falcon45ca wrote: ↑Tue Dec 28, 2021 7:05 pm
Gav has talked about the doc save preventing the Maf kill, and asked Marmot why he's voting me when I claimed to have saved Marmot.
Even though I said I lied about it.
So basically if I understand this correctly your theory is that Gav attacked Marmot and received the name of the Doctor because of it.
Gav then was confused why you were claiming Doctor to have saved Marmot and accidentally TMI'd that he didn't believe you because he knew it was fake.
falcon45ca wrote: ↑Tue Dec 28, 2021 7:05 pm
Gav has talked about the doc save preventing the Maf kill, and asked Marmot why he's voting me when I claimed to have saved Marmot.
Even though I said I lied about it.
So basically if I understand this correctly your theory is that Gav attacked Marmot and received the name of the Doctor because of it.
Gav then was confused why you were claiming Doctor to have saved Marmot and accidentally TMI'd that he didn't believe you because he knew it was fake.
I mean it would make sense to have Gav preform the kill. Since he claimed Sniper D2 and had 2 votes nobody really had a reason to roleblock him since he couldn't kill with his role anyways.
The only thing is Gav seems rather natural. His D1 read for Sabie was null reading her to then town reading her saying that her and TSP were both Town.
Only to now turn around and say that TSP has to be Mafia with Sabie.
I may be getting a bit hung up here, but I don't really see Gav!Mafia just null reading an ally and then later Town reading them without much comment and their change in read on TSP seems to be Town motivated as well.
From what people have said about how Gav plays that just seems way too passive with Gav and I don't think he would be able to resist giving reads on his allies.
Dolby wrote: ↑Mon Dec 27, 2021 10:16 pm
I still think it's more likely that Marmot was doc saved successfully than scum kill was roleblocked, but also, Nanook was even worse looking on the CFD than NAA imo and should probably just go
I’m honestly not entirely sure what happened tbh.
this is straight up a scum claim
I’m pretty sure if I said “it was for sure the roleblock!” That would be a straight up “TMI” eh?
Maybe a “Scum Claim”.
You can call me a wolf but don’t make up lies.
K thanks.
Gavial wrote: ↑Mon Dec 27, 2021 10:26 pm
I’m town. I don’t know why there was no kill last night as there are many ways of which it could be.
Roleblock, Doctor or some other method probable.
I’m curious who Sig medic’ed.
This is basically the extent of Gav talking about it.
Dolby wrote: ↑Mon Dec 27, 2021 10:16 pm
I still think it's more likely that Marmot was doc saved successfully than scum kill was roleblocked, but also, Nanook was even worse looking on the CFD than NAA imo and should probably just go
I’m honestly not entirely sure what happened tbh.
this is straight up a scum claim
I’m pretty sure if I said “it was for sure the roleblock!” That would be a straight up “TMI” eh?
Maybe a “Scum Claim”.
You can call me a wolf but don’t make up lies.
K thanks.
Gavial wrote: ↑Mon Dec 27, 2021 10:26 pm
I’m town. I don’t know why there was no kill last night as there are many ways of which it could be.
Roleblock, Doctor or some other method probable.
I’m curious who Sig medic’ed.
This is basically the extent of Gav talking about it.
Hmmm, OK.
I talked to Dolby about that post, and I don't feel he ever answered to my satisfaction.
Why does he think Marmot was doc saved? Why not Mac's self save, or another player getting saved or Maf RB all together?
Dolby wrote: ↑Tue Dec 28, 2021 2:10 am
Anyone in that tier I don't feel like I have a confident read on socially
That said given two medic claims Sig/Falcon probably aren't w/w since there's a greater than 50% chance they stopped a kill imo
I honestly just wanna know whom @sig protected.
I don't think that that is neccessary
Like, yes it's great if they got a correct protect, but if they claim, mafia knows whether or not they can target Marmot tonight. I personally think that it's just likeliest that Marmot or Mac were targetted and knowing another protection probably wouldn't help
Yes but my theory is Marmot/Falcon/TSP wolf team.
Meaning if that is the case. (I as I said before can be wrong about that hunch but still) Falcon’s protect us Fake and Sig has the real clear.
Was this before or after Faclon said it was fake?
Because actually if this was before Falcon said he lied about the heal then that might actualyl be TMI.
Dolby wrote: ↑Tue Dec 28, 2021 2:10 am
Anyone in that tier I don't feel like I have a confident read on socially
That said given two medic claims Sig/Falcon probably aren't w/w since there's a greater than 50% chance they stopped a kill imo
I honestly just wanna know whom @sig protected.
I don't think that that is neccessary
Like, yes it's great if they got a correct protect, but if they claim, mafia knows whether or not they can target Marmot tonight. I personally think that it's just likeliest that Marmot or Mac were targetted and knowing another protection probably wouldn't help
Yes but my theory is Marmot/Falcon/TSP wolf team.
Meaning if that is the case. (I as I said before can be wrong about that hunch but still) Falcon’s protect us Fake and Sig has the real clear.
Is this not just tmi that the kill wasn't block and it hit a protect?
Dolby wrote: ↑Tue Dec 28, 2021 2:10 am
Anyone in that tier I don't feel like I have a confident read on socially
That said given two medic claims Sig/Falcon probably aren't w/w since there's a greater than 50% chance they stopped a kill imo
I honestly just wanna know whom @sig protected.
I don't think that that is neccessary
Like, yes it's great if they got a correct protect, but if they claim, mafia knows whether or not they can target Marmot tonight. I personally think that it's just likeliest that Marmot or Mac were targetted and knowing another protection probably wouldn't help
Yes but my theory is Marmot/Falcon/TSP wolf team.
Meaning if that is the case. (I as I said before can be wrong about that hunch but still) Falcon’s protect us Fake and Sig has the real clear.
Was this before or after Faclon said it was fake?
Because actually if this was before Falcon said he lied about the heal then that might actualyl be TMI.
Like it seems really fucking weird to randomly sayd Falcon is lying about being a Doctor.
That seems like Mafia has a Doctor and knows Sig stopped the heal so Falcon can't be real.
But like why does Gav go with Nanook and not Falcon if he is Mafia?
If Gav thought the heal was fake and hte kill wasn't roleblocked why ever vote Nanook?
LinearPoint wrote: ↑Tue Dec 28, 2021 7:39 pm
While I'm tempted to go with a Gav CFD, no one's online so like that'll never happen.
Also still traumatized by the last CFD.
LinearPoint wrote: ↑Tue Dec 28, 2021 7:39 pm
While I'm tempted to go with a Gav CFD, no one's online so like that'll never happen.
Also still traumatized by the last CFD.
LinearPoint wrote: ↑Tue Dec 28, 2021 7:39 pm
While I'm tempted to go with a Gav CFD, no one's online so like that'll never happen.
Also still traumatized by the last CFD.
if its town then im kinda not looking forward to it as I prob have to re-eval most people on it (i.e. effort)
if its mafia then I think less so but prob scan for any immediate signs of bussing, and if nanooks dead mafia that just leaves 2 maf and I could imagine they're anywhere
MartinGG99 wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 12:40 am
The only notable "solving" I've done publicly has managed to kill someone who had the same power role and alignment as me.
If that doesn't make a mockery of my confidence in my solving then I don't know what will.
Town Wins (on TS) Mafia Wins (on TS)
None lol Other/3P Wins (on TS)
None lol Hosted Games (on TS) Neat Quote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote: ↑Fri Jul 23, 2021 12:54 pm
Competition is only impressive when it is kind.
MartinGG99 wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 12:40 am
The only notable "solving" I've done publicly has managed to kill someone who had the same power role and alignment as me.
If that doesn't make a mockery of my confidence in my solving then I don't know what will.
Town Wins (on TS) Mafia Wins (on TS)
None lol Other/3P Wins (on TS)
None lol Hosted Games (on TS) Neat Quote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote: ↑Fri Jul 23, 2021 12:54 pm
Competition is only impressive when it is kind.
I mean to be honest Jack probably was going to be lynch if I didn't campaign for a Nanook lynch.
Boy will I feel dumb when Nanook flips Town and Jack is Mafia who survived to MyLo.
LinearPoint wrote: ↑Tue Dec 28, 2021 7:44 pm
I mean to be honest Jack probably was going to be lynch if I didn't campaign for a Nanook lynch.
Boy will I feel dumb when Nanook flips Town and Jack is Mafia who survived to MyLo.
So, we've tried to locate the Spy but we couldn't. He's good at not being found. Yeah, that's kind of his job. We did find the Medic but he is busy performing a surgery and asked us to come back later.
The Soldier was hiding in a trench that he built in his own backyard, but he came out when I yelled "Communists!". He will now explain what is... uh... in his mind.
(RIP Rick May, voice actor of the Soldier, and many other famous characters.
We have found the Spy. Oh wait, sorry, the Spy has allowed himself to be found. (please keep that knife away from my neck, Mr. Spy).
His name is unknown (like a good spy), but we know he is from France (Not british? How original!). And huh... I guess I'll let him talk about the rest.
We had two deaths today (finally!). Mr. Gavial and Mr. Jack.
