The Syndicate

Polo wrote:This counter bandwagon on DFaraday is making me really suspicious of those who are voting him. Not only sig and Bubbles (who had awful reasons for doing so) but those who voted later, considering Matt has lots of votes.

If DFaraday is lynched and he turns out to be a civ, then there's a chance Matt is mafia and the mafiosos are trying to protect him by having DFaraday take the bullet.

Hahaha.

To MM, Faraday, Scotty

You helped contribute to a civ lynch on Day 1 by voting Bwt (yeah I did too), and you currently all have your votes on me.

Step it up, gentleman.

I'm going to vote Illy for now in case we want to do a surprise attack on her, but I may change it in about 20 minutes depending on what happens with bea/bubbles and DF.

Matt wrote:To MM, Faraday, Scotty

You helped contribute to a civ lynch on Day 1 by voting Bwt (yeah I did too), and you currently all have your votes on me.

Step it up, gentleman.

I'm going to vote Illy for now in case we want to do a surprise attack on her, but I may change it in about 20 minutes depending on what happens with bea/bubbles and DF.

I suppose instead, I should not contribute to lynches at all?



I changed my mind, I'm leaving my vote on Matt.

What do you think about Polo, MM?

I just noticed this, but it makes it more obvious that ika was silenced.

Ika has his vote on the Host option.

Spacedaisy wrote:This replacement actually makes me more inclined to vote Bubbles/bea at this point over Matt.

What makes you think Matt was looking for a replacement?

Black Rock wrote:

Spacedaisy wrote:I'm at work so let me keep my explanation quick. Matt is low engagement right now, but he has not been replaced. I think a person who believes they might not have time is more likely to hang in there longer if they are a civ, because they don't have teammates they know they are letting down. Civs don't know who their teammates are so they are less likely to feel the pressure of helping their team. That was a very fast replacement and she didn't say anything about getting a replacement in her post that I recall. Most civs announce they are going to ask for one.

That is a very good point.

No it's not because Matt didn't ask for one.

Matt wrote:

Polo wrote:Dr. Wilgy, are you going to insist on lurking?

Your sole contribution to the game so far has been "Let's not lynch anyone" or "let's lynch absent folks". You're pretty much lurking, disguised as playing.

This is my second mafia game. What do you expect from me?

Metalmarsh89 wrote:I just noticed this, but it makes it more obvious that ika was silenced.

Ika has his vote on the Host option.

What do you think about Polo?

What are your thoughts on Scotty?

Oh, and I forgot to include Daisy on my list for you, on who I would consider voting for. What do you think of Daisy?

Linki - I'm not following you, Dom. But no, I did not ask for a replacement.

Linki Polo - Of all time or on this site?

Matt wrote:Polo - Of all time or on this site?

Of all time; I don't include Avant Mafia 1 (@Progarchives) because that was a good 6 years ago.

Matt wrote:To MM, Faraday, Scotty

You helped contribute to a civ lynch on Day 1 by voting Bwt (yeah I did too), and you currently all have your votes on me.

Step it up, gentleman.

I'm going to vote Illy for now in case we want to do a surprise attack on her, but I may change it in about 20 minutes depending on what happens with bea/bubbles and DF.

Well the bad news is you have also just voted for a civilian, and the fact that you are calling to take me out makes you not only wrong, but also contributing to the Mafia goals. What happened to Polo being in the lead? you flipped back to me with no explanation? When I called you out for your illogical stance on me, you came back with "you didn't understand me" not any kind of clarification.

With all of this I am still not voting for you, as right now I think you are simply confused and trying to survive not evil. This can change however.

So I went back and looked at the player list to remind myself who all is playing and I realized I am worried about LoRab. She has been pretty quiet, which is for me, disconcerting. I am putting a vote on her because I want her to know that I am watching. Closely.


Linki: Dom how do you know that Matt didn't ask for one? You are not making me feel awesome about you, can you clarify please?

*votes LoRab*

Matt wrote:What do you think about Polo, MM?

I am leaning civ on him. I disagree with your assessment of him earlier. You stated that he has only been "not lynching anyone or only lynching absent folks".

That is far from the truth. He has endorsed your lynch, and unless you consider yourself to be an absent folk, then the reason was warranted.

All right, I guess I'll make things interesting.

*The corpse falls over, the computer screen in the room flicks on*


...let's see how you have your monitors set...

thellama73 wrote:All right, I guess I'll make things interesting.

Now we're talkin'!

Polo wrote:

Matt wrote:Polo - Of all time or on this site?

Of all time; I don't include Avant Mafia 1 (@Progarchives) because that was a good 6 years ago.

Oh. I didn't know that. I thought you were just new to this site.

Give me a name of a non-absentee who you think might be bad.

Linki - Illy - at least I have reasons for voting for you. The votes on me seem purely because I "haven't been around", and that's lame. Especially from MM, who somewhat knows my situation.

In fact, MM not changing his vote at all makes me think there might be a baddie between Faraday and Bubbles (if MM were bad, of course), and I'm wondering if I should vote one of them.

Linki MM - Until today, I was an absent folk, so your point? Haha

Interesting, Llama

Matt wrote:

Polo wrote:

Matt wrote:Polo - Of all time or on this site?

Of all time; I don't include Avant Mafia 1 (@Progarchives) because that was a good 6 years ago.

Oh. I didn't know that. I thought you were just new to this site.

Give me a name of a non-absentee who you think might be bad.

Linki - Illy - at least I have reasons for voting for you. The votes on me seem purely because I "haven't been around", and that's lame. Especially from MM, who somewhat knows my situation.

In fact, MM not changing his vote at all makes me think there might be a baddie between Faraday and Bubbles (if MM were bad, of course), and I'm wondering if I should vote one of them.

Linki MM - Until today, I was an absent folk, so your point? Haha

I concur, which is why I am not voting for you.

Obviously, I am wanting you to take your vote off me. I am leaning mafia for Bubbles, but I still want to give Bea a shot to respond.

Illy - If you had to vote for one of Bubbles or DF, who would you vote?

Linki - So Bubbles or DF?

Matt wrote:Illy - If you had to vote for one of Bubbles or DF, who would you vote?

Linki - So Bubbles or DF?

Bubbles, as I do not totally follow how we got to DF's bandwagon. I have him in an undecided category right now.

Dr. Wilgy voting for me with no post. Awesome. Here comes to blitz ladies and gents.

Matt wrote:

Polo wrote:

Matt wrote:Polo - Of all time or on this site?

Of all time; I don't include Avant Mafia 1 (@Progarchives) because that was a good 6 years ago.

Oh. I didn't know that. I thought you were just new to this site.

Give me a name of a non-absentee who you think might be bad.

You, Wilgy, Sorsha.

I voted DF real quick, then switched to Bubbles.

And back to DF. I'm indecisive.

Matt wrote:And back to DF. I'm indecisive.

Apparently....

Matt wrote:

Spacedaisy wrote:Of all the people garnering votes at the moment Matt is the one that seems the most likely to be bad. For the moment my vote is going there, but I'm not certain I'll leave it there yet. Plus, I really don't know that I think DF is bad and I'm historically crap at reading him so I have no desire to mislynches him early yet again.

What? Why am I most likely to be bad? Were you able to determine my alignment based on the few "gotta catch up" posts I had?

Hrm.

Aren't you caught up? I never felt confident in voting you, it was kind of the best of a bunch of bad options and I have since changed my vote to bubbles. I got nothing but love for you!

Matt wrote:

Spacedaisy wrote:I should feel bad about bwt getting lynched early yet again, but frankly his vote was hella shady, so I have no regrets about where I out it. I was hoping he might defend and would have considered changing my vote if he could convince me. But he didn't show back up, so I'm cool with my vote. Now to wait for the flip...

Linki: Well not ideal but if we are going to lose a civ, I'd rather it be the vote manipulation role I think so it could be worse IMO.

Linki feels a bit shady. "I'd rather it be the vote manip role...I think..."

Hrm.

Would you prefer I weep and well, rend my clothes and wear sack cloth instead? I'm just owning my vote and I have no regrets over it. If I were bad I could summon some fake regret, but I'm not so I don't feel bad about making an honest mistake.

Crap. At least she was vanilla.

Illyria wrote:

Matt wrote:And back to DF. I'm indecisive.

Apparently....

Let's see what happens, yo, I'm pumped!

Gotta get ready for work, then I'll be back for RIP or RIH.

Linki - Daisy you da bomb. You bad, tho?

Linki - K then RIP Bubbles.

• "Dear diary,
  
  I'm trusting Doms judgement and read. He seems to have a good head on his shoulders unlike I.
  
  A blitz on to Illy would be cool, but I don't expect this to happen."

*whatever ink was used to write that smells horrid*

• "p.s. RIP and welcome to the club"

At least we lynched bea, a total no-show. Right?



Sorry bea. That was shit.

Bugger. That is not ideal.

Dr Wilgy, anytime you want to present some actual evidence I am right here. Dom and you trying to kill me does not make me feel great about either one of you. This lynch has actually been very helpful for me to clarify a few undecideds into categories. Yourself included.

Spoiler alert: It is not the civilians category.

Speaking of Daisy, this the second time she has led us away from voting for DFaraday. I'll probably be voting for her tomorrow.

Illyria wrote:Bugger. That is not ideal.

Dr Wilgy, anytime you want to present some actual evidence I am right here. Dom and you trying to kill me does not make me feel great about either one of you. This lynch has actually been very helpful for me to clarify a few undecideds into categories. Yourself included.

Spoiler alert: It is not the civilians category.

*the ghost Wilgy appears*
Oh... Spooky! A NO U don't work on ghooooooossssttttsssss!!!

Still gonna be busier then normal, but I'll be around more peeps.

Not a great result today. Interesting, Wilgy broke the tie in Bubbles' favor by voting Illy. Hrm.

Anyway, peace

Matt wrote:Still gonna be busier then normal, but I'll be around more peeps.

Not a great result today. Interesting, Wilgy broke the tie in Bubbles' favor by voting Illy. Hrm.

Anyway, peace

Or rather, I guess in DF's favor haha. But you know what I mean. Derp.

thellama73 wrote:Speaking of Daisy, this the second time she has led us away from voting for DFaraday. I'll probably be voting for her tomorrow.

1. You are a big boy, take responsibility for your own vote.

2. Mislynching someone does not make me a baddie, just a mistaken civ.

3. So you want to lynch me because I have supposedly shielded DF, but we don't know know DF's alignment. Makes total sense.

I'll tell you what, lynch DF if you think he's bad, and if he flips bad, then talk about voting for me. But until you know DF is bad, stop trying to paint me as bad for not wanting to vote for him. I am not bad.

Matt wrote:After SW was lynched...

thellama73 wrote:I guess we can rule out Ika as being mafia, then, can't we?

Why? From what little I've seen of them, they pride themselves on being able to see right through each other, so ika NKing the Wolf would actually make sense so she doesn't catch on to him later.

and you would relaize i would never kill her as logn as she town reads me

AND FIANNLY NOT FUCKING SILENCED OMFG.......

ika can talk now, right?

Well hell.

ill get ot this later i got a lot of stuff to do now that i am home

im quetion who the doc is too why were they not on silver n1?

ika wrote:ill get ot this later i got a lot of stuff to do now that i am home

im quetion who the doc is too why were they not on silver n1?

If I were "the doc" (and I think you mean "Lord Grantham"), I would not be "on silver n1."

Epignosis wrote:

ika wrote:ill get ot this later i got a lot of stuff to do now that i am home

im quetion who the doc is too why were they not on silver n1?

If I were "the doc" (and I think you mean "Lord Grantham"), I would not be "on silver n1."

why?

RIP Bubble-bea.

If I had known bea was going to replace in I would have given her a shot and not voted there. I'm kinda surprised that so many players followed my vote for bubbles... I know a couple of them (epi & llama) are players I know have voiced frustrations about no show/extremely low posters so I'm not really surprised at those two. I'll have to look at the other reasons though.

sig wrote:

Epignosis wrote:I'm almost positive Polo is a civilian.

I agree with Epi here.

@Ika Why do you think Silver was killed?

because of her reads

Polo wrote:Then I have three scenarios in my mind:

1) SIlverwolf was Lady Rose MacClare;
2) Lady Rose MacClare targeted ika but ika got silenced;
3) Lady Rose MacClare is someone else who did not use the Insanify ability. Why is that?
3.1) Nobody was insanified because Lady Rose didn't want to use her power (booo);
3.2) Lady Rose MacClare is one of those people who have yet to catch up, e.g. Bubbles or Matt.

silverwolf would never ansaify me either

i think thats most everything about it?

its was dumb to lynch that, dfar needs rope tommorw,him or MM im using silvers reads to lycnht em all

ika wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

ika wrote:ill get ot this later i got a lot of stuff to do now that i am home

im quetion who the doc is too why were they not on silver n1?

If I were "the doc" (and I think you mean "Lord Grantham"), I would not be "on silver n1."

why?

Because I would not have expected Mafia to kill her Night 1, and she was not my top pick as a civilian, as much as you would expect everyone to believe.

Epignosis wrote:

ika wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

ika wrote:ill get ot this later i got a lot of stuff to do now that i am home

im quetion who the doc is too why were they not on silver n1?

If I were "the doc" (and I think you mean "Lord Grantham"), I would not be "on silver n1."

why?

Because I would not have expected Mafia to kill her Night 1, and she was not my top pick as a civilian, as much as you would expect everyone to believe.

why would she not be killed n1? she died n2 in heist that you were follwing and i knwo shes not everyones top civ read but she was univeraly town read comapred to everyone else or do you have soemthing to disprove that

Let me run this question by you, ika: Instead of telling Lord Grantham what he should have done, why not tell us who you think murdered Silverwolf? That would be the most helpful use of your time. I find it bizarre that I should even have to raise this question to you.

ika wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

ika wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

ika wrote:ill get ot this later i got a lot of stuff to do now that i am home

im quetion who the doc is too why were they not on silver n1?

If I were "the doc" (and I think you mean "Lord Grantham"), I would not be "on silver n1."

why?

Because I would not have expected Mafia to kill her Night 1, and she was not my top pick as a civilian, as much as you would expect everyone to believe.

why would she not be killed n1? she died n2 in heist that you were follwing and i knwo shes not everyones top civ read but she was univeraly town read comapred to everyone else or do you have soemthing to disprove that

Night 2 is not Night 1. I would not have expected Mafia to kill her Night 1 because I think the two of you can be manipulated to defend each other or work with each other to the mafia's favor. I don't know what heist I was following where she died Night 2.

She was not "universally town read." Nobody is Day and Night 1 unless you are bad and know better. Universally means everybody, and everybody didn't agree she was good.