Arkham Mafia [ENDGAME]

#7851

juliets wrote:
Golden wrote:I'm not overly opposed to a DF vote either. I'm essentially ambivalent.
Yes, this is what I'm feeling on DF. I'm actually considering voting myself.

Do you mean voting for yourself or voting for DF yourself?

#7852

Dom wrote:
juliets wrote:
Dom wrote:The answer is no. She would only have to be around every other phase.
Hmmmm this is true. Dom how do you account for those votes she made for Wayne Manor?
I don't know. That is a weakness that this case has.

Golden wrote:
Dom wrote:I'm not really feeling a Dfaraday lynch, I don't think. The suddenness of the case coupled with the fact that I don't really see why those points make him bad does not sit well with me.

I'd rather lynch Matt or Bubbles or Golden.
I'm not overly feeling a DF vote either, but you can't count on my vote for any of the people you named.
Is there anyone we do agree on?

juliets wrote:I missed MP coming in. He voted Bubbles.
That's where I want to vote but I want to make sure that I can stop DFaraday from being lynched. I really don't think he's bad.

ok, I don't really think he's bad either and at least he participates in the game so I will vote Bubbles if you will.

#7853

How do we feel about LoRab?

#7854

I'll vote DF if the pair of you vote Bubbles.

#7855

Golden wrote:How do we feel about LoRab?

Unsure. I was feeling good before, but her posts on DFaraday lacked an attention to detail that I would expect from her.

#7856

And DF would probably vote bubbles, so I'd guess we'd end in a tie unless bubbles came by to save herself.

#7857

Golden wrote:I'll vote DF if the pair of you vote Bubbles.

What do you do if DFaraday comes back civ/not bad?

#7858

Mind you if we all voted LoRab, DF would only be tying it up too, so he is probably doomed to a tie either way.

#7859

Dom wrote:
Golden wrote:I'll vote DF if the pair of you vote Bubbles.
What do you do if DFaraday comes back civ/not bad?

I mean, I don't see DF and Bubbles as a one must be good, one must be bad scenario. I just think DF is a better bet than Bubbles. I really genuinely think Bubbles is on her civ game. I could be wrong, I just really don't think I am.

#7860

And I already gave in on glorfindel and I don't want to give in on two of my stronger town reads in two days. I should have backed myself yesterday.

#7861

juliets - how do you feel about LoRab?

#7862

Dom wrote:
juliets wrote:
Golden wrote:I'm not overly opposed to a DF vote either. I'm essentially ambivalent.
Yes, this is what I'm feeling on DF. I'm actually considering voting myself.
Do you mean voting for yourself or voting for DF yourself?

I was talking about voting for myself because I couldnt come to terms with anyone. But as I said, I will go with Bubbles.

linki Golden I'm not seeing a baddie Lorab and Golden I understand your voting for DF.

linki again, I admit it makes me uneasy that you Golden seem so sure she's good. I think this is going to end in a tie any way we go.

#7863

Golden wrote:And I already gave in on glorfindel and I don't want to give in on two of my stronger town reads in two days. I should have backed myself yesterday.

What does this mean?

Golden, what do you think of LoRab?

#7864

I voted Bubbles.

#7865

Dom wrote:
Golden wrote:And I already gave in on glorfindel and I don't want to give in on two of my stronger town reads in two days. I should have backed myself yesterday.
What does this mean?

Golden, what do you think of LoRab?

I think LoRab is relying on being given a slightly easier ride for having been away for much of the early game. However, I also didn't like her responses to DF (I felt like DF was fairly clear) and, well, I'd prefer her as the lynch to DF or bubbles, basically.

#7866

Dom wrote:I voted Bubbles.

OK. Guess I'm voting DF.

#7867

Ok I'm voting Bubbles and crossing my fingers. I hated this lynch.

#7868

Dom wrote:
Golden wrote:And I already gave in on glorfindel and I don't want to give in on two of my stronger town reads in two days. I should have backed myself yesterday.
What does this mean?

It means I let doubt get in the way of a strong read yesterday when I should have continued to stick up for glorf.

#7869

I think the best point against Bubbles is that she actually has continued to turn up despite the fact she mostly isn't checking in on the lynches. So, if bubbles is lynched, I do have some hope. I just feel like she always gets lynched and comes back town for basically the same reasons.

#7870

Come on, Equivocate, Bass, Ekeknat, now would be a great time for you guys to come back to the game.

#7871

I can't even wait up to see the results because I have an appointment in the morning. So good night all I hope this turns out for the best, whatever that is.

#7872

DFaraday wrote:Come on, Equivocate, Bass, Ekeknat, now would be a great time for you guys to come back to the game.

What if they voted for you?

#7873

Golden wrote:
DFaraday wrote:Come on, Equivocate, Bass, Ekeknat, now would be a great time for you guys to come back to the game.
What if they voted for you?

At least I wouldn't have to wait in anticipation. I forget, did the hosts establish how ties are resolved?

#7874

DFaraday wrote:
Golden wrote:
DFaraday wrote:Come on, Equivocate, Bass, Ekeknat, now would be a great time for you guys to come back to the game.
What if they voted for you?
At least I wouldn't have to wait in anticipation. I forget, did the hosts establish how ties are resolved?

Epi is never so nice when it comes to ties, but I do think we had one at the start and there was nothing to suggest it wasn't simply a coin flip. It implied the joker may have had a hand in deciding, but the joker is dead. Who knows.

#7875

Anyway, the better question might be how does LC resolve lynch ties lol!

#7876

Golden wrote:Anyway, the better question might be how does LC resolve lynch ties lol!

All voters die in a tie!

#7877

Long Con wrote:
Golden wrote:Anyway, the better question might be how does LC resolve lynch ties lol!
All voters die in a tie!

Then that means the final four would be DH and the inactives. I'd almost be okay with dying just to see that happen.

#7878

For posterity, my suspects are LoRab, DH, and Bubbles, in that order.

#7879

Holy Vengeance

Jean-Paul Valley was a man who lived without doubt. Since conception, he had been subjected to The System, a rigorous regimen of mental and physical brainwashing, training, and enhancement by the Order of St Dumas. Now, he was Azrael, a vengeful angel against the baser aspects of the world. When he donned his red and gold armour, and wore the red mask and cloak, he wrought God's will upon criminals as the Angel of Death.

Tonight, his target was DFaraday. Azrael had been following him for twenty minutes through the streets of Gotham, and DFaraday was getting more and more nervous, sensing that something was wrong. Azrael smirked under his mask when he saw DFaraday's distress, knowing it was more than well-founded.

He decided to end the game, leaping down from a second-storey rooftop and landing with a pavement-cracking crash that knocked DFaraday from his feet. When he saw Azrael standing over him, his eyes widened. "Please, I have money, I'll pay you TRIPLE what your employer is paying!"

Azrael laughed, drawing a flaming sword from his belt. "God is my employer, scum, and his payment is the everlasting bliss of my soul in His presence! Can you match the price?"

"Valley!" Batman's voice echoed down the alley as the Caped Crusader landed silently from a nearby rooftop. "This is not the way! He needs to go to prison!"

"This one is beyond mortal judgment, Batman!" cried Azrael, his eyes flashing with religious frenzy as he raised his sword. "The Devil will decide his fate now!"

Batman rushed forward, throwing batarangs which simply skipped off Azrael's thick armour, and he was unable to stop the Sword of Sin from executing DFaraday where he lay in the filthy alley.

DFaraday has been lynched. He was Maroni. It is now Night 9. You have 23 hours to get your PMs in. If they are all in early, the Night may be shortened.

#7880

Great job. Well played do, see ya baddie!

#7881

Holy shit.

Nice result!!! One team down, righht?

#7882

Who burned Turnip Head?

Poll ended at Mon Mar 14, 2016 12:27 am

Bass_the_Clever
0
No votes

Bubbles
5
S~V~S (9), MovingPictures07 (15), Dom (16), juliets (18), DFaraday (19) 26%

Bullzeye
0
No votes

DharmaHelper
2
Matt (6), MacDougall (13) 11%

DFaraday
5
Typhoony (7), Bullzeye (8), Enrique (10), LoRab (12), Golden (17) 26%

Dom
0
No votes

ekeknat
0
No votes

Enrique
0
No votes

Equivocate
0
No votes

Golden
0
No votes

juliets
0
No votes

Lorab
0
No votes

MacDougall
0
No votes

Matt
0
No votes

MovingPictures07
0
No votes

S~V~S
0
No votes

Turnip Head
0
No votes

Typhoony
0
No votes

Howl (The Host, the Non, the Dead)
7
Epignosis (1), Quin (2), Scotty (3), sig (4), Metalmarsh89 (5), Turnip Head (11), Long Con (14)

#7883

Df* autocorrect is, per sprityo, a cruel mistrust.

#7884

Floyd was maroni, so yes.

And Scottys case was bang on.

#7885

The Maroni Crime Family has been eliminated.

#7886

#7887

Matt wrote:FYI, the quotes up there...

When I quote DH saying "Let's lynch Nero" for the first time, that is on Day 2. Everything before that was Day 1, I believe. Sorry for not making that more clear. Derp.

Anyway, off to sleep. Peace

P.S.

A BONUS QUOTE

DharmaHelper wrote:
Epignosis wrote:TheFloyd73 was working (working, Jesus, it kills me to even use that verb) for Maroni, in case the post wasn't plain.

Oh, BONUS QUOTE # 2

DharmaHelper wrote:Bass_the_Clever No read
Bubbles No Read
Bullzeye No Read
DharmaHelper Good
DFaraday Bad
Dom Barely Good
ekeknat Huuuuh
Enrique Good
Equivocate Would love to meet him one day
Golden False
Glorfindel Good
juliets Might be good
Lorab Good
MacDougall Good
Matt Bad
MetalMarsh89 Good or Bad or Indy
MovingPictures07 Good
sabie12 Bad
Sorsha Good?
sprityo Dunno
S~V~S Might be bad
TheFloyd73 Would love to meet him one day
Turnip Head Good
Typhoony Bad
Doesn't give a read on Floyd.

Night!

To your first point, I was offering Epignosis my condolences because Floyd was a no show. Having just co-hosted the most legendary no show game of all time with the man, I was feeling sympathetic.

Speaking of pathetic, lets move on to your second point.

What did you want me to read from TheFloyd exactly? Which posts of his are so fraught with insight as to warrant a read? What reads did you have on Floyd?

I had no read on Floyd because he was a nonissue. A nonplayer.

#7888

Oh man this is gonna be fun thanks for volunteering to be this game's Dr. Wilgy Matt.

Matt wrote:Okay. So I went ahead and looked at which locations Nero picked on Nights 0 and 1. Arkham and GCPD. Then I decided to cross check with other players to see if they haven't gone to those locations or if they've only recently gone there.

Check it...

On Nights 6 and 8, DH chose GCPD and Arkham. What's kind of curious to me is that DH seems to be in the know with comics, and we're playing a Batman game, a Batman Arkham game at that, and he doesn't visit the Asylum until Night 8? Hrm. Anyway, before Night 6, assuming DH is Maroni, this would mean their team already had 7 voice recordings so why not skip a night to keep up appearances in case anyone goes around sniffing at the polls?

Anyway, so I'm getting ahead of myself.

Here are some quotes...

DharmaHelper wrote:
Nerolunar wrote:Just cast my vote for Arkham Asylum.

Also, why has the hosts voted for the zoo?
Every poll is going to have a "Host Option" for the hosts, anyone who is dead, and anyone who is not playing to vote for. It helps the Hosts keep track of the poll without having too much trouble.
We know Nero was bad so he could have easily asked his teamies this question which makes it seem fake. And there's DH to answer his fake question. Distance!

I've already addressed this point, if you can even call it that. He asked a question, I answered it because despite popular opinion I am not an asshole.

DharmaHelper wrote:People calling Nero out for being quiet moments before his essay makes me nervous.
This was said on Day 1 when TH and others (?) were looking Nero's way. Interesting sidenote, I looked through a few pages and didn't see Nero speak of any essay, so I don't know where that came from, but perhaps it's there somewhere and I missed it. Derp. Either way, DH lightly defending Nero.

I referred to Nero's large post after being called out as an essay because it was a rather large post. I literally said "Nero coming in with a large post moments after people called him out is suspicious." That is the exact opposite of defending Nero.

DharmaHelper wrote:
Nerolunar wrote:I misread Friday am as pm, so Im suddenly in a hurry to vote, as I'm going to bed soon.

I honestly don´t know, and its stressing me out that I have to vote for someone. Im considering Floyd, even though I don´t like lynching low posters. I did notice him being online earlier today while I was reading and he hasn´t posted. I know I did it myself, but at least I gave an explanation for doing it.

Yeah Im going with Floyd. Time zones suck.

Im interested in seeing the outcome tomorrow. Goodnight ya´ll.

This was also Day 1. DH never elaborates on his chin stroke. If indeed teamies with Nero and Floyd, then this could just be an honest reaction of "Why?" Haha.

Or, Haha, it could be I found his vote suspicious haha. HAHA.

DharmaHelper wrote:Lets lynch Nero.
Keep in mind, he says this, but has already placed his vote on MP. Then someone, I'm assuming, asked him why and his response...

DharmaHelper wrote:Why? Because I don't want to lynch Matt right now and Nero has a couple of votes.
That's weird because I think DH would usually want to lynch someone for more then "cuz they have a few votes". This just kind of sounds sarcastic to me honestly, like he doesn't even mean it. Again, he had already placed his vote on MP.

DharmaHelper wrote:The case against Matt is - "Nevermind there is no case against Matt"

And the case against Nero is that Matt thinks he might be the Riddler or something.
Again, he doesn't seem to even want to lynch Nero despite saying "Let's lynch Nero." "Matt thinks he might be the Riddler or something" seems very dismissive, not supportive of a case on Nero. Remember all this later because it's important.

I've addressed this already as well. On what planet does it make sense to draw attention and votes to someone you don't want to lynch? Why did I not instead draw votes to Sig or, better yet, press the MP issue? Are you fucking kidding me with this noise. I said LETS LYNCH NERO so I must be his teammate.

DharmaHelper wrote:I think we're making the best decision Enrique could make and that's all we can ask for in any lynch.
A riff of the 3J quote in Mac's sig, basically making fun of Enrique's "Don't lynch Matt, lynch sig or Nero!" post. Again, doesn't feel like he really wants Nero lynched.

Or, and here's a wild theory so hang with me for a second or two Matt. I used the 3J quote to express an endorsement of the Nero lynch. Because guess what.

DharmaHelper wrote:JC/Golden, had I said "Let's lynch X" would you have voted for X?
In response to JC/Golden both voting Nero. This doesn't look like someone who wants Nero lynched, questioning those who chose to vote him.

I asked them because I was curious if their Nero votes were solely because I said so. In Juliets case, (as I express later) Her glomping onto peoples votes and suspicious is, at least I think, baddie indicative. You know what DOES sound like someone who wants to lynch Nero? "LETS LYNCH NERO"

DharmaHelper wrote:
Sorsha wrote:Isn't it a Syndicate Mafia tradition to lynch the new player first? Maybe that's why there was a no lynch yesterday

I had been thinking of giving Matt the botd in his lynch Nero/Enrique crusade anyway (and I don't think Matt is bad, I think he's Indy based on a couple of posts he's made today) so I'll be voting for Nero today's since he's come up with both Matt and Enrique.

I hope you guys are right!
What do you mean you hope "you guys" are right? Why are you unconcerned if you yourself are correct? Why pawn off the accountability?
Again, Sorsha follows a Nero vote, and DH doesn't seem happy about it.

Heres the thing though. I'm not commenting on her voting for Nero, I'm commenting on her remark that she hopes "you guys" are right. I don't like when people avoid accountability for any vote. She could have voted for anyone and used "I hope you guys are right" and it would have been equally suspect. Same thing when she made that scummy vote before she got NKed.

DharmaHelper wrote:Welcome to the site, Nero.
In response to the lynch ending. Again, sounds sarcastic, he doesn't seem happy.

Making a joke about our tendency to lynch new players.

Now the following quotes occur when DH starts taking heat for being Nero's teamie, here is what DH says...

DharmaHelper wrote:Bruv I literally convinced two people to vote for Nero in order to save you what the fuck are you smoking.

DharmaHelper wrote:I voiced my assent in a Nero lynch. That alone should be enough to tell you he was not my teammate.

DharmaHelper wrote:Remember that time I literally said "Hey lets lynch Nero"

Yeah me too
He goes on to say the same thing over and over again to sig and MP who are questioning him over it, but like...yeah you said "Let's lynch Nero" but then you made a ridiculous reason as to why you wanted him lynched ("cuz he has votes"), downplayed why I wanted him lynched ("Matt thinks he's the Riddler or something"), made a riff off of 3J's quote to make Enrique look silly based on his turnaround, questioned Golden, JC, and Sorsha who all voted Nero...

Basically, he didn't really "lead" or "advocate" a Nero lynch as he claims. Not at all.

I didn't lead or advocate a Nero lynch. At all. Unless you count me saying "Hey you know what we should do? Lynch Nero. Hey look at that, Juliets, who values my opinion on the matter, is now considering a Nero vote in place of an MP vote. Man it makes a lot of sense for me as Nero's teammate to steer the lynch right towards him and away from like, sig or my main suspect MP. Gosh I'm so fucking smart and clever nobody will ever uncover this massive conspiracy. Hey Matt whats up dude. What are you talking about? Jet fuel can totally melt steel beams."

I did a search of Floyd in DH's post history, too...the following quotes take place on Day 1

DharmaHelper wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:So... I'm swamped beyond belief and there's no way I'll make it before EoD. I'm still on page 11 when I last posted. Sorry everyone.

I know this is very unlike me, but I don't have any remotely firm leads on anyone from what I can recall, since the only player I had thought even seemed slightly suspicious (zebra) no longer seemed suspicious to me after I talked with her, so... yeah. I randomized among "low posters" (i.e., those with less than 5 posts) and got TheFloyd73.

Hopefully I can catch up and get back into this game fully by this weekend.

MP votes Floyd. DH refers to MP as Darth Vader. K.

More like MP, a player famous for his dedication to scum hunting and posting and participating, falls to the dark side of nonparticipation. Golly which one of those makes more fucking sense.

DharmaHelper wrote:
Glorfindel wrote:OK, I'm out now until the EoD because of work commitments so despite not having a convincing argument against any particular individual I'm voting for TheFloyd73. As the votes stand right now, my priority is to avoid the lynching of someone who appears to be at risk and who I am (on balance) convinced may be potentially an asset to us.
Your priority is to avoid the lynching of someone who appears at risk so you voted for the guy with the most votes what are you talking about
Not happy with Glorfy's vote for Floyd, and tries to make Glorfy look nonsensical.

I think we have our Sal Maroni. Boop.

#7889

Also lol at DF being Maroni guess I didn't need those posts.

#7890

Golden wrote:
Dom wrote:
Golden wrote:And I already gave in on glorfindel and I don't want to give in on two of my stronger town reads in two days. I should have backed myself yesterday.
What does this mean?
It means I let doubt get in the way of a strong read yesterday when I should have continued to stick up for glorf.

#7891

Lol @ dh defending himself against accusations that he is on the eliminated team.

#7892

Golden wrote:Lol @ dh defending himself against accusations that he is on the eliminated team.

I wrote those posts 6 hours ago I'm not gonna waste them.

#7893

DharmaHelper wrote:
Golden wrote:Lol @ dh defending himself against accusations that he is on the eliminated team.
I wrote those posts 6 hours ago I'm not gonna waste them.

I'd have posted them too

#7894

DharmaHelper wrote:
Golden wrote:Lol @ dh defending himself against accusations that he is on the eliminated team.
I wrote those posts 6 hours ago I'm not gonna waste them.

This guy is awesome.

#7895

Amusement Mile isn't denoted as a host option so that's the one I picked.

#7896

DharmaHelper wrote:Amusement Mile isn't denoted as a host option so that's the one I picked.

Well, what's Amusement Mile without a little amusement? Your Hosts will be amused by your choice.

#7897

Votes are changeable in this poll.

#7898

Long Con wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Golden wrote:Lol @ dh defending himself against accusations that he is on the eliminated team.
I wrote those posts 6 hours ago I'm not gonna waste them.
This guy is awesome.

If I believed in sigging things I would sig this.

#7899

So that was Floyd/Nero/Faraday?

Sabie was on the other family, but there are still possibly two of them alive?

#7900

DharmaHelper wrote:
Golden wrote:Lol @ dh defending himself against accusations that he is on the eliminated team.
I wrote those posts 6 hours ago I'm not gonna waste them.

Like that time I died while writing really long posts.

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Who killed no one?