potentialsheltervet wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 12:59 am
From my half-hearted skimming of the thread it looks like a lot of the content thus far is based on meta, which is useless to me. So I hereby declare all of that poopoo and shan't be bothering.
Do you have any reads in general that aren't requiring meta?
Aside from what I've stated, not really. I'm intrigued by nutella voting me.
potentialsheltervet wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 12:59 am
From my half-hearted skimming of the thread it looks like a lot of the content thus far is based on meta, which is useless to me. So I hereby declare all of that poopoo and shan't be bothering.
Do you have any reads in general that aren't requiring meta?
Aside from what I've stated, not really. I'm intrigued by nutella voting me.
I'm trying out a new kind of read list. I think this diagram is going to help me understand every connection between the players and eventually solve the game. Prepare for genius
Tl;dr I'm actually trying out basing some reads on my belief that tutuu is town and assessing how people are reading her and uhhh doing something after that
It’s midnight Tuesday night. So it’s Wednesday the 15th. I took an embarrassingly long time to figure out that I hadn’t in fact showed up 4 hours late to eod to a somehow open thread.
tutuu wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 10:16 am
The other thread probably has 10 pages of spammy nonsense by now. I would like to think that we are the more intelligent group. Perhaps Jay divided us by intelligence. We are the scientists, and the other group are the primates.
must be a mod error then cos i think i ended up in the wrong group in that case
nutella wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 11:43 am
nearly everyone has posted but it hardly feels like it
Yeah definitely ?_? it feels weirdly quiet
How are you feeling so far? Any thoughts? \o/
I’m trying to fill the thread with thots
People I’m liking thus far and whom I wouldn’t mind have a little dance party with in the break room:
You
Long Con
jack
ilario
People that need some coffee or something to be a productive member of society:
tutuu
Lime Coke
Nutella
People that apparently work here but only come out when the lunch bell chimes:
is the second list people you scumread or people you just find null? if its scumreads then why is there a discrepancy between me and nutella? we both have outed very similar takes and i dont feel like i have posted anything too alignment indicative yet so far
Cape90 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 3:48 pm
Anyways, sup?
My nutella read was based on #15 and #18 primarily there
My Scotty read was him making me chuckle when i realized he was literally not finishing sentences and that was it LOL, perhaps not as strong .
the gimmick could have been chosen pre-rand, why was that something you felt was more likely to come from town than a wolf?
I was going off the logic of "townies funny wolves arent" and that was it.
Though as I previously said, I also feel like Scotty was/has been productive in a way which I don't think comes from mafia? IDK I kinda imagine if mafia were doing that it would be less game-related and more shitposty or whatever
ilario wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 8:22 am
a little pinged by lime cokes opening, i think he leans into copypasta and meme openers more as wolf. still early though and if hes town im sure ill find him at some point this game
didnt like capes opener either but cant really pinpoint why other than it felt a little awkward to me
delta leaning town on everyone might be slightly towny, wolves tend to be slightly more pressured to find something to scumread or shade in their openers
is this not what you just did? :wowee:
Is there anyone aside from me you think had a townie entrance?
yep it sure is, but thats cos im on a timer most games im village so ive shifted my focus from towncore building into just trying to kill wolves
there were other entrances that seemed fine but i havent played as much with those players so i was waiting for the day to play out some more. but since you brought it up id scotty seemed relaxed tonally, and i liked tutuu but im not sure if thats alignment indicative for them or not, they strike me as someone id probably like and get along with as either alignment
I kinda dislike this post, especially the tutuu part feels just wrong to me
I feel like you dont know how to respond to my earlier callout on your slot so instead you're trying to reverse it back onto me. Maybe im being a little ungenerous though but I also know we have played a bunch and you're used to me making these kinds of posts. What part of it stuck out to you as feeling wrong when its a pretty standard post for me i feel like
tutuu wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 4:27 pm
Has anybody seen Scotty mafia? And Cape mafia? And Jack mafia? I've seen none of those. Any chance they have tells that they haven't been able to overcome?
ive seen cape scum, he has a few tells ive been waiting to see if he hits before i go full send on him lol
tutuu wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 4:27 pm
Has anybody seen Scotty mafia? And Cape mafia? And Jack mafia? I've seen none of those. Any chance they have tells that they haven't been able to overcome?
Cant remember with scotty like probably but cant recall
Cape you'll be able to tell imo but ppl read him wrong all the time so idk maybe defer and outsource your read if you need
Think I've only seen jack wolf when he is afk lol
actually ur right, i have seen jack wolf and he was afk that game lmao. pretty sure we were wolfbuddies on some game amrock hosted
ilario wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 8:22 am
a little pinged by lime cokes opening, i think he leans into copypasta and meme openers more as wolf. still early though and if hes town im sure ill find him at some point this game
didnt like capes opener either but cant really pinpoint why other than it felt a little awkward to me
delta leaning town on everyone might be slightly towny, wolves tend to be slightly more pressured to find something to scumread or shade in their openers
is this not what you just did? :wowee:
Is there anyone aside from me you think had a townie entrance?
yep it sure is, but thats cos im on a timer most games im village so ive shifted my focus from towncore building into just trying to kill wolves
there were other entrances that seemed fine but i havent played as much with those players so i was waiting for the day to play out some more. but since you brought it up id scotty seemed relaxed tonally, and i liked tutuu but im not sure if thats alignment indicative for them or not, they strike me as someone id probably like and get along with as either alignment
I kinda dislike this post, especially the tutuu part feels just wrong to me
How can he be wrong? Well sure he can be wrong that I'm town, but he's just saying that he likes me. Is that not a subjective preference? Where is the room for error?
(unless you're using wrong to say scummy rather than incorrect?)
I was more bothered by the hedginess of it tbh
theres no hedginess. i didnt give a read on tutuu in that post. ironically enough your response to me was more hedgy than the actual post you accused of being hedgy
if I were to predict who gets D1ed, atm it would be Porscha
and I might be on board with that
I definitely need more engagement from PSV though. And the new folks Alexy and Darling
porscha makes her alignment obvious the more the game goes along, not a good idea for a d1 unless the thread is excessively towny otherwise, which is far from the case
nutella wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 1:16 am
I'm trying out a new kind of read list. I think this diagram is going to help me understand every connection between the players and eventually solve the game. Prepare for genius
tutuu wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 3:45 am
I don't know. I don't hate Delta's posts. But he can fake those posts with his eyes closed.
I think nutella and lime coke are towny.
Psv ... I wrongly scumread quite a lot last game. She's scumreadable. I hesitate.
No idea how to read ilario.
A lot of people posted once or twice and then dipped. Not exactly easy.
[VOTE:
unvote] aubergine
I will probably just sheep ... someone.
?_?
For what it's worth I can definitely see that being townie from you because I'm 90% sure you made that exact read when I was a wolf x_x
But if you'd like to work out if they're fakeable or not, why not just. Ask? ;_; I want people to engage me on my reads as is & it seems a little silly going 'yep thats fakeable :3' then not pushing further to see if it is
ilario wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 8:22 am
a little pinged by lime cokes opening, i think he leans into copypasta and meme openers more as wolf. still early though and if hes town im sure ill find him at some point this game
didnt like capes opener either but cant really pinpoint why other than it felt a little awkward to me
delta leaning town on everyone might be slightly towny, wolves tend to be slightly more pressured to find something to scumread or shade in their openers
is this not what you just did? :wowee:
Is there anyone aside from me you think had a townie entrance?
yep it sure is, but thats cos im on a timer most games im village so ive shifted my focus from towncore building into just trying to kill wolves
there were other entrances that seemed fine but i havent played as much with those players so i was waiting for the day to play out some more. but since you brought it up id scotty seemed relaxed tonally, and i liked tutuu but im not sure if thats alignment indicative for them or not, they strike me as someone id probably like and get along with as either alignment
I kinda dislike this post, especially the tutuu part feels just wrong to me
I feel like you dont know how to respond to my earlier callout on your slot so instead you're trying to reverse it back onto me. Maybe im being a little ungenerous though but I also know we have played a bunch and you're used to me making these kinds of posts. What part of it stuck out to you as feeling wrong when its a pretty standard post for me i feel like
idk it just felt like u were "forced" to make those reads.
In terms of your accusation to me having a bad entrance, I didn't really have a lot to say about that, I explained those reads later on.
Also you say I am used to you making posts like this... but you also realize I always scumread you for your posts.
And you wonder why
tutuu wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 4:27 pm
Has anybody seen Scotty mafia? And Cape mafia? And Jack mafia? I've seen none of those. Any chance they have tells that they haven't been able to overcome?
ive seen cape scum, he has a few tells ive been waiting to see if he hits before i go full send on him lol
and yet you vote me later on without me even saying anything and yet you talk about "wanting to see more from me before you full send" and then you full sent
Cape90 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 11:45 pm
I think Delta is ~fine so far though I am wondering how much I attribute that to how their tone comes across since content wise, idk if they are rly there for me
Thinking tutuu is actually town here though I see what they got pinged out for (Looking at #79), except for having verbose reads, I don't really take that as a scumtell. Had a silly read that #135 was towny because custom meme that fit in with #79, but since then I think they have been towny soz, like I think #177 was a towny read on DarlingMonroe, though I kinda think mafia would just check
same as this ^^' if you're not sure on my content, why not ask over just throwing it out ;_;
Delta wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:19 am
But if you'd like to work out if they're fakeable or not, why not just. Ask?
That doesn't sound sensible to me. I've seen you wolf, I know they aren't unfakeable. Asking you about it would lead to nothing.
This is on the micro scale of this argument. On the macro - engaging people in the way I think you want to sounds to me like asking them "Are you mafia?" which I also don't find fruitful to do,
Delta wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 4:19 am
But if you'd like to work out if they're fakeable or not, why not just. Ask?
That doesn't sound sensible to me. I've seen you wolf, I know they aren't unfakeable. Asking you about it would lead to nothing.
This is on the micro scale of this argument. On the macro - engaging people in the way I think you want to sounds to me like asking them "Are you mafia?" which I also don't find fruitful to do,
There's only so much I can fake as a wolf, and if my argument to read someone is obviously bullshit then asking me to make those reads should be a good step forward?
I'm not completely like. Everything is unfakeable you'll never be able to tell whats real (mwahahah). & I just want some engsgement on my reads anyway because like. Whats the use in just acknowledging them and nodding and then complaining about my content anyway ;_; I dont get it
Delta wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 4:43 am
First skim done, based on general vibes I'd say:
Both LCs lean town
Nutella lean town
Scotty lean town
Cape slight lean town
Wilgy slight(?) lean town
Alexy
Tutuu
I'm not huge on their sole focus being on mech stuff, not necessarily scummy but more just. Eh. For now \o/
These are more just vibe things but my thoughts for now anyway
what made u lean town on me here? I only had my opener to go off of at this point
It was slight because I liked that you sortve hit the ground running in a thread that felt slow as is, similar to Wilgy who did the same & your reads were similar to my first impressions which I liked \o/
ilario wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 3:36 am
yeah maybe im just confbiased but everything cape says feels ridiculous to me
define "everything"
you only really tackled:
my opening
my attack on your lingo
a very generic read on potentialsheltervet that i obviously copied from your read on tutuu... as you say yourself. Okay you call my posts wack and yet you make this read LMAO
potentialsheltervet wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2023 12:59 am
From my half-hearted skimming of the thread it looks like a lot of the content thus far is based on meta, which is useless to me. So I hereby declare all of that poopoo and shan't be bothering.
Do you have any reads in general that aren't requiring meta?
Aside from what I've stated, not really. I'm intrigued by nutella voting me.
[VOTE:
potentialsheltervet] aubergine for
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
nutella wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 11:43 am
nearly everyone has posted but it hardly feels like it
Yeah definitely ?_? it feels weirdly quiet
How are you feeling so far? Any thoughts? \o/
I’m trying to fill the thread with thots
People I’m liking thus far and whom I wouldn’t mind have a little dance party with in the break room:
You
Long Con
jack
ilario
People that need some coffee or something to be a productive member of society:
tutuu
Lime Coke
Nutella
People that apparently work here but only come out when the lunch bell chimes:
is the second list people you scumread or people you just find null? if its scumreads then why is there a discrepancy between me and nutella? we both have outed very similar takes and i dont feel like i have posted anything too alignment indicative yet so far
Yes to the first part
Yes to the second part
Redfish blue
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
Liked #283 for the call back read on tutuu
Liked #291 which is the response to "Delta's logs have been fakeable" which tbf I was thinking that based on the questions that Delta was doing to I guess move the game forward ie. #94/#98
Cape90 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 14, 2023 3:48 pm
Anyways, sup?
My nutella read was based on #15 and #18 primarily there
My Scotty read was him making me chuckle when i realized he was literally not finishing sentences and that was it LOL, perhaps not as strong .
the gimmick could have been chosen pre-rand, why was that something you felt was more likely to come from town than a wolf?
I was going off the logic of "townies funny wolves arent" and that was it.
Though as I previously said, I also feel like Scotty was/has been productive in a way which I don't think comes from mafia? IDK I kinda imagine if mafia were doing that it would be less game-related and more shitposty or whatever
This would be a mistake to assume.
I had a phase where people jumped on me because my humor was awkward and stilted- most times they were wrong, and occasionally they were right. It’s one of those biases not indicative of my alignment.
I’m perfectly cringey as both alignments
I would also expect the general public to be as shit-posty as a rural gas station bathroom on Day 1. It’s good to mix in a little farts in between the productive movements,
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
.
