It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia [END]

[Sloonei]

Did you just shush me!?

[juliets]

So Sloonei, I'm not sure I understand some things in your post. You give MP credit for not having been here yet give me no credit for not having been here since early this morning. I saw some things worth commenting on this afternoon and so I did. So he gets a C for one post and I get a D?

I agree with you on some others. Colin for example speed and Mongoose. Mac I don't give an F at this point because I haven't seen him do anything that he doesn't do when he's civ. dunya I'm not sure about, you make the point she throws out reads whether she is good or bad so I really can't tell yet.

I don't give MP credit for his absence, I just don't discredit him either. He hasn't played in forever because he's been too busy. That he's only made one post on Day 0 does not alarm me. Like dunya said, you were in the thread for an extended period of relative activity, but you did not jump in at the time.

I was mostly being cheeky with Mac's F because he went after me. But you've defended him twice now because you "haven't seem him do anything that he doesn't do as civ." Do you read him as civ here, then?

Where do you get the impression I was in the thread for an extended period of time? The window is always open on my computer.

I don't read Mac right now. I need to see more. My point is he throws out names at the beginning of every game regardless of alignment.

[MacDougall]

Did you just shush me!?

[Sloonei]

So Sloonei, I'm not sure I understand some things in your post. You give MP credit for not having been here yet give me no credit for not having been here since early this morning. I saw some things worth commenting on this afternoon and so I did. So he gets a C for one post and I get a D?

I agree with you on some others. Colin for example speed and Mongoose. Mac I don't give an F at this point because I haven't seen him do anything that he doesn't do when he's civ. dunya I'm not sure about, you make the point she throws out reads whether she is good or bad so I really can't tell yet.

I don't give MP credit for his absence, I just don't discredit him either. He hasn't played in forever because he's been too busy. That he's only made one post on Day 0 does not alarm me. Like dunya said, you were in the thread for an extended period of relative activity, but you did not jump in at the time.

I was mostly being cheeky with Mac's F because he went after me. But you've defended him twice now because you "haven't seem him do anything that he doesn't do as civ." Do you read him as civ here, then?

Where do you get the impression I was in the thread for an extended period of time? The window is always open on my computer.

I don't read Mac right now. I need to see more. My point is he throws out names at the beginning of every game regardless of alignment.

You made 3 posts between roughly 4 PM and 8 PM, so you were at least around the game. In this time, things started to happen. You commented indirectly on some of them in response to Mongoose, but you didn't really engage anyone else in discussion. That's what I'm referring to here.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Would you like for me to send you character information pertaining to role play?
Please note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

You may select 1 option


Sure, Mr. Host, go right on ahead.
3
33%
Voters: juliets, Lunalee, MacDougall
Naw, I know my character already.
2
22%
Voters: dunya, Sloonei
Naw, I don't feel like role playing.
0
No votes
Voters: None
I'm literally not playing.
4
44%
Voters: novaselinenever, leetic, JaggedJimmyJay, Epignosis

[juliets]

So Sloonei, I'm not sure I understand some things in your post. You give MP credit for not having been here yet give me no credit for not having been here since early this morning. I saw some things worth commenting on this afternoon and so I did. So he gets a C for one post and I get a D?

I agree with you on some others. Colin for example speed and Mongoose. Mac I don't give an F at this point because I haven't seen him do anything that he doesn't do when he's civ. dunya I'm not sure about, you make the point she throws out reads whether she is good or bad so I really can't tell yet.

I don't give MP credit for his absence, I just don't discredit him either. He hasn't played in forever because he's been too busy. That he's only made one post on Day 0 does not alarm me. Like dunya said, you were in the thread for an extended period of relative activity, but you did not jump in at the time.

I was mostly being cheeky with Mac's F because he went after me. But you've defended him twice now because you "haven't seem him do anything that he doesn't do as civ." Do you read him as civ here, then?

Where do you get the impression I was in the thread for an extended period of time? The window is always open on my computer.

I don't read Mac right now. I need to see more. My point is he throws out names at the beginning of every game regardless of alignment.

You made 3 posts between roughly 4 PM and 8 PM, so you were at least around the game. In this time, things started to happen. You commented indirectly on some of them in response to Mongoose, but you didn't really engage anyone else in discussion. That's what I'm referring to here.

ok though I was certainly not in the thread the whole time. I didn't consider anything I saw to be of great importance. I don't make reads off of one post or even two. I want to see some behavior or even a total lack of behavior before I make serious reads.

[Sloonei]

ok though I was certainly not in the thread the whole time. I didn't consider anything I saw to be of great importance. I don't make reads off of one post or even two. I want to see some behavior or even a total lack of behavior before I make serious reads.

Are there enough posts for you to make reads yet?

[juliets]

ok though I was certainly not in the thread the whole time. I didn't consider anything I saw to be of great importance. I don't make reads off of one post or even two. I want to see some behavior or even a total lack of behavior before I make serious reads.

Are there enough posts for you to make reads yet?

No. It's day 0. I want to see more behavior out of everyone.

[dunya]

ok though I was certainly not in the thread the whole time. I didn't consider anything I saw to be of great importance. I don't make reads off of one post or even two. I want to see some behavior or even a total lack of behavior before I make serious reads.

my concern was not that you didn't make reads, indeed, i don't at all expect them from juliets day 0. my concern stems from the fact of what you chose to address in the thread all the few times you were online. they don't match my civ-tone notes of juliets. it's a genuine concern. i don't expect reads, but i expect a certain level of curiosity and inquisition. you posted those 3 in the midst of everything else going on as though you didn't care; as though you already knew who was good and bad.

and i actually really don't like this:

So I've gathered that dunya is town. That's always a plus.

tell me why you have gathered i'm town

dunya, your town is shining so brightly it hurts. Mostly the way you suspected juliets for her posts. I wouldn't have necessarily noticed anything about her, but you did and said something about it.

So if I'm civ, do you still have a civ read on dunya?

if you are civ, and dunya is accusing you, does that make dunya bad?

[dunya]

i wanna believe ya'll can townread dunya so badly, so i'm gonna believe ya'll.

Don't worry dunya, if we last until lylo or mylo, I will re-evaluate my stance on you. Consider all town-reads temporary.

hold my beer while i go and re-read luna in spaceforce for civ-civ dunya-luna action.

[juliets]

ok though I was certainly not in the thread the whole time. I didn't consider anything I saw to be of great importance. I don't make reads off of one post or even two. I want to see some behavior or even a total lack of behavior before I make serious reads.

my concern was not that you didn't make reads, indeed, i don't at all expect them from juliets day 0. my concern stems from the fact of what you chose to address in the thread all the few times you were online. they don't match my civ-tone notes of juliets. it's a genuine concern. i don't expect reads, but i expect a certain level of curiosity and inquisition. you posted those 3 in the midst of everything else going on as though you didn't care; as though you already knew who was good and bad.

and i actually really don't like this:

So I've gathered that dunya is town. That's always a plus.

tell me why you have gathered i'm town

dunya, your town is shining so brightly it hurts. Mostly the way you suspected juliets for her posts. I wouldn't have necessarily noticed anything about her, but you did and said something about it.

So if I'm civ, do you still have a civ read on dunya?

if you are civ, and dunya is accusing you, does that make dunya bad?

no not at all. But Luna seems to be saying she reads you as good because you are suspecting me for my posts. So my question is what if you're bad and just pushing me as bad because I'm an easy mark.

Today is Day 0. I have some questions this afternoon but at the times I posted yesterday I didn't see anything that made me curious. That's just the way it is.

[dunya]

i wanna believe ya'll can townread dunya so badly, so i'm gonna believe ya'll.

Don't worry dunya, if we last until lylo or mylo, I will re-evaluate my stance on you. Consider all town-reads temporary.

hold my beer while i go and re-read luna in spaceforce for civ-civ dunya-luna action.

what a disgusting performance by me that game.

i'll give you some town cred luna for seeing through to town-dunya early that game as well.

[dunya]

i'll never get over how i didn't lynch dizzy that last day. never forgive myself.

[dunya]

So my question is what if you're bad and just pushing me as bad because I'm an easy mark.

what makes you an easy mark?

[juliets]

So my question is what if you're bad and just pushing me as bad because I'm an easy mark.

what makes you an easy mark?

I don't come out of the gate with names to get people talking or voting. I have a different approach to playing - not right or wrong but different. I don't defend well when I haven't done anything yet. I ask a lot of questions and then think about them for awhile unless something really sticks out to me. Things like that.

[dunya]

i think you're an excellent mafia player, easy to town read and very good intuition and your line of questioning always takes you good places. you'd never be an easy mark for scum dunya to get mislynched, trust me on that.

[juliets]

i think you're an excellent mafia player, easy to town read and very good intuition and your line of questioning always takes you good places. you'd never be an easy mark for scum dunya to get mislynched, trust me on that.

ok thanks, I feel better about your questioning me, that it comes from a real place.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

The Gang Solves a Murder

Jay's corpse remained sprawled on the bar floor, and the gang needed to come to a solution.

Dee: "Oh my God. We need to call the police, or clean this up, or do something, we can't keep standing around. Jay is completely dead right here. *restrained gag reflex*

Frank: "You know we could probably catch a killing for this guy's spleen. The Chinese will pay big."

Mac: "Right Frank, check it out. I can extract the spleen with my new Bowie knife using my training in deer organ removal." *demonstrates technique in the air with hands and a phantom knife*

Dee: "What? What? I don't care. I don't care! I DON'T CARE! I DON'T CARE! Gaddamnit! What? What?

Dennis: "I'll let you disgusting sewer people do... whatever it is you're doing there. I'm going to have a beer in the bunker."

Charlie: "Do you guys think the cops will mind if I like borrow Jay's pants? They're looking pretty clean and fitted, and I think the waitress will like them on me."

Day 1 has begun. You have 48 hours to lynch someone. I've added a "placeholder" option to function for that purpose as well as for "unvotes".

[dunya]

speedchuck and colin have given me 0 reasons to town read them. discuss.

[juliets]

speedchuck and colin have given me 0 reasons to town read them. discuss.

One thing I remember about speed is he doesn't post very much on the weekends because he is usually very busy. But I agree I haven't seen anything that makes me think he's civ yet. Same for Colin. Hopefully they show up soon.

[Sloonei]

[VOTE: Colin] aubergine

[Epignosis]

I'm your mod. If you're feeling hurt or upset at any point in this thing, just shoot me a PM, and I can help you, right?

Spoiler: show

[Sloonei]

Sweet Dee is sick of town’s losing streak too. We’re gonna correct it this game, gang. Since nobody’s around to yell any louder than me right now, I’m gonna put myself in charge.

Votes are changeable, as they always are. There is no reason not to put a vote on the poll as soon as possible. We’ve even been given a placeholder option if folks are uncomfortable leaving a dangling vote in the poll. My suggestion is that everybody votes right away. Votes are action, and action is good for town, especially in the early stages of a game. If you don’t vote, you don’t care that Jay is dead.

I voted for Colin because his entry looked like a stiff attempt to be casual and loose.

[novaselinenever]

What about yours?

I assume that if I give any reads you’ll all just tell me that I look like some sort of bird, or that I have nothing to contribute, and that I should just give up trying.

This is a mafia

I don't like this

What about it? Mac saying "this is mafia?" or Sloonei preemptively giving up?

Mac's. I don't buy what he's selling, and it reads more like him trying to throw a hot take out there and emulate supatown mac rather than being genuinely pinged. It's his only post, and it's the only thing he commented on even though there were stuff before it

In all the most recent games I've played with Mac he has thrown out names from the beginning that he says are bad or sometimes good. Why does this particular instance look like he's "emulating supatown" instead of being supatown. I just don't see the difference in this game and the others.

The context and the continuity. This instance is detached from anything.

[novaselinenever]

I don't recall ever getting a town read from Luna. She's always uneasy or unsure about me when I'm town 'cause I mess around. Funny thing is she read me as scum when she was a baddie in our last game together and she ended up getting lynched. Trying a new approach?

[novaselinenever]

I'll have to agree with Dunya also about Luna's read on her. That "Town shines brightly" is funny looking, and it looks like something right out of Jay's eloquent gut reads.

[novaselinenever]

Little surge of activity from Juliet, and a lot of inquiries in a very short amount of time. Exactly what Dunya said she would expect from civ juliets.

Omoshiroi

[juliets]

I assume that if I give any reads you’ll all just tell me that I look like some sort of bird, or that I have nothing to contribute, and that I should just give up trying.

This is a mafia

I don't like this

What about it? Mac saying "this is mafia?" or Sloonei preemptively giving up?

Mac's. I don't buy what he's selling, and it reads more like him trying to throw a hot take out there and emulate supatown mac rather than being genuinely pinged. It's his only post, and it's the only thing he commented on even though there were stuff before it

In all the most recent games I've played with Mac he has thrown out names from the beginning that he says are bad or sometimes good. Why does this particular instance look like he's "emulating supatown" instead of being supatown. I just don't see the difference in this game and the others.

The context and the continuity. This instance is detached from anything.

I don't understand what this means. Explain please.

[dunya]

I assume that if I give any reads you’ll all just tell me that I look like some sort of bird, or that I have nothing to contribute, and that I should just give up trying.

This is a mafia

I don't like this

What about it? Mac saying "this is mafia?" or Sloonei preemptively giving up?

Mac's. I don't buy what he's selling, and it reads more like him trying to throw a hot take out there and emulate supatown mac rather than being genuinely pinged. It's his only post, and it's the only thing he commented on even though there were stuff before it

In all the most recent games I've played with Mac he has thrown out names from the beginning that he says are bad or sometimes good. Why does this particular instance look like he's "emulating supatown" instead of being supatown. I just don't see the difference in this game and the others.

The context and the continuity. This instance is detached from anything.

tbf, mac has indicated one of his employees resigned and he was thrown a pile of poopy work on his shoulders. i give some credit to people experiencing hard situations in the real world.

[novaselinenever]

This is a mafia

I don't like this

What about it? Mac saying "this is mafia?" or Sloonei preemptively giving up?

Mac's. I don't buy what he's selling, and it reads more like him trying to throw a hot take out there and emulate supatown mac rather than being genuinely pinged. It's his only post, and it's the only thing he commented on even though there were stuff before it

In all the most recent games I've played with Mac he has thrown out names from the beginning that he says are bad or sometimes good. Why does this particular instance look like he's "emulating supatown" instead of being supatown. I just don't see the difference in this game and the others.

The context and the continuity. This instance is detached from anything.

I don't understand what this means. Explain please.

What I mean by it being detached from everything is that there has been content before that Sloonei's posts and after it, as well as it being the only contribution of Mac at that time. It wasn't one of the early posts, rather right in the meat of some interactions. It feels more nitpicky, him just jumping on a post to throw a hot take out rather than reading the whole game and being genuinely pinged. In the later case, I'd have expected a little bit more than just that one post. It's pretty soulless, and Sloonei avoiding to share a read when he's instead trying to roleplay is too easy of a ping. Not original and cheap

[novaselinenever]

This is a mafia

I don't like this

What about it? Mac saying "this is mafia?" or Sloonei preemptively giving up?

Mac's. I don't buy what he's selling, and it reads more like him trying to throw a hot take out there and emulate supatown mac rather than being genuinely pinged. It's his only post, and it's the only thing he commented on even though there were stuff before it

In all the most recent games I've played with Mac he has thrown out names from the beginning that he says are bad or sometimes good. Why does this particular instance look like he's "emulating supatown" instead of being supatown. I just don't see the difference in this game and the others.

The context and the continuity. This instance is detached from anything.

tbf, mac has indicated one of his employees resigned and he was thrown a pile of poopy work on his shoulders. i give some credit to people experiencing hard situations in the real world.

Duly noted

[novaselinenever]

[VOTE: Juliets] aubergine

[juliets]

This is a mafia

I don't like this

What about it? Mac saying "this is mafia?" or Sloonei preemptively giving up?

Mac's. I don't buy what he's selling, and it reads more like him trying to throw a hot take out there and emulate supatown mac rather than being genuinely pinged. It's his only post, and it's the only thing he commented on even though there were stuff before it

In all the most recent games I've played with Mac he has thrown out names from the beginning that he says are bad or sometimes good. Why does this particular instance look like he's "emulating supatown" instead of being supatown. I just don't see the difference in this game and the others.

The context and the continuity. This instance is detached from anything.

tbf, mac has indicated one of his employees resigned and he was thrown a pile of poopy work on his shoulders. i give some credit to people experiencing hard situations in the real world.

Yes, I agree with giving some credit for hard situations in the real world. Maybe I misunderstood you, I thought in your earlier post you were saying you didn't think he was being genuine, but here you seem to be saying you're giving him the benefit of the doubt due to the work issue.

oh linki I see you are posting something else so I'll read

[juliets]

Well dang I thought that post was from nova. Never mind dunya.

[juliets]

I don't like this

What about it? Mac saying "this is mafia?" or Sloonei preemptively giving up?

Mac's. I don't buy what he's selling, and it reads more like him trying to throw a hot take out there and emulate supatown mac rather than being genuinely pinged. It's his only post, and it's the only thing he commented on even though there were stuff before it

In all the most recent games I've played with Mac he has thrown out names from the beginning that he says are bad or sometimes good. Why does this particular instance look like he's "emulating supatown" instead of being supatown. I just don't see the difference in this game and the others.

The context and the continuity. This instance is detached from anything.

I don't understand what this means. Explain please.

What I mean by it being detached from everything is that there has been content before that Sloonei's posts and after it, as well as it being the only contribution of Mac at that time. It wasn't one of the early posts, rather right in the meat of some interactions. It feels more nitpicky, him just jumping on a post to throw a hot take out rather than reading the whole game and being genuinely pinged. In the later case, I'd have expected a little bit more than just that one post. It's pretty soulless, and Sloonei avoiding to share a read when he's instead trying to roleplay is too easy of a ping. Not original and cheap

Ok, I understand now. Thanks.

Also, why are you voting for me?

[dunya]

hahaha i was scratching my head for a minute and checked my iso of when i did that no worries!

[dunya]

[VOTE: Juliets] aubergine

https://media.giphy.com/media/l0IydskeK ... /giphy.gif

[dunya]

[VOTE: Juliets] aubergine

[Sloonei]

Little surge of activity from Juliet, and a lot of inquiries in a very short amount of time. Exactly what Dunya said she would expect from civ juliets.

Omoshiroi

Let’s talk about that. When she ws caught in A World Asunder, she responded by doing the exact things which it had been noted she’d not done up until that point.

[dunya]

i do think juliets is bad, but i'm not a monster despite what you all think of me. no way would i lynch her day 1.

let's talk about how mongoose is mia today after getting a little heat from me yesterday

[VOTE: Mongoose] aubergine

[novaselinenever]

[VOTE: Juliets] aubergine

[juliets]

I am most certainly not bad.

[dunya]

Little surge of activity from Juliet, and a lot of inquiries in a very short amount of time. Exactly what Dunya said she would expect from civ juliets.

Omoshiroi

Let’s talk about that. When she ws caught in A World Asunder, she responded by doing the exact things which it had been noted she’d not done up until that point.

didn't a world asunder have 2 mafia teams though?

[novaselinenever]

Little surge of activity from Juliet, and a lot of inquiries in a very short amount of time. Exactly what Dunya said she would expect from civ juliets.

Omoshiroi

Let’s talk about that. When she ws caught in A World Asunder, she responded by doing the exact things which it had been noted she’d not done up until that point.

didn't a world asunder have 2 mafia teams though?

How does that come into play?

[dunya]

Little surge of activity from Juliet, and a lot of inquiries in a very short amount of time. Exactly what Dunya said she would expect from civ juliets.

Omoshiroi

Let’s talk about that. When she ws caught in A World Asunder, she responded by doing the exact things which it had been noted she’d not done up until that point.

didn't a world asunder have 2 mafia teams though?

How does that come into play?

if you're on a mafia team in a game with 2 mafia teams, i feel like you can authentically scum hunt itt much more easily.

[dunya]

that said, i didn't spectate a world asunder. i'll go take a peek.

[Sloonei]

Little surge of activity from Juliet, and a lot of inquiries in a very short amount of time. Exactly what Dunya said she would expect from civ juliets.

Omoshiroi

Let’s talk about that. When she ws caught in A World Asunder, she responded by doing the exact things which it had been noted she’d not done up until that point.

didn't a world asunder have 2 mafia teams though?

I don’t see why that’s relevant.

[juliets]

Little surge of activity from Juliet, and a lot of inquiries in a very short amount of time. Exactly what Dunya said she would expect from civ juliets.

Omoshiroi

Let’s talk about that. When she ws caught in A World Asunder, she responded by doing the exact things which it had been noted she’d not done up until that point.

didn't a world asunder have 2 mafia teams though?

How does that come into play?

if you're on a mafia team in a game with 2 mafia teams, i feel like you can authentically scum hunt itt much more easily.

Yes, and I'm not sure what Sloonei is talking about. I was asking questions in day 1 which is my norm.

[Sloonei]

Little surge of activity from Juliet, and a lot of inquiries in a very short amount of time. Exactly what Dunya said she would expect from civ juliets.

Omoshiroi

Let’s talk about that. When she ws caught in A World Asunder, she responded by doing the exact things which it had been noted she’d not done up until that point.

didn't a world asunder have 2 mafia teams though?

How does that come into play?

if you're on a mafia team in a game with 2 mafia teams, i feel like you can authentically scum hunt itt much more easily.

I see. My point is only about her in-thread response to criticism.

[novaselinenever]

Little surge of activity from Juliet, and a lot of inquiries in a very short amount of time. Exactly what Dunya said she would expect from civ juliets.

Omoshiroi

Let’s talk about that. When she ws caught in A World Asunder, she responded by doing the exact things which it had been noted she’d not done up until that point.

didn't a world asunder have 2 mafia teams though?

How does that come into play?

if you're on a mafia team in a game with 2 mafia teams, i feel like you can authentically scum hunt itt much more easily.

Oh for sure. But the point here is that baddie!juliets had a reaction in that game similar to this game after being confronted.