The Syndicate

Bass or Vomps or Mata?

MovingPictures07 wrote:Bass or Vomps or Mata?

I feel strongest about Vomps currently.

Mongoose wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:Bass or Vomps or Mata?

I feel strongest about Vomps currently.

You're only saying that because you don't know you're no longer on my suspect list.

Mongoose wrote:

Epignosis wrote:I am recreating my spreadsheet from scratch.

Question about Boddy targets:

SVS was Boddy's target on Night 1. Correct?

MP was targeted by Boddy on Night 4. Correct?

That means Boddy HAD to have voted on Day 4, correct?

That seeems right to me.

If this is true, Bass has to be Boddy. I've recreated my spreadsheet three times now.

I'm excluding myself from the list, obviously because I know my own role. On day four, three players voted - MP, Bass, and Epig, and Boddy targeted that night. I tend to trust Epig. I'm unsure of the other two. Bass pulled a fairly risky bluff by implying he had something to do with one of the switches. MP kind of questioned it, and then came back later and said he thought he understood, (his post wasn't all that clear to me), so I'm wondering if something has happened that totally rules MP out as Boddy, as Boddy could self-target )long shot, I know. Any help would be appreciated.

Matahari wrote:I'm excluding myself from the list, obviously because I know my own role. On day four, three players voted - MP, Bass, and Epig, and Boddy targeted that night. I tend to trust Epig. I'm unsure of the other two. Bass pulled a fairly risky bluff by implying he had something to do with one of the switches. MP kind of questioned it, and then came back later and said he thought he understood, (his post wasn't all that clear to me), so I'm wondering if something has happened that totally rules MP out as Boddy, as Boddy could self-target )long shot, I know. Any help would be appreciated.

I have MP ruled out as Boddy for three reasons.

Epignosis wrote:

Mongoose wrote:

Epignosis wrote:I am recreating my spreadsheet from scratch.

Question about Boddy targets:

SVS was Boddy's target on Night 1. Correct?

MP was targeted by Boddy on Night 4. Correct?

That means Boddy HAD to have voted on Day 4, correct?

That seeems right to me.

If this is true, Bass has to be Boddy. I've recreated my spreadsheet three times now.

Ture, him surviving the vote is hardly conclusive, YET in my mind it makes it more likely than not.

Ok, thanks. So the chief claim was more than likely a bluff.

If Bass is voted and revealed to be the chief, who would your next suspect for Boddy be?

Matahari wrote:If Bass is voted and revealed to be the chief, who would your next suspect for Boddy be?

If Bass isn't Boddy, then I call shenanigans.

Do we want to kill Boddy?

I'm calling bull shit on epig I am 100% he isn't civ this game. He knows I know and thats why he is pushing my lynch today.

Vompatti wrote:Do we want to kill Boddy?

I've thought about this a lot. His role doesn't mention any secrets (maybe the blackmail has some kill provision based upon how the target responds? maybe it's chance?), but he's a Last Man Standing, which is contravenous to both civs and mafia. Due to the LMS nature of his role, it would behoove him to sow discord and doubt through the thread -- that player is definitely going to be steering us into chaos.

Bass_the_Clever wrote:I'm calling bull shit on epig I am 100% he isn't civ this game. He knows I know and thats why he is pushing my lynch today.

So you're a lynch switcher, a role checker, and a mind reader.

Please hold off voting till later so I can make my case

Intriguing.

I'm willing to hold my vote until the late evening. Be back then.

See? Shenanigans!

Recreating my spreadsheet for a fourth (!) time.

Im voting so i wont forget tomorrow morning during my training. Voting Bass again.

I'm confused, what does this mean?

^ I',m asssuming Bass mighgtt not be Boboddddody. Does that mean we shoduld vote Mata?

MovingPictures07 wrote:I'm confused, what does this mean?

It means that Boogs shouldn't have rushed in here to vote like that.

I'll post the Wadsworth and Boddy suspects when I finish computing.

Waddy suspects: Boogs and Vompatti
Boddy suspects: Mongoose

Epignosis wrote:Waddy suspects: Boogs and Vompatti
Boddy suspects: Mongoose

That sounds more like it, well, it kind of makes sense now.

Folks, may I remind you that the vote ends tomorrow morning? Unless someone can make a strong point against Boogs or Vompatti, I will be voting Mongoose.

hmmm, are we in agreement on the nature of the host's post? I assumed it had to do with something being inconsistent with rules?

I'm not going to comment further on the host's last post. I hope that's okay with everyone.

I'm fine with a Mongoose vote.

Ok so I won the quote contest and was allowed to send a message to someone. That person was trying to get me lynched until the host said there was misinformation then that person changed what they thought. That why I thought that person was bad.

ok, nevermind, I'm lost again.

There was a day when Mongoose didn't vote, but Boddy prodded MP that night. I think. I'll look again, but I'm aware that there is much going on that I don't know about, so I'm also going to trust the majority rule this time.

ok, I'm wrong, mongoose missed vote on day 3, mp got bothered on night 4. I can see a Mongoose vote.

Suits me. I'll vote before bed unless anyone raises any other point.

I have voted.

I voted Bass because I'm confused.

I voted mongoose

Who is a dirty communist?

Poll ended at Wed Oct 08, 2014 9:04:56 am

Bass_the_Clever
2
Boogs (2), Vompatti (8)
22%

Boogs
0
No votes

Epignosis
0
No votes

Vompatti
0
No votes

Matahari
0
No votes

Mongoose
4
MovingPictures07 (5), Matahari (6), Epignosis (7), Bass_the_Clever (9)
44%

MovingPictures07
0
No votes

Communism was just a red herring. (Host/Mod/Dead/Non)
3
thellama73 (1), zeek (3), Metalmarsh89 (4)
33%


Total votes : 9

Ding ding ding. We have a winner.

thellama73 wrote:And no one really knows what's going on at all.

Patently false.

These are not the droids you are looking for.

Not asking for any names or anything, but I'm curious to know whether any other calculations about players have changed since yesterday.

I wish more people would die.

Epignosis wrote:Ding ding ding. We have a winner.

thellama73 wrote:And no one really knows what's going on at all.

Patently false.

Indeed, I will be voting Mongoose again as soon as the night ends.

Also, as having hosted and played many games the last 4+ years that I've been into mafia, the best answer to the question stated in the poll is "It depends".

I wish night was only 12 hours

Vompatti wrote:I wish more people would die.

It comes out there, it happens here. Coincidence? Or do Vompatti's words have some sort of prophetic power?
The bodies are really starting to pile up. We're gonna need a bigger sofa.

Matahari has been killed by Wadsworth.
You have 24 hours to lynch a bad guy.

Should the host have admitted his error?

Poll runs till Thu Oct 09, 2014 9:16:51 am

Yes. Honesty is the best policy.
5
Mongoose (4), Matahari (5), Epignosis (7), MovingPictures07 (9), Bass_the_Clever (12)
38%

No. It is the host's responsibility to feign infallibility at all times. To do otherwise sows needless doubt and confusion among the masses, who require leadership with a firm hand.
2
Vompatti (6), Boogs (13)
15%

What? (Host/Mod/Dead/Non)
6
thellama73 (1), zeek (2), Hedgeowl (3), Dom (8), S~V~S (10), Made (11)
46%


Total votes : 13

Damn! RIP Matahari.

Damn, that sucks.

So should we vote Mongoose again or Vomps? I think Vomps is Wadsworth.