U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[Adam_]

people who have only played with village!me and thus think im a wolf here because im different should noto be citing meta i verifiably try far harder as wolf

plsplspls anyone who can verify this [mention]beeboy[/mention] [mention]PunchyTheCat[/mention] [mention]Maple[/mention]

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

ITA2 Spicy Shots
Urist - Rej - [/color]HIT, Town Doctor/Vig thing (cool role) Sorta-POE-But-Not-Really
iaafr - motel room - HIT, Town Odd Night Somewhat Guilty Vigilante Sorta-POE-But-Not-Really
MartinGG99 - Exalt - HIT, Town Role Cop? Sorta-POE-But-Not-Really
DaisyCloud - funnygirl55 - HIT, Mafia Mikey Sub Out Traveller Thing Heroshot hit a wolf
Long Con - NANOOK - Refunded/failed Bimps

Shooting someone with like five posts is uh

Not normally called a hero shot kek

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

ITA2 Spicy Shots
Urist - Rej - [/color]HIT, Town Doctor/Vig thing (cool role) Sorta-POE-But-Not-Really
iaafr - motel room - HIT, Town Odd Night Somewhat Guilty Vigilante Sorta-POE-But-Not-Really
MartinGG99 - Exalt - HIT, Town Role Cop? Sorta-POE-But-Not-Really
DaisyCloud - funnygirl55 - HIT, Mafia Mikey Sub Out Traveller Thing Heroshot hit a wolf
Long Con - NANOOK - Refunded/failed Bimps

Shooting someone with like five posts is uh

Not normally called a hero shot kek

Correction: one post

[Urist]

The distinction between straight POE and sorta-POE is just decided based on whether you want to call the person town or scum right

[nutella]

Can someone with meta on beeboy help me out with that slot

I've technically played with him in anni and that extra big turbo and a couple normal turbos or something but idk he feels like a big ol blind spot for me

[Urist]

Like did we actually have a POE halfway through d1? Don't think so.

[Urist]

Can someone with meta on beeboy help me out with that slot

I've technically played with him in anni and that extra big turbo and a couple normal turbos or something but idk he feels like a big ol blind spot for me

beeboy is mafia.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Can someone with meta on beeboy help me out with that slot

I've technically played with him in anni and that extra big turbo and a couple normal turbos or something but idk he feels like a big ol blind spot for me

beeboy is mafia.

I begrudgingly agree

[nutella]

ok cool thanks urine

any particular reason there are no votes on him

[Urist]

ok cool thanks urine

any particular reason there are no votes on him

because that's what happens when you're mafia

[nutella]

oh nice nanook agrees we might be onto something here

Moving from 112 to [VOTE: beeboy] aubergine

[ColinIsCool]

I feel like half of the names I read in the thread aren’t even real players. You could probably convince me there’s someone in this game named Denim_Horse if you wanted to

[nutella]

I feel like half of the names I read in the thread aren’t even real players. You could probably convince me there’s someone in this game named Denim_Horse if you wanted to

Jorse

[Urist]

sure i'll bite

[ColinIsCool]

As an FYI I will be celebrating paying off my most high-interest student loans and my car today and will be getting drunk in the thread tonight.

[Urist]

how many days do we have to wait before executing maple, or do we just let him win for the half-baked fake cop clear play

[Urist]

As an FYI I will be celebrating paying off my most high-interest student loans and my car today and will be getting drunk in the thread tonight.

congrats!

[Urist]

how many days do we have to wait before executing maple, or do we just let him win for the half-baked fake cop clear play

To summarize:

Maple claims miller
HK claims "piercing day cop" which goes through miller apparently, and has a green on maple
HK dies immediately without a flip.

am i missing something, because this obviously is totally unbelievable.

[Marcher Jovian]

how many days do we have to wait before executing maple, or do we just let him win for the half-baked fake cop clear play

To summarize:

Maple claims miller
HK claims "piercing day cop" which goes through miller apparently, and has a green on maple
HK dies immediately without a flip.

am i missing something, because this obviously is totally unbelievable.

Thinking maybe d4?
Well Maple did claim that protection fails so /shrug

[Urist]

actually i have to log off, if i don't get to post and die n1, make sure to kill the low posters tomorrow

[SilverKeith]

how many days do we have to wait before executing maple, or do we just let him win for the half-baked fake cop clear play

To summarize:

Maple claims miller
HK claims "piercing day cop" which goes through miller apparently, and has a green on maple
HK dies immediately without a flip.

am i missing something, because this obviously is totally unbelievable.

What's your theory on what happened then.

Because your theory prolly implies that HK is Scum and died. Which would require a pretty funky wonky role.

[Timsup2nothin]

how many days do we have to wait before executing maple, or do we just let him win for the half-baked fake cop clear play

To summarize:

Maple claims miller
HK claims "piercing day cop" which goes through miller apparently, and has a green on maple
HK dies immediately without a flip.

am i missing something, because this obviously is totally unbelievable.

Maybe. Without having access to the wolf list but just playing the odds...there are very likely people in wolf chat that have a lot less to offer than Hollowkatt, so if the wolves were to run the kind of gambit described I would expect them to burn someone further down the lineup.

Something something WIFOM mutter mutter.

More specifically...three days at least?

[nutella]

hm yeah I can see that being a gambit

Prob just going to keep an eye on the outcomes of maple's pushes etc after a couple days

[nutella]

if hk was a scum sacrifice again I'd laugh p hard

[MacDougall]

I'm on drugs

[ThisIsNotAceMarvel]

I'm on drugs

Drink lots of water

[Timsup2nothin]

I'm on drugs

Like...sitting on a nest full to see if they hatch or...?

[Iwan]

Going into ITAs I made a pretty extensive list of "don't hero shoot today" peeps, which was crowdsourced from a bunch of people who were in thread at the time.

When ITAs opened, I said "I want to shoot JPIC and Daisy" and I more or less said "I don't care if you shoot cayvee, do it if you want". So people shooting Daisy are making the choice to 1) sheep me 2) not shoot JPIC 3) not take the maybe onto cayvee.

In essence, the shots list was more or less JPIC, Daisy, Cayvee.

I have a couple more thoughts as well, one moment while I check the chart again

And Cayvie is still town and I tried to argue in her favor but welp.

I could see why from your POV you think Daisy was a POE shot but if you're town then mafia could've actively made the decision to sheep you and to vote a town from that list (which could have been caivye) but Daisy is the most POE shot in that sense because no one would've batted an eye on Daisy dying which it really isn't true for JPIC and Cayvie.

Like I think most town would shoot on their own more or less but if people decided to sheep you it could be cause they were mafia and by sheeping you, a confirmed townie, they could justify their shots a lot more.

Actually, you just made me realize something kind of related to this lol

JPIC is not votable today, Daisy is. Trying to figure out of wolves would factor that at all in their thinking, gonna ponder that for a bit.

Aight. Lemme know when you find the wolf in that ITA session. All of em can't be town.

I mean a mafia sub out micley did die on the ITA session no ?

[Iwan]

Or do you mean the ITA 1 ?

[Sloonei]

Current Sloonei voters: [Epignosis, nutella, Maple, Hyena, 112, AWESOM-O, jumpluff, Adam_]

I have played exactly 0 games with 4 of these 8 people and do not know why any of them are doing what they are doing.
Epi's vote isn't serious.

'sup sloonei. We haven't interacted.

Who are the woofs in this game?

I do not have a satisfying answer to that question at this time.

maybe that's the reason people are voting you

It's ok to be wrong I won't judge I'm wrong all the time.

I am not afraid of being wrong, I am just answering truthfully. I’m not attempting a full scale analysis of this game while there’s over 30 players remaining. I’m taking little bites. As such, I don’t have any definitive scum reads yet.

[Timsup2nothin]

Current Sloonei voters: [Epignosis, nutella, Maple, Hyena, 112, AWESOM-O, jumpluff, Adam_]

I have played exactly 0 games with 4 of these 8 people and do not know why any of them are doing what they are doing.
Epi's vote isn't serious.

'sup sloonei. We haven't interacted.

Who are the woofs in this game?

I do not have a satisfying answer to that question at this time.

maybe that's the reason people are voting you

It's ok to be wrong I won't judge I'm wrong all the time.

I am not afraid of being wrong, I am just answering truthfully. I’m not attempting a full scale analysis of this game while there’s over 30 players remaining. I’m taking little bites. As such, I don’t have any definitive scum reads yet.

Do you have any serious town reads?

No pressure...unless some abundance of kill power falls into town hands I think it is unlikely to reach you before the game is pared down to a size you are willing to chew over, but some preliminary thoughts would be helpful.

[Sloonei]

I feel like half of the names I read in the thread aren’t even real players. You could probably convince me there’s someone in this game named Denim_Horse if you wanted to

[Sloonei]

Current Sloonei voters: [Epignosis, nutella, Maple, Hyena, 112, AWESOM-O, jumpluff, Adam_]

I have played exactly 0 games with 4 of these 8 people and do not know why any of them are doing what they are doing.
Epi's vote isn't serious.

'sup sloonei. We haven't interacted.

Who are the woofs in this game?

I do not have a satisfying answer to that question at this time.

maybe that's the reason people are voting you

It's ok to be wrong I won't judge I'm wrong all the time.

I am not afraid of being wrong, I am just answering truthfully. I’m not attempting a full scale analysis of this game while there’s over 30 players remaining. I’m taking little bites. As such, I don’t have any definitive scum reads yet.

Do you have any serious town reads?

No pressure...unless some abundance of kill power falls into town hands I think it is unlikely to reach you before the game is pared down to a size you are willing to chew over, but some preliminary thoughts would be helpful.

112, nutella, Epignosis, tedxtr.

Like I said, I’ve just been keeping an eye on things that directly involve me. So all of these reads sans Epi are related to the way these players have handled their reads on the player called Sloonei.

[SilverKeith]

Going into ITAs I made a pretty extensive list of "don't hero shoot today" peeps, which was crowdsourced from a bunch of people who were in thread at the time.

When ITAs opened, I said "I want to shoot JPIC and Daisy" and I more or less said "I don't care if you shoot cayvee, do it if you want". So people shooting Daisy are making the choice to 1) sheep me 2) not shoot JPIC 3) not take the maybe onto cayvee.

In essence, the shots list was more or less JPIC, Daisy, Cayvee.

I have a couple more thoughts as well, one moment while I check the chart again

And Cayvie is still town and I tried to argue in her favor but welp.

I could see why from your POV you think Daisy was a POE shot but if you're town then mafia could've actively made the decision to sheep you and to vote a town from that list (which could have been caivye) but Daisy is the most POE shot in that sense because no one would've batted an eye on Daisy dying which it really isn't true for JPIC and Cayvie.

Like I think most town would shoot on their own more or less but if people decided to sheep you it could be cause they were mafia and by sheeping you, a confirmed townie, they could justify their shots a lot more.

Actually, you just made me realize something kind of related to this lol

JPIC is not votable today, Daisy is. Trying to figure out of wolves would factor that at all in their thinking, gonna ponder that for a bit.

Aight. Lemme know when you find the wolf in that ITA session. All of em can't be town.

I mean a mafia sub out micley did die on the ITA session no ?

There was prolly people who shot in that session (or in either session) who were mafia.

Who are those people.

That is my question.

Town and Mafia make ITA shots for different reasons.

[nutella]

[mention]Sloonei[/mention] how do you expect Epi to have approached this game any differently based on his alignment rand?

[Adam_]

heads up i'm unlikely to be able to participate much more until 9pm which is unfortunate timing for this game obviously. i claimed my mediocre action (made it so jumpluff can't be RBed by non-town tonight) and they will be able to verify that. would love to see a medic save on jumpluff tonight, not just cause they're so great, not just cause i want them more than anyone to live through the night, not just cause they've made the game so much nicer with all the bunny posts, not just cause they're such a likely n1 for half the field, but cause they're having a good time playing this game and that means a lot to me. sorry and tag me with anything exceptionally important

[Timsup2nothin]

Spoiler: show

Current Sloonei voters: [Epignosis, nutella, Maple, Hyena, 112, AWESOM-O, jumpluff, Adam_]

I have played exactly 0 games with 4 of these 8 people and do not know why any of them are doing what they are doing.
Epi's vote isn't serious.

'sup sloonei. We haven't interacted.

Who are the woofs in this game?

I do not have a satisfying answer to that question at this time.

maybe that's the reason people are voting you

It's ok to be wrong I won't judge I'm wrong all the time.

I am not afraid of being wrong, I am just answering truthfully. I’m not attempting a full scale analysis of this game while there’s over 30 players remaining. I’m taking little bites. As such, I don’t have any definitive scum reads yet.

Do you have any serious town reads?

No pressure...unless some abundance of kill power falls into town hands I think it is unlikely to reach you before the game is pared down to a size you are willing to chew over, but some preliminary thoughts would be helpful.

112, nutella, Epignosis, tedxtr.

Like I said, I’ve just been keeping an eye on things that directly involve me. So all of these reads sans Epi are related to the way these players have handled their reads on the player called Sloonei.

I think that is a perfectly reasonable approach in a game this size. FWIW I consider Tedxtr town for the way he handled his reads on me as well
Epi I think has been even more enigmatic than you. nutella has been...well...nutella and I have no basis for anything there. No involvement with 112 at all either. So three out of four your view is all I have, and on one we agree.

Good talk.

[ColinIsCool]

I don’t know how it’s possible to have a read on Epi.

[SilverKeith]

Spoiler: show

'sup sloonei. We haven't interacted.

Who are the woofs in this game?

I do not have a satisfying answer to that question at this time.

maybe that's the reason people are voting you

It's ok to be wrong I won't judge I'm wrong all the time.

I am not afraid of being wrong, I am just answering truthfully. I’m not attempting a full scale analysis of this game while there’s over 30 players remaining. I’m taking little bites. As such, I don’t have any definitive scum reads yet.

Do you have any serious town reads?

No pressure...unless some abundance of kill power falls into town hands I think it is unlikely to reach you before the game is pared down to a size you are willing to chew over, but some preliminary thoughts would be helpful.

112, nutella, Epignosis, tedxtr.

Like I said, I’ve just been keeping an eye on things that directly involve me. So all of these reads sans Epi are related to the way these players have handled their reads on the player called Sloonei.

I think that is a perfectly reasonable approach in a game this size. FWIW I consider Tedxtr town for the way he handled his reads on me as well
Epi I think has been even more enigmatic than you. nutella has been...well...nutella and I have no basis for anything there. No involvement with 112 at all either. So three out of four your view is all I have, and on one we agree.

Good talk.

This is a wolfy post

or robot roleplay.

[PunchyTheCat]

The distinction between straight POE and sorta-POE is just decided based on whether you want to call the person town or scum right

no, there wasn't talk about shooting any of the 3 labeled sorta-POE before or during the ITA session

[nutella]

Spoiler: show

I do not have a satisfying answer to that question at this time.

maybe that's the reason people are voting you

It's ok to be wrong I won't judge I'm wrong all the time.

I am not afraid of being wrong, I am just answering truthfully. I’m not attempting a full scale analysis of this game while there’s over 30 players remaining. I’m taking little bites. As such, I don’t have any definitive scum reads yet.

Do you have any serious town reads?

No pressure...unless some abundance of kill power falls into town hands I think it is unlikely to reach you before the game is pared down to a size you are willing to chew over, but some preliminary thoughts would be helpful.

112, nutella, Epignosis, tedxtr.

Like I said, I’ve just been keeping an eye on things that directly involve me. So all of these reads sans Epi are related to the way these players have handled their reads on the player called Sloonei.

I think that is a perfectly reasonable approach in a game this size. FWIW I consider Tedxtr town for the way he handled his reads on me as well
Epi I think has been even more enigmatic than you. nutella has been...well...nutella and I have no basis for anything there. No involvement with 112 at all either. So three out of four your view is all I have, and on one we agree.

Good talk.

This is a wolfy post

or robot roleplay.

Robot 11

[PunchyTheCat]

Spoiler: show

I do not have a satisfying answer to that question at this time.

maybe that's the reason people are voting you

It's ok to be wrong I won't judge I'm wrong all the time.

I am not afraid of being wrong, I am just answering truthfully. I’m not attempting a full scale analysis of this game while there’s over 30 players remaining. I’m taking little bites. As such, I don’t have any definitive scum reads yet.

Do you have any serious town reads?

No pressure...unless some abundance of kill power falls into town hands I think it is unlikely to reach you before the game is pared down to a size you are willing to chew over, but some preliminary thoughts would be helpful.

112, nutella, Epignosis, tedxtr.

Like I said, I’ve just been keeping an eye on things that directly involve me. So all of these reads sans Epi are related to the way these players have handled their reads on the player called Sloonei.

I think that is a perfectly reasonable approach in a game this size. FWIW I consider Tedxtr town for the way he handled his reads on me as well
Epi I think has been even more enigmatic than you. nutella has been...well...nutella and I have no basis for anything there. No involvement with 112 at all either. So three out of four your view is all I have, and on one we agree.

Good talk.

This is a wolfy post

or robot roleplay.

it's a wolfy post

can we never do "no voting lists" d1 ever again please i'd be wagoning tim so hard rn

[nutella]

I heard the east coast is experiencing some Weather TM stay safe friendos

[Sloonei]

@Sloonei how do you expect Epi to have approached this game any differently based on his alignment rand?

I don’t, I’m just calling him town because yolo.

[PunchyTheCat]

I'm on drugs

can i have some?

[PunchyTheCat]

I heard the east coast is experiencing some Weather TM stay safe friendos

it hasn't rained in two weeks send rain pls

[Sloonei]

I heard the east coast is experiencing some Weather TM stay safe friendos

I just lost power for an hour, but it is currently bright and sunny.

[sabie12]

I don’t know how it’s possible to have a read on Epi.

This is how I feel even when epi posts actual words rather than memes. Also, welcome to the game.

[sabie12]

I heard the east coast is experiencing some Weather TM stay safe friendos

it hasn't rained in two weeks send rain pls

It rained all day here. Fun.

[WerewolfHunter]

I heard the east coast is experiencing some Weather TM stay safe friendos

Mine was mostly this morning before I woke up so not so bad