Pikachu Tribe - Day 9

[DharmaHelper]

TFW you crack the case and townfirm Sprityo.

[DharmaHelper]

I suppose it helps me that I already had two town reads before I showed up. Sprityo is the only player here I don't have a read of.

the town likes to assume im cecil based off a pure chance comparison DH made (which i quoted for you earlier) but of course infodumping is not allowed and so it's realistically up to you guys to believe if it's true

Its a townfirm afterall.

[sprityo]

I suppose it helps me that I already had two town reads before I showed up. Sprityo is the only player here I don't have a read of.

the town likes to assume im cecil based off a pure chance comparison DH made (which i quoted for you earlier) but of course infodumping is not allowed and so it's realistically up to you guys to believe if it's true

Its a townfirm afterall.

it's not a townfirm because you dont know cecil's alignment but i can assure you I, Sprityo, am town

[Scotty]

Did you guys even get Chucks flip on Cerberus?

I believe we did, but the last week has been an exhausted blur for me so I might be creating false memories for convenience.

You know, now that I’m thinking about it, no we didn’t. We only got the lynch flip, not the nutella-induced flip.

It was a surprise to see it when I read the thread here

[Sloonei]

There are still multiple people over there who have seen speedchuck's flip and hopefully they've not all forgotten about it.

[Epignosis]

sprityo is a civilian based largely on his role not being very useful to mafia.

That on its own isn't enough to clear him.

However, sprityo's activity helps in that regard, and I'm not inclined to vote for him any time soon.

[Scotty]

There are still multiple people over there who have seen speedchuck's flip and hopefully they've not all forgotten about it.

It’s probably easier to believe someone’s info when you can read the thread verbatim and make out those eccentricities.

Plus speedchucks’s team member(s) probably wouldn’t have piled on him.

[DharmaHelper]

There are still multiple people over there who have seen speedchuck's flip and hopefully they've not all forgotten about it.

It’s probably easier to believe someone’s info when you can read the thread verbatim and make out those eccentricities.

Plus speedchucks’s team member(s) probably wouldn’t have piled on him.

Speedchuck's teammate is over here tho

[Scotty]

Here’s a very likely thing to note:
Strexcorp does not kill on even nights.

Marmot most definitely used his one-shot negation of night actions on N4, because not only was there no kill, Cecil didn’t post.

So either there was a protect of the NK target and someone blocked Cecil, or Marmot used his power on a night they didn’t kill. There is no reason to do so on a night that they would have had a chance to kill.

So therefore, if there are only 2 teams (Evil Evens and Strexcorp) then Evil Evens DO kill on even nights

[Scotty]

There are still multiple people over there who have seen speedchuck's flip and hopefully they've not all forgotten about it.

It’s probably easier to believe someone’s info when you can read the thread verbatim and make out those eccentricities.

Plus speedchucks’s team member(s) probably wouldn’t have piled on him.

Speedchuck's teammate is over here tho

We don’t know how many teammates are on each mafia team.

Do you?

[Sloonei]

Google tells me Strexcorp is from Nightvale. I am unfamiliar with the product and did not play in that game. Anyone got info on the flavor?

[Epignosis]

Google tells me Strexcorp is from Nightvale. I am unfamiliar with the product and did not play in that game. Anyone got info on the flavor?

Hell, I was Strexcorp and don't really remember it other than we were doomed from the getgo due to the setup.

[Epignosis]

I had an extra vote or something like that, which meant I had to be care voting because I could be exposed. I remember that much. I was bad with Eloh and LC.

[Scotty]

if there is a kill tonight, and there are only 2 teams, that means Evil Evens kill tonite. It’s already lost 2 members, and the killer on the team can only target someone on their tribe. So I guess we’ll see if there is a kill and which tribe still has Evil Evens on it, if any.

This tribal switch is going to turn this game into a Sudoku to solve

[Sloonei]

If the "targeted abilities must target a member of your own tribe" rule applies to nightkills, we could also be in interesting territory.

[Sloonei]

Interactive reads between Long Con/nutella and speedchuck might be illuminating. But he's not here.

[Scotty]

If the "targeted abilities must target a member of your own tribe" rule applies to nightkills, we could also be in interesting territory.

That is my thought.

Interactive reads between Long Con/nutella and speedchuck might be illuminating. But he's not here.

Looking through that now in any case for possible combinations of teammate compatibilities on Pikachu

[Scotty]

Oh, and that initial thought I had yesterday that a bad nutella = bad nijuu sounds more likely. And on opposing teams.

Why on God’s green earth would there be a masonry role where one person is bad and one person is good, and they can’t reveal names? Like how bogus would that be for nijuu??

I think nijuu is on Strexcorp [or another team god save the queen]

[Epignosis]

Oh, and that initial thought I had yesterday that a bad nutella = bad nijuu sounds more likely. And on opposing teams.

Why on God’s green earth would there be a masonry role where one person is bad and one person is good, and they can’t reveal names? Like how bogus would that be for nijuu??

I think nijuu is on Strexcorp [or another team god save the queen]

If the Evil Evens kill on even Nights, then Strex killed nijuukyugou, and so she didn't start out on their team.

[Sloonei]

We talked in our thread about the possibility of a mafia team killing one of their own for credibility in a game where we all have two lives.

[Scotty]

Oh, and that initial thought I had yesterday that a bad nutella = bad nijuu sounds more likely. And on opposing teams.

Why on God’s green earth would there be a masonry role where one person is bad and one person is good, and they can’t reveal names? Like how bogus would that be for nijuu??

I think nijuu is on Strexcorp [or another team god save the queen]

If the Evil Evens kill on even Nights, then Strex killed nijuukyugou, and so she didn't start out on their team.

good point.

I guess she could have started indie or something. I hat don’t see a civ role being in that position. I would be pissed at my role if I learned i was good and btscing with mafia.

So she could be anything at this point then.

All assuming there are only 2 mafia teams.

[Scotty]

We talked in our thread about the possibility of a mafia team killing one of their own for credibility in a game where we all have two lives.

She did seem like an odd choice of kill N1.

[Epignosis]

We talked in our thread about the possibility of a mafia team killing one of their own for credibility in a game where we all have two lives.

Which would be stupid. I cannot fathom a team seriously doing this.

I mean...I can. Long Con was here at one point.

[Sloonei]

We talked in our thread about the possibility of a mafia team killing one of their own for credibility in a game where we all have two lives.

She did seem like an odd choice of kill N1.

She did. For all of the reasons Epi talked about.

[Epignosis]

I still don't believe speedchuck was bad in his first incarnation.

[Epignosis]

And I don't think speedchuck would have killed nijuukyugou.

[Epignosis]

To the best of your ability, newcomers:

What did nijuukyugou do during Day 1 / Night 1?

[Scotty]

This is speedchuck’s D1 rainbow. Posting for posterity.

speedchuck
Long Con
sprityo
S~V~S
Quin
Epignosis
nutella
Dragon D Luffy
Dharmahelper
colonialbob
dom

Readlist

I would expect if Speedchuck had a teammate on this tribe (which isn’t definite), the teammate(s) would lie somewhere in the middle-low range. Not too high, not too low. Epi certainly fits that bill, but so does DDL and DH

I still don't believe speedchuck was bad in his first incarnation.

Well then, there is that possibility.

[Scotty]

To the best of your ability, newcomers:

What did nijuukyugou do during Day 1 / Night 1?

Day 1:







And then on night 1 she

[Epignosis]

To the best of your ability, newcomers:

What did nijuukyugou do during Day 1 / Night 1?

Day 1:







And then on night 1 she

That sounds about right.

What did Boomslang do?

[Sloonei]

I just remembered speedchuck can't be nutella's/LC's teammate.

[Scotty]

To the best of your ability, newcomers:

What did nijuukyugou do during Day 1 / Night 1?

Day 1:







And then on night 1 she

That sounds about right.

What did Boomslang do?

Boomslang:
sig said some odd stuff and it came off as odd. [VOTE:



He had a total of 30 posts or so when we were swapped] aubergine

[Scotty]

The fuck.

Fixed:

To the best of your ability, newcomers:

What did nijuukyugou do during Day 1 / Night 1?

Day 1:







And then on night 1 she

That sounds about right.

What did Boomslang do?

Boomslang:
sig said some odd stuff and it came off as odd. (vote sig)



He had a total of 30 posts or so when we were swapped

[Sloonei]

Sig made a comment about being "70% sure" that he'd submitted a haiku on Day 1 and Boomslang fixated on this as the focal point of a sig case. People suspected boomslang for this.

[Epignosis]

Sloonei, has your opinion on Wilgy changed given the reveal?

[Scotty]

I just remembered speedchuck can't be nutella's/LC's teammate.

Here’s a theory:

Anyone not mafia in the first incarnation that becomes mafia in the 2nd incarnation gains an entirely new mafia team that gradually grows in members and stops once it reaches {3??} players. It would take over a kill of the first team that’s eliminated.

I dunno, that sounds like a cool setup. And annoying for us.

[Sloonei]

Sloonei, has your opinion on Wilgy changed given the reveal?

I would be going back to review wilgy/marmot interactions if I could right now. My POE pool in this tribe is pretty limited and he's one of the people still in it.

[Epignosis]

I just remembered speedchuck can't be nutella's/LC's teammate.

Here’s a theory:

Anyone not mafia in the first incarnation that becomes mafia in the 2nd incarnation gains an entirely new mafia team that gradually grows in members and stops once it reaches {3??} players. It would take over a kill of the first team that’s eliminated.

I dunno, that sounds like a cool setup. And annoying for us.

Just no.

[Epignosis]

Sloonei, has your opinion on Wilgy changed given the reveal?

I would be going back to review wilgy/marmot interactions if I could right now. My POE pool in this tribe is pretty limited and he's one of the people still in it.

What does it mean to be "in it?"

[Sloonei]

Sloonei, has your opinion on Wilgy changed given the reveal?

I would be going back to review wilgy/marmot interactions if I could right now. My POE pool in this tribe is pretty limited and he's one of the people still in it.

What does it mean to be "in it?"

I could vote for wilgy.

[Epignosis]

Also, that other tribe must be shitty as hell. I'd be losing my mind over there.

[Epignosis]

Were missing votes a problem over there or something?

[Scotty]

I just remembered speedchuck can't be nutella's/LC's teammate.

Here’s a theory:

Anyone not mafia in the first incarnation that becomes mafia in the 2nd incarnation gains an entirely new mafia team that gradually grows in members and stops once it reaches {3??} players. It would take over a kill of the first team that’s eliminated.

I dunno, that sounds like a cool setup. And annoying for us.

Just no.

No like you don’t think it’s possible or like, ‘nuh uh, girlfriend’?

[Scotty]

Also, that other tribe must be shitty as hell. I'd be losing my mind over there.

I have some extra pills if you wanna meet my dealer

[Epignosis]

I just remembered speedchuck can't be nutella's/LC's teammate.

Here’s a theory:

Anyone not mafia in the first incarnation that becomes mafia in the 2nd incarnation gains an entirely new mafia team that gradually grows in members and stops once it reaches {3??} players. It would take over a kill of the first team that’s eliminated.

I dunno, that sounds like a cool setup. And annoying for us.

Just no.

No like you don’t think it’s possible or like, ‘nuh uh, girlfriend’?

If it's possible, then fuck this.

[Sloonei]

Were missing votes a problem over there or something?

Inactivity and absenteeism in general were an issue.

[Scotty]

Were missing votes a problem over there or something?

I wouldn’t say that was the problem exactly- we definitely had days without 1-2 voters. Maybe 3 I don’t remember.

The problem was a stasis in agreement among who looked the most guilty. There were so many wallflowers that there were reasons for basically voting everyone. I don’t think we stuck with the same lynch from one day to another

[Epignosis]

Then I'm down to lynch Wilgy next.

[sprityo]

Here’s a very likely thing to note:
Strexcorp does not kill on even nights.

Marmot most definitely used his one-shot negation of night actions on N4, because not only was there no kill, Cecil didn’t post.

So either there was a protect of the NK target and someone blocked Cecil, or Marmot used his power on a night they didn’t kill. There is no reason to do so on a night that they would have had a chance to kill.

So therefore, if there are only 2 teams (Evil Evens and Strexcorp) then Evil Evens DO kill on even nights

i'd like to point out it's also possible cecil just straight up didnt submit anything for night 4. i dont think the hosts would come on and say "cecil didnt send anything in tonight"

[Scotty]

Here’s a very likely thing to note:
Strexcorp does not kill on even nights.

Marmot most definitely used his one-shot negation of night actions on N4, because not only was there no kill, Cecil didn’t post.

So either there was a protect of the NK target and someone blocked Cecil, or Marmot used his power on a night they didn’t kill. There is no reason to do so on a night that they would have had a chance to kill.

So therefore, if there are only 2 teams (Evil Evens and Strexcorp) then Evil Evens DO kill on even nights

i'd like to point out it's also possible cecil just straight up didnt submit anything for night 4. i dont think the hosts would come on and say "cecil didnt send anything in tonight"

Did he?