lapluie wrote: ↑Wed Jan 24, 2018 11:19 pm
If we are voting Simon tonight, we will mislynched & kill another townie, (possibly). So genuine reads from those two are better than a confused & unsure read on simon.
Dunya's info was probably wrong because of a bit of 3P advice we got. Tony's info, based on his role, could very easily be wrong. Assuming he had info, let's look at the following:
Don't forget that the mafia have five players, and only one of them carries out the kill. Tony was a tracker. He would have had to have been lucky, and tracked the exact right one that was carrying out the kill.
AND
Every single role in this crazy game is a targeting role. I just checked. Everyone is visiting someone.
So IDK. My scumread on Simon, combined with the way his lynch has been PREVENTED and DEFLECTED and BUSSED all in a 48 hour period, feels a lot more certain than some possible info from a guy that would have been insanely lucky to track the kill, and also could easily be wrong because of the way tracking works. My vote stays.