Guitar Mafia [Day 3]

[Roxy]

I'd like to hear thoughts on JPIC from Long Con

I just read over his ISO and I feel pretty towny about him. He'd be shaded a notch more green than Roxy and hal if I remade my list.

Is there something specific you're reading in their ISO that gives you the towny vibes?





Ditto Roxy & Hal plz

Probs bc they posted!!!

LC called JPIC town with zero posts - why change it up now?

[Roxy]

Long Con
falcon45ca
Scotty
Roxy
Justplayingitcool
hal
S~V~S

Roughly where I stand right now. Could be hal and S~V~S. Roxy and S~V~S is fun. JPIC, I'm just not sure about you yet. You'll be the first I reread ISO on.

lmmfao

after that last list this is no better

You seem to be just phoning it in

[Roxy]

Anyway, one of the things that I like to do is build potential teams and i know i know it's not a great idea without a scum flip, but humour me:

From my perspective, I feel like the potential words atm are Scotty/Long Con vs SVS or X/X. I feel like X is either Roxy or Hal. Don't really have a read on either. Thought it was weird for roxy to show up out of the blue to say the timmer vote was bad like a few minutes before the phase ended without there being much chance to change the course. but eh, don't hard to find any mafia intent in that really as probably best for them to stay quiet

well it was when I could be here.
would you have rathered I lied and said --- "oooo what a great elim!!!!!"

I just spill truth sorry if you do not like it.

You seem to be playing a very sheeping style game do you have any thoughts of your own or are you just going to follow any leader this game?

[Roxy]

Hal/Roxy

I am going to be vvery blunt here - If I was ever put on a baddie team with them again I would just quit the game the instant I found out.

They are horrible as a team bc they play only for themselves and do not think of anyone on their team while doing so.

[Roxy]

Right now, my vague Roxy read is separate from my SVS read.

lmao
do better

[Roxy]

Yeah I think I’d rather focus on the timmer wagon because I think that is a hit. Not ready to believe both wolves are on that wagon. Gut says no, but I want a wolf flip

better flip yourself then - just saying

[Justplayingitcool]

Anyway, one of the things that I like to do is build potential teams and i know i know it's not a great idea without a scum flip, but humour me:

From my perspective, I feel like the potential words atm are Scotty/Long Con vs SVS or X/X. I feel like X is either Roxy or Hal. Don't really have a read on either. Thought it was weird for roxy to show up out of the blue to say the timmer vote was bad like a few minutes before the phase ended without there being much chance to change the course. but eh, don't hard to find any mafia intent in that really as probably best for them to stay quiet

well it was when I could be here.
would you have rathered I lied and said --- "oooo what a great elim!!!!!"

I just spill truth sorry if you do not like it.

You seem to be playing a very sheeping style game do you have any thoughts of your own or are you just going to follow any leader this game?

Ironically you are quoting one of the posts where i made a thought this game

[Justplayingitcool]

Also that was very defensive

[Justplayingitcool]

Hal/Roxy

I am going to be vvery blunt here - If I was ever put on a baddie team with them again I would just quit the game the instant I found out.

They are horrible as a team bc they play only for themselves and do not think of anyone on their team while doing so.

No idea what the context is but i believe that you believe this

[Justplayingitcool]

I'd like to hear thoughts on JPIC from Long Con

I just read over his ISO and I feel pretty towny about him. He'd be shaded a notch more green than Roxy and hal if I remade my list.

Is there something specific you're reading in their ISO that gives you the towny vibes?





Ditto Roxy & Hal plz

Probs bc they posted!!!

LC called JPIC town with zero posts - why change it up now?

He called me mafia with 0 posts ackshually

[Roxy]

Also that was very defensive

you are damn right it is defensive why should I not be defensive?

[Justplayingitcool]

Also that was very defensive

you are damn right it is defensive why should I not be defensive?

Probs because it was a passing thought of mine that wasn’t to be taken too intensely

[Justplayingitcool]

Like literally in the last sentence i disregarded the thought as i was typing lol

[Roxy]

No, just a good schemer.

I have never played with anyone in this playlist before, who do you think are good wolves here and how comfortable do you feel in the playerlist?

I do feel comfortable with this playlist. Now that that Hal guy's gone. Either way, you are the newest player to me on this list. Everyone else is someone I've played with 3 million times.

falcon45ca - Town
hal - robyn
Justplayingitcool - Lean Scum
Long Con - I can't read this guy
Roxy - Scum
Seanzie - Lean town
Scotty - Lean Scum
S~V~S - Town
timmer - Scum

How about that?

You were right JPIC I am sorry and offer you a peace sign.

This list tho......he never answered any of my questions about it.

Like how you were scum with zero posts
or
seanzie was town with zero posts
or
no read at all for hal/robyn/lucy
or
Timmer scum bc they said they would not be around d 1

[Roxy]

He called me mafia with 0 posts ackshually

My point being you are now town (according to LC) *bc* you have posted.

srsly you do not find it odd at all?

[Justplayingitcool]

Yeah the list is bizarre. Part me though does think it might be towny? I feel like mafia would take more care in posting a reads list like that

[Justplayingitcool]

I know when im mafia i have the habit of being a lot more structured in my thoughts and i’d be more careful in who i label as my town/mafia reads

[Justplayingitcool]

Does mafia!long con label half the team as mafia lol

[falcon45ca]

I'm fine with LC or Hal

[falcon45ca]

Does mafia!long con label half the team as mafia lol

Why not? Can't get caught not trying to find Maf, may as well toss a bunch of candidates out there.




Do you feel they're solving? Just feels like they've been quite focused on just SVS IMO

[Roxy]

Yeah the list is bizarre. Part me though does think it might be towny? I feel like mafia would take more care in posting a reads list like that

I guess but honestly everyone plays their own way.

Maybe *you* would take more care but others not so much.

[Roxy]

I'm fine with LC or Hal

what happened to your baddie read of me?

[Roxy]

scotty stuff:

Ahh doesn’t day end soon?

What are we doing? Right now it’s LC

Anyone around???

I am guessing Scotty did not want LC elimmed

[VOTE: jpic] aubergine

Ties aren’t a no lynch right?

voting all over the map EXCEPT LC

[VOTE: hal] aubergine

This was ootb (out of the blue)

Let it rand

[VOTE: hal] aubergine

why

because

For literally no reason

@Scotty why'd you vote me, i thought you said i was a bad d1 on multiple occasions

I was trying to be spicy

Can’t I be spicy?

I am sorry there was a reason - he wanted to be spicy - yah ok but I am not buying it

Ok well if game is still going, I’d prefer a timmer vote

Now coming back around to Timmer since there was a more receptive audience for that elim

Hal hanging out here at end of day without adding much since the Roxy thunderdome is a bad vibe. That’s more of why I voted there

Added this reasoning after the fact instead of spicy he now has come up with reasons

now the question is, is scotty clear for the derp?

lol no that’s stupid

Derp is gonna deep regardless of if I’m a dirty wolfboi

yeah wolfboy indeed

[VOTE: timmer] aubergine

finally getting his Timmer vote in

Is there any world in which LC and timmer are scumbuddies?

Like, in a probably 7v2, wolves will be screwed if one dies d1

shading the shadiest player lol


Scotty's Day 1 felt like an awful lot of shit throwing to see what was gonna stick he was all over the map with many different reasons given, none of them were outstanding, all were just seeing what was going to fly.

Me no likey.

[Roxy]

yay I chased away both falcon and JPIC......

[Roxy]

LongCon and Hal/robyn/lucy need to be done and I hope I'll have time - got a meeting rn tho

[Justplayingitcool]

Does mafia!long con label half the team as mafia lol

Why not? Can't get caught not trying to find Maf, may as well toss a bunch of candidates out there.




Do you feel they're solving? Just feels like they've been quite focused on just SVS IMO

I’ve not been fully focused on long con but when I’ve interacted them i never got baddie vibes, and even the stuff that made me raise an eyebrow i could see a townie perspective in them

[Justplayingitcool]

There is indeed a world where scotty and long con are power wolfing us

[falcon45ca]

I'm fine with LC or Hal

what happened to your baddie read of me?

You're not out of the woods, but really I wanted you to engage



[VOTE: LC] aubergine

[S~V~S]

Does mafia!long con label half the team as mafia lol

Why not? Can't get caught not trying to find Maf, may as well toss a bunch of candidates out there.




Do you feel they're solving? Just feels like they've been quite focused on just SVS IMO

I was on his Townie list until I voted for him. He’s been No U-ing me ever since.

If I need to move my vote to save I will, but I’m good where I am.

[falcon45ca]

There is indeed a world where scotty and long con are power wolfing us

GTH, who are the wolves? Gut feels allowed.

[Justplayingitcool]

There is indeed a world where scotty and long con are power wolfing us

GTH, who are the wolves? Gut feels allowed.

rn im wrestling between scotty/long con or hal/SVS. I know it's not the answer you're hoping for from me.

Though, if I had to go further than that I would opt for the latter as being baddies, purely because Hal hasn't done anything to reassure me so far this phase. I don't scumread SVS but they make the most sense as a partner to hal as of right now

[Roxy]

hal/robyn/lucy - I was going to pull quotes but honestly there is no reason.

They said we always keep Timmer here

They said Seanzie always dies here

They did not like getting votes yet did nothing to help push the game forward except to follow others with a Timmer vote.

Has really not helped find their own suspects.

This post kinda shows what I mean inre to their play this game:

mmer had 3-4 votes, no i haven’t thought about the game much at all except that the seanzie kill was extremely strange. and what changed my mind was when scotty said that seanzie would be subbed out, and that until an hour before eod i was gonna chopped by a dice roll

and the last line I am not even sure what it is trying to say or mean.

Their iso is nagl.

[Roxy]

I'm fine with LC or Hal

what happened to your baddie read of me?

You're not out of the woods, but really I wanted you to engage



[VOTE: LC] aubergine

yah ok.....

I wanted an answer tho.

What has happened to your baddie read of me?

What was baddie to begin with?

[Roxy]

I was v surprised Scotty has voted SVS. I couldn't really find any reason. Except for - myopic.

Like what?

Wants me to read SVS for him - uh no. Not gonna happen. Get your own read.

[Roxy]

LongCon I would just like you to respond to my D 1 post about your "list" that was not a joke. I will not be buying that answer so come up with another.

I do feel comfortable with this playlist. Now that that Hal guy's gone. Either way, you are the newest player to me on this list. Everyone else is someone I've played with 3 million times.

falcon45ca - Town
hal - robyn
Justplayingitcool - Lean Scum
Long Con - I can't read this guy
Roxy - Scum
Seanzie - Lean town
Scotty - Lean Scum
S~V~S - Town
timmer - Scum

I forgot to ask this earlier but I got a few questions:

How do read Seanzie as town when they haven't posted at all?

How do you read Justplayingitcool as a baddie when they haven't posted at all?

You skipped "Hal" what is your read on them?

Why do you read me as a baddie?

and this one too while you are at it:

Long Con
falcon45ca
Scotty
Roxy
Justplayingitcool
hal
S~V~S

Roughly where I stand right now. Could be hal and S~V~S. Roxy and S~V~S is fun. JPIC, I'm just not sure about you yet. You'll be the first I reread ISO on.

lmmfao

after that last list this is no better

You seem to be just phoning it in

[Roxy]

My order of baddies:
Scotty
LongCon
Hal/Robyn/Lucy

[falcon45ca]

I'm fine with LC or Hal

what happened to your baddie read of me?

You're not out of the woods, but really I wanted you to engage



[VOTE: LC] aubergine

yah ok.....

I wanted an answer tho.

What has happened to your baddie read of me?

What was baddie to begin with?

I mentioned it to Scotty earlier, you messaged me to get into the game, but have felt passive (up til now) this RD




You're outside my POE right now

[Roxy]

ok got it I do not like your answer or sort of your lack of one but I will live

[hal]

Hal/Roxy

I am going to be vvery blunt here - If I was ever put on a baddie team with them again I would just quit the game the instant I found out.

They are horrible as a team bc they play only for themselves and do not think of anyone on their team while doing so.

i'm a team player and that's why my winrate is high, it just so happens being a team player with my brain typically involves ignoring others for the greater good

[hal]

I'm fine with LC or Hal

uwu

[hal]

hal/robyn/lucy - I was going to pull quotes but honestly there is no reason.

They said we always keep Timmer here

They said Seanzie always dies here

They did not like getting votes yet did nothing to help push the game forward except to follow others with a Timmer vote.

Has really not helped find their own suspects.

This post kinda shows what I mean inre to their play this game:

mmer had 3-4 votes, no i haven’t thought about the game much at all except that the seanzie kill was extremely strange. and what changed my mind was when scotty said that seanzie would be subbed out, and that until an hour before eod i was gonna chopped by a dice roll

and the last line I am not even sure what it is trying to say or mean.

Their iso is nagl.

good analysis, are you trying to actively chop me?

[hal]

My order of baddies:
Scotty
LongCon
Hal/Robyn/Lucy

wowee i'm here 3 times

[hal]

unsure i'm not being completely pummeled here, especially because i dropped off the face of the planet this cycle, i did expect to die here but whatever. i've been extremely busy recently and i can't be on for eod. and i will be present d3

apologies for the inactivity

[hal]

falcon45ca
0
No votes
Voters: None
hal
1
14%
Voters: Justplayingitcool
Justplayingitcool
0
No votes
Voters: None
Long Con
2
29%
Voters: S~V~S, falcon45ca
Roxy
0
No votes
Voters: None
Scotty
0
No votes
Voters: None
S~V~S
2
29%
Voters: Long Con, Scotty
timmer
0
No votes
Voters: None

[hal]

falcon45ca
0
No votes
Voters: None
hal
1
13%
Voters: Justplayingitcool
Justplayingitcool
0
No votes
Voters: None
Long Con
3
38%
Voters: S~V~S, falcon45ca, hal
Roxy
0
No votes
Voters: None
Scotty
0
No votes
Voters: None
S~V~S
2
25%
Voters: Long Con, Scotty
timmer
0
No votes
Voters: None

[hal]

falcon and svs are town i'm p sure, roxy too and she had issue with LC before

[falcon45ca]

I likely won't be here for EOD.




[VOTE: hal] aubergine




I'll pop in if I can, but it's Hal/LC for me this RD



TRing JPIC, Roxy



Less sure on SVS, Scotty

[falcon45ca]

There's 3 wagons right now, Hal, LC, SVS



I am town, which leaves Scotty, Roxy, JPIC.



I find it hard to believe that there are 2 Maf in Scotty, Roxy, JPIC

[Long Con]

LongCon I would just like you to respond to my D 1 post about your "list" that was not a joke. I will not be buying that answer so come up with another.

I do feel comfortable with this playlist. Now that that Hal guy's gone. Either way, you are the newest player to me on this list. Everyone else is someone I've played with 3 million times.

falcon45ca - Town
hal - robyn
Justplayingitcool - Lean Scum
Long Con - I can't read this guy
Roxy - Scum
Seanzie - Lean town
Scotty - Lean Scum
S~V~S - Town
timmer - Scum

I forgot to ask this earlier but I got a few questions:

How do read Seanzie as town when they haven't posted at all?

How do you read Justplayingitcool as a baddie when they haven't posted at all?

You skipped "Hal" what is your read on them?

Why do you read me as a baddie?

and this one too while you are at it:

Long Con
falcon45ca
Scotty
Roxy
Justplayingitcool
hal
S~V~S

Roughly where I stand right now. Could be hal and S~V~S. Roxy and S~V~S is fun. JPIC, I'm just not sure about you yet. You'll be the first I reread ISO on.

lmmfao

after that last list this is no better

You seem to be just phoning it in

First list was just about reactions, and was obviously not that serious as it ascribed alignments to zero-posters. Second list is my alignment opinion of the players in the game at the time. Glad I could clear that up.

[Long Con]

Right now, my vague Roxy read is separate from my SVS read.

lmao
do better

Thanks for the advice, what would you like specifically?