The Syndicate

Chuck

Oh, this isn't a tie. My apologies.

I am not really seeing why the good doctor's disingenuity makes him a baddie, but I trust 2/3 of the people that want to lynch him. I guess this was fated.

Chuck

I will not argue with this tie.

Chuck

I have arrived with 5 minutes to spare, my friends

Chuck

I think I know who is under Dom's skin suit and I think they are town in that light. I will vote for Golden. Golden Why Golden? Golden's posts just don't look good. I have at least one reason to townread everyone else here, but Golden. It is a easy vote to fall on, though, so don't think I'm not lo...

Chuck

MacDöugall wrote: ↑Wed Apr 04, 2018 10:39 am I think you are a civ. DrWilgy is a civ. Epignosis and Dom are sus. Vompatti and Golden are null. Marmot is scum.

Why is Marmot a scumster?

Chuck

I think I know who is under Dom's skin suit and I think they are town in that light. I will vote for Golden. Golden Of course if you're a freakin pleb you would read Dom as town at face value. But when you're a legend like me you can use remote viewing when reading posts to see the face of the pers...

Chuck

I think I know who is under Dom's skin suit and I think they are town in that light.

I will vote for Golden.

[VOTE: Golden] aubergine

Chuck

Mármot wrote: ↑Wed Apr 04, 2018 6:44 am Look what I woke up to

Beautiful

Chuck

Voting golden noone asks for a supatown role without intending to deliver if town. Guaranteed bad guy right there. Besides, I liked dom's entry just then. That's the dom I know and trust. Town dom. Scratching dom from the list today. I trust dom, epignosis and glorfindel. That's a good town core ri...

Chuck

It's so hard to read people with so few posts, and not knowing who anyone is. But I feel good about Marmot right now, and maybe Golden, for their contributions. Not as great about Epi and Dom. Epi's been avoiding discussion , and I don't like his vote for marmot where it was. Dom just gives me the ...

Chuck

It's so hard to read people with so few posts, and not knowing who anyone is. But I feel good about Marmot right now, and maybe Golden, for their contributions. Not as great about Epi and Dom. Epi's been avoiding discussion, and I don't like his vote for marmot where it was. Dom just gives me the wi...

Chuck

I'm sorry JiggySlooneiJay, I thought I had a decent D1 read.

Chuck

[VOTE: Jiggedjimmyjay] aubergine

I can't exactly explain this beyond a gut feeling. Jay has been prodding all different players and not following up.

Chuck

[mention]JiggedJammyJay[/mention] Do you still think Golden is scum? I don't know how to judge inactivity in this game because I don't know who anyone is. Golden could be the real drwilgy and be role playing kinda badly. I don't know if I want to lynch him for that, and dunya is even worse if we jud...

Chuck

Dôm wrote: ↑Sun Apr 01, 2018 4:24 pm
Glōrfindel wrote: ↑Sun Apr 01, 2018 4:05 pm [VOTE: Dunya] aubergine
no you didn't. Why say you did when you didn't?

same question for marmot; he said he was self voting and he didn't. why?

[VOTE: Marmot] aubergine

Sorry, I forgot.

Does Marmot self-vote when bad? In my opinion it doesn't seem like a good move for mafia.

Chuck

[VOTE: Dunya] aubergine

Chuck

Gólden wrote: ↑Sun Apr 01, 2018 1:58 pm In my experience, Dom is not a player that "chooses" to go after someone. He probes endlessly of anyone.

That quadruple post from Jay seems very uncharacteristic.

How much does that mean in a game where everyone is faking? In my opinion we will have to look past that sort of thing.

Chuck

I come back to mafia for one special game, leave for 24 hours, and this is what I come back to? I don't know why I even try. I'm not going to be addressing any alignment questions, or questions about alignment questions.

Chuck

Epignósis wrote: ↑Fri Mar 30, 2018 9:42 pm Now we’re talking.

Hey Glorfindel- I have two questions for you:

1) Are you a civvie?
2) Are you mafia?

Chuck

Greetings, my friends. :) I'm glad I have the chance to play with you all again! Hey Glorf. I was pleased to see this enthusiasm to begin the game. Where has it gone? Huh? You haven't had a thing to say since! I'm sorry my friends, I've been away at a retreat for the last 24 hours. I'll be catching...

Chuck

Greetings, my friends.

I'm glad I have the chance to play with you all again!

Chuck

Alpha wrote: ↑Fri Dec 15, 2017 11:21 pm
India wrote: ↑Wed Dec 13, 2017 2:26 pmDisguiser is a scary role. I want them to sweat.
India is a fucking badass.

Spoiler: show

Chuck

If I die, lynch . . . Echo?

Chuck

@India were you not around for any of the time Kilo was getting votes? I don't think you missed all of it because Bravo expressed suspicion of Kilo long before EOD, and I followed that. If you had some reason to object to those suspicions, or some specific reason to think Kilo was town, you could h...

Chuck

It appears that I missed an entire page before posting that. Rest in peace, K. Those who lynched you are probably scum. I see nothing in your posts worth the animosity. Number of times you mentioned "K" or "Kilo" prior to the deadline: zero If you felt this way, why did you wait...

Chuck

[mention]Foxtrot[/mention] Would my alignment depend on the alignment of Golf?

Chuck

It appears that I missed an entire page before posting that.

Rest in peace, K. Those who lynched you are probably scum. I see nothing in your posts worth the animosity.

Chuck

India why didn't you respond? To my accusation before stating "She's scared of my hunting?" India's comment towards G was very scummy. Instructing one to catch up is just needless coaching. It was an empty sentence that was disgenuine. In my comment to G, I was referencing their seeming i...

Chuck

India why didn't you respond? To my accusation before stating "She's scared of my hunting?" India's comment towards G was very scummy. Instructing one to catch up is just needless coaching. It was an empty sentence that was disgenuine. In my comment to G, I was referencing their seeming i...

Chuck

Foxtrot is scared of my ability to hunt.

Complaining about game mechanics is dumb. I have played no flip games before. It is doable, though usually utilizes more power roles. Complaints should have happened when the game was proposed.

My phone is destroying all effort to post.

Chuck

I'm also concerned about the fact that Juliet is trying to imply they are Dr. Wilgy. Why? If it is Wilgyi would be inclined to think he is good, but if it is not actually Wilgy, I am inclined to think they are trying to appear as Wilgy to look more benign. I do not know why you would assume that, o...

Chuck

Could we spell fig?

I understand your concerns, Foxtrot, but mafia is all about building suspicions, I think. Even without concrete reason. Just treat every day like a stupid day one, and have fun. But do hunt.

Chuck

I am not going along with random or ordered selection. I refuse. We were given this unique setup to play, and if all it comes down to is vote ordering, then the actual game is already over. The bad guys have the advantage. No information. No results. This leaves a void for us to work in, with nothin...

Chuck

I have no issue with Juliet's choice to rap. I believe I inspired it.

Lack of content is lack of content.

Chuck

Alpha wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2017 4:24 pm tl;dr would force legible content and prevent rapping being used as a smokescreen.

Okay. This does make sense.

Chuck

Without any reliable flips in this game it's more important than ever for everyone to be pretty dang clear about why they're voting for who they're voting for. Without any flips - reliable or unreliable - it will be harder than most other games to determine which voting reasons are genuine. Hello f...

Chuck

Without any reliable flips in this game it's more important than ever for everyone to be pretty dang clear about why they're voting for who they're voting for. Without any flips - reliable or unreliable - it will be harder than most other games to determine which voting reasons are genuine. Hello f...

Chuck

I think it's less likely the Mafia will kill me because they don't want info out there. Also, it was a little spontaneous. Tell me about a better way for more strategic utility. I already have given you a more strategic way to utilize this role, in my initial response. Do you lack the ability to do...

Chuck

I have now voted for Golf. Charlie has made the one off-kilter post. I can understand voting Charlie for that. I do understand, yes. But in lynching Charlie on this day, in this situation, we are limiting discussion. Charlie is one who talks. Golf, perhaps due to unfortunate circumstance, is or was ...

Chuck

We could have waited for day two to pull that. Then the oracle would have a choice regarding who to reveal. How unfortunate. And furthermore, since the oracle is vanilla so long as it lives, I would imagine that the bad guys would avoid killing it. And the good guys would avoid lynching it as well....

Chuck

We could have waited for day two to pull that. Then the oracle would have a choice regarding who to reveal. How unfortunate. And furthermore, since the oracle is vanilla so long as it lives, I would imagine that the bad guys would avoid killing it. And the good guys would avoid lynching it as well. ...

Chuck

The argument I usually see against lynching an inactive player on day one is that we get no information from that. In this game, we get no information anyway. I am not opposed to lynching a mostly inactive player. Though it is frustrating that we have so many.

Chuck

We need to look for changes in post frequency, sentence structure, typo frequency, verbage, term usage, gimmick usage, formality, and so on.

Disguiser is a scary role. I want them to sweat.

Chuck

I should say: I know what a gimmick is, but what is the benefit you believe it offers with regard to hindering the disguiser role? If the gimmick is annoying, subtle, or restrictive to use, the disguiser may not want to kill the person who has it. On the contrary, if the gimmick is easy to mimic, t...

Chuck

A potential 'thing' to look at is the way people post. The playstyle. There is one role, the disguiser, that can mimic people when it kills them. This means: 1. We should look out for people who post different after a night cycle. 2. Gimmicks would make getting killed by the disguiser more of a hind...

Chuck

I don't understand what you think I did wrong. It was an honest question that nobody has directly answered. Nothing is necessarily wrong. What's important to me is the first question I asked -- do you find both Alpha and Charlie suspicious for their part in the conversation? Hum. Charlie more than ...

Chuck

Is this to suggest that you find both suspicious? What makes Charlie's post egregious? Charlie, is your over-the-top Knights Templar thing real or is it just an act to seem more civ? *Voting Charlie* India , opening voting doors with that either/or question on opposite sides of a discussion (whethe...

Chuck

As a component of this hypothetical dick, I must admit that I fail to appreciate its relevance to our objective. I shall not promise that I will not participate should a timely opportunity present itself, but I shall heretofore assume that any participant who focuses disproportionately on that goal...

Chuck

As a component of this hypothetical dick, I must admit that I fail to appreciate its relevance to our objective. I shall not promise that I will not participate should a timely opportunity present itself, but I shall heretofore assume that any participant who focuses disproportionately on that goal...

Chuck

That is about right. I agree with Alpha. Spelling dick is of importance. But what if Delta is scum and Charlie is also scum? Then Delta could be absent and we wouldn't be able to lynch Charlie either. Unless Delta appears day 1, we must abandon this need to profane Sprityo's game. For the good of to...

Search found 424 matches