Arrowverse Mafia - Day 8

[Dragomir]

I know that my scum hunting seems dumb but I guarantee you that the list is full of Mafia.

Of course it is, they're just in your town reads instead.

[Ultra]

Speedchuck and sprityo are both mafia and it's very obvious and Ultra is the other rogue. Let me write down my scoresheet so you can bask in my glory post game. One sec.

Pikachu face

[Ultra]

I've been slanking a bit the last day or so but I promise I'll buckle down.

Voted Lux over Nutella because the former looks scummier at a surface level. And I haven't paid close enough attention to have confidence to push my own wagon atm

[Ultra]

FYI I called Mac indi first and I feel he's a much better fit still *shrugs*

[Ultra]

ck-things he normally does as civ. One caveat though, I've not read the last few pages so if he came in and posted I haven't seen it.

@Sloonei why are you voting Ultra? I probably missed the reason but I'm afraid when I get home from work I won't be able to go back to the pages I have missed so if you can just quote your post explaining it I would appreciate it.

Wondering this myself

sufficiently annoyed now, I'll be back in this thread soon to whole ass

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I know that my scum hunting seems dumb but I guarantee you that the list is full of Mafia.

I'm pretty sure of that, thugh I bet a lot of them have "Town" in front of their names.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I've been getting civ vibes on Jack. I think a baddie would be trying harder to generate a lot of reads and stuff. He is super chill about the fact he's tunneling on nutella and doesn't care about her complaints of it. And Jack does tnnel as a civ. A lot.


I don't necessarily agree with his points though, but nutella is blank for me. Will take a while for me to figure her out.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Lux's responses give me a bad tone. Might vote there. Though I'm worried it may be confirmation bias because I'm kind of making an effort to see what other people are seeing in Lux.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Sabie feels civ as fuck. Sloonei feels good. Drago is pretty good too. I don't think I have more.

Ultra felt town on early Day 0 now he's kind of missing.

[Cooler]

I've been slanking a bit the last day or so but I promise I'll buckle down.

Voted Lux over Nutella because the former looks scummier at a surface level. And I haven't paid close enough attention to have confidence to push my own wagon atm

This is a rather bland and vague way to justify voting for someone. Basically sounds like you've gone for the easy choice while throwing in a nice little excuse for bandwagoning.

You're paying enough attention to say Lux looks scummier than Nutella but not enough to have your own thoughts on the game? Any other players on your suss list?

[speedchuck]

Okay, I super townread Mac, Nutella, and Ultra coming into D0, and was wary of or lightly scumreading sloonei.

What's up? What's changed?

[Cooler]

Okay, I super townread Mac, Nutella, and Ultra coming into D0, and was wary of or lightly scumreading sloonei.

What's up? What's changed?

Can you explain your reads?

[speedchuck]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

"Why Lux?"
I don't feel good about this post. I don't agree with the sentiment of the first line, nor do I feel like that behavior would been to be qualified as suspicious. I also do not see why Lux is suspecting MafiaMenace for not committing to a read on Ultra right away. Lux has not playing with MafiaMenace, to my knowledge. This whole post feels like a reach for suspicion.
Moving on.
This feels a bit like a minimization of what Ultra's doing.

And the bottom line has already been called into question by Ultra. I'm intrigued by that slip, but unable to do anything decisive with it. An explanation exists. It does nothing for me.

This post bothers me for reasons that are difficult to articulate. nutella essentially just says that she is capable of seeing two sides of an argument, and that warrants a "mindmeld" comment from Lux. I dunno, I guess I'm just used to seeing "mindmeld" reserved for strong, drawn out cases, not basic gameplay. Feels like a reach to establish a bond with nutella. This comes back later in a post I've already highlighted. Time for me to share my own thoughts on it:

Spoiler: show

This mindmeld is the only thing convincing me that you have potential to be town

Again, the point which is being "mindmelded" over does not feel particularly strong or meaningful, which makes me feel like it's insincere. And I also do not like it when players dangle suspicion like this. "I would suspect you, but..."
If you are going to say that, you should attach the reasons you have for considering the person a suspect. I don't see Lux doing that anywhere. I see a lot of softball questions for people, but I don't see a really compelling chain of thoughts anywhere in Lux's ISO. And I see this read on nutella that looks very fake.

Sloonei treating day 0 like a super extension on day 1 is like good

But I think this is a bit early of a jump

I can see this coming from an anxious town or a trigger happy scum.

Since y’all apparently bus like there’s no tomorrow here, I’m leaning scum

Another thing I hate is this. Nowhere in this post does Lux attach any of my behavior to bussing. She observes that I am being very active. She then makes the leap from "Sloonei is active" to "People on the Syndicate like to bus", and somehow puts these two pieces together to create a suspicion against me. She would later elaborate that it was "an associative read" between nutella and I, but I do not see why that is the conclusion she is drawing. All Lux has said about me is that I'm extremely active and therefore suspicious. Bogus.

tl;dr: Lux was on fire in the scrimmage. She was the town MVP. This is a limp start, and I don't see threads connecting her thoughts. Her reads feel arbitrary and baseless.

I stopped reading this when you turned my words back around on me lol

By that I mean you suspect me for doing something and then do the same thing so I’m not reading the rest of this
[/quote]

Hypocrisy is a staple of the town playbook.

But also I’m not sure what you’re referring to.

Back to looking for The One Question.
[/quote]

I fixed it because it looked so ugly

I mean firstly i dont think town usually plays hypocritically but I also feel like such a thing has happened before so Fair enough

Secondly, I say “i feel like mafiamenace is trying to discrete ultra” and you express how you think that’s shady. And then you say “i feel like lux is trying to discrete ultra”

And my brain just shuts down
[/quote][/spoiler]

That... was the point? You accused a player of being shady for a thing, and then you did the thing yourself.

That is hypocritical.

And I just said that hypocrisy is a staple of the town playbook. By that I mean that a civilian is perfectly capable of accusing a player of doing something they are also guilty of; just because I do X and know what my intentions were, it does not mean I cannot become suspicious of you when you also do X, because I do not know your intentions.

So here I am, accusing you of being suspicious because you were hypocritical, in open acknowledgment that this itself is hypocritical.
[/quote]

I randomly jumped to a sloonei post to scumread it. Had to comb a bit.

This seems really self-aware and like it's pre-empting discussion.
Which should be a scumtell, but it's been annoyingly unreliable.

[speedchuck]

Never have I been so tempted to just delete a post. What an unholy mess.

[speedchuck]

Okay, I super townread Mac, Nutella, and Ultra coming into D0, and was wary of or lightly scumreading sloonei.

What's up? What's changed?

Can you explain your reads?

I think I did, way back on early D0. Ultra was completely different from his recent scumgame, and was really engaging the thread. Mac and nutella were also different, on a fundamental level, from what they had been.

Sloonei feels stiff and mechanical, and he's spending a lot of time inflating his post count with rote questions. At least he was early on, when he had like 2 pages of posts instead of 7.

[Ultra]

I've been slanking a bit the last day or so but I promise I'll buckle down.

Voted Lux over Nutella because the former looks scummier at a surface level. And I haven't paid close enough attention to have confidence to push my own wagon atm

This is a rather bland and vague way to justify voting for someone. Basically sounds like you've gone for the easy choice while throwing in a nice little excuse for bandwagoning.

You're paying enough attention to say Lux looks scummier than Nutella but not enough to have your own thoughts on the game? Any other players on your suss list?

It is.

And yeah, I've made that abundantly clear.

Iso me

I'm inpatient rn

*handwaves*

[Ultra]

Sabie feels civ as fuck. Sloonei feels good. Drago is pretty good too. I don't think I have more.

Ultra felt town on early Day 0 now he's kind of missing.

Low motive because I haven't had any fire burning gut scum reads.

I probably will when I do my reread.

[Ultra]

Actually, I'm transparently going to OMGUS here on Mac

I think it sets a bad precedent not to hold him accountable for his reads just because his meta as seen as paranoid or whatever. Most players are capable to adapting to such expectations and especially in a multiball game, I can see him totally get away with aggressive play that mirrors his town game as scum.

So with that being said Mac you're going to need to explain your sus on me now.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Sabie feels civ as fuck. Sloonei feels good. Drago is pretty good too. I don't think I have more.

Ultra felt town on early Day 0 now he's kind of missing.

Low motive because I haven't had any fire burning gut scum reads.

I probably will when I do my reread.

I keep thinking your posts are from Creature too, because of youir similarly colored avatars.

[speedchuck]

Like “speed scum” and then “speed scum (although Im not really feeling that anymore)”

Which hasnt really been conveyed here in such a way

But again, similar tone so huff

Did nutella scumread me at some point?

[speedchuck]

Apparently not.

I just visited nutella's ISO and I'm pretty much mindmelded. Legit have no idea why anyone would be voting there.

[speedchuck]

Of the three people voting nutella right now, at least three of them are bad.

[speedchuck]

Maybe not mafia, but just... bad. *hits them with rolled up newspaper*

[speedchuck]

But actually possibly mafia. Worth ISOing.

[Long Con]

I am a bit concerned that Mac is buddying me by declaring me Civ for next to nothing.

[speedchuck]

I am a bit concerned that Mac is buddying me by declaring me Civ for next to nothing.

Almost none of Mac's reads are substantiated. It concerns me as well.

Not because it's scummy. Mac's changing up his game completely, and somehow being completely serious and unable to take seriously at the same time, and I have no idea how to read it. Is he mixing up his town game or scumgame?

[speedchuck]

Of the three people voting nutella right now, at least three of them are bad.

Jack
Mac
Lux

But I didn't read Lux's ISO because it's too long. :3

[Jackofhearts2005]

Let's see if Jack keeps his vote on nutella.

As long as she’s a viable lynch option.

You know how I love to bus.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I've been getting civ vibes on Jack. I think a baddie would be trying harder to generate a lot of reads and stuff. He is super chill about the fact he's tunneling on nutella and doesn't care about her complaints of it. And Jack does tnnel as a civ. A lot.


I don't necessarily agree with his points though, but nutella is blank for me. Will take a while for me to figure her out.

Here’s the thing, too. When I tunnel as a civ (or even as a neutral or scum player in multiball) I’m generally right.

See: Silver Lantern in Mass Effect, SenorSalt in BSG (MU), Fraggernaut in One Punch Mash (MU), Speedchuck in Ancient Greece, Rich in Restless Communication 2 (MU Discord).

I tunnel because I’m certain and I’m certain because I’m right.

[Ultra]

I am a bit concerned that Mac is buddying me by declaring me Civ for next to nothing.

Almost none of Mac's reads are substantiated. It concerns me as well.

Not because it's scummy. Mac's changing up his game completely, and somehow being completely serious and unable to take seriously at the same time, and I have no idea how to read it. Is he mixing up his town game or scumgame?

I'm telling you he's SK

[Jackofhearts2005]

[mention]speedchuck[/mention]

Trust me. I’ve never steered you wrong.

(Mostly because every time I rand scum, you’re on my team but still.)

[speedchuck]

I've been getting civ vibes on Jack. I think a baddie would be trying harder to generate a lot of reads and stuff. He is super chill about the fact he's tunneling on nutella and doesn't care about her complaints of it. And Jack does tnnel as a civ. A lot.


I don't necessarily agree with his points though, but nutella is blank for me. Will take a while for me to figure her out.

Here’s the thing, too. When I tunnel as a civ (or even as a neutral or scum player in multiball) I’m generally right.

See: Silver Lantern in Mass Effect, SenorSalt in BSG (MU), Fraggernaut in One Punch Mash (MU), Speedchuck in Ancient Greece, Rich in Restless Communication 2 (MU Discord).

I tunnel because I’m certain and I’m certain because I’m right.

I've been here over two years, and played in a lot of games with you. AG is the only correct tunnel you can reference from those games? Weak.

Let's see if Jack keeps his vote on nutella.

As long as she’s a viable lynch option.

You know how I love to bus.

You and I both know that isn't true.

[Sloonei]

[mention]Dragomir[/mention] are speedchuck’s posts on this page more in line with my description of “Good wishywahsy” or “Bad wishywashy”?

I can’t decide.

[speedchuck]

@Dragomir are speedchuck’s posts on this page more in line with my description of “Good wishywahsy” or “Bad wishywashy”?

I can’t decide.

Why ask him?

[Sloonei]

[VOTE: Cooler] aubergine

I've been slanking a bit the last day or so but I promise I'll buckle down.

Voted Lux over Nutella because the former looks scummier at a surface level. And I haven't paid close enough attention to have confidence to push my own wagon atm

This is a rather bland and vague way to justify voting for someone. Basically sounds like you've gone for the easy choice while throwing in a nice little excuse for bandwagoning.

You're paying enough attention to say Lux looks scummier than Nutella but not enough to have your own thoughts on the game? Any other players on your suss list?

This is the most cherrypicked, obligatory suspicion I’ve ever seen. Creature says nothing for a long time but then picks this post out of the rubble to say unkind things about. Why?

[Sloonei]

@Dragomir are speedchuck’s posts on this page more in line with my description of “Good wishywahsy” or “Bad wishywashy”?

I can’t decide.

Why ask him?

Because we just had a conversation about this last night. I want to see what be thinks.

[speedchuck]

@Dragomir are speedchuck’s posts on this page more in line with my description of “Good wishywahsy” or “Bad wishywashy”?

I can’t decide.

Why ask him?

Because we just had a conversation about this last night. I want to see what be thinks.

Cool.

I am missing quite a bit of context. Thanks for the answer.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I've been getting civ vibes on Jack. I think a baddie would be trying harder to generate a lot of reads and stuff. He is super chill about the fact he's tunneling on nutella and doesn't care about her complaints of it. And Jack does tnnel as a civ. A lot.


I don't necessarily agree with his points though, but nutella is blank for me. Will take a while for me to figure her out.

Here’s the thing, too. When I tunnel as a civ (or even as a neutral or scum player in multiball) I’m generally right.

See: Silver Lantern in Mass Effect, SenorSalt in BSG (MU), Fraggernaut in One Punch Mash (MU), Speedchuck in Ancient Greece, Rich in Restless Communication 2 (MU Discord).

I tunnel because I’m certain and I’m certain because I’m right.

I've been here over two years, and played in a lot of games with you. AG is the only correct tunnel you can reference from those games? Weak.

Let's see if Jack keeps his vote on nutella.

As long as she’s a viable lynch option.

You know how I love to bus.

You and I both know that isn't true.

Well I don’t always rand town and when I do, I don’t always tunnel. 2 for 2 isn’t bad.

You got me. I’m not bussing Nutella. I’m still certain she’s mafia.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Also DDL in Addams Family. 3/3 when a tunnel a single player until they die in games with opposing scum.

[nutella]

Sorry jack but you are wrong this time.

Speed you buddying me bro jk, for now I believe you were actually mindmelding me

I'm not sure I'm feeling the lux vote anymore. But I can't think of anyone else I really suspect rn (besides sloonei still but Mac is probably right that he won't realistically get lynched, and it appears I have to worry about self preservation now). Maybe just a quiet person.

[Dragomir]

Never have I been so tempted to just delete a post. What an unholy mess.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Sorry jack but you are wrong this time.

Speed you buddying me bro jk, for now I believe you were actually mindmelding me

I'm not sure I'm feeling the lux vote anymore. But I can't think of anyone else I really suspect rn (besides sloonei still but Mac is probably right that he won't realistically get lynched, and it appears I have to worry about self preservation now). Maybe just a quiet person.

So you’ve jettisoned your scumreads on Lux and me. You threw out your Mac scumread awhile ago.

What about Mata?

[Jackofhearts2005]

Give me two players you’d lynch and a third you’d maybe lynch.

[Jackofhearts2005]

When you’re above reusing gifs but not above reusing jokes.

[Dragomir]

@Dragomir are speedchuck’s posts on this page more in line with my description of “Good wishywahsy” or “Bad wishywashy”?

I can’t decide.

Neither. He's perfectly neutral.

If dunya posts a big long spiel where she identifies possible scenarios for the player she’s ISOing to be either town of scum without committing to one side of the other, that’s good wishywashy.

If JaggedJimmyJay says “well maybe this person is possibly bad because of this but I don’t know, don’t look at me, go away”, that’s bas wishywashy.

I don't see him trying to find possible scenarios for where a certain is town or wolf but neither is he questioning his own reads like the JJJ example.

[nutella]

Sorry jack but you are wrong this time.

Speed you buddying me bro jk, for now I believe you were actually mindmelding me

I'm not sure I'm feeling the lux vote anymore. But I can't think of anyone else I really suspect rn (besides sloonei still but Mac is probably right that he won't realistically get lynched, and it appears I have to worry about self preservation now). Maybe just a quiet person.

So you’ve jettisoned your scumreads on Lux and me. You threw out your Mac scumread awhile ago.

What about Mata?

Mata is still on the table, yeah. I cooled down on her when she started to give thoughts but she's been quiet for a while again.

[speedchuck]

Give me two players you’d lynch and a third you’d maybe lynch.

"please give me player salad"

[speedchuck]

(besides sloonei still but Mac is probably right that he won't realistically get lynched, and it appears I have to worry about self preservation now).

You never know until you try

[nutella]

(besides sloonei still but Mac is probably right that he won't realistically get lynched, and it appears I have to worry about self preservation now).

You never know until you try

You down?

[nutella]

It's certainly a gamble. If sloonei is town after all losing him would be a significant hot to the thread activity and we'd all have to step it up. But, if he's bad he's all the more dangerous with his influence.