Gira wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 1:46 am
Ran, at what point did you come around to actually believing Dizzy is scum?
Around the word "Wolfmillia" although "actually believing" is considerably overselling.
well it was enough to earn him a vote and your initial reaction to it seemed very blasé so was wondering if there was, like, some underlying thought that motivated it. possible i'm just misinterpreting how much weight you're putting on the vote.
I don't have a stronger wolfread elsewhere yet, and I'm Extremely Done with that sort of heckling driveby posting when I'm town and trying to play. There is definitely underlying thought, which is learning from past mistakes.
The last game I played was Lumi's big role madness thing, in which I led town against wolf Macdougall and his team constantly trying to undermine me with exactly that sort of posting. I had an opportunity to vig him and chickened out because other people townread him and I didn't want to be the one who sunk the game. I should've shot. We lost. The game I played before that was SCI '22 and Alison came at me out the gate with a similar wolfread; I let her off the hook and wow, she was a wolf. When I look back at all the games I've played since coming back to mafia one of the things that stands out the most is the people attacking me were in fact mafia and I should have killed them for it.
I'm well aware of how strong a player Dizzy is when he's active, which is why it's concerning that he's wrong on me. I see three worlds: reaction test (unlikely and didn't accomplish much), bad take based on not reading (uncharacteristic and deserves a paddling) or wolf (also uncharacteristic but nothing makes it impossible.) It's uncharacteristic no matter what.
cool i can buy this as a town mindset, ty for elaborating, definitely been there myself at times, thank you for elaboratng
Gira wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 1:43 am
by all accounts dizzy is an excellent and highly motivated player of the mafia alignment, so i don't particularly think him being "flaccid" is a valid scumtell. I struggle to believe he chooses to start a game off by lowposting and taking potshots at one player as mafia. I have, on the other hand, seen him get miskilled for being "underwhelming".
neon is, uh, i think town in that she is doing her usual stream of consciousness and the thoughts that come out seem believable even if some of the reasoning is bizarre
what are the odds wolf gira makes this post
below rand, methinks, unless there's a partner in dizzy/abi. which I have no reason to suspect
Gira wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 1:43 am
by all accounts dizzy is an excellent and highly motivated player of the mafia alignment, so i don't particularly think him being "flaccid" is a valid scumtell. I struggle to believe he chooses to start a game off by lowposting and taking potshots at one player as mafia. I have, on the other hand, seen him get miskilled for being "underwhelming".
neon is, uh, i think town in that she is doing her usual stream of consciousness and the thoughts that come out seem believable even if some of the reasoning is bizarre
what are the odds wolf gira makes this post
below rand, methinks, unless there's a partner in dizzy/abi. which I have no reason to suspect
why do you think that?
there's been too much townreading so far this game
in so far as, if it's accurate, it's going to form a towncore e.g. Abigail will pop off on D2/D3, robyn will form a solve and tunnel it, I'll accidentally vote mafia and clear myself
ranmilla was one person who actually tried to shake things up re: reads, but everyone not getting the questions thing is pretty funny and humanizing
in context consider this a reaction to my previous game where I was scum and I feel like a big mistake I made was letting town find each other fairly easily
the thread feels quite chummy and I think it's generally a good thing so I would expect scum (i restate: no meta on you on this) to want to stir things more or just sit things out for a bit and let lowposters be afk and then maybe jump in with ~24h to go to start some topics, idk
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 2:38 am
by JaggedJimmyJay
I added spoilers to the huge spam. Please refrain from doing or quoting that. As always, don't respond to this post in the game thread. Thanks, folks.
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 2:39 am
by pyxxy
yeah the show had me from the start though, in that wonderful way where you go "ah yes, I am going to enjoy this", always a nice feeling
Gira wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 1:43 am
by all accounts dizzy is an excellent and highly motivated player of the mafia alignment, so i don't particularly think him being "flaccid" is a valid scumtell. I struggle to believe he chooses to start a game off by lowposting and taking potshots at one player as mafia. I have, on the other hand, seen him get miskilled for being "underwhelming".
neon is, uh, i think town in that she is doing her usual stream of consciousness and the thoughts that come out seem believable even if some of the reasoning is bizarre
what are the odds wolf gira makes this post
below rand, methinks, unless there's a partner in dizzy/abi. which I have no reason to suspect
why do you think that?
there's been too much townreading so far this game
in so far as, if it's accurate, it's going to form a towncore e.g. Abigail will pop off on D2/D3, robyn will form a solve and tunnel it, I'll accidentally vote mafia and clear myself
ranmilla was one person who actually tried to shake things up re: reads, but everyone not getting the questions thing is pretty funny and humanizing
in context consider this a reaction to my previous game where I was scum and I feel like a big mistake I made was letting town find each other fairly easily
the thread feels quite chummy and I think it's generally a good thing so I would expect scum (i restate: no meta on you on this) to want to stir things more or just sit things out for a bit and let lowposters be afk and then maybe jump in with ~24h to go to start some topics, idk
is scum twink (you) capable of this post?
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 2:44 am
by Gira
oh yeah i loved it from the start but the end of episode 3 felt like when shit got real
Gira wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 1:43 am
by all accounts dizzy is an excellent and highly motivated player of the mafia alignment, so i don't particularly think him being "flaccid" is a valid scumtell. I struggle to believe he chooses to start a game off by lowposting and taking potshots at one player as mafia. I have, on the other hand, seen him get miskilled for being "underwhelming".
neon is, uh, i think town in that she is doing her usual stream of consciousness and the thoughts that come out seem believable even if some of the reasoning is bizarre
what are the odds wolf gira makes this post
below rand, methinks, unless there's a partner in dizzy/abi. which I have no reason to suspect
why do you think that?
there's been too much townreading so far this game
in so far as, if it's accurate, it's going to form a towncore e.g. Abigail will pop off on D2/D3, robyn will form a solve and tunnel it, I'll accidentally vote mafia and clear myself
ranmilla was one person who actually tried to shake things up re: reads, but everyone not getting the questions thing is pretty funny and humanizing
in context consider this a reaction to my previous game where I was scum and I feel like a big mistake I made was letting town find each other fairly easily
the thread feels quite chummy and I think it's generally a good thing so I would expect scum (i restate: no meta on you on this) to want to stir things more or just sit things out for a bit and let lowposters be afk and then maybe jump in with ~24h to go to start some topics, idk
if you had to list 3 names of scum who would they be
Gira wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 1:43 am
by all accounts dizzy is an excellent and highly motivated player of the mafia alignment, so i don't particularly think him being "flaccid" is a valid scumtell. I struggle to believe he chooses to start a game off by lowposting and taking potshots at one player as mafia. I have, on the other hand, seen him get miskilled for being "underwhelming".
neon is, uh, i think town in that she is doing her usual stream of consciousness and the thoughts that come out seem believable even if some of the reasoning is bizarre
what are the odds wolf gira makes this post
below rand, methinks, unless there's a partner in dizzy/abi. which I have no reason to suspect
why do you think that?
there's been too much townreading so far this game
in so far as, if it's accurate, it's going to form a towncore e.g. Abigail will pop off on D2/D3, robyn will form a solve and tunnel it, I'll accidentally vote mafia and clear myself
ranmilla was one person who actually tried to shake things up re: reads, but everyone not getting the questions thing is pretty funny and humanizing
in context consider this a reaction to my previous game where I was scum and I feel like a big mistake I made was letting town find each other fairly easily
the thread feels quite chummy and I think it's generally a good thing so I would expect scum (i restate: no meta on you on this) to want to stir things more or just sit things out for a bit and let lowposters be afk and then maybe jump in with ~24h to go to start some topics, idk
is scum twink (you) capable of this post?
scwink
yes, caveat being I would need energy to make it, lower energy needed when town
Gira wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 1:43 am
by all accounts dizzy is an excellent and highly motivated player of the mafia alignment, so i don't particularly think him being "flaccid" is a valid scumtell. I struggle to believe he chooses to start a game off by lowposting and taking potshots at one player as mafia. I have, on the other hand, seen him get miskilled for being "underwhelming".
neon is, uh, i think town in that she is doing her usual stream of consciousness and the thoughts that come out seem believable even if some of the reasoning is bizarre
what are the odds wolf gira makes this post
below rand, methinks, unless there's a partner in dizzy/abi. which I have no reason to suspect
why do you think that?
there's been too much townreading so far this game
in so far as, if it's accurate, it's going to form a towncore e.g. Abigail will pop off on D2/D3, robyn will form a solve and tunnel it, I'll accidentally vote mafia and clear myself
ranmilla was one person who actually tried to shake things up re: reads, but everyone not getting the questions thing is pretty funny and humanizing
in context consider this a reaction to my previous game where I was scum and I feel like a big mistake I made was letting town find each other fairly easily
the thread feels quite chummy and I think it's generally a good thing so I would expect scum (i restate: no meta on you on this) to want to stir things more or just sit things out for a bit and let lowposters be afk and then maybe jump in with ~24h to go to start some topics, idk
if you had to list 3 names of scum who would they be
tsp ranmilla and unsure
ted feels like a lazy pick / ignoring slank cover but maybe ted
Gira wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 1:43 am
by all accounts dizzy is an excellent and highly motivated player of the mafia alignment, so i don't particularly think him being "flaccid" is a valid scumtell. I struggle to believe he chooses to start a game off by lowposting and taking potshots at one player as mafia. I have, on the other hand, seen him get miskilled for being "underwhelming".
neon is, uh, i think town in that she is doing her usual stream of consciousness and the thoughts that come out seem believable even if some of the reasoning is bizarre
what are the odds wolf gira makes this post
below rand, methinks, unless there's a partner in dizzy/abi. which I have no reason to suspect
why do you think that?
there's been too much townreading so far this game
in so far as, if it's accurate, it's going to form a towncore e.g. Abigail will pop off on D2/D3, robyn will form a solve and tunnel it, I'll accidentally vote mafia and clear myself
ranmilla was one person who actually tried to shake things up re: reads, but everyone not getting the questions thing is pretty funny and humanizing
in context consider this a reaction to my previous game where I was scum and I feel like a big mistake I made was letting town find each other fairly easily
the thread feels quite chummy and I think it's generally a good thing so I would expect scum (i restate: no meta on you on this) to want to stir things more or just sit things out for a bit and let lowposters be afk and then maybe jump in with ~24h to go to start some topics, idk
if you had to list 3 names of scum who would they be
tsp ranmilla and unsure
ted feels like a lazy pick / ignoring slank cover but maybe ted
what do u think of ran finding me
and what would u say if i totally disagreed with you irt ran trying to shake things up
Dubz wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 1:21 am
I'm useless until I've spewed enough fluff to be cozy. So forgive me if I ignore the fact that y'all have skipped over the shit-posting stage.
no we're just waiting for @MacDougall to give the thread its quota of shitty posts
Gira wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 1:43 am
by all accounts dizzy is an excellent and highly motivated player of the mafia alignment, so i don't particularly think him being "flaccid" is a valid scumtell. I struggle to believe he chooses to start a game off by lowposting and taking potshots at one player as mafia. I have, on the other hand, seen him get miskilled for being "underwhelming".
neon is, uh, i think town in that she is doing her usual stream of consciousness and the thoughts that come out seem believable even if some of the reasoning is bizarre
what are the odds wolf gira makes this post
below rand, methinks, unless there's a partner in dizzy/abi. which I have no reason to suspect
why do you think that?
there's been too much townreading so far this game
in so far as, if it's accurate, it's going to form a towncore e.g. Abigail will pop off on D2/D3, robyn will form a solve and tunnel it, I'll accidentally vote mafia and clear myself
ranmilla was one person who actually tried to shake things up re: reads, but everyone not getting the questions thing is pretty funny and humanizing
in context consider this a reaction to my previous game where I was scum and I feel like a big mistake I made was letting town find each other fairly easily
the thread feels quite chummy and I think it's generally a good thing so I would expect scum (i restate: no meta on you on this) to want to stir things more or just sit things out for a bit and let lowposters be afk and then maybe jump in with ~24h to go to start some topics, idk
if you had to list 3 names of scum who would they be
tsp ranmilla and unsure
ted feels like a lazy pick / ignoring slank cover but maybe ted
what do u think of ran finding me
and what would u say if i totally disagreed with you irt ran trying to shake things up
wouldnt think much mid ep 4 rn and it's cooking
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 3:20 am
by MacDougall
Macaque
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 3:50 am
by tedxtr
[VOTE:
dubz ] aubergine
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:08 am
by RondoDimBuckle
OK! I just had something dropped on my foot so I am not going out tonight so I have some time to spare. I also thought that day ended like today or tomorrow and it turns out I have for AGES to spend in thread. Probably still not going to back read.
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:09 am
by RondoDimBuckle
MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 3:20 amMacaque
Sup with MacGoonal?
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:10 am
by RondoDimBuckle
MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 3:07 am
So I'm town
Okay bye
Come back, hang with me
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:10 am
by RondoDimBuckle
Ranmilia wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 3:14 am
Mac is out of his scumrange.
cool well, gonna dip unless someone wants to real time. Time to find some ice
Re: Severance [Phase Zero]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:23 am
by WindwardAway
robyn wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 6:38 pm
fuck is this, wwa has no wolf games on mu
I have plenty of wolf games but I guess you're right, I don't have any on MU? I can link them if anyone wants, not sure the ones on the paywalled forum are viewable but the ones on FoL should be. Two of the forums I've played the most on went down permanently, though, so there are a lot of broken links I need to fix
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:26 am
by MacDougall
Oh I'm here if anyone wants to point at things and ask me to talk about them
Almost certainly unreadable without a (paywalled) account but this is Wind nearly endgaming as godfather in a 23 player. Role madness but highly skilled list. She hid behind a massive mountain of mech talk, mainly.
Yeah, after my only teammate got mech outed on N1 lol.
But yeah that's what I meant, I can fake ignorance in terms of flavor and mech, and I will also genuinely derp as both town and scum (although this game that was references was more like 4 teams of serial killers rather than a cohesive scum team).
I also hid in that game behind genuinely trying to find the other scum teams, since I needed them dead and not town.
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:28 am
by Ranmilia
MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:26 am
Oh I'm here if anyone wants to point at things and ask me to talk about them
Me/Dizzy/Bereft, the latter two are very brief ISOs
robyn wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 6:38 pm
fuck is this, wwa has no wolf games on mu
I have plenty of wolf games but I guess you're right, I don't have any on MU? I can link them if anyone wants, not sure the ones on the paywalled forum are viewable but the ones on FoL should be. Two of the forums I've played the most on went down permanently, though, so there are a lot of broken links I need to fix
Hey WWA what is going on?
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:30 am
by Ranmilia
What's up Wind, it's late here but I'm up a bit more and this is probably our best overlap time.
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:31 am
by RondoDimBuckle
MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:26 am
Oh I'm here if anyone wants to point at things and ask me to talk about them
me/myself/i
why are you not hype to play with me Mac? Is this love one sided? Whats going on?
☆Princess Abigail☆ wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 8:23 pm
Imma user the bottle as a water bottle
that's slightly unhinged but I do also like their bottles
Imagine walking in on someone and they are just chugging a Grey Goose bottle
You dunno it's water at first
One time I threw a party and we reused a Jameson bottle as a water bottle and apparently I was drunk enough that I totally forgot about it and put the bottle back with the other alcohol bottles, then the next time I had people over I *attempted* to pour whiskey for everyone but was very confused by the lack of color and flavor until i realized it was just water... Lol
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:36 am
by WindwardAway
JaggedJimmyJay wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 10:00 pm Evening One is underway. You have 48 hours to vote someone out.
Oh, I thought we would start on day phase. Interesting.
JaggedJimmyJay wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 10:00 pm Evening One is underway. You have 48 hours to vote someone out.
Oh, I thought we would start on day phase. Interesting.
maybe its reversed? days are night and night are days?
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:39 am
by MacDougall
Ranmilia's ISO starts off beautifully, entering the game and immediately attempting to create an environment of joy and love is usually relatively town indicative and the confidence and authoritativeness is particularly townie for someone like Ranmnilia whom I consider to be a relatively uncomfortable wolf, and certainly not one who attempts to generally take on a position of town leader or heartbeat of the game as a mafia slot.
I have only read three posts but I am already heavily inclined to town lock this very towny person, but in fact I will, out of a desire to not be flippant and instead actually offer further candid remark, read on.
Unbelievably consistent already insisting on holding others to account. Truly incredible WIM. This might be considered by a lesser player (not me) to be borderline lamist in a wolfy way, but I indeed know better. For I, am MacDougall. The one true, and returned, esteemed and Glorious King of the Syndicate. Not of Fuck Mountain, for that is the darkerlends. The FUCK lands. The lands of the King of FUCK Mountain. Nobody dwells there but trolls. No, I am the King of SYNDICATE, returned benevolent dictator. Aragorn-like. Bask in my glory. Two time Champs Podium, multiple time MVP of this very website and reigning Town MVP of the entire UNIVERSE of MAFIA.
MAFIA RANDS KNEEL AND QUIVER IN FEAR AS I E̶͔͘͠X̸̨̗͋̂S̶̛͎̅Ȧ̶̱N̴͙̹̈́̄Ǧ̴͍U̸̼̳͝I̸̧̝̍͑N̴̼͒A̷̱͔̒̈́T̵̬̭̑͝Ȇ̴̮̇ ̴̪͌̇T̷͇̹͑H̸̘͌E̸̯͐Ḯ̷̩R̵̹̃ ̵͍͖̋͗V̶́̎ͅE̵̠̖̎͝R̷̘͍̔Ÿ̵̗͛ ̷͇̌͑B̷̰̏È̵̱̟I̵̛̜͙N̶̪̮̎G̶̫͐ ̸̩̱̾W̴͔̉́I̷̪̙͗͘T̸̙̃ͅH̶̻̏ͅ ̶͉͊S̶̻͈̎̕H̴̡͘Ē̵̞Ë̶͈́̂R̵̝͗̃ ̸̻͖̇İ̸̮M̶̜͎̾P̵̫̹̔̋Ȩ̴̻̐Ṅ̴͚͎̆E̶̤͝͠T̴̰̓Ŗ̸͉͆Ả̸̞͠B̶͇̎L̵͈̈̌Ë̷͙̺́ ̸͖͖͋L̶̖̙͆Ó̵̫͝G̶̗̐̕I̷̥̫̐C̵̱̔ͅ ̷̡̟̈́Ȃ̷͙̈Ǹ̴̛̞D̷̨͓̏ ̵͖̥̃̾W̵̜̩̒I̵̺̩͘͠L̴̲̿͑L̸͚̈ ̴͓́Ṫ̸̝̥̍Ò̶̢ ̴̢͍͛͘Ẅ̸͍́̈I̶͇̔̽N̴̘̂̈ ̷̝̓̕M̴̲͒Ḁ̵̘́̀F̸̦́Ȋ̴̬̹A̷̗͍̓̌ ̸̯̋͆G̸̡̱͗A̸͈̔͜͝Ḿ̷̡E̶̗͋S̶̤͉͒.̵̰̭̌͝
TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 12:32 am
I only remember this because I just skimmed hot dog game earlier and I warned everyone about the day 1 rondo chop
Lol
I'm against chopping Rondo here, I thought Dubz was towny off the little they posted
MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:39 am
Ranmilia's ISO starts off beautifully, entering the game and immediately attempting to create an environment of joy and love is usually relatively town indicative and the confidence and authoritativeness is particularly townie for someone like Ranmnilia whom I consider to be a relatively uncomfortable wolf, and certainly not one who attempts to generally take on a position of town leader or heartbeat of the game as a mafia slot.
I have only read three posts but I am already heavily inclined to town lock this very towny person, but in fact I will, out of a desire to not be flippant and instead actually offer further candid remark, read on.
Unbelievably consistent already insisting on holding others to account. Truly incredible WIM. This might be considered by a lesser player (not me) to be borderline lamist in a wolfy way, but I indeed know better. For I, am MacDougall. The one true, and returned, esteemed and Glorious King of the Syndicate. Not of Fuck Mountain, for that is the darkerlends. The FUCK lands. The lands of the King of FUCK Mountain. Nobody dwells there but trolls. No, I am the King of SYNDICATE, returned benevolent dictator. Aragorn-like. Bask in my glory. Two time Champs Podium, multiple time MVP of this very website and reigning Town MVP of the entire UNIVERSE of MAFIA.
MAFIA RANDS KNEEL AND QUIVER IN FEAR AS I E̶͔͘͠X̸̨̗͋̂S̶̛͎̅Ȧ̶̱N̴͙̹̈́̄Ǧ̴͍U̸̼̳͝I̸̧̝̍͑N̴̼͒A̷̱͔̒̈́T̵̬̭̑͝Ȇ̴̮̇ ̴̪͌̇T̷͇̹͑H̸̘͌E̸̯͐Ḯ̷̩R̵̹̃ ̵͍͖̋͗V̶́̎ͅE̵̠̖̎͝R̷̘͍̔Ÿ̵̗͛ ̷͇̌͑B̷̰̏È̵̱̟I̵̛̜͙N̶̪̮̎G̶̫͐ ̸̩̱̾W̴͔̉́I̷̪̙͗͘T̸̙̃ͅH̶̻̏ͅ ̶͉͊S̶̻͈̎̕H̴̡͘Ē̵̞Ë̶͈́̂R̵̝͗̃ ̸̻͖̇İ̸̮M̶̜͎̾P̵̫̹̔̋Ȩ̴̻̐Ṅ̴͚͎̆E̶̤͝͠T̴̰̓Ŗ̸͉͆Ả̸̞͠B̶͇̎L̵͈̈̌Ë̷͙̺́ ̸͖͖͋L̶̖̙͆Ó̵̫͝G̶̗̐̕I̷̥̫̐C̵̱̔ͅ ̷̡̟̈́Ȃ̷͙̈Ǹ̴̛̞D̷̨͓̏ ̵͖̥̃̾W̵̜̩̒I̵̺̩͘͠L̴̲̿͑L̸͚̈ ̴͓́Ṫ̸̝̥̍Ò̶̢ ̴̢͍͛͘Ẅ̸͍́̈I̶͇̔̽N̴̘̂̈ ̷̝̓̕M̴̲͒Ḁ̵̘́̀F̸̦́Ȋ̴̬̹A̷̗͍̓̌ ̸̯̋͆G̸̡̱͗A̸͈̔͜͝Ḿ̷̡E̶̗͋S̶̤͉͒.̵̰̭̌͝
Ranmilia wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 1:20 am
actually leetic what are your reads, overall?
Dropped my GTH reads already. For now I am interested in pushing people and seeing where they develop. Dyslexicon looks worst, and I'm not really a fan of pyxxy either. Windward looks better than at the beginning of the game but not off the hook yet. I'm still getting a lukewarm feeling from most of your posts. Abby is Abby, but lean town due to her treatment of me vs. the last game. tedxtr is mostly just there, but I do like that a few of their posts have been seemingly trying to solve. TSP is also just there but with less good-looking posts. robyn has been dense and I don't really give a rat's ass about their previous game but their reactions at least seem natural. And I guess there's Gira, who had a decent early game but just seems blendy recently. If there's anyone I'm missing they just haven't stood out to me at all in the grand scheme of the game.
Yeah, I gotta say, idk whether to give Gira the benefit of the doubt in case he's been busy irl but he sort of fell off after the start of the game. He went into peacekeeping for a brief time, got himself some townreads for it (which I disagreed with), and then went quiet. Which imo is actually how a wolf would want to play the early game, before votes open. Do just enough to get some light townreads and then dip so that nobody changes their opinion.
I did have that reason for slightly townleaning him earlier but I don't think it has enough weight in the grand scheme of things. I think that was a micro read, and his macro isn't actually that great.
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:48 am
by RondoDimBuckle
man I feel like no one is fuckin responding to me. Aight, Gonna bounce and watch movies.
TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 11:34 pm
I stared at the list and decided Gira was the most likely wolf
oh word?
Hey, why are TSP, Robyn and me voting you?
[VOTE:
Rondo] aubergine
OMGUS, or is there more to this vote?
well - I didn't like dubz's content and thought it was possibly scum struggling to make an entry into the game thread, was waiting to see more from her, obv did not get that, think the entrance from rondo is, well, trash. comes across as blatant bandwagoning with no real thought behind it
tsp's vote on me is w/e, i would have voted him back but i actually liked how he reacted to ranmilia saying she'd shoot dizzy - the immediate skepticism i thought was a very plausible reaction. don't know what to think about robyn
Don't you think Rondo mightve questioned the votes on you BEFORE joining the bandwagon if he were a wolf? To appear more solvy? I got the impression he didn't really care how his entrance looked.
Re: Severance [Evening One]
Posted: Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:52 am
by MacDougall
RondoDimBuckle wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:48 am
man I feel like no one is fuckin responding to me. Aight, Gonna bounce and watch movies.
Gira wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 1:43 am
by all accounts dizzy is an excellent and highly motivated player of the mafia alignment, so i don't particularly think him being "flaccid" is a valid scumtell. I struggle to believe he chooses to start a game off by lowposting and taking potshots at one player as mafia. I have, on the other hand, seen him get miskilled for being "underwhelming".
neon is, uh, i think town in that she is doing her usual stream of consciousness and the thoughts that come out seem believable even if some of the reasoning is bizarre
what are the odds wolf gira makes this post
below rand, methinks, unless there's a partner in dizzy/abi. which I have no reason to suspect
Gira wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 1:43 am
by all accounts dizzy is an excellent and highly motivated player of the mafia alignment, so i don't particularly think him being "flaccid" is a valid scumtell. I struggle to believe he chooses to start a game off by lowposting and taking potshots at one player as mafia. I have, on the other hand, seen him get miskilled for being "underwhelming".
neon is, uh, i think town in that she is doing her usual stream of consciousness and the thoughts that come out seem believable even if some of the reasoning is bizarre
what are the odds wolf gira makes this post
below rand, methinks, unless there's a partner in dizzy/abi. which I have no reason to suspect
why do you think that?
there's been too much townreading so far this game
in so far as, if it's accurate, it's going to form a towncore e.g. Abigail will pop off on D2/D3, robyn will form a solve and tunnel it, I'll accidentally vote mafia and clear myself
ranmilla was one person who actually tried to shake things up re: reads, but everyone not getting the questions thing is pretty funny and humanizing
in context consider this a reaction to my previous game where I was scum and I feel like a big mistake I made was letting town find each other fairly easily
the thread feels quite chummy and I think it's generally a good thing so I would expect scum (i restate: no meta on you on this) to want to stir things more or just sit things out for a bit and let lowposters be afk and then maybe jump in with ~24h to go to start some topics, idk
if you had to list 3 names of scum who would they be
tsp ranmilla and unsure
ted feels like a lazy pick / ignoring slank cover but maybe ted
Wow interesting cause that's like the polar opposite of my readlist
