Battlestar Galactica Mafia - GAME OVER

[Epignosis]

So I think Daisy was killed since she wanted to lynch Wilgy, I believe the mafia team is attempting to redirect the lynch onto another player (right now it is me) away from Wilgy and it was clear Daisy wasn't going to budge and wanted Wilgy gone.

This is silly.

[a2thezebra]

linki: I like me to Zebra glad we agree.
Why not Wilgy.
Also Zebra voting so early ffor anyone other then the outted cylon who isn't acting civvie at all is proof enough I'm the counterwagon to an evil cylon.

What is the point of asking me a question ("why not Wilgy") and then immediately going on to dismiss me (with "proof" no less, lmao) as mafia conspiring to mislynch you? Like if you already believe beyond a shadow of a doubt that not only am I anti-town but that I'm anti-town trying to mislynch you so my "evil cylon" friend doesn't get killed, why even bother asking me what I think? It's all disingenuous anyway, so you know I'm just going to give you a bullshit answer.

linki - That's an understatement.

[a2thezebra]

Unless I'm mistaken, this is the third game where I've made clear that DrWilgy involuntarily expresses certain patterns with his play style. This is most certainly civ Wilgy, all of the patterns indicate so. Anyone who thinks otherwise is either unfamiliar with DrWilgy's meta or isn't paying attention.

[Silverwolf]

So say we all!

Vote: Glorfindel

[a2thezebra]

I am glad that the captain agrees that sig is suspicious and that the Cylon-claiming bullshit needs to be put aside, at the very least temporarily.

[a2thezebra]

Also, let me make clear that if I'm the lynch candidate for today, I will claim you-know-what at the very end. Don't even fucking try it, I'm town.

[sig]

So I think Daisy was killed since she wanted to lynch Wilgy, I believe the mafia team is attempting to redirect the lynch onto another player (right now it is me) away from Wilgy and it was clear Daisy wasn't going to budge and wanted Wilgy gone.

This is silly.

Yeah since god forbid we look for reasons why the mafia might've killed someone, not like it could help the civs at all I'm sure.

Also the captain is a regular player and like I said he isn't the boss of me.


linki: That really proves you'e town yeah and if you are then claiming would do nothing so you basically just admitted to being a cylon who would claim to get out of a lynch.

[sig]

So say we all!

Vote: Glorfindel

wtf? I thought you were voting for Wilgy no matter what.

[Silverwolf]

So say we all!

Vote: Glorfindel

wtf? I thought you were voting for Wilgy no matter what.

I have my reasons.

[a2thezebra]

linki: That really proves you'e town yeah and if you are then claiming would do nothing so you basically just admitted to being a cylon who would claim to get out of a lynch.

I don't give two plum shits what you think. I made my point. If you try and lynch me, I'll claim. That's it.

[a2thezebra]

So say we all!

Vote: Glorfindel

wtf? I thought you were voting for Wilgy no matter what.

She was obviously forced, do you really think you can throw shade on her for that vote?

[a2thezebra]

Town really needs to get their act together today, or else.

[Epignosis]

Town really needs to get their act together today, or else.

Nah. There's plenty of time to dick around.

[Silverwolf]

So say we all!

Vote: Glorfindel

wtf? I thought you were voting for Wilgy no matter what.

She was obviously forced, do you really think you can throw shade on her for that vote?

Nope, I wasn't forced. Glorfindel needs to be lynched today for the good of the town. If he claims, then get him tomorrow.

[sig]

your "point" oh yes lets not forget your point that I'm confirmed mafia and then like six people are somehow confirmed town, including Wilgy since you can meta read him perfectly. Just like you can read me perfectly oh wait, but you can't. You're really one to tell town to get their act together considering how many nonsensical one line posts you've made this game, also no it wasn't and isn't obvious and it isn't throwing shade it's asking a question.

[sig]

Oh and look it seems like Zebra is once again making stuff up re Silver being forced.

[a2thezebra]

your "point" oh yes lets not forget your point that I'm confirmed mafia and then like six people are somehow confirmed town, including Wilgy since you can meta read him perfectly. Just like you can read me perfectly oh wait, but you can't. You're really one to tell town to get their act together considering how many nonsensical one line posts you've made this game, also no it wasn't and isn't obvious and it isn't throwing shade it's asking a question.

I never said you were confirmed mafia. Continue to misrepresent me for mafia-motivated purposes and I will permanently refrain from speaking to you in this game. I have also yet to make a single nonsensical post this entire game, not even one. So yes, you're damn right I'm one to tell town that.

[a2thezebra]

I voted for you yesterday, sig. Town, for the most part, didn't. That alone is enough.

[Epignosis]

I am tempted to vote GlorFIENDel again.

I want to know whom you suspect and why.

[a2thezebra]

Town really needs to get their act together today, or else.

Nah. There's plenty of time to dick around.

I didn't say that there wasn't, but when it comes to the last five minutes of the day and anyone other than sig or Polo is town's lynch of choice, I don't want to be the one saying "I told you so" after a disappointing flip.

[a2thezebra]

So say we all!

Vote: Glorfindel

wtf? I thought you were voting for Wilgy no matter what.

She was obviously forced, do you really think you can throw shade on her for that vote?

Nope, I wasn't forced. Glorfindel needs to be lynched today for the good of the town. If he claims, then get him tomorrow.

If he's bad, he'll claim. If he's good - and I believe he is - he will be yet another mislynch that we can't afford right now.

I don't believe that you weren't forced. Perhaps you were also forced to not make it obvious or even flat-out deny it, but you were definitely forced.

[Epignosis]

Town really needs to get their act together today, or else.

Nah. There's plenty of time to dick around.

I didn't say that there wasn't, but when it comes to the last five minutes of the day and anyone other than sig or Polo is town's lynch of choice, I don't want to be the one saying "I told you so" after a disappointing flip.

You don't have enough credibility with me to say "I told you so." Broken clocks and all that.

[a2thezebra]

Oh and look it seems like Zebra is once again making stuff up re Silver being forced.

Such a short post yet so much wrong with it.

First of all, not only do we still not know that Silver wasn't forced, there's considerable reason to think otherwise. Her initial post was the obligatory salute followed immediately by an unexplained, out-of-nowhere vote for Glorfindel with zero clarification or comment. Her denial that she was forced shortly thereafter was also bizarrely vague for her, perhaps indicating that she is hinting to anyone willing to consider the possibility that she does not mean what she is saying.

Second, even if Silver's denial that she was forced is in fact true, how does that mean that I'm making stuff up? Wouldn't that simply mean that I was wrong? You expect me to co-operate with you but your anti-town reactionary confidence is showing, typical overcompensation for the captain making it clear that it's not just the fringe folk like me suspecting you. You're not in a position to misrepresent me and expect to get away with it, if you don't step on your tip-toes today then you could find yourself dead by the time this is all over.

[a2thezebra]

Town really needs to get their act together today, or else.

Nah. There's plenty of time to dick around.

I didn't say that there wasn't, but when it comes to the last five minutes of the day and anyone other than sig or Polo is town's lynch of choice, I don't want to be the one saying "I told you so" after a disappointing flip.

You don't have enough credibility with me to say "I told you so." Broken clocks and all that.

I could not give less of a shit how much credibility you think I have.

[Silverwolf]

So say we all!

Vote: Glorfindel

wtf? I thought you were voting for Wilgy no matter what.

She was obviously forced, do you really think you can throw shade on her for that vote?

Nope, I wasn't forced. Glorfindel needs to be lynched today for the good of the town. If he claims, then get him tomorrow.

If he's bad, he'll claim. If he's good - and I believe he is - he will be yet another mislynch that we can't afford right now.

I don't believe that you weren't forced. Perhaps you were also forced to not make it obvious or even flat-out deny it, but you were definitely forced.

I wasn't forced!! OMG

[Epignosis]

Town really needs to get their act together today, or else.

Nah. There's plenty of time to dick around.

I didn't say that there wasn't, but when it comes to the last five minutes of the day and anyone other than sig or Polo is town's lynch of choice, I don't want to be the one saying "I told you so" after a disappointing flip.

You don't have enough credibility with me to say "I told you so." Broken clocks and all that.

I could not give less of a shit how much credibility you think I have.

Sure you could. But you don't. And that's fine.

[Black Rock]

So say we all!

[a2thezebra]

If any mislynch is being set up today, then it's not sig, it's Glorfindel.

Or Glorfindel is in fact bad and the other baddies are trying to turn the tide towards him today so no one will be lynched when he claims Cylon right at the end. After that the baddies can sit back, watch town make just a few more mistakes, and the game is lost for us.

It's one of those two.

linki - No Epi, I seriously could not. I mean physically could not. It's mathematically impossible.

[Epignosis]

linki - No Epi, I seriously could not. I mean physically could not. It's mathematically impossible.

My point was that I don't give a shit if you say "I told you so."

In your need to tell me about how much you don't give a shit, you missed it.

[Dex]

SO SAY WE ALL!

My first preference would be Rico. I could happily vote Glorfindel. I could also go after Obscure.

I will oppose an attempt on Wilgy any way I can.

[a2thezebra]

linki - No Epi, I seriously could not. I mean physically could not. It's mathematically impossible.

My point was that I don't give a shit if you say "I told you so."

In your need to tell me about how much you don't give a shit, you missed it.

Missed what?

[a2thezebra]

SO SAY WE ALL!

My first preference would be Rico. I could happily vote Glorfindel. I could also go after Obscure.

I will oppose an attempt on Wilgy any way I can.

Obscure is risky since unless I missed it, they also have yet to claim. Same with Glorfindel. I believe Rico is pro-town so I will oppose that.

[Silverwolf]

If any mislynch is being set up today, then it's not sig, it's Glorfindel.

Or Glorfindel is in fact bad and the other baddies are trying to turn the tide towards him today so no one will be lynched when he claims Cylon right at the end. After that the baddies can sit back, watch town make just a few more mistakes, and the game is lost for us.

It's one of those two.

OMG can you just stop and think for two seconds or do you always just let loose with whatever the hell comes into our brain without thinking it through?

[a2thezebra]

If any mislynch is being set up today, then it's not sig, it's Glorfindel.

Or Glorfindel is in fact bad and the other baddies are trying to turn the tide towards him today so no one will be lynched when he claims Cylon right at the end. After that the baddies can sit back, watch town make just a few more mistakes, and the game is lost for us.

It's one of those two.

OMG can you just stop and think for two seconds or do you always just let loose with whatever the hell comes into our brain without thinking it through?

Of all the posts I've made in this game to provoke such a response from you, why this one? I actually present two possibilities here instead of one.

:P

But really, what is your criticism of my opposition to a Glorfindel lynch today? And by criticism, I mean actual criticism.

[Epignosis]

I'll be voting sig, Wilgy, zebra, or GlorFIENDel most likely. I could get behind a Ricochet lynch too. I don't think he's good. I think he's bullshitting, as I said long ago.

[Epignosis]

If you wanted to get cute, put GlorFIENDel in first place and sig in second, or something like that.

[Epignosis]

Black Rock! I want an update on S~V~S and your accusation of her. What say you?

[a2thezebra]

If you wanted to get cute, put GlorFIENDel in first place and sig in second, or something like that.

If you are not afraid that GlorFIENDel will claim Cylon at the last minute and dodge the lynch, could you elaborate on why?

[Epignosis]

If you wanted to get cute, put GlorFIENDel in first place and sig in second, or something like that.

If you are not afraid that GlorFIENDel will claim Cylon at the last minute and dodge the lynch, could you elaborate on why?

I'm not afraid of anything. I was picking on the claiming bullshit that consumed the thread for ages.

[a2thezebra]

If you wanted to get cute, put GlorFIENDel in first place and sig in second, or something like that.

If you are not afraid that GlorFIENDel will claim Cylon at the last minute and dodge the lynch, could you elaborate on why?

I'm not afraid of anything. I was picking on the claiming bullshit that consumed the thread for ages.

I'm with you on that, but nevertheless most agree that it may be dangerous to go after a Cylon that hasn't claimed yet.

What are your thoughts on DrWilgy?

[Silverwolf]

If any mislynch is being set up today, then it's not sig, it's Glorfindel.

Or Glorfindel is in fact bad and the other baddies are trying to turn the tide towards him today so no one will be lynched when he claims Cylon right at the end. After that the baddies can sit back, watch town make just a few more mistakes, and the game is lost for us.

It's one of those two.

OMG can you just stop and think for two seconds or do you always just let loose with whatever the hell comes into our brain without thinking it through?

Of all the posts I've made in this game to provoke such a response from you, why this one? I actually present two possibilities here instead of one.

:P

But really, what is your criticism of my opposition to a Glorfindel lynch today? And by criticism, I mean actual criticism.

I like Epi's plan to put Glorfindel up in first place today but the second place person better be someone we are fairly certain is bad. I can't case Glorfindel again right now because I have a fever and am going to bed. But I will. I will be pushing this hard this day phase. I think it's critical we force him to claim. Just make sure number two is someone we have a consensus is scum and make sure Glorf is number one at the end.

[Epignosis]

If you wanted to get cute, put GlorFIENDel in first place and sig in second, or something like that.

If you are not afraid that GlorFIENDel will claim Cylon at the last minute and dodge the lynch, could you elaborate on why?

I'm not afraid of anything. I was picking on the claiming bullshit that consumed the thread for ages.

I'm with you on that, but nevertheless most agree that it may be dangerous to go after a Cylon that hasn't claimed yet.

What are your thoughts on DrWilgy?

I don't really give a toss about Wilgy. If he's bad, he's bad, and can be mopped up later. If he's not bad, there's no reason to mop him up now.

There are other objectives besides Wilgy if he's bad, I say.

[a2thezebra]

If any mislynch is being set up today, then it's not sig, it's Glorfindel.

Or Glorfindel is in fact bad and the other baddies are trying to turn the tide towards him today so no one will be lynched when he claims Cylon right at the end. After that the baddies can sit back, watch town make just a few more mistakes, and the game is lost for us.

It's one of those two.

OMG can you just stop and think for two seconds or do you always just let loose with whatever the hell comes into our brain without thinking it through?

Of all the posts I've made in this game to provoke such a response from you, why this one? I actually present two possibilities here instead of one.

:P

But really, what is your criticism of my opposition to a Glorfindel lynch today? And by criticism, I mean actual criticism.

I like Epi's plan to put Glorfindel up in first place today but the second place person better be someone we are fairly certain is bad. I can't case Glorfindel again right now because I have a fever and am going to bed. But I will. I will be pushing this hard this day phase. I think it's critical we force him to claim. Just make sure number two is someone we have a consensus is scum and make sure Glorf is number one at the end.

Wouldn't it have been wiser to force him to claim before admitting that you'll be pushing for his lynch?

I mean considering that I myself have threatened to claim if I end up being the lynch candidate for today.

[a2thezebra]

If you wanted to get cute, put GlorFIENDel in first place and sig in second, or something like that.

If you are not afraid that GlorFIENDel will claim Cylon at the last minute and dodge the lynch, could you elaborate on why?

I'm not afraid of anything. I was picking on the claiming bullshit that consumed the thread for ages.

I'm with you on that, but nevertheless most agree that it may be dangerous to go after a Cylon that hasn't claimed yet.

What are your thoughts on DrWilgy?

I don't really give a toss about Wilgy. If he's bad, he's bad, and can be mopped up later. If he's not bad, there's no reason to mop him up now.

There are other objectives besides Wilgy if he's bad, I say.

Very interesting. Aside from not really giving a toss about him, do you have a neutral read on him?

Or are you more swayed towards him being a certain alignment?

[Dex]

I like Epi's plan to put Glorfindel up in first place today but the second place person better be someone we are fairly certain is bad. I can't case Glorfindel again right now because I have a fever and am going to bed. But I will. I will be pushing this hard this day phase. I think it's critical we force him to claim. Just make sure number two is someone we have a consensus is scum and make sure Glorf is number one at the end.

I'm on board. How about Rico second?

[Epignosis]

If you wanted to get cute, put GlorFIENDel in first place and sig in second, or something like that.

If you are not afraid that GlorFIENDel will claim Cylon at the last minute and dodge the lynch, could you elaborate on why?

I'm not afraid of anything. I was picking on the claiming bullshit that consumed the thread for ages.

I'm with you on that, but nevertheless most agree that it may be dangerous to go after a Cylon that hasn't claimed yet.

What are your thoughts on DrWilgy?

I don't really give a toss about Wilgy. If he's bad, he's bad, and can be mopped up later. If he's not bad, there's no reason to mop him up now.

There are other objectives besides Wilgy if he's bad, I say.

Very interesting. Aside from not really giving a toss about him, do you have a neutral read on him?

Or are you more swayed towards him being a certain alignment?

When did I express neutrality? I said I would lynch him. I also said he's not important right now (that was the not giving a toss comment).

[Epignosis]

People don't get that my PLAN was tongue-in-cheek.

[a2thezebra]

If you wanted to get cute, put GlorFIENDel in first place and sig in second, or something like that.

If you are not afraid that GlorFIENDel will claim Cylon at the last minute and dodge the lynch, could you elaborate on why?

I'm not afraid of anything. I was picking on the claiming bullshit that consumed the thread for ages.

I'm with you on that, but nevertheless most agree that it may be dangerous to go after a Cylon that hasn't claimed yet.

What are your thoughts on DrWilgy?

I don't really give a toss about Wilgy. If he's bad, he's bad, and can be mopped up later. If he's not bad, there's no reason to mop him up now.

There are other objectives besides Wilgy if he's bad, I say.

Very interesting. Aside from not really giving a toss about him, do you have a neutral read on him?

Or are you more swayed towards him being a certain alignment?

When did I express neutrality? I said I would lynch him. I also said he's not important right now (that was the not giving a toss comment).

You have no reason to ask that since I didn't imply that you did express neutrality. You've already established that you would lynch him and you've already established that you believe he's not important right now, there's no need to repeat yourself. I asked you what your read of him is.

[Epignosis]

You have no reason to ask that since I didn't imply that you did express neutrality. You've already established that you would lynch him and you've already established that you believe he's not important right now, there's no need to repeat yourself. I asked you what your read of him is.

What the fuck is the difference?

I don't have "reads" on people.

[a2thezebra]

You have no reason to ask that since I didn't imply that you did express neutrality. You've already established that you would lynch him and you've already established that you believe he's not important right now, there's no need to repeat yourself. I asked you what your read of him is.

What the fuck is the difference?

I don't have "reads" on people.

The difference between what and what? It's a simple question, what is your read of Wilgy?