knowing we would have to deal with the fallout.

Then you posted that you never got a question and we were like, "OH THANK GOD."
I was certain that you would never have allowed such obvious NKs. I see I misunderestimated you again. ;)

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:06 pm
by Golden
Dragon D. Luffy wrote:Also lol at MM having the info to take down Golden but never doing it because timmer was alive.
NKing BR was completely the right move. Good job you two!

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:06 pm
by Dragon D. Luffy
Golden played the entire game while only being able to talk to us at 2 times in the day, and not at the phase end.

We had to coordinate the d1 votes and pray for Golden to do the right thing. Thankfully he did. :nicenod:

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:09 pm
by Golden
Hey DDL

You are now eligible for the champs game :)

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:10 pm
by Epignosis
thellama73 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
thellama73 wrote:I told you Golden was Mafia! I'm really surprised about Epi though.
Dude, you had us feeling RUINED. We thought you had info on Golden the entire time, and we strove to lynch you anyway, knowing we would have to deal with the fallout.

Then you posted that you never got a question and we were like, "OH THANK GOD."
I was certain that you would never have allowed such obvious NKs. I see I misunderestimated you again. ;)
Here's a thought: Civilians shouldn't put their cards on the table at night.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:15 pm
by DharmaHelper
thellama73 wrote:I'm going to go ahead and predict that the baddies get crushed in this game. I hope I am not among their number.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:16 pm
by Epignosis
You're slow.
Epignosis wrote:I want to mention this post from sign-ups
thellama73 wrote:I'm going to go ahead and predict that the baddies get crushed in this game. I hope I am not among their number.
and add "Neener neener neener." :p

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:17 pm
by DharmaHelper
If you remember, first is the worst. second is the best.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:19 pm
by Ricochet
If I wouldn't have been a victim of it, all the WIFOM killing spree would have, in principle, made me doubt a bit that Llama is doing it on purpose and that someone else (like Epi :kadaj:) is messing with it, if only he wouldn't continued to do scummy things, like bantering about how the kills are oh so lame. I've never seen him ever make such comments in previous games (where he was civ or indie all the time) and it kept my belief, even from the sidelines, that he has to be bad all the way until he flipped.

Anyway, all of this is perfect WIFOM material for a future game... whichever future game, which is simply ironic.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:21 pm
by Epignosis
Ricochet wrote:If I wouldn't have been a victim of it, all the WIFOM killing spree would have, in principle, made me doubt a bit that Llama is doing it on purpose and that someone else (like Epi :kadaj:) is messing with it, if only he wouldn't continued to do scummy things, like bantering about how the kills are oh so lame. I've never seen him ever make such comments in previous games (where he was civ or indie all the time) and it kept my belief, even from the sidelines, that he has to be bad all the way until he flipped.

Anyway, all of this is perfect WIFOM material for a future game... whichever future game, which is simply ironic.
Thank God llama and I are hosting the next two. :grin:

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:22 pm
by Dragon D. Luffy
Actually the best player in the game was Sockman, who named the entire scum team on d1 to his fiancé without even reading the thread.

Too bad he wasn't actually in the game. :feb:

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:24 pm
by Ricochet
Dragon D. Luffy wrote:Actually the best player in the game was Sockman, who named the entire scum team on d1 to his fiancé without even reading the thread.

Too bad he wasn't actually in the game. :feb:
Figuring out all the socks in Biblical by Day 2.
Blindly naming the entire mafia team on Day 1.

What sorcery is this?

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:25 pm
by thellama73
Ricochet wrote:If I wouldn't have been a victim of it, all the WIFOM killing spree would have, in principle, made me doubt a bit that Llama is doing it on purpose and that someone else (like Epi :kadaj:) is messing with it, if only he wouldn't continued to do scummy things, like bantering about how the kills are oh so lame. I've never seen him ever make such comments in previous games (where he was civ or indie all the time) and it kept my belief, even from the sidelines, that he has to be bad all the way until he flipped.

Anyway, all of this is perfect WIFOM material for a future game... whichever future game, which is simply ironic.
I like to keep people guessing.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:27 pm
by Ricochet
OMG, I would have also been eligible for Roxy's question, had I still been alive! Image

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:29 pm
by Dragon D. Luffy
Exactly, that's why I was complaining about the tie one page ago.

You were my shield in this game.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:30 pm
by Elohcin
DharmaHelper wrote:If you remember, first is the worst. second is the best.
Oh my goodness, I LOLed for real. So who's got the hairy chest?

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:30 pm
by thellama73
Epignosis wrote:
Ricochet wrote:If I wouldn't have been a victim of it, all the WIFOM killing spree would have, in principle, made me doubt a bit that Llama is doing it on purpose and that someone else (like Epi :kadaj:) is messing with it, if only he wouldn't continued to do scummy things, like bantering about how the kills are oh so lame. I've never seen him ever make such comments in previous games (where he was civ or indie all the time) and it kept my belief, even from the sidelines, that he has to be bad all the way until he flipped.

Anyway, all of this is perfect WIFOM material for a future game... whichever future game, which is simply ironic.
Thank God llama and I are hosting the next two. :grin:
Speaking of which, will people please sign up for Frisky Dingo? It's taking forever.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:31 pm
by Ricochet
thellama73 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Ricochet wrote:If I wouldn't have been a victim of it, all the WIFOM killing spree would have, in principle, made me doubt a bit that Llama is doing it on purpose and that someone else (like Epi :kadaj:) is messing with it, if only he wouldn't continued to do scummy things, like bantering about how the kills are oh so lame. I've never seen him ever make such comments in previous games (where he was civ or indie all the time) and it kept my belief, even from the sidelines, that he has to be bad all the way until he flipped.

Anyway, all of this is perfect WIFOM material for a future game... whichever future game, which is simply ironic.
Thank God llama and I are hosting the next two. :grin:
Speaking of which, will people please sign up for Frisky Dingo? It's taking forever.
Since you didn't actually kill me here, I will probably eventually sign up.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:52 pm
by thellama73
Ricochet wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Ricochet wrote:If I wouldn't have been a victim of it, all the WIFOM killing spree would have, in principle, made me doubt a bit that Llama is doing it on purpose and that someone else (like Epi :kadaj:) is messing with it, if only he wouldn't continued to do scummy things, like bantering about how the kills are oh so lame. I've never seen him ever make such comments in previous games (where he was civ or indie all the time) and it kept my belief, even from the sidelines, that he has to be bad all the way until he flipped.

Anyway, all of this is perfect WIFOM material for a future game... whichever future game, which is simply ironic.
Thank God llama and I are hosting the next two. :grin:
Speaking of which, will people please sign up for Frisky Dingo? It's taking forever.
Since you didn't actually kill me here, I will probably eventually sign up.
I know, right? I was actually on your side! Weird.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:54 pm
by Ricochet
Nah, your compliments and your distancing from my entire case wouldn't have made me feel any better about you.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:56 pm
by Golden
Yeah, how did MP name our entire team on day one? That was so :huh:

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 9:01 pm
by Dragon D. Luffy
He had about 1 in 2000 chance of doing it lol

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 9:44 pm
by Spacedaisy
I have no clue but you should have seen my reaction when he did. Something along the lines of, "you fucking cheater, who told you?!?" No one did though. It was the craziest thing I've ever seen.

Forthe record Timmer, my timing of my votes were what screwed me but it was due to my work schedule. And my posts on the day I died were all made before I even knew I was dead. So while correct about golden and I being on a team, I intended to cast my vote hoping to live and if I had I would have continued after golden. But I unknowingly missed the vote and was doomed anyway.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 9:48 pm
by Black Rock
Congratulations. I was going to go after Golden but I was killed a night early. I even tried to leave like I somewhat believed him so maybe he wouldn't kill me. I knew he must be Mafia when Llama turned civ.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 9:53 pm
by G-Man
That was painful to watch play out. Golden, I will now vote for you automatically on Day 1 if there is no obvious baddie slip-up. As with Economics, you being bad only started to make sense to me near the very end. I never pegged Epi as a baddie. Did you guys plan to set up DDL to be steamrolled or did he come by that on his own? Either way, it was the perfect way for Epi and Golden to sink to the bottom of everyone's suspect lists.

I'm glad I was right about DDL and SD but that only helps confirm that I still totally suck as a civvie.

Well done, you two. I am about to pay you the highest compliment I can give in this game: I hate you both. :fist:

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 10:01 pm
by Golden
G-Man wrote:That was painful to watch play out. Golden, I will now vote for you automatically on Day 1 if there is no obvious baddie slip-up. As with Economics, you being bad only started to make sense to me near the very end. I never pegged Epi as a baddie. Did you guys plan to set up DDL to be steamrolled or did he come by that on his own? Either way, it was the perfect way for Epi and Golden to sink to the bottom of everyone's suspect lists.

I'm glad I was right about DDL and SD but that only helps confirm that I still totally suck as a civvie.

Well done, you two. I am about to pay you the highest compliment I can give in this game: I hate you both. :fist:
G-Man, never forget...

I won in economics because you lynched me day one :mafia:

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 10:02 pm
by Dragon D. Luffy
Epi planned to to bus me hard since d1 to gain cred, and I played along. Getting me lynched was not the goal, but we figured out that if I managed to survive long enough it would give Epi enough cred to win us the game in the long term. He was worried the question system would make the game really complicated for us so he wanted to make strategic bussing from the start.

On d2, when I made that slip with G-Man and he voted me, it became clear I was going down. So the team literally threw me under the bus. Again, I just played along.

Golden wasn't bussing me from the start like Epi was, but he did it on d2 after we decided to sacrifice me.

Re: Guess Who? Mafia

Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2015 10:05 pm
by Golden
I don't usually plan to bus teammates. I planned Roxy's bus a bit in economics, but it was only because I wanted to hit the ground running with exactly what I have said as civ, I didn't really realise at the time it would result in her lynch. But in that moment bussing DDL was clearly the right thing to do.

Another funny - more or less the first thing I said in the chatroom was "epi and I don't stand a hope in this game. Our avatars are too obvious. Daisy and DDL, it's on you".