U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[Timsup2nothin]

A'ight can anyone explain the counter to the obvious?

The obvious being that HK knew he was gonna get janitored and set up Maple to go deep as his "dock clear"?

Best counter is that it’s fucking awkward for Maple to claim miller if that’s their plan

Why? Just in case any other cop checks that isn't a "strongman cop that reads through the role" they get a different result than HK.

Why would another cop check him

Who knows, but the miller claim doesn't seem "fucking awkward" it seems to make perfect sense.

Why would w!Hollowkatt, knowing he was about to be bus janitored, claim to be a cop that can read a miller and lock clear v!Maple?

[Maple]

Which kills were all redacted anyway

HK and Jovian

Third kill being missing implies they didnt expect to die

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Which kills were all redacted anyway

HK and Jovian

Third kill being missing implies they didnt expect to die

Or they threw a shot out right before dying in the popcorn game and didnt get a third one out in time

[Timsup2nothin]

Which kills were all redacted anyway

HK and Jovian

Third kill being missing implies they didnt expect to die

Third kill being missing implies he died before he got it in...he was playing popcorn at the same time...getting one kill off was pretty impressive.

[Maple]

I havent read that section of the thread so I wouldnt know

Its early as fuck over here

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

A'ight can anyone explain the counter to the obvious?

The obvious being that HK knew he was gonna get janitored and set up Maple to go deep as his "dock clear"?

Best counter is that it’s fucking awkward for Maple to claim miller if that’s their plan

Why? Just in case any other cop checks that isn't a "strongman cop that reads through the role" they get a different result than HK.

Why would another cop check him

Who knows, but the miller claim doesn't seem "fucking awkward" it seems to make perfect sense.

Why would w!Hollowkatt, knowing he was about to be bus janitored, claim to be a cop that can read a miller and lock clear v!Maple?

A miller claim doesn’t make much sense at all, not claiming miller gives HK’s claim so much more credibility

And why would they ever expect maple to get checked by a real cop if this is their plan??????

[Maple]

I claim

Spoiler: show

Edgelord Maple

Witness my artistic brilliance

[Timsup2nothin]

A'ight can anyone explain the counter to the obvious?

The obvious being that HK knew he was gonna get janitored and set up Maple to go deep as his "dock clear"?

Best counter is that it’s fucking awkward for Maple to claim miller if that’s their plan

Why? Just in case any other cop checks that isn't a "strongman cop that reads through the role" they get a different result than HK.

Why would another cop check him

Who knows, but the miller claim doesn't seem "fucking awkward" it seems to make perfect sense.

Why would w!Hollowkatt, knowing he was about to be bus janitored, claim to be a cop that can read a miller and lock clear v!Maple?

A miller claim doesn’t make much sense at all, not claiming miller gives HK’s claim so much more credibility

And why would they ever expect maple to get checked by a real cop if this is their plan??????

Because eventually if things go to shit under lock cleared Maple's guidance the idea that maybe HK was a wolf would probably resurface. And a 'just in case' recheck might happen. The miller claim can be a pre-empt...

But this sets aside the main question...why would a wolf HK lock clear a villager on their way out? Of all fucking villagers, MANTI. What wolf team says "hey lets run a sacrifice gambit and put MANTICHORA IN CHARGE OF THE TOWN, that seems like it will really help the wolf cause."

[Maple]

My role is town lost wolf

Redacting details for now, my role is mostly neg utility. Dont target me.

[Justplayingitcool]

Kinda want to target maple

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Arguments based around “but manti is so good uwu” aren’t gonna go far with me kek

This is the first time I’ve seen him play a real game

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Also jpic if you’re town why do you think it’s a good idea to announce your target?

[Maple]

Kinda want to target maple

Yes, do so

[DaisyCloud]

what happed? what's going on? why did they kill adam? where is jumpluff

[Timsup2nothin]

Arguments based around “but manti is so good uwu” aren’t gonna go far with me kek

This is the first time I’ve seen him play a real game

I know and in your world the only good player there is is you, but you were already a tree stump, so the wolves couldn't commit suicide by putting you in charge of the town and had to settle for a second choice...since for some reason they were dead set on NOT JUST PICKING A WOLF they went for Maple...makes perfect sense.

C'mon man.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Arguments based around “but manti is so good uwu” aren’t gonna go far with me kek

This is the first time I’ve seen him play a real game

I know and in your world the only good player there is is you, but you were already a tree stump, so the wolves couldn't commit suicide by putting you in charge of the town and had to settle for a second choice...since for some reason they were dead set on NOT JUST PICKING A WOLF they went for Maple...makes perfect sense.

C'mon man.

You asked what the counter argument was

[DaisyCloud]

I can no longer see the poll. did I miss EOD?

[Timsup2nothin]

what happed? what's going on? why did they kill adam? where is jumpluff

Chaos...there was a middle of the night popcorn game with casualties...it's messy...but ISO McDougal and look at the Exalt flip

[DrWilgy]

#welivinstill

[Timsup2nothin]

I can no longer see the poll. did I miss EOD?

Yes

[Timsup2nothin]

Arguments based around “but manti is so good uwu” aren’t gonna go far with me kek

This is the first time I’ve seen him play a real game

I know and in your world the only good player there is is you, but you were already a tree stump, so the wolves couldn't commit suicide by putting you in charge of the town and had to settle for a second choice...since for some reason they were dead set on NOT JUST PICKING A WOLF they went for Maple...makes perfect sense.

C'mon man.

You asked what the counter argument was

I asked for a counter argument to "HK ON HIS WAY OUT WOULD LOCK CLEAR A WOLF."

You have wandered far afield friend stump, but not addressed that basic fact.

[DaisyCloud]

I can no longer see the poll. did I miss EOD?

Yes

I'm on mobile ill try

[MacDougall]

Tonystarkprime - The Embodiment of Champs Hero Syndrome - Town (ITA)
Trustworthy Liberal - Jinx - Indie (SHOT)
Relm - Chevalier D'Eon - Town (SHOT)
hollowkatt - [Redacted] (SHOT)
Exalt - George A Tsoukalos - Town (ITA)
Funnygurl555 - [NSM] Mikey - Mafia (ITA)
motel room - The Shame After Masturbation - Town (ITA)
Rej - Victor Steinberg - Town (ITA)
112 - Darth Vader - Town (Popcorn)
Adam_ - A Power Rack - Town (SHOT)
Marcher Jovian - [Redacted] (SHOT)
MartinGG99 - That One Roblox Character (oof!) - Town (Popcorn)
polypies73 - Wario - Town (Popcorn)
Silverkeith - Spanish Nutella - Town (Popcorn)
xalt - Katarina - Mafia (Popcorn)
Jumpluff - Bun 2 Head reads - Town (Mod-killed at request)
Hank - Randy Marsh - Indie (Lost fight)
nutella - Tim Hortons - Mafia (Eliminated)
Sloonei - Dr. Eggman's Existential Crisis - Town (Eliminated)

I hope this helps.

[Timsup2nothin]

Xalt has died.

Spoiler: show

Xalt was Katarina Du Couteau.

You are an undetectable, unstoppable anytime janitor vigilante with three shots. But to get the 2nd and 3rd shot you have to kill a mafia teammate with the first one. You cannot use the first one on anything other than a mafia teammate.

Mafia.

Well, it seems obvious to me that this guy probably killed Hollowkatt so HK was red. Is that a widely held theory that I can't be bothered checking that last four hours for?

Here, this flip

[Maple]

Why wouldn't they fake check Xalt, who this entire ploy would revolve around

Faking on w!me after ive already claimed Miller seems suboptimal

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Why do I bother responding to you

[Maple]

I'm way too smart to make such an awful

Take that to the bank

[Timsup2nothin]

Xalt had to janitor a mafia to get the extra kills.

HK was mafia who KNEW he was about to be janitored so he could claim anything he wanted.

He claimed THE ONE THING that could clear Maple, and claimed to green check Maple...then he got janitored.

Why would he do that if Maple is town?

[Justplayingitcool]

Xalt has died.

Spoiler: show

Xalt was Katarina Du Couteau.

You are an undetectable, unstoppable anytime janitor vigilante with three shots. But to get the 2nd and 3rd shot you have to kill a mafia teammate with the first one. You cannot use the first one on anything other than a mafia teammate.

Mafia.

Well, it seems obvious to me that this guy probably killed Hollowkatt so HK was red. Is that a widely held theory that I can't be bothered checking that last four hours for?

Here, this flip

Probably been asked before and I don't care if it has already. Do we know who xalt killed, if he hadn't already?

[Timsup2nothin]

Why wouldn't they fake check Xalt, who this entire ploy would revolve around

Faking on w!me after ive already claimed Miller seems suboptimal

Because Xalt was a low poster who wasn't gonna take charge of the thread.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Xalt has died.

Spoiler: show

Xalt was Katarina Du Couteau.

You are an undetectable, unstoppable anytime janitor vigilante with three shots. But to get the 2nd and 3rd shot you have to kill a mafia teammate with the first one. You cannot use the first one on anything other than a mafia teammate.

Mafia.

Well, it seems obvious to me that this guy probably killed Hollowkatt so HK was red. Is that a widely held theory that I can't be bothered checking that last four hours for?

Here, this flip

Probably been asked before and I don't care if it has already. Do we know who xalt killed, if he hadn't already?

Very likely HK and Jovian

[Timsup2nothin]

Xalt has died.

Spoiler: show

Xalt was Katarina Du Couteau.

You are an undetectable, unstoppable anytime janitor vigilante with three shots. But to get the 2nd and 3rd shot you have to kill a mafia teammate with the first one. You cannot use the first one on anything other than a mafia teammate.

Mafia.

Well, it seems obvious to me that this guy probably killed Hollowkatt so HK was red. Is that a widely held theory that I can't be bothered checking that last four hours for?

Here, this flip

Probably been asked before and I don't care if it has already. Do we know who xalt killed, if he hadn't already?

There were two redacted flips...HK and Marcher Jovian

[Timsup2nothin]

Why do I bother responding to you

Because you are the only person I trust to figure this out if I am somehow wrong.

[Maple]

Why wouldn't they fake check Xalt, who this entire ploy would revolve around

Faking on w!me after ive already claimed Miller seems suboptimal

Because Xalt was a low poster who wasn't gonna take charge of the thread.

Hes also lowposting fodder who would inevitably die randomly in ITAs

If I were mafia, I'd do a red check instead

[Timsup2nothin]

I'm way too smart to make such an awful

Take that to the bank

Seems like an almost bulletproof plan...HK dies lock clearing you...you run the town so Xalt doesn't get flipped...profit.

[Timsup2nothin]

I'm way too smart to make such an awful

Take that to the bank

Seems like an almost bulletproof plan...HK dies lock clearing you...you run the town so Xalt doesn't get flipped...profit.

This popcorn madness flipping Xalt is a seriously surprising wrench crashing in I admit...but without that the plan would be brilliant...certaimly worthy of you.

[Maple]

I'm way too smart to make such an awful

Take that to the bank

Seems like an almost bulletproof plan...HK dies lock clearing you...you run the town so Xalt doesn't get flipped...profit.

He got flipped, therefore I'm not mafia :hattip:

[Timsup2nothin]

I mean I'm open to an alternative...someone just explain why a dying wolf HK spends his last hour lock clearing a villager.

[Timsup2nothin]

I'm way too smart to make such an awful

Take that to the bank

Seems like an almost bulletproof plan...HK dies lock clearing you...you run the town so Xalt doesn't get flipped...profit.

He got flipped, therefore I'm not mafia :hattip:

This popcorn thing was a bit of a surprise, eh?

[DaisyCloud]

Players

Apogee
AWESOM-O
beeboy
cayvie
ColinIsCool
colonialbob
DaisyCloud
DDL
DrWilgy
Ephemeral
Epignosis
Hyena
iaafr
iwan
Jackofhearts2005
Justplayingitcool
Logic
Long Con
Maple
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
Poison Chan
PunchyTheCat
sabie12
sheepsaysmeep
Shizune
speedchuck
Sprityo
tedxtr
TenThousandCalories
ThisIsNotAceMarvel
Timsup2nothin
Urist
WerewolfHunter

Dead

Day 1 -
Tonystarkprime - The Embodiment of Champs Hero Syndrome - Town
Trustworthy Liberal - Jinx - Indie
Relm - Chevalier D'Eon - Town
hollowkatt - [Redacted]
Exalt - George A Tsoukalos - Town
Funnygurl555 - [NSM] Mikey - Mafia
motel room - The Shame After Masturbation - Town
Rej - Victor Steinberg - Town
112 - Darth Vader - Town
Adam_ - A Power Rack - Town
Marcher Jovian - [Redacted]
MartinGG99 - That One Roblox Character (oof!) - Town
polypies73 - Wario - Town
Silverkeith - Spanish Nutella - Town
xalt - Katarina - Mafia
Jumpluff - Bun 2 Head reads - Town
Hank - Randy Marsh - Indie
nutella - Tim Hortons - Mafia
Sloonei - Dr. Eggman's Existential Crisis - Town

Thread Summary

Day 1 Begins
ITA Window 1 Opens

okay so my reads were not all complete trash. jumpluff was town, adam, SilverKeith. nuteela was scum. I only had a town lean.

iirc i don't think i made me 2nd vote. I wanted to vote hank but I wanted to go away from the thunderdome as it looked like enough voted there we could get more info if I voted another top wagon. but I doubted my reads.

I think i might die and not make it to day 2.

not sure on the Maple thing now? idk

In my community we sometimes make nite plans because we allow chatting in game during nite phase. . they arr a hot topic debate tho. mafia can use it, go off it. makes potential lots of targets for mafia.

sometimes I make them sometimes I don't. depends on if plsyers do make 1 and if I town or scum read them. also depends on if I'm vt or town pr too. also depends on if I randed mafia.

as a whole I think nite plans r not neccesarily alignment indicative. depends on my reads at eod, end of nite phase and SOD.

it's good to look back on for infos.

having said that idk if I will make one here in this game or if someone already has. this community is different then mine. idk if nite plans is something they do or not, nor what their take away is about them. there is good and bad reasons depending on your side when it comes to forming and sharing a nite plan.

typically if you have alot of new players or randed a unique role or have not played in a long time having one helps. is my thoughts. but it's usually better to not give out the blue prints for mafia to exploit.

[Timsup2nothin]

I mean I'm open to an alternative...someone just explain why a dying wolf HK spends his last hour lock clearing a villager.

[mention]DaisyCloud[/mention] can you take a shot at this?

I'm basically playing to be night killed here so maybe you won't be. But if I am don't let the wolves just bury this question.

[DaisyCloud]

Tonystarkprime - The Embodiment of Champs Hero Syndrome - Town (ITA)
Trustworthy Liberal - Jinx - Indie (SHOT)
Relm - Chevalier D'Eon - Town (SHOT)
hollowkatt - [Redacted] (SHOT)
Exalt - George A Tsoukalos - Town (ITA)
Funnygurl555 - [NSM] Mikey - Mafia (ITA)
motel room - The Shame After Masturbation - Town (ITA)
Rej - Victor Steinberg - Town (ITA)
112 - Darth Vader - Town (Popcorn)
Adam_ - A Power Rack - Town (SHOT)
Marcher Jovian - [Redacted] (SHOT)
MartinGG99 - That One Roblox Character (oof!) - Town (Popcorn)
polypies73 - Wario - Town (Popcorn)
Silverkeith - Spanish Nutella - Town (Popcorn)
xalt - Katarina - Mafia (Popcorn)
Jumpluff - Bun 2 Head reads - Town (Mod-killed at request)
Hank - Randy Marsh - Indie (Lost fight)
nutella - Tim Hortons - Mafia (Eliminated)
Sloonei - Dr. Eggman's Existential Crisis - Town (Eliminated)

I hope this helps.

thank you ♡♡

I remembered how to go to desk top view and made a post. my poor eyes.. it hurts us. so tiny.. i went back to mobile version. im.a slo poke on my phone.

but having this here so I can stay on mobile is very helpful.

[Urist]

I'm way too smart to make such an awful

Take that to the bank

apparently not

[Timsup2nothin]

I'm way too smart to make such an awful

Take that to the bank

apparently not

I think it was a brilliant use of Xalt...if Xalt hadn't flipped in this popcorn madness I think it was a lock win for the wolves.

[Urist]

I'm way too smart to make such an awful

Take that to the bank

apparently not

I think it was a brilliant use of Xalt...if Xalt hadn't flipped in this popcorn madness I think it was a lock win for the wolves.

it was completely transparent... so no

[colonialbob]

Oh my

[MacDougall]

Check out this post as it contains all the flips and a summary of key events of day 1.

[Timsup2nothin]

I'm way too smart to make such an awful

Take that to the bank

apparently not

I think it was a brilliant use of Xalt...if Xalt hadn't flipped in this popcorn madness I think it was a lock win for the wolves.

it was completely transparent... so no

Okay...I grant that you were pushing the "HK was a wolf and this was a setup" theory, but were you really getting any traction?

[Urist]

I'm way too smart to make such an awful

Take that to the bank

apparently not

I think it was a brilliant use of Xalt...if Xalt hadn't flipped in this popcorn madness I think it was a lock win for the wolves.

it was completely transparent... so no

Okay...I grant that you were pushing the "HK was a wolf and this was a setup" theory, but were you really getting any traction?

nanook knew what was up and he's unkillable town so BIG SHRUG

[Timsup2nothin]

I'm way too smart to make such an awful

Take that to the bank

apparently not

I think it was a brilliant use of Xalt...if Xalt hadn't flipped in this popcorn madness I think it was a lock win for the wolves.

it was completely transparent... so no

Okay...I grant that you were pushing the "HK was a wolf and this was a setup" theory, but were you really getting any traction?

nanook knew what was up and he's unkillable town so BIG SHRUG

Well, he's arguing against it now so BIGGER SHRUG