Hogwarts Mafia - END

[DharmaHelper]

Voting Mac, because he's probably bad, and it looks like I'm going to die anyways. Do me a favor and lynch Mac tommow, kay?

Lol no.

If you flip town it's DH or Colin.

Is it tho

[nutella]

Voting Mac, because he's probably bad, and it looks like I'm going to die anyways. Do me a favor and lynch Mac tommow, kay?

Lol no.

If you flip town it's DH or Colin.

Is it tho

I mean there is some tiny chance it's juliets or poutanko but like nah. Prob just Colin if not Luna.

[nutella]

If it's poutanko I'ma feel real dumb tho

[DharmaHelper]

Now I feel mad stupid for getting that Leprachaun coin

[Jackofhearts2005]

If it's poutanko I'ma feel real dumb tho

Now I feel mad stupid for getting that Leprachaun coin

Lol you liar.

[ColinIsCool]

Hey poutanko, have you gotten any other reads since me?

[nutella]

Jack thinks me feeling dumb would be funny. I'm a Ravenclaw you jerk!

[nutella]

Hey poutanko, have you gotten any other reads since me?

she said she was obilviated and hasn't been able to use the cop power since then

[ColinIsCool]

Hey poutanko, have you gotten any other reads since me?

she said she was obilviated and hasn't been able to use the cop power since then

Ah ok. I figured I missed something.

[juliets]

This Epi quote is from day 2 before Luna checked him N2. He didn't have a lot to say between this and his death. I know we've already said he suspected her but it kinda hit me in the face in his ISO.

I changed my vote to Colin for now.

I'm curious as to why, would you share? Also, do you still suspect Lunalee? I don't expect you to answer at night but maybe when Day 3 comes around you would.

I'll answer this tomorrow. I know you are dead, but I'll answer it tomorrow. I'm zonked.

Yes, I suspect Luna. I suspect Luna more than Colin.

[juliets]

I'm changing my vote to Luna.

[DharmaHelper]

I'mma put it this way fam:

If it is Luna I will shit a brick.

[nutella]

I'mma put it this way fam:

If it is Luna I will shit a brick.

Just because of the Sloonei thing or?

[DharmaHelper]

I'mma put it this way fam:

If it is Luna I will shit a brick.

Just because of the Sloonei thing or?

There was a 0% chance I was wrong about Jack, there is a 2% maybe maybe maybe chance I'm wrong about Luna. That's yalls beef.

[DharmaHelper]

Yall wanna fuck around at end game and kill a cop thats on yall

[juliets]

I'mma put it this way fam:

If it is Luna I will shit a brick.

Just because of the Sloonei thing or?

There was a 0% chance I was wrong about Jack, there is a 2% maybe maybe maybe chance I'm wrong about Luna. That's yalls beef.

DH, could you say why you see the chances of her being bad as so slim?

[nutella]

I still don't get how you could have been 100% sure about Jack unless you're his teammate but whatev man.

[DharmaHelper]

I'mma put it this way fam:

If it is Luna I will shit a brick.

Just because of the Sloonei thing or?

There was a 0% chance I was wrong about Jack, there is a 2% maybe maybe maybe chance I'm wrong about Luna. That's yalls beef.

DH, could you say why you see the chances of her being bad as so slim?

Because she outted herself as a cop to stop Sloonei from being lynched lol

[DharmaHelper]

I still don't get how you could have been 100% sure about Jack unless you're his teammate but whatev man.

Cuz I'm smart as fuck

[ColinIsCool]

I'mma put it this way fam:

If it is Luna I will shit a brick.

Just because of the Sloonei thing or?

There was a 0% chance I was wrong about Jack, there is a 2% maybe maybe maybe chance I'm wrong about Luna. That's yalls beef.

DH, could you say why you see the chances of her being bad as so slim?

Because she outted herself as a cop to stop Sloonei from being lynched lol

Or she pretended to be a cop on a team where another person had already pretended to be a cop in order to gain civ credit.

[juliets]

I'mma put it this way fam:

If it is Luna I will shit a brick.

Just because of the Sloonei thing or?

There was a 0% chance I was wrong about Jack, there is a 2% maybe maybe maybe chance I'm wrong about Luna. That's yalls beef.

DH, could you say why you see the chances of her being bad as so slim?

Because she outted herself as a cop to stop Sloonei from being lynched lol

Or she pretended to be a cop on a team where another person had already pretended to be a cop in order to gain civ credit.

Yeah that could be. As I said before I am suspicious of the two civ cop angle and I don't suspect poutanko.

[DharmaHelper]

Aight yall god bless I gotta scoot

[Lunalee]

Aight yall god bless I gotta scoot

vote Mac with me?

[ColinIsCool]

I believe that if Luna is lynched, should she not be scum, Mac will inherit the unable-to-use-dark-arts stuff, but I am not sure and I think Luna is bad anyway.

[nutella]

I believe that if Luna is lynched, should she not be scum, Mac will inherit the unable-to-use-dark-arts stuff, but I am not sure and I think Luna is bad anyway.

...what?

[nutella]

Oh the canary thing.

[Lunalee]

Gut read is both Mac and Colin are town.

That said, I kind of suspect Colin and Mac for jumping on it.

Maybe I'll just shut up and wait for bullzeye to respond.

How come for though?

It's about jumping on an action that could easily be innocuous Civ Day 1 "I didn't pay enough attention". It's real easy to put a negative spin on it, so it's the kind of thing that's common for baddies to jump on.

Yeah but it's more common for non baddies to jump on it

Checkmate

But that would leave Pout or nutella...

[Lunalee]

Why didn't we lynch Pout again?

[Lunalee]

What if Poutanko v. Jack was scum v. scum?

[nutella]

actually that's a good question, I keep sorta forgetting about pout and now that I think about it I don't really have a solid case for her being town

[DharmaHelper]

It ain't gonna do fuck all but I'll vote Mac sure.

[Lunalee]

It ain't gonna do fuck all but I'll vote Mac sure.

no wait. vote Poutanko

[DharmaHelper]

Huh? OK?

[nutella]

hot poutanko potato?

[DharmaHelper]

But Jack wanted to lynch poutanko before I dunked on him tho is the thing

[nutella]

she gon b mad cause she's probably asleep so if she flips town i'll feel real bad but yolo

[nutella]

But Jack wanted to lynch poutanko before I dunked on him tho is the thing

oh worm?

[nutella]

I have a really important question that everyone should answer

I'm kinda taking for granted here that Epi wasn't killed because Luna or Colin was specifically worried about him. Epi wasn't really making waves in the thread. If I was in Luna or Colin's shoes as scum, I wouldn't be scured enough to kill him.

Is this WIFOM or TMI? In other words, does this post make it look more like Luna or Colin is Jack's teammate or less?

[DharmaHelper]

But Jack wanted to lynch poutanko before I dunked on him tho is the thing

oh worm?

Uh yeah it was his whole thing.

[Lunalee]

Examining [mention]poutanko[/mention]'s votes. Two days look a bit weird:
Day 3 she was the single voter of speedchuck while the rest of us tied up Glorf and Long Con.

Day 4 joined the "what if" wagon on speedchuck while the rest of us lynched INH

[nutella]

But Jack wanted to lynch poutanko before I dunked on him tho is the thing

oh worm?

Uh yeah it was his whole thing.

Idk I just reread the portion of his iso from that part of the game and I can see it as teammate compatible. Before he was in danger of being lynched, he could bus pout and look good for it, and he wanted to keep up that appearance when it was between them. I guess it would be risky if she's the horcrux but idk, especially in their other/slightly earlier interactions I can definitely see it (he was very hesitant to include her in his POE at first).

[DharmaHelper]

I got 2/3rds of a mind to vote for Pout and MJPopcorn this tie.

Lol what how did Jack "hint" that Luna's cop claim was bunk before Luna made a cop claim

[Lunalee]

But Jack wanted to lynch poutanko before I dunked on him tho is the thing

No, he wanted to lynch Sloonei. Once you outed him, he had no choice but push the vote onto another cop claimer. Clever if he meant to do it the way it turned out. I'm town, and Jack kept sticking up for me. What if Poutanko is his teammate and he bussed her for the cred, knowing she would flip scum?

[Lunalee]

linki nutella, you said what i was thinking

[DharmaHelper]

But Jack wanted to lynch poutanko before I dunked on him tho is the thing

No, he wanted to lynch Sloonei. Once you outed him, he had no choice but push the vote onto another cop claimer. Clever if he meant to do it the way it turned out. I'm town, and Jack kept sticking up for me. What if Poutanko is his teammate and he bussed her for the cred, knowing she would flip scum?

I guess but if Pout is his teammate would he bus her and tank the horcrux protection just for cred?

[juliets]

I have a really important question that everyone should answer

I'm kinda taking for granted here that Epi wasn't killed because Luna or Colin was specifically worried about him. Epi wasn't really making waves in the thread. If I was in Luna or Colin's shoes as scum, I wouldn't be scured enough to kill him.

Is this WIFOM or TMI? In other words, does this post make it look more like Luna or Colin is Jack's teammate or less?

Well my gut read is it's WIFOM, but I could probably be convinced otherwise.

linki

[nutella]

Colin and poutanko are our scum who's with me

If you were going to fake claim cop would you say “My teammate is town. This innocent person is scum”?

You’d mix truth with a lie. Colin really is town. Speed isn’t actually scum.

I might do this because I like to fuck with things like the rule of 3 or “he wouldn’t say this about his teammate” but I don’t think most people would do this.

Are the Pout suspicions more coming from the Colin suspicions or vice versa?

[mention]DharmaHelper[/mention] explain this then

[DharmaHelper]

Colin and poutanko are our scum who's with me

If you were going to fake claim cop would you say “My teammate is town. This innocent person is scum”?

You’d mix truth with a lie. Colin really is town. Speed isn’t actually scum.

I might do this because I like to fuck with things like the rule of 3 or “he wouldn’t say this about his teammate” but I don’t think most people would do this.

Are the Pout suspicions more coming from the Colin suspicions or vice versa?

@DharmaHelper explain this then

Heh fuck it, I've got nothing better.

[nutella]

oh I might have misread that, he's tying Colin to pout (more here)

[Lunalee]

I have a really important question that everyone should answer

I'm kinda taking for granted here that Epi wasn't killed because Luna or Colin was specifically worried about him. Epi wasn't really making waves in the thread. If I was in Luna or Colin's shoes as scum, I wouldn't be scured enough to kill him.

Is this WIFOM or TMI? In other words, does this post make it look more like Luna or Colin is Jack's teammate or less?

Jack's post is confusing, and at this point I sort of think Colin is town, so I don't know what Jack was trying to get at if we're both town.