Hogwarts Mafia - END

[DharmaHelper]

"I am suspicious of Long Con in case he gets fucked on today and flips bad but also check out this cool and good post of reasons why he's totally not bad lol I'm so random uwu"

[DharmaHelper]

Pretty wild how Luna townread Long Con before he got fucked on tho

[speedchuck]

*pulls Colin out of tinfoil POE*
*places Jay into Colin's place*

Continue

[JaggedJimmyJay]

"I am suspicious of Long Con in case he gets fucked on today and flips bad but also check out this cool and good post of reasons why he's totally not bad lol I'm so random uwu"

I tend to adhere to a certain trait that we in the business of hunting for bad guys call "thoroughness", and it's really quite a concept. You see, the idea is that you check into all sides of a dialogue and carefully consider the information available before you make a final decision, or moreover influence others on that decision. It's a rather controversial notion I understand, but I really think it can go far if given the chance.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

*pulls Colin out of tinfoil POE*
*places Jay into Colin's place*

Continue

spreadsheet updated!

[Jackofhearts2005]

Who are we missing on the spreadsheet?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Anyone remember that time I made a case against INH and DharmaHelper was like "omg lol is this like a third-party no u??"

wild so wild

[nutella]

*pulls Colin out of tinfoil POE*
*places Jay into Colin's place*

Continue

spreadsheet updated!

Lol

[speedchuck]

Thanks Jay. I can always trust...

wait.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Who are we missing on the spreadsheet?

Everyone not named Jackofhearts2005, Sloonei, nutella, speedchuck, ColinIsCool, JaggedJimmyJay

[JaggedJimmyJay]

sorry I think juliets posted a list that I forgot to add, so she good

[speedchuck]

I have an idea guys.

What if we just lynched and killed everyone except for me?

Then town would win.

[DharmaHelper]

Anyone remember that time I made a case against INH and DharmaHelper was like "omg lol is this like a third-party no u??"

wild so wild

"Case" lol u crazy fam.

[juliets]

If poutanko was redirected night 1 wouldn't his results have shown someone other than Bullzeye? Or is that not the way it works? Also is Imperio the only thing that could have redirected him? I looked at that dirithingy but couldn't quite figure out how that would work. It would seem odd to me to use Imperio before you even knew what a player's power was because it can only be used one time for each player.

I know I'm asking some nitpick questions but I'm just trying to look at all angles of the Quin/speed thing.

linki yes I did post a list

[speedchuck]

If poutanko was redirected night 1 wouldn't his results have shown someone other than Bullzeye? Or is that not the way it works? Also is Imperio the only thing that could have redirected him? I looked at that dirithingy but couldn't quite figure out how that would work. It would seem odd to me to use Imperio before you even knew what a player's power was because it can only be used one time for each player.

I know I'm asking some nitpick questions but I'm just trying to look at all angles of the Quin/speed thing.

linki yes I did post a list

I asked the host about my watch. Apparently if I'd been redirected to say timmer, I would have seen who watched Timmer, but not that I was watching Timmer. That's what I understood, anyway. So no, the results would have just said SCUM/TOWN afaik.

Scum have secrets. We cannot know what else redirected. Except Diricawl, which you mentioned.

Diricawl would mean that some scum switched themselves with me on night 1, and Pout targeted them instead of me. Not inconceivable. It's the perfect measure against cop checks, trackers, and other info roles.

[speedchuck]

If I were a scum with a Diricawl, I'd use it on a townie every night I could.

[juliets]

If poutanko was redirected night 1 wouldn't his results have shown someone other than Bullzeye? Or is that not the way it works? Also is Imperio the only thing that could have redirected him? I looked at that dirithingy but couldn't quite figure out how that would work. It would seem odd to me to use Imperio before you even knew what a player's power was because it can only be used one time for each player.

I know I'm asking some nitpick questions but I'm just trying to look at all angles of the Quin/speed thing.

linki yes I did post a list

I asked the host about my watch. Apparently if I'd been redirected to say timmer, I would have seen who watched Timmer, but not that I was watching Timmer. That's what I understood, anyway. So no, the results would have just said SCUM/TOWN afaik.

Scum have secrets. We cannot know what else redirected. Except Diricawl, which you mentioned.

Diricawl would mean that some scum switched themselves with me on night 1, and Pout targeted them instead of me. Not inconceivable. It's the perfect measure against cop checks, trackers, and other info roles.

Thanks speed - very clear.

[Sloonei]

My first comment was about the speedchuck/quin conflict. Note my confusion in another post where poutanko responded to me.

You've been around and seen a lot in this game now. Do you still feel hopelessly behind?

No. I have a general pulse, but still not a complete image, and I still don’t have the time to do all the things that I normally would.

I’m just trying to provide pockets of insight whenever and wherever I can. It’d be hopeless for me to try to get a full grasp on this game.

[DharmaHelper]

Pretty wild how Glorf/Juliets had a rezz this whole time and the one time it gets used a baddie gets rezzed huh

[speedchuck]

Pretty wild how Glorf/Juliets had a rezz this whole time and the one time it gets used a baddie gets rezzed huh

It's apparently an odd-night only power.

Glorf prolly didn't use it night one because JJJ wasn't dead yet. (or someone of equivalence)

But if you want to explore this, I'm all ears.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Pretty wild how Glorf/Juliets had a rezz this whole time and the one time it gets used a baddie gets rezzed huh

A 7-player process of elimination pool would be super

[DharmaHelper]

Pretty wild how Glorf/Juliets had a rezz this whole time and the one time it gets used a baddie gets rezzed huh

It's apparently an odd-night only power.

Glorf prolly didn't use it night one because JJJ wasn't dead yet. (or someone of equivalence)

But if you want to explore this, I'm all ears.

Pretty crazy how Glorf/Juliets didn't use their rezz to bring back TH who was confirmed ciiv lol thats nuts man I'm trippin out.

[juliets]

Pretty wild how Glorf/Juliets had a rezz this whole time and the one time it gets used a baddie gets rezzed huh

This whole time? Glorf could have used it night 1 only because it was an odd night only use, and then I used it the first night I was back in the game, night 3.

linki

[DharmaHelper]

Pretty wild how Glorf/Juliets had a rezz this whole time and the one time it gets used a baddie gets rezzed huh

This whole time? Glorf could have used it night 1 only because it was an odd night only use, and then I used it the first night I was back in the game, night 3.

linki

[juliets]

Pretty wild how Glorf/Juliets had a rezz this whole time and the one time it gets used a baddie gets rezzed huh

It's apparently an odd-night only power.

Glorf prolly didn't use it night one because JJJ wasn't dead yet. (or someone of equivalence)

But if you want to explore this, I'm all ears.

Pretty crazy how Glorf/Juliets didn't use their rezz to bring back TH who was confirmed ciiv lol thats nuts man I'm trippin out.

I tried to bring back Turnip Head - thats who I targeted. But continue on I need some suspicion.

[DharmaHelper]

I read DH as town, but I also wasn't around for the whole LC lynch thing. If I have a reason to suspect him right now, it's that he refused to talk about his current reads a few moments ago, but whatever, I'll see what he does tomorrow.

Lol so crazy that Hufflepuff McTownslip "reads DH as town" after jumping on Mac/Jay's goose chase huh thats fuckin nuts man wow this game is so wild lol

[speedchuck]

Pretty crazy how Glorf/Juliets didn't use their rezz to bring back TH who was confirmed ciiv lol thats nuts man I'm trippin out.

It was Glorf at the time, and I could totally see him refusing to rez TH. 100%.

I tried to bring back Turnip Head - thats who I targeted. But continue on I need some suspicion.

Why do you need suspicion?

[juliets]

Pretty crazy how Glorf/Juliets didn't use their rezz to bring back TH who was confirmed ciiv lol thats nuts man I'm trippin out.

It was Glorf at the time, and I could totally see him refusing to rez TH. 100%.

I tried to bring back Turnip Head - thats who I targeted. But continue on I need some suspicion.

Why do you need suspicion?

Because of the truth meta. Glorf claimed town before I replaced him.

[speedchuck]

Pretty crazy how Glorf/Juliets didn't use their rezz to bring back TH who was confirmed ciiv lol thats nuts man I'm trippin out.

It was Glorf at the time, and I could totally see him refusing to rez TH. 100%.

I tried to bring back Turnip Head - thats who I targeted. But continue on I need some suspicion.

Why do you need suspicion?

Because of the truth meta. Glorf claimed town before I replaced him.

I understand this.

Why do you need suspicion? What are you/we supposed to do with it?

[DharmaHelper]

Hufflepuff

Speedchuck 2.0
Epignosis
juliets 2.0
Sloonei
poutanko
Soneji - civilian


Soneji ain't bad.
Epignosis ain't bad
Juliets 2.0 aint bad
----


Chuckeye
Poutanko
Sloonei

These are your 3 suspects for D5 my people.

[juliets]

Pretty crazy how Glorf/Juliets didn't use their rezz to bring back TH who was confirmed ciiv lol thats nuts man I'm trippin out.

It was Glorf at the time, and I could totally see him refusing to rez TH. 100%.

I tried to bring back Turnip Head - thats who I targeted. But continue on I need some suspicion.

Why do you need suspicion?

Because of the truth meta. Glorf claimed town before I replaced him.

I understand this.

Why do you need suspicion? What are you/we supposed to do with it?

if I'm suspicious I'm less likely to be night killed.

[speedchuck]

Pretty crazy how Glorf/Juliets didn't use their rezz to bring back TH who was confirmed ciiv lol thats nuts man I'm trippin out.

It was Glorf at the time, and I could totally see him refusing to rez TH. 100%.

I tried to bring back Turnip Head - thats who I targeted. But continue on I need some suspicion.

Why do you need suspicion?

Because of the truth meta. Glorf claimed town before I replaced him.

I understand this.

Why do you need suspicion? What are you/we supposed to do with it?

if I'm suspicious I'm less likely to be night killed.

Oh bless your heart.

[juliets]

Hufflepuff

Speedchuck 2.0
Epignosis
juliets 2.0
Sloonei
poutanko
Soneji - civilian


Soneji ain't bad.
Epignosis ain't bad
Juliets 2.0 aint bad
----


Chuckeye
Poutanko
Sloonei

These are your 3 suspects for D5 my people.

DH, do you think poutanki lied about his cop checks and/or is not a cop at all? Or is there something else about him that is bothering you?

[juliets]

EBWOP - poutanko

[DharmaHelper]

Hufflepuff

Speedchuck 2.0
Epignosis
juliets 2.0
Sloonei
poutanko
Soneji - civilian


Soneji ain't bad.
Epignosis ain't bad
Juliets 2.0 aint bad
----


Chuckeye
Poutanko
Sloonei

These are your 3 suspects for D5 my people.

DH, do you think poutanki lied about his cop checks and/or is not a cop at all? Or is there something else about him that is bothering you?

[juliets]

Hufflepuff

Speedchuck 2.0
Epignosis
juliets 2.0
Sloonei
poutanko
Soneji - civilian


Soneji ain't bad.
Epignosis ain't bad
Juliets 2.0 aint bad
----


Chuckeye
Poutanko
Sloonei

These are your 3 suspects for D5 my people.

DH, do you think poutanki lied about his cop checks and/or is not a cop at all? Or is there something else about him that is bothering you?

why are you reluctant to share your "whys"?

[DharmaHelper]

I already shared my why's.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@DharmaHelper, can I have four more non-Hufflepuff suspects? I'm doing a thing.

[DharmaHelper]

@DharmaHelper, can I have four more non-Hufflepuff suspects? I'm doing a thing.

You can have as many suspects as you want my guy, that's how mafia works.

[juliets]

I already shared my why's.

oh, so they are back somewhere in your iso. ok cool.

[ColinIsCool]

I already shared my why's.

Do you think there are only 4 scum?

[DharmaHelper]

I already shared my why's.

Do you think there are only 4 scum?

[nutella]

I already shared my why's.

Do you think there are only 4 scum?

Dude come the fuck on. There's gotta be 5. Sfop spewing nonsense. Try harder.

[DharmaHelper]

I already shared my why's.

Do you think there are only 4 scum?

Dude come the fuck on. There's gotta be 5. Sfop spewing nonsense. Try harder.

Why must there be 5?

[speedchuck]

This is going to be a really long night.

[juliets]

I already shared my why's.

oh, so they are back somewhere in your iso. ok cool.

Ok I went back to the point where you brought up your Hufflepuff idea but the only person you mentioned any suspicion of in Hufflepuff is Sloonei. You were asked twice who you thought was bad and you said you'd tell us today. You've done that but I cannot find reasons. Can you point me to the post where you explained your poutanko suspicion? I just don't have time to go back even further in your ISO.

[Sloonei]

I read DH as town, but I also wasn't around for the whole LC lynch thing. If I have a reason to suspect him right now, it's that he refused to talk about his current reads a few moments ago, but whatever, I'll see what he does tomorrow.

Lol so crazy that Hufflepuff McTownslip "reads DH as town" after jumping on Mac/Jay's goose chase huh thats fuckin nuts man wow this game is so wild lol

According to you I’m not allowed to play this game.

[DharmaHelper]

I already shared my why's.

oh, so they are back somewhere in your iso. ok cool.

Ok I went back to the point where you brought up your Hufflepuff idea but the only person you mentioned any suspicion of in Hufflepuff is Sloonei. You were asked twice who you thought was bad and you said you'd tell us today. You've done that but I cannot find reasons. Can you point me to the post where you explained your poutanko suspicion? I just don't have time to go back even further in your ISO.

I didn't. I don't currently have a reason to suspect Poutanko, because I haven't read their posts.

[DharmaHelper]

I read DH as town, but I also wasn't around for the whole LC lynch thing. If I have a reason to suspect him right now, it's that he refused to talk about his current reads a few moments ago, but whatever, I'll see what he does tomorrow.

Lol so crazy that Hufflepuff McTownslip "reads DH as town" after jumping on Mac/Jay's goose chase huh thats fuckin nuts man wow this game is so wild lol

According to you I’m not allowed to play this game.

[juliets]

I already shared my why's.

oh, so they are back somewhere in your iso. ok cool.

Ok I went back to the point where you brought up your Hufflepuff idea but the only person you mentioned any suspicion of in Hufflepuff is Sloonei. You were asked twice who you thought was bad and you said you'd tell us today. You've done that but I cannot find reasons. Can you point me to the post where you explained your poutanko suspicion? I just don't have time to go back even further in your ISO.

I didn't. I don't currently have a reason to suspect Poutanko, because I haven't read their posts.

ok so your suspicions are based on believing there is a scum in Hufflepuff and those are the people you have left after ruling out the others. Thats my assumption out of this anyway.