Secret Playerlist - ENDGAME

[Jackofhearts2005]

Compare and contrast. Porscha and Falcon both don't "get" my strong townread on Wilgy. Falcon votes for me.

[VOTE: DrWilgy] aubergine

Wilgy is town if he's in the game to begin with. I'd bet my wincon on it.

[VOTE: DrWilgy] aubergine

Wilgy is town if he's in the game to begin with. I'd bet my wincon on it.

What?


[VOTE: Jackofhearts2005] aubergine

Ya'll horses look real thirsty so follow me.

[Michelle]

Jack is that a complicated way to say Nut can go either way and you will not be surprised to see her flipping red?

[falcon45ca]

Compare and contrast. Porscha and Falcon both don't "get" my strong townread on Wilgy. Falcon votes for me.

[VOTE: DrWilgy] aubergine

Wilgy is town if he's in the game to begin with. I'd bet my wincon on it.

[VOTE: DrWilgy] aubergine

Wilgy is town if he's in the game to begin with. I'd bet my wincon on it.

What?


[VOTE: Jackofhearts2005] aubergine

Ya'll horses look real thirsty so follow me.

I don't know what a horse is, I pilot a motor carriage

[Inawordyes]

Wilgy, you got majorly pushed as a wagon, survived an ensuing tie because NPCs, and then it seems like most of the sus on you has disappeared since to where you still have dissenters but nobody is really pushing to vote you out

Do you think your wagon that day was scum-led or at least scum-motivated?

No one expressed any REAL read on me though. I was mostly AFK and Ran kept shouting VCA VCA without actually defining why that made sense. I still have half the mind to think that Ran was just a wolfsiding npc and that's where most of the momentum came from.

Knowing and seeing some of how you’ve been scumread on the days since that wagon, I find the bolded hard to believe just because a top wagon doesn’t just form out of nothing with no basis. There has to be a read there, otherwise the wagon stagnates and disappears, and yours clearly didn’t

Why even did Ran become the CW that day? That still doesn’t make sense to me who they got pushed so hard there (and died because of it)

Because players who were reading even noticed that Ran's push was wolfy as hell. Also not like a majority of the voters had any stakes in the game, most were npcs.

The only one I still have slight questioning for is Nutella (who I also don't think explained the vote outside of wagonomics), but I still think that it's a t slot, or at least pro t.

Alright, so if you believe all of the impetus is on Ran (an NPC), and primarily the other NPCs who voted on you for your wagon becoming a thing (which is the sense I’m getting from your responses), should I be taking away from this that you don’t think your wagon was led by mafia?

Why or why not?

[Inawordyes]

I'm autopiloting on Schia for that EoD. Don't see a reason to deviate and he didn't show up either to do anything about it.
Today head empty no thoughts, otherwise. Appreciate that this game even exists and I'm in it but am hardly in the shape to play for a couple of raisins.
Acceptable vibes so far. Porscha locktown.

What your reasons for locktowning her?

[Vivax]

Fwiw I found a candy cane shaped spaghetti in the box yesterday
Or maybe a walking stick, or a magic wand to fend off a talking ****

[Jackofhearts2005]

Jack is that a complicated way to say Nut can go either way and you will not be surprised to see her flipping red?

No. It's a complicated way to say "I mostly think Nutella is town but I notice she's doing a thing that might be wolf indicative so I'm flagging it."

[Seanzie]

Can someone who understands the underworld timezones tell me if day is ending in approximately 9 hours 19 minutes, or did I do it wrong?

[Jackofhearts2005]

I've been wolves with Wilgy a few times. I've watched wolf Wilgy skate to victory in spite of suspicion and watched town Wilgy get misyeeted. There are things he does as a wolf that he's not doing here.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Timezones are hard.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Falcon is not legitimately attempting to solve this game. He's acting. He's reacting. He's not digging. Falcon is a wolf. This one is a gimmie, folks.

[Seanzie]

Compare and contrast. Porscha and Falcon both don't "get" my strong townread on Wilgy. Falcon votes for me.

[VOTE: DrWilgy] aubergine

Wilgy is town if he's in the game to begin with. I'd bet my wincon on it.

[VOTE: DrWilgy] aubergine

Wilgy is town if he's in the game to begin with. I'd bet my wincon on it.

What?


[VOTE: Jackofhearts2005] aubergine

Ya'll horses look real thirsty so follow me.

I don't know what a horse is, I pilot a motor carriage

My horse is a shackled old man. His - his remorse is that we couldn't survey the skies right before - right before they turned grey. My horse and my remorse FLYING OVER A GREAT BAY

[Jackofhearts2005]

There's no fire at all.

[Jackofhearts2005]

The joke is "you can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink."

Where "drinking water" is "yeeting wolf Falcon."

[Jackofhearts2005]

Fwiw I found a candy cane shaped spaghetti in the box yesterday
Or maybe a walking stick, or a magic wand to fend off a talking ****

[Inawordyes]

Wolves are ok with today's main wagon or they can't make a save for an obvious mate to not expose themselves?

I’m starting to wonder exactly that too, Schia is an obvious vote after that EoD spree, but the fact that a bunch of players (myself included) are just parking votes and without much further explanation or consideration doesn’t sit right with me

It actually kinda does make me think more strongly that Schia is mafia here, the reason being that Mafia, in their innate self-awareness of how they could across, usually tend to feel the need to preemptively explain or otherwise over-explain themselves when it comes to reads like this on a slot that would be a lhf townie. Parking your vote on an easy iachop could look back once they flip, so mafia explain their reasonings to justify their vote after the fact

Contrast that with a bus, where the team is sacrificing a buddy and obviously they know that player is mafia, so they don’t worry so much about explaining themselves because they know they’ll flip mafia and not be scrutinized as much for being correct as they would if they were wrong. Basically it’s the complete comfortability (and ensuing apathy) of being on a bus wagon vs. any sort of uncomfortablility over it being on an easy mischop

Town doesn’t care either way because they don’t have to and if they die it’s whatever, but mafia does, and very much so because they have to be alive in order to win.

So parsing out my thoughts, I do think Schia is more likely mafia and this feels very much like a bus wagon rn, but the question is who on the wagon is mafia that’s bussing Schia?

[Jackofhearts2005]

What's the votecount anyway?

[Seanzie]

The joke is "you can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink."

Where "drinking water" is "yeeting wolf Falcon."

No.

[Seanzie]

Who is the main wagon right now?

[Inawordyes]

There’s pretty much no pushback whatsoever to the idea of a Schia wagon today, which is a huge red flag on a threadstate level because if everybody’s content with it, that means Mafia is content with it, and if Mafia is content with it, that means either Schia is town, or mafia is actively bussing rn. i’m basically rehashing Michelle’s thoughts in saying that, but former means that we need to be looking elsewhere, and the latter means that there is likely at least one mafia on Schia’s wagon right now

It’s just a question of which one is the reality

[Seanzie]

What's the votecount anyway?

wow, I'm blind. I got ninja'd two posts back.

[Jackofhearts2005]

The joke is "you can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink."

Where "drinking water" is "yeeting wolf Falcon."

No.

Why? What is townie about Falcon?

[Seanzie]

There’s pretty much no pushback whatsoever to the idea of a Schia wagon today, which is a huge red flag on a threadstate level because if everybody’s content with it, that means Mafia is content with it, and if Mafia is content with it, that means either Schia is town, or mafia is actively bussing rn. i’m basically rehashing Michelle’s thoughts in saying that, but former means that we need to be looking elsewhere, and the latter means that there is likely at least one mafia on Schia’s wagon right now

It’s just a question of which one is the reality

We could always flip Neon.

[Jackofhearts2005]

There’s pretty much no pushback whatsoever to the idea of a Schia wagon today, which is a huge red flag on a threadstate level because if everybody’s content with it, that means Mafia is content with it, and if Mafia is content with it, that means either Schia is town, or mafia is actively bussing rn. i’m basically rehashing Michelle’s thoughts in saying that, but former means that we need to be looking elsewhere, and the latter means that there is likely at least one mafia on Schia’s wagon right now

It’s just a question of which one is the reality

Or....mafia doesn't know who is getting yeeted atm.

[Inawordyes]

Can someone who understands the underworld timezones tell me if day is ending in approximately 9 hours 19 minutes, or did I do it wrong?

Yes…n’t? I think you’re one hour ahead, it usually ends around 6PM EST, which is 8 hours 19 minutes from your post

So pull back an hour earlier I think

[Seanzie]

The joke is "you can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink."

Where "drinking water" is "yeeting wolf Falcon."

No.

Why? What is townie about Falcon?

He has not stricken me as particularly uncomfortable. I am not like 100% sold on town!Falcon yet, but I know I'll be able to sort him as time goes on. I'm at like 80% town Falcon, and if he likes good music, it might go up to 90% (this last part is a joke... it'd be 99.98%).

[Inawordyes]

I've been wolves with Wilgy a few times. I've watched wolf Wilgy skate to victory in spite of suspicion and watched town Wilgy get misyeeted. There are things he does as a wolf that he's not doing here.

Alright, so what are your thoughts on Vivax, Michelle and myself?

[Jackofhearts2005]

I've been wolves with Wilgy a few times. I've watched wolf Wilgy skate to victory in spite of suspicion and watched town Wilgy get misyeeted. There are things he does as a wolf that he's not doing here.

Alright, so what are your thoughts on Vivax, Michelle and myself?

Haven't paid much attention to, probably town, haven't paid any attention to at all.

[Seanzie]

I'd elim Michelle. Also this was a separate thought from IAWY asking about Michelle a few posts ago. I didn't see that post before I decided I'd elim Michelle.

[Jackofhearts2005]

The joke is "you can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink."

Where "drinking water" is "yeeting wolf Falcon."

No.

Why? What is townie about Falcon?

He has not stricken me as particularly uncomfortable. I am not like 100% sold on town!Falcon yet, but I know I'll be able to sort him as time goes on. I'm at like 80% town Falcon, and if he likes good music, it might go up to 90% (this last part is a joke... it'd be 99.98%).

Lol first of all, "uncomfortable" is not the way to find wolf Falcon. It's "lacking townie fire."

Secondly, Falcon is voting the player pushing him hard because he doesn't understand why I townread Wilgy. That looks pretty uncomfortable and awkward by any reasonable standard.

[Vivax]

The joke is "you can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink."

Where "drinking water" is "yeeting wolf Falcon."

[VOTE: Falcon45ca] aubergine

Alright. Schia can wait I guess, and I'll pretend that this is a hint.
Thank you jack.

[Inawordyes]

There’s pretty much no pushback whatsoever to the idea of a Schia wagon today, which is a huge red flag on a threadstate level because if everybody’s content with it, that means Mafia is content with it, and if Mafia is content with it, that means either Schia is town, or mafia is actively bussing rn. i’m basically rehashing Michelle’s thoughts in saying that, but former means that we need to be looking elsewhere, and the latter means that there is likely at least one mafia on Schia’s wagon right now

It’s just a question of which one is the reality

Or....mafia doesn't know who is getting yeeted atm.

They don’t have to, apathy is death and it doesn’t matter if it’s 2 hours after SoD or 2 hours to EoD, if there is mafia on the line there is almost always thread agitation because the mafia squirm and put out feelers to try and steer the ship away from their buddy without exposing themselves and the wagon player in the process by being too blatant

There is no agitation, and the absence is unsettling because of its implications for the threadstate right now

[santygrass]

[VOTE: falconc45a] aubergine

[Seanzie]

The joke is "you can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink."

Where "drinking water" is "yeeting wolf Falcon."

[VOTE: Falcon45ca] aubergine

Alright. Schia can wait I guess, and I'll pretend that this is a hint.
Thank you jack.

No.

[Seanzie]

[VOTE: falconc45a] aubergine

No!

[santygrass]

I'd elim Michelle. Also this was a separate thought from IAWY asking about Michelle a few posts ago. I didn't see that post before I decided I'd elim Michelle.

Why?

[Inawordyes]

I've been wolves with Wilgy a few times. I've watched wolf Wilgy skate to victory in spite of suspicion and watched town Wilgy get misyeeted. There are things he does as a wolf that he's not doing here.

Alright, so what are your thoughts on Vivax, Michelle and myself?

Haven't paid much attention to, probably town, haven't paid any attention to at all.

Well that’s problematic, you should get on that

[santygrass]

I think Michelle is pretty much town fwiw

[Jackofhearts2005]

I've been wolves with Wilgy a few times. I've watched wolf Wilgy skate to victory in spite of suspicion and watched town Wilgy get misyeeted. There are things he does as a wolf that he's not doing here.

Alright, so what are your thoughts on Vivax, Michelle and myself?

Haven't paid much attention to, probably town, haven't paid any attention to at all.

Well that’s problematic, you should get on that

I suppose. Figure I've got time.

[Inawordyes]

[VOTE: falconc45a] aubergine

Where did you come from Santy?

[Seanzie]

The joke is "you can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink."

Where "drinking water" is "yeeting wolf Falcon."

No.

Why? What is townie about Falcon?

He has not stricken me as particularly uncomfortable. I am not like 100% sold on town!Falcon yet, but I know I'll be able to sort him as time goes on. I'm at like 80% town Falcon, and if he likes good music, it might go up to 90% (this last part is a joke... it'd be 99.98%).

Lol first of all, "uncomfortable" is not the way to find wolf Falcon. It's "lacking townie fire."

Secondly, Falcon is voting the player pushing him hard because he doesn't understand why I townread Wilgy. That looks pretty uncomfortable and awkward by any reasonable standard.

Idk how I find wolf!Falcon, I know how to find town!Falcon, and I find town!Falcon by figuring out how confortable he is.

show me his discomfort and I might agree.

I also don't understand why you townread WIlgy, but I also didn't read any of your posts about it.

[Seanzie]

I'd elim Michelle. Also this was a separate thought from IAWY asking about Michelle a few posts ago. I didn't see that post before I decided I'd elim Michelle.

Why?

Looked at a page of her ISO and got meh vibes.

[santygrass]

[VOTE: falconc45a] aubergine

Where did you come from Santy?

I just quickly catched up and am vibing with Jack and want to be carried rn

[Inawordyes]

I'd elim Michelle. Also this was a separate thought from IAWY asking about Michelle a few posts ago. I didn't see that post before I decided I'd elim Michelle.

Why?

I’ll echo, can you expand on this Seanzie?

[Inawordyes]

I'd elim Michelle. Also this was a separate thought from IAWY asking about Michelle a few posts ago. I didn't see that post before I decided I'd elim Michelle.

Why?

Looked at a page of her ISO and got meh vibes.

Oh

Can you expand on this more?

[Inawordyes]

[VOTE: falconc45a] aubergine

Where did you come from Santy?

I just quickly catched up and am vibing with Jack and want to be carried rn

Carried howso and carried why so?

[Jackofhearts2005]

Fwiw, my gut instinct is that Schia is an NPC but I'm more confident that Schia is just not town.

[falcon45ca]

[VOTE: falconc45a] aubergine

Where did you come from Santy?

I just quickly catched up and am vibing with Jack and want to be carried rn

Can you elaborate on which vibes vibe you the most?

[Seanzie]

I'd elim Michelle. Also this was a separate thought from IAWY asking about Michelle a few posts ago. I didn't see that post before I decided I'd elim Michelle.

Why?

I’ll echo, can you expand on this Seanzie?

Looked at a page of her ISO and got meh vibes.

[falcon45ca]

I'd elim Michelle. Also this was a separate thought from IAWY asking about Michelle a few posts ago. I didn't see that post before I decided I'd elim Michelle.

Why?

Looked at a page of her ISO and got meh vibes.

Michelle having an ISO is Townie, she's quite quiet as Maf