The Witcher Mafia [Game Over]

[RondoDimBuckle]

Wait a sec but why would someone shoot axe regardless of alignment and poison

yeah especially when (AFAIK) he was read mostly towny

[sig]

Man cmon jpic u finna make us google the lore? Aint gonna give us role flips? Smh

I can tell you show/video game lore.

Witches are (generally) good, the empire uses the church in game to kill/take over including burning at stake. Basically standard fantasy fare.

Based off the info we have is why I'm thinking mafia/3rd party. But, if someone with more lore knowledge wants to weight in that would be great.

My tin foil theory is Epi is mafia and day vigged Axe.

But why mafia vig NAA over the IC? I guess soup kill? Ok bet

But still doe. NAA was barely postin, he wasnt towncore or nothing

I still think he died to his own role to vig Epi tonight. Either that or Epi vigged him regardless of Epis alignment. Iono lmao

Even ignoring soup a claimed town this point in the game isn't the end of the world especially if his reads are all wrong. In fact I'd keep them around.

I don't think the write up would be burned at the stake for that type of thing.

Also could be a preemptive strike idk.

[tutuu]

whatever is a bog?

Swamp

[sig]

Or he was right about mafia members to they knocked him out. If I'm alive tomorrow I'll read him over and see.

[Poison]

Man cmon jpic u finna make us google the lore? Aint gonna give us role flips? Smh

I can tell you show/video game lore.

Witches are (generally) good, the empire uses the church in game to kill/take over including burning at stake. Basically standard fantasy fare.

Based off the info we have is why I'm thinking mafia/3rd party. But, if someone with more lore knowledge wants to weight in that would be great.

My tin foil theory is Epi is mafia and day vigged Axe.

Waiit i read this again

Ok so NAA was a witch

He got burned at a stake

So like ... The death message was specific for him?

Maybe theres evil 3p in the game thats job is to kill witches, like submit a shot every day on someone they think is a witch and kill their ass?

Or maybe thay burn at stake thing was a flavor and NAA jist got anti claimed killed by claiming vig

Bruh

As a former 3p of Radiohead mafia I think tutuu has a good point.

[KZA]

Does anyone that knows creature really think he would rwstfo? That kid top posts as a wolf. I dont really get the suspicion on the slot

nobody should be making reads like this imo

are you directly suspicious of me or you think the logic is flawed?

I think you should read Dya by their own posts, not read Dya based on what Creature did (which was nothing)

[RondoDimBuckle]

MacDougall
RondoDimBuckle
EnderWiggin
Urist
tedxtr
Scotty
KZA
TonyStarkPrime

112
Michelle
Epignosis
DrWilgy

Master Radishes
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
sig
Made
Poison
falcon45ca
Ruri
DkKoba
Syn

NotAnAxehole
Creature

I dont agree with Urist, KZA (But mac says they are town so whatever), TSP,

can I get you to tell me some more about that

I townread urists scumread on uhhh. It was me + someone else. Yesterday. Rondo? Ender? Idr

I townread kzas highposting and her seeming interest to guide the game to be more serious

I townread tsp's lack of posting due to his meta

that seems fine to me, any changes now axe has been murdered?

[Poison]

Or he was right about mafia members to they knocked him out. If I'm alive tomorrow I'll read him over and see.

But no one was listening to him why would scum do that?

[tutuu]

Naw

[RondoDimBuckle]

I've got two working theories on Axe.

There vote was of course on Tuutuu, so I'd say it isn't vote related directly.

If we jump into lore/flavor side the church isn't ever good to my limited knowledge on the series. So that points to a mafia/Indy kill.

I'd say we need to wait to see what other kill powers are used to see, but I'd say it's like 65/35 mafia to civ.

The other theory is that I know exactly who did it and its NAI

there are plenty of people the mafia would've shot at before Axe imo, highly doubt it was them

this

[KZA]

I see we're in the part where a bunch of baseless mech speculation we can't prove right now happens

[DrWilgy]

I guess here's the thing.

Both Sig and Scotty felt like counter-wagons to Syn that formed.

Yes there would be town in them, but scum forming hard counter wagons makes the most sense if it is Syn.

[RondoDimBuckle]

Ooooh wait NAA said he will vig epi

So i think that means NAA role required him to die so he kill epi tonight maybe

ok that is an interesting take on things. OR wolf cover for a kill that will happen on epi later tonight. OR I am paranoid

[tutuu]

I guess here's the thing.

Both Sig and Scotty felt like counter-wagons to Syn that formed.

Yes there would be town in them, but scum forming hard counter wagons makes the most sense if it is Syn.

K bet

[VOTE: syn] aubergine

[Poison]

I see we're in the part where a bunch of baseless mech speculation we can't prove right now happens

Exactly I'm not going to bed late for this

[RondoDimBuckle]

hi guys. I've read literally none of the game. Can someone catch me up a bit?

things happened. You low posted and now you are mafia.

creature highposts as mafia regularly though

you get why that's a terrible read right?

I mean I was just meming but I do think this slot is mafia

[DrWilgy]

Like I want to yeet Sig d1 as much as the next guy (love you buddy), but it feels like idk where this wagon came from.

Perhaps I'm rambling. Oh well. Locked in Syn. Gotta drive to Austin now. Gl ppl.

[tedxtr]

i don't pride myself on d1 dya

but michelle and poison (from the people i at least have an idea how to read) seem villagery to me

i had a yolo 112 v read but ~could be wrong

i think syn is wolfy as per the he isn't solving stuff method of reading him, i cased scotty but have no experience with him and tutuu is being a bit weird but idk what that means yet, i have it noted down tho

[dyachei]

hi guys. I've read literally none of the game. Can someone catch me up a bit?

things happened. You low posted and now you are mafia.

creature highposts as mafia regularly though

you get why that's a terrible read right?

I mean I was just meming but I do think this slot is mafia

is it because I called you mafia?

it's ok if it is. you can tell me

[falcon45ca]

@NotAnAxehole has been burnt at the stake.

Spoiler: show

They were Keira Metz: Glamorous Sorceress Living in a Bog

Rip,

now we gotta figure out if civ, mafia, or 3rd party.

What?

I'm big into advocating for analyzing actions used. Especially any type of kill or silencing/post restrictions. It gives alot of useful information to the town. So it's worth discussing on what faction we think Axed Axe, why they might've done it, ect

What?

[RondoDimBuckle]

Does anyone that knows creature really think he would rwstfo? That kid top posts as a wolf. I dont really get the suspicion on the slot

Hmmmmm

how do you feel about the NAA Epi situation that just happend?

Spoiler: show

Prediciton: Fuck

[tutuu]

i don't pride myself on d1 dya

but michelle and poison (from the people i at least have an idea how to read) seem villagery to me

i had a yolo 112 v read but ~could be wrong

i think syn is wolfy as per the he isn't solving stuff method of reading him, i cased scotty but have no experience with him and tutuu is being a bit weird but idk what that means yet, i have it noted down tho

When was i not weird famlam

[dyachei]

i don't pride myself on d1 dya

but michelle and poison (from the people i at least have an idea how to read) seem villagery to me

i had a yolo 112 v read but ~could be wrong

i think syn is wolfy as per the he isn't solving stuff method of reading him, i cased scotty but have no experience with him and tutuu is being a bit weird but idk what that means yet, i have it noted down tho

whats your case on scotty?

I don't expect like miracles on d1 but I'm trying to get into the game and I need a little help because I'm not reading 2k posts in a few hours

[tedxtr]

i don't think rondo is a wolf, also

he seems to be an IRL mafia player and only had ~3 games on forum if ender is correct

[KZA]

i don't pride myself on d1 dya

but michelle and poison (from the people i at least have an idea how to read) seem villagery to me

i had a yolo 112 v read but ~could be wrong

i think syn is wolfy as per the he isn't solving stuff method of reading him, i cased scotty but have no experience with him and tutuu is being a bit weird but idk what that means yet, i have it noted down tho

112 is a potential deep wolf to worry about later imo

[Poison]

I guess here's the thing.

Both Sig and Scotty felt like counter-wagons to Syn that formed.

Yes there would be town in them, but scum forming hard counter wagons makes the most sense if it is Syn.

Honestly I think there can be at least one town in there which is probably not syn, but I haven't read the other two properly yet

[RondoDimBuckle]

I've got two working theories on Axe.

There vote was of course on Tuutuu, so I'd say it isn't vote related directly.

If we jump into lore/flavor side the church isn't ever good to my limited knowledge on the series. So that points to a mafia/Indy kill.

I'd say we need to wait to see what other kill powers are used to see, but I'd say it's like 65/35 mafia to civ.

The other theory is that I know exactly who did it and its NAI

you seem to be very interested in it, more than anything in the thread so far?

Yea since it doesn't require me to slog through like 40 pages of one line random fluff nonsense.

So tell me this, are you planning to solve or look solvy?
If you plan the former you have to go through the 40 pages and actually assign name and collect proof for the faction you are deducing.

But your action seems to point at the other options imo.

lol

[TonyStarkPrime]

@MacDougall stop voting for sig

[dyachei]

i don't think rondo is a wolf, also

he seems to be an IRL mafia player and only had ~3 games on forum if ender is correct

I really didn't like his interactions w/ mac. felt like he wasn't doing much and his suspicion was like level 0

[TonyStarkPrime]

Do we know what happened to NAA

[RondoDimBuckle]

Man cmon jpic u finna make us google the lore? Aint gonna give us role flips? Smh

I can tell you show/video game lore.

Witches are (generally) good, the empire uses the church in game to kill/take over including burning at stake. Basically standard fantasy fare.

Based off the info we have is why I'm thinking mafia/3rd party. But, if someone with more lore knowledge wants to weight in that would be great.

My tin foil theory is Epi is mafia and day vigged Axe.

why epi?

come on, the timing of everything and that smug reaction gif. You gotta be blind or partnered with epi to not see that

[TonyStarkPrime]

Is Dya a wolf?

[tedxtr]

i wasn't even talking about that interaction

around this part

I understand [VOTE: Made] aubergine gets voted out of the tribe a lot early, and I can see why.

What’s the hit rate like? Has he been mafia a lot recently?

What can u see? (Bolded)

Afaik the hit rate is low but im not certain

The proof is in the pudding- he’s scummy looking on D1.

But actually tho, if he usually a candidate for a D1 lynch, what better way to build up meta so the town in future games will turn a blind eye?

my chain of posts after this post is the case

there's a spoiler with his entire progression on tutuu after this post, you'll know when the posts towards him stop

[dyachei]

Man cmon jpic u finna make us google the lore? Aint gonna give us role flips? Smh

I can tell you show/video game lore.

Witches are (generally) good, the empire uses the church in game to kill/take over including burning at stake. Basically standard fantasy fare.

Based off the info we have is why I'm thinking mafia/3rd party. But, if someone with more lore knowledge wants to weight in that would be great.

My tin foil theory is Epi is mafia and day vigged Axe.

why epi?

come on, the timing of everything and that smug reaction gif. You gotta be blind or partnered with epi to not see that

I want his answer, thanks very much. I don't think epi gains by being that obvious. so I want to know why anyone would think epi would be that obvious

get your head out of your tunnel and think about the game

[dyachei]

Is Dya a wolf?

no. I randed village

[Scotty]

what post did you vote her for? why did she seem suspicious?

and while you’re at it, if you can quote where you’ve already answered me why you voted for her, that’d be great, since i don’t remember you ever saying why beyond “i just felt like it”

You’re pissing me off

“I just felt like it” WAS THE ANSWER AND THE POINT I WAS MAKING BECAUSE IT LACKS ANY MORE THAN THAT

To be fair to scotty, half of the time I vote people its literally just this

If we were in day 3 with flips and voting analyses, then I would also view this as suspect.

This felt like I was being interrogated because my socks didn’t match. But I guess wtf else are you gonna look for in day 1 besides surface level feels?

[KZA]

fuck idk what to do

I'm gonna go make breakfast then come back for a sloppy EOD

[RondoDimBuckle]

Does anyone that knows creature really think he would rwstfo? That kid top posts as a wolf. I dont really get the suspicion on the slot

Iuhhhh like your funny words magic man

what does this even mean?

I dont understand your acronyms

[RondoDimBuckle]

Does anyone that knows creature really think he would rwstfo? That kid top posts as a wolf. I dont really get the suspicion on the slot

nobody should be making reads like this imo

are you directly suspicious of me or you think the logic is flawed?

I mean, I'm directly suspicious of you but it's based on your interactions with mac

well thats unfortunate

[Scotty]

@NotAnAxehole has been burnt at the stake.

Spoiler: show

They were Keira Metz: Glamorous Sorceress Living in a Bog

What the fuck

[Poison]

Is Dya a wolf?

Are you?

[dyachei]

Does anyone that knows creature really think he would rwstfo? That kid top posts as a wolf. I dont really get the suspicion on the slot

Iuhhhh like your funny words magic man

what does this even mean?

I dont understand your acronyms

rwstfo = rand wolf sub the fuck out

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Does anyone that knows creature really think he would rwstfo? That kid top posts as a wolf. I dont really get the suspicion on the slot

Hmmmmm

how do you feel about the NAA Epi situation that just happend?

Spoiler: show

Prediciton: Fuck

Naa: fuck

Epi: hmmmm

[tutuu]

fuck idk what to do

I'm gonna go make breakfast then come back for a sloppy EOD

U been making posts like this for the second half of the day. Maybe i shouldnt townread u

[RondoDimBuckle]

Does anyone that knows creature really think he would rwstfo? That kid top posts as a wolf. I dont really get the suspicion on the slot

nobody should be making reads like this imo

are you directly suspicious of me or you think the logic is flawed?

I think you should read Dya by their own posts, not read Dya based on what Creature did (which was nothing)

You're not wrong. But how am I supposed to get a read if I dont poke them?

[Scotty]

This reads as either you vigging him or he vigging you, and it backfiring.

Either way, hard to read your alignment on this, besides how smug you’re coming off from witnessing a town die

[tedxtr]

i guess i could be wrong, apparently people now vote people for something that they are pinged by yet they can't explain what pinged them at all / act like they didn't have to be pinged to vote them

beats me

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Is Dya a wolf?

Mm

[RondoDimBuckle]

hi guys. I've read literally none of the game. Can someone catch me up a bit?

things happened. You low posted and now you are mafia.

creature highposts as mafia regularly though

you get why that's a terrible read right?

I mean I was just meming but I do think this slot is mafia

is it because I called you mafia?

it's ok if it is. you can tell me

nah its because I hate 0 posters

[dyachei]

hi guys. I've read literally none of the game. Can someone catch me up a bit?

things happened. You low posted and now you are mafia.

creature highposts as mafia regularly though

you get why that's a terrible read right?

I mean I was just meming but I do think this slot is mafia

is it because I called you mafia?

it's ok if it is. you can tell me

nah its because I hate 0 posters

but I'm not a 0 poster anymore