U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

*pool

[Timsup2nothin]

ColinIsCool... you could say that he is just playing it cool

In all seriousness, he seems better than bob but not by too much. I see signs of solving and I feel like they have contributed more than Colonial in terms of content when you consider that they have less posts.

Rabbit sees it the opposite.

They do seem to have not w/w interactions.

One is first tier for the vigs and the other is second.

[Timsup2nothin]

*pool

He can just use the kill list for the vigs maybe?

[Timsup2nothin]

Actually maybe not...if he runs someone against you and they come up green and a vig is killing them at the same time that's not good.

[Timsup2nothin]

We should use him to probe for deep wolf.

[Justplayingitcool]

ColinIsCool... you could say that he is just playing it cool

In all seriousness, he seems better than bob but not by too much. I see signs of solving and I feel like they have contributed more than Colonial in terms of content when you consider that they have less posts.

Rabbit sees it the opposite.

They do seem to have not w/w interactions.

One is first tier for the vigs and the other is second.

Rabbit is wrong, I think. If I had a gun I would shoot bob over Colin

[iaafr]

Actually maybe not...if he runs someone against you and they come up green and a vig is killing them at the same time that's not good.

i mean even if nanook somehow gets implied to not be town we cant mechanically do anything about it rofl

also he just seems town idk

or hes mafia treestump townsiding until lategame...?

but hes probably just town

[Justplayingitcool]

Should be said that Tim is very likely to be town. We know Tim wasn't hit with a PBO because of my role. I do not believe in town silencers because it's an anti-town role.

[Timsup2nothin]

ColinIsCool... you could say that he is just playing it cool

In all seriousness, he seems better than bob but not by too much. I see signs of solving and I feel like they have contributed more than Colonial in terms of content when you consider that they have less posts.

Rabbit sees it the opposite.

They do seem to have not w/w interactions.

One is first tier for the vigs and the other is second.

Rabbit is wrong, I think. If I had a gun I would shoot bob over Colin

K...I read it the same FWIW but now we have this claim from Bob to consider.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

*pool

He can just use the kill list for the vigs maybe?

Naw we need separate pools, don’t want vig shooting into a green check

I’ll put one together tonight, I’m thinking vig the POE and use bob’s thing to look for greens/confirm townreads.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Actually it’ll probably be tomorrow morning, it’s 4am kek

[DaisyCloud]

are the low posters not posting because we are just talk about them in circles and creating this narrative that what we say goes and so they don't want to enter because 1 they gotta play catch up so already stressed and 2 feel that something they say will get attacked?

cause it's bugging me :/

I want them to talk.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

We should use him to probe for deep wolf.

Yeh exactly, we’ll use bob’s thing to check our non-mech clears, use vig/s to clear POE.

[Timsup2nothin]

Actually maybe not...if he runs someone against you and they come up green and a vig is killing them at the same time that's not good.

i mean even if nanook somehow gets implied to not be town we cant mechanically do anything about it rofl

also he just seems town idk

or hes mafia treestump townsiding until lategame...?

but hes probably just town

I agree...what I mean is if we give Bob the same list and he runs say Colin against Nanook and gets back "same team no kill" on the same night that one of our vigs looks at the list and says "huh, okay, kill Colin"...

[Justplayingitcool]

are the low posters not posting because we are just talk about them in circles and creating this narrative that what we say goes and so they don't want to enter because 1 they gotta play catch up so already stressed and 2 feel that something they say will get attacked?

cause it's bugging me :/

I want them to talk.

Hello.... jpic is here

AMA

[Timsup2nothin]

We should use him to probe for deep wolf.

Yeh exactly, we’ll use bob’s thing to check our non-mech clears, use vig/s to clear POE.

Rabbit, JPIC, Long Con

Top of my head I'm interested in those.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

We should use him to probe for deep wolf.

Yeh exactly, we’ll use bob’s thing to check our non-mech clears, use vig/s to clear POE.

Rabbit, JPIC, Long Con

Top of my head I'm interested in those.

Yeah top of my head pool is something like rabbit/jpic/cayvie/you, I think. Having any of those four hard confirmed would be awesome.

[iaafr]

im still a bit sus of long con i just keep forgetting he exists

[Timsup2nothin]

SHOOTING LIST IS:

Beeboy
DrWigly
Colin
Iwan

DO NOT SHOOT OFF THE LIST

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Idk I have to actually get some sleep now, we’ll hammer it out tomorrow morning/afternoon

[Timsup2nothin]

We should use him to probe for deep wolf.

Yeh exactly, we’ll use bob’s thing to check our non-mech clears, use vig/s to clear POE.

Rabbit, JPIC, Long Con

Top of my head I'm interested in those.

Yeah top of my head pool is something like rabbit/jpic/cayvie/you, I think. Having any of those four hard confirmed would be awesome.

I plan on JPIC locking me down for the night so that may not work on me...I'm game but I am pretty sure that the same wolves that silenced me will probably kill me given the chance.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

That’s fair re: LC, but I think more value in confirming in the tim/rabbit/cayvie/JPIC group first. If we get past that we can start working on people like LC, WWH, etc.

Maybe not WWH since apparently they’re gonna die D3, but you get my drift.



Oh and btw [mention]cayvie[/mention] do you still have at least one shot left? Don’t claim how many, just 1+ or none. This plan requires vigs to actually be able to shoot people kek

[Timsup2nothin]

im still a bit sus of long con i just keep forgetting he exists

I threw him in there but he'd probably not be great choice since not real active.

[DaisyCloud]

are the low posters not posting because we are just talk about them in circles and creating this narrative that what we say goes and so they don't want to enter because 1 they gotta play catch up so already stressed and 2 feel that something they say will get attacked?

cause it's bugging me :/

I want them to talk.

Hello.... jpic is here

AMA

I know been reading what you been posting.

I am a little lost/confused but I think I have you sorted. so yay, right??


I can't think of anything specific to ask you.

wait

what ar your thoughts/reads on maple? luffy? long con? punchy? sabie?

be nice if you could include specific posts too.

seems like most like to just give summaries of things from reading isos and nothing to bsck up their take aways.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

We should use him to probe for deep wolf.

Yeh exactly, we’ll use bob’s thing to check our non-mech clears, use vig/s to clear POE.

Rabbit, JPIC, Long Con

Top of my head I'm interested in those.

Yeah top of my head pool is something like rabbit/jpic/cayvie/you, I think. Having any of those four hard confirmed would be awesome.

I plan on JPIC locking me down for the night so that may not work on me...I'm game but I am pretty sure that the same wolves that silenced me will probably kill me given the chance.

If the silence worked but the check doesn’t it’s a weird JK right?

Tbh I’m not used to JK that aren’t a role blocker/stopper combo, but as I found out last game apparently the default JK is roleblocker/doctor and looks like that’s what we have in this game, so. Yeah. Check should work on you I think?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Ok now I’m actually going to bed lol

[Justplayingitcool]

Nah, checking Tim would work still. If I jail Tim, I roleblock him and protect him for the night

[Timsup2nothin]

We should use him to probe for deep wolf.

Yeh exactly, we’ll use bob’s thing to check our non-mech clears, use vig/s to clear POE.

Rabbit, JPIC, Long Con

Top of my head I'm interested in those.

Yeah top of my head pool is something like rabbit/jpic/cayvie/you, I think. Having any of those four hard confirmed would be awesome.

I plan on JPIC locking me down for the night so that may not work on me...I'm game but I am pretty sure that the same wolves that silenced me will probably kill me given the chance.

If the silence worked but the check doesn’t it’s a weird JK right?

Tbh I’m not used to JK that aren’t a role blocker/stopper combo, but as I found out last game apparently the default JK is roleblocker/doctor and looks like that’s what we have in this game, so. Yeah. Check should work on you I think?

Not if it is a killing check? Like if I live am I the same as you so Bob couldn't kill me or did JPIC just keep me alive? I dunno.

[DaisyCloud]

I've seen in games a jailor who: can kill their prisoner, talk to them, will die if they don't kill the prisoner should they imprison a serial killer, is just a roleblocker and can't also protect, can role block and protect, will be the one who dies instead, can leave a death note. there is so many combos and variants of this stuff

[Timsup2nothin]

JPIC you need to be thunder in the thread here. As people wake up and check in bring them up to date. Show them that vig shot list and get their opinions. See if any of them have a solid clear on one of those people. Work them through the case on Maple.

Make yourself useful

See you tomorrow.

[Timsup2nothin]

I've seen in games a jailor who: can kill their prisoner, talk to them, will die if they don't kill the prisoner should they imprison a serial killer, is just a roleblocker and can't also protect, can role block and protect, will be the one who dies instead, can leave a death note. there is so many combos and variants of this stuff

And Mac just made a lot of shit up as he went along, so here we are.

Keep JPIC on the path yeah? I gotta sleep.

[DaisyCloud]

I can't go 24hrs with no sleep

[DaisyCloud]

if i gave boss ideas then much love and hope he uses them well ♡♡

[DaisyCloud]

[mention]Justplayingitcool[/mention] I'm debating looking into those people i asked you about again for like the milliionth time if you don't or just sleep.

will you at least look into one or 2? and if so tell me who?

[Justplayingitcool]

@Justplayingitcool I'm debating looking into those people i asked you about again for like the milliionth time if you don't or just sleep.

will you at least look into one or 2? and if so tell me who?

fear not, I am writing a post now with thoughts

[Justplayingitcool]

are the low posters not posting because we are just talk about them in circles and creating this narrative that what we say goes and so they don't want to enter because 1 they gotta play catch up so already stressed and 2 feel that something they say will get attacked?

cause it's bugging me :/

I want them to talk.

Hello.... jpic is here

AMA

I know been reading what you been posting.

I am a little lost/confused but I think I have you sorted. so yay, right??


I can't think of anything specific to ask you.

wait

what ar your thoughts/reads on maple? luffy? long con? punchy? sabie?

be nice if you could include specific posts too.

seems like most like to just give summaries of things from reading isos and nothing to bsck up their take aways.

maple's iso was too long. But, I don't believe that they are w/w with colonialbob unless maple is hellbussing. Specifically, this post made me think this is not a w/w interaction. I do think there is exactly one wolf between one of the two.

Spoiler: show

(Aka if I become the next in line to be shot at I would at least appreciate the chance to claim)

Do not throw the ITA into chaos...if you got it, spill it

Sorry was legit trying to avoid the chaos. Failed. Not used to ITAs, clearly.

I'm a town backup, I grabbed Rej's role and targeted tedxtr and awesom-o last night. Figured somebody had to be around to use Xalts shot

Didn't want my claim getting lost in the hubbub since maf will have a list somewhere anyway. My sweet claim went away when cayvie called the shot on tedxtr, and tbh I don't really want to counterclaim the vig which is why I stayed quiet

Interesting

Were you looking for a green check on ted?

No, I figured they were likely w/v and while ted was the more likely choice for wolf I could also see a world in which awesom-o shoots fellow mafioso for cred knowing there's no way xalt lives at that point (iirc).

The claim in question is in this chain. No way is this real. The guy has been softing a easily confirmable role this entire time. He is claiming that he doublestacked with the other vigi, who had claimed at sod

sabie was a meh start. Too many jokey responses but then got better as the game progressed. Null to a slight townlean

Punchy sounds townish. Not afraid to get reads out there. Only read the first page but feel pretty confident that he's town from that alone.

Luffy soft defended me after shooting Tony iirc, so could be pocketing but I don't think scum would bother helping or getting involved there unless they wanted to get free towncred when I inevitably flip town. On another note, unless I am blind I do not see him in the active player list???

Not too much there with Long Con, but I do like that they attempted to shoot Nanook for the stump claim. If it wasn't for that I would think scum.

[Justplayingitcool]

Nevermind, luffy has been shorterned to DDL

[Justplayingitcool]

Why does ted have 5 votes

Does a wolf openly say this to their partner?

[Justplayingitcool]

Random thoughts
Jumpluff seems townie getting the conversation going hunting with the power of buns
Daisy seems genuine and killed FG so that's a plus.
Maple I guess was checked didn't know day cop was a thing but this game does whatever it wants it is its own entity.
Nanook I guess is the unkillable stump or something and bffs!
Werewolf is roleplaying the ice cream thing and I find it amusing.
Didn't have an opinion on cayvie but I would think if they had teammates they would have discussed the box thing with them? I don't know weird.

It felt like you took a textbook tell and applied it wrongly (without reading in context), thus, making up reads.

it's like you take a cylinder puzzle piece and trying to fit it in a square one

Right, so why is having a wrong/bad read scummy? You've not really explained why this is making up reads.

you've mistaken my posts intention at an attempt to push me - I've basically elaborated on why you interpreted it the wrong way and you shrugged it off

It's hard for me to see how you, as a villager, would interpret my post the way you did.

I'm engaging with you now so it's hardly shrugging it off. If you're a villager you're gonna be in a world of shock when I flip town.

you're only engaging when tim started pushing the gas pedal on me and it doesn't feel like you're even reaching a point

I think my push on you has made me conclude that you are town.

So... anyone else want to shade me as scum after calling out ted within my first few posts?

After all your discussions with ted you said he was town.

This sounds pretty townish

[Justplayingitcool]

Unless I am mistaken I don't recall anybody defending maple at all in the thread. Not even once?

idk, where are the wolves trying to save him? (don't say me because I am town)

[Justplayingitcool]

What does everyone think of Jack and Urists' redacted flip, town or wolf?

[iaafr]

both felt like town

[iaafr]

checked in randomly to say i still dont trust wwh myself despite the xalt shot cred

and i will fully admit its gotta be partly omgus but her presence just feels differnet to me this time

and a lot of people have been saying this about me but lol idk

fresh wwh takes appreciated

[iaafr]

[mention]Justplayingitcool[/mention] do you understand the situation with bob's claim and role?

he's claiming that he backed up rej's role, where he sends in 2 people, if theyre the same they live, if theyre different they die

so he can use it for 1:1 town:nontown trades

we were going to test people against nanook who can't die so he's just a vig who hits only nontown

[Justplayingitcool]

@Justplayingitcool do you understand the situation with bob's claim and role?

he's claiming that he backed up rej's role, where he sends in 2 people, if theyre the same they live, if theyre different they die

so he can use it for 1:1 town:nontown trades

we were going to test people against nanook who can't die so he's just a vig who hits only nontown

Alright, I formally request that Bob tests me

[Justplayingitcool]

who did bob target n1? I suppose that role does sound pretty creative for it to be faked

[Justplayingitcool]

both felt like town

Do we think wolves killed them for their godly reads?

[iaafr]

who did bob target n1? I suppose that role does sound pretty creative for it to be faked

well he didnt have to fake it he's claiming back up who backed it up

rej flipped it

he targeted tedxtr / awesome and it killed awesome

who seemed rly clear from the popcorn event

and thats also part of why ppl are sussing him, because he killed awesome, and cayvie's claiming the tedxtr kill too

[iaafr]

still testable claim tho to an extent

big fear is that if hes not this at all and its completely fakeclaim and he's wolf kp but idk

[Justplayingitcool]

who did bob target n1? I suppose that role does sound pretty creative for it to be faked

well he didnt have to fake it he's claiming back up who backed it up

rej flipped it

he targeted tedxtr / awesome and it killed awesome

who seemed rly clear from the popcorn event

and thats also part of why ppl are sussing him, because he killed awesome, and cayvie's claiming the tedxtr kill too

Hmm, alright. Probably makes sense to leave both cayvie and Bob alone this phase and let them self-resolve. I'm inclined to believe they both are telling the truth there because if they lied they would know it would get counterclaimed