Fargo Mafia [Game Ends]

[Strawhenge]

Wait, Esooa started as a tree stump? So there never was a protect ability?

I'm extremely fucking confused.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I'm reasonably sure its best not to speculate too much on esooas role

She's very likely either town or town siding 3p and I don't really care about 3p at this stage of the game so


The claim I have more issue with is Alison's

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Wait, Esooa started as a tree stump? So there never was a protect ability?

I'm extremely fucking confused.

She can't be killed, she can protect and roleblock her target each night (basically a jailkeeper), except for one night where can choose just to protect them

Thats the claim @Esooa is making as I understand it, probably best to let it be

[BoKnows]

So esooa is a dead player who can post in the thread?

[fingersplints]

https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Tree_Stump

Thank you for the link. However that says a player has lost all their abilities, and Esooa has mentioned ability since the stump claim.

[Strawhenge]

Wait, Esooa started as a tree stump? So there never was a protect ability?

I'm extremely fucking confused.

She can't be killed, she can protect and roleblock her target each night (basically a jailkeeper), except for one night where can choose just to protect them

Thats the claim @Esooa is making as I understand it, probably best to let it be

'Best to let it be'? That's one of the most ridiculously OP role claims I've heard in recent memory.

Now, I'm not saying it makes Esooa scum. Like I said, her posts have been consistently hyperbolic. So, the way I see it, either Esooa's being intentionally misleading, or we're all taking her erroneous claims seriously, or both. It warrants some questions, at least.

[fingersplints]

I'm reasonably sure its best not to speculate too much on esooas role

She's very likely either town or town siding 3p and I don't really care about 3p at this stage of the game so


The claim I have more issue with is Alison's

What is the issue with Alison’s claim?

[fingersplints]

Yea I don’t see the harm in discussing Esooa’s claim. It’s been a quiet day

[KZA]

Esooa is a tree stump that started as one and has at least one night action

[Strawhenge]

I'm reasonably sure its best not to speculate too much on esooas role

She's very likely either town or town siding 3p and I don't really care about 3p at this stage of the game so


The claim I have more issue with is Alison's

What is the issue with Alison’s claim?

She seems to think Odd has the trooper abilities KZA has, and vice versa. Their claims contradict hers. That also warrants questions.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Wait, Esooa started as a tree stump? So there never was a protect ability?

I'm extremely fucking confused.

She can't be killed, she can protect and roleblock her target each night (basically a jailkeeper), except for one night where can choose just to protect them

Thats the claim @Esooa is making as I understand it, probably best to let it be

'Best to let it be'? That's one of the most ridiculously OP role claims I've heard in recent memory.

Now, I'm not saying it makes Esooa scum. Like I said, her posts have been consistently hyperbolic. So, the way I see it, either Esooa's being intentionally misleading, or we're all taking her erroneous claims seriously, or both. It warrants some questions, at least.

Meh idk im not concerned about her today and I don't wanna say why but please sheep me as im confirmed town

[Strawhenge]

Esooa is a tree stump that started as one and has at least one night action

I imagine that it would be considered a thoroughly unproductive gamble, but I have to admit that my impulse is to chop Esooa to test her claim.

[fingersplints]

I'm reasonably sure its best not to speculate too much on esooas role

She's very likely either town or town siding 3p and I don't really care about 3p at this stage of the game so


The claim I have more issue with is Alison's

What is the issue with Alison’s claim?

She seems to think Odd has the trooper abilities KZA has, and vice versa. Their claims contradict hers. That also warrants questions.

Has she explained the contradiction?
Do you still feel ok about Odd and KZA claims?

[Strawhenge]

I'm reasonably sure its best not to speculate too much on esooas role

She's very likely either town or town siding 3p and I don't really care about 3p at this stage of the game so


The claim I have more issue with is Alison's

What is the issue with Alison’s claim?

She seems to think Odd has the trooper abilities KZA has, and vice versa. Their claims contradict hers. That also warrants questions.

Has she explained the contradiction?
Do you still feel ok about Odd and KZA claims?

I no longer feel okay about any of them. There is the possibility of a mod error, and the information was mistakenly swapped, but there's also a possibility that one party is lying.

[BoKnows]

There's two hyperimportant things that needs to happen before EoD.

1) @Oddmerta explaining this straw thing.
2) @Michelle revealing this name.

[KZA]

I'm reasonably sure its best not to speculate too much on esooas role

She's very likely either town or town siding 3p and I don't really care about 3p at this stage of the game so


The claim I have more issue with is Alison's

What is the issue with Alison’s claim?

She seems to think Odd has the trooper abilities KZA has, and vice versa. Their claims contradict hers. That also warrants questions.

Has she explained the contradiction?
Do you still feel ok about Odd and KZA claims?

I no longer feel okay about any of them. There is the possibility of a mod error, and the information was mistakenly swapped, but there's also a possibility that one party is lying.

Alison said it was indeed a mod error

[fingersplints]

There's two hyperimportant things that needs to happen before EoD.

1) @Oddmerta explaining this straw thing.
2) @Michelle revealing this name.

I too am interested in hearing more about both these things.

[falcon45ca]

What's consensus, should we work out the POE from players who have no claim? Or the claims that aren't as fleshed out/believable?

[BoKnows]

Odd and Michelle love building up the suspense

[Michelle]

Odd and Michelle love building up the suspense

I fell asleep, these days were tiresome for me

But yes, i wanted a day with everyone solving, not making one wagon and complainig for lack of WIM
Ah, and Odd is grandmaster in building up a plan no matter alignament ^^

[falcon45ca]

Odd and Michelle love building up the suspense

I fell asleep, these days were tiresome for me

But yes, i wanted a day with everyone solving, not making one wagon and complainig for lack of WIM
Ah, and Odd is grandmaster in building up a plan no matter alignament ^^

I checked out accents from Bucharest, they're awesome.



Not like a Canadian accent, which sounds like we just got hit in the head with a rock

[Alison]

sup

is there anything new or am I just going to vote the POE again

[Alison]

sorry but my WIM is at an all time low for this game. I'm incredibly detached and find it hard to care about what happens here now

[BoKnows]

sup

is there anything new or am I just going to vote the POE again

We're just waiting for Odd and Michelle to make their big reveals

[Alison]

okidoki

[KZA]

Flip LC, Fingersplints, then tinfoil SPF is my current plan lol

If Falcon, BK, or Esooa actually crafted a fake claim that lines up perfectly with their respective flavours I'll probably just lose to it

[Michelle]

Well, I didn't expect so little curiosity

I was informed that Alison is guilty

[Michelle]

[VOTE: Alison] aubergine

[KZA]

wtf lmao

[Michelle]

Spoiler: show

knowing their names?
Poll runs till Fri Apr 16, 2021 1:00 am
Please note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

You may select 1 option


Alison
1
7%
Voters: Michelle
BoKnows
0
No votes
Voters: None
Esooa
2
13%
Voters: falcon45ca, Long Con
falcon45ca
0
No votes
Voters: None
fingersplints
0
No votes
Voters: None
Hally
0
No votes
Voters: None
Justplayingitcool
1
7%
Voters: Esooa
KZA
0
No votes
Voters: None
Long Con
0
No votes
Voters: None
Michelle
1
7%
Voters: NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
0
No votes
Voters: None
Oddmerta
0
No votes
Voters: None
staypositivefriend
0
No votes
Voters: None
Strawhenge
1
7%
Voters: Oddmerta
Unvote
0
No votes
Voters: None
No Elimination
1
7%
Voters: BoKnows
Now that's just lazy (Host/Dead/Non)
8
53%
Voters: TonyStarkPrime, MacDougall, novaselinenever, JaggedJimmyJay, nutella, Sloonei, Marmot, Made
Total votes: 15

and VC

[Strawhenge]

Well, I didn't expect so little curiosity

I was informed that Alison is guilty

When did you receive this info?

[KZA]

what kind of mech nightmare is this game

[falcon45ca]

[VOTE: VOTE ALISON] aubergine Fuckin' pissed I didn't kill her D2

[Alison]

Well, I didn't expect so little curiosity

I was informed that Alison is guilty

what

I'm not mafia

[Alison]

are you a cop? what exactly is your role

[Alison]

also how did you get a check on an intermission that isn't actually a night

[Michelle]

I didn't receive the result now

[Strawhenge]

I didn't receive the result now

When did you receive it?

[Michelle]

I didn't receive the result now

When did you receive it?

After the last night with actions

[Alison]

the last night with actions was a night I was swapped with sloonei

so if you targeted me, you got a result on sloonei, who is flipped town

[Alison]

also why did you hold a red check for so long

[Michelle]

Who swapped you?

[Michelle]

also why did you hold a red check for so long

Why should I tell about it immediately?

[Michelle]

the last night with actions was a night I was swapped with sloonei

so if you targeted me, you got a result on sloonei, who is flipped town

I don't trust this

[Alison]

Who swapped you?

oddmerta

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Who's claiming the busdrive again? Bo?

[Alison]

and he claimed his swap before you claimed your check, it's well established that he swapped me that night. he says he was trying to redirect mafia shot from me to sloonei which fits since sloonei was his mafia read.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Oh odd, close enough

[Alison]

Who's claiming the busdrive again? Bo?

oddmerta

[BoKnows]

also why did you hold a red check for so long

Why should I tell about it immediately?

Why wouldn't you?