Return to “[END] Pikmin Mafia”
Maybe he's just going to post nonsense until town wises up and lynches that kid of his?Glorfindel wrote:I'm wanting to vote Epi right now. I harbour some suspicions about his alignment but more than that, I just want to shut him up!
Per the underline, you suggest Typh was trying to avoid his teammate getting lynched. The following sentence you even speak of how he voted Zeebs over Enrique.kneel4justice wrote:Yay, no death!
Because...you voted for a civilian, and essentially had no reason for your vote other than it going along with the majority. The way I look at it, near the end, zebra seemed rather town - but with a vote like yours, it made it more difficult to stop the lynch. It makes me wonder if there was a reason you wanted to better ensure zebra's lynch, such as your teammate being another candidate at the time. In this case you favored zebra's lynch over Enrique's, but did not give a reason? I just do not follow the logic.Typhoony wrote:What's wrong with that when you don't have time for an informed vote? Much better than a random vote in my opinion.kneel4justice wrote: Although, I do not like Typhoony's vote at all. Seemed like the vote just chose the person with the most votes and for no reason on top of that.
It's a vote. And no.FZ. wrote:I don't even know what this is. Is that your answer to my suspicion?Matt wrote:Went ahead and voted FZ for being reasonable.
Hmmm, just ISO'd you.agleaminranks wrote:Can I interject to mention that, with regards to Simon being Mafia, a lot of people are taking his age and inexperience into consideration. It might only be a matter of time before he role-outs himself due to aforementioned reasons. But I think until then I'm leaning a bit more towards civilian than baddie with regards to him, it seems like his defenses have been more out of frustration from an early onslaught and I too would probably get flustered if such a person was attacking me.
Who said you were on a team?Dragon D. Luffy wrote:I know this is WIFOM, but I like to believe if this were the mafia team you wouldn't have both me and Daisy defending Glorfindel, and vice-versa, like we are right now.Matt wrote:Glorfindelkneel4justice wrote:Here's a question for everyone: If you had to vote someone other than Simon or Epi, who would it be and why?
Daisy
DDL
Unlike some of you, I don't have any prob with Glorfindel's play style whatsoever. I just have a feeling he's bad. Am I wrong? Quite likely, I'll give it a random 73% chance of being wrong. But I dunno. Something about him screams baddie.kneel4justice wrote:Matt, if you know your case against Glorfindel is weak, then why do you suspect him? Or was it not that serious? Is it simply because of Sig's suspicion and the fact that he had a meta?
Personally, I don't find Glorfindel to be scummy. I was pinged by the fact that he was kind of piggybacking on Zebra's suspicion after she died, but everything else has seemed ok to me. It reads genuine, I think the play-style (while I wouldn't necessarily agree with it) comes down to personality rather than alignment. I agree with DDL's ISO
Glorfindelkneel4justice wrote:Here's a question for everyone: If you had to vote someone other than Simon or Epi, who would it be and why?
I have a problem with the underlined here.Glorfindel wrote:I honestly don't know, Matt. To this point, I've had a feeling the whole thing was a sideshow, a distraction (and not necessarily a deliberate one). It's probably just me but I don't have any trouble looking at Simon's comment about Sig generously and I personally think that what he said was interpreted less generously and then the whole thing got blown out of all proportion. I could be wrong but I sincerely have some problems seeing an eight year old as a Mafia mastermind. As for Epi, I don't know. I respect his experience and his capability but the way he seems to dodge questions that are put to him and derail other's lines of questioning by asking them questions in return to be frankly annoying. Let me ask you - I assume you have lots of experience playing in games with him, is this behaviour typical of his individual 'Town playstyle'?Matt wrote:Glorfindel. What do you make of the Simon/Epignosis thing? If one were bad, who would you choose?
Hi Epi how are you doing today??Epignosis wrote:I don't know that Simon didn't make that mistake (the mistake being that he's on a team but didn't look up who his teammates were when he responded).FZ. wrote:RIP Sig.
Wow, this sucks. I was really hoping this day ended better. Sorry, I should have trusted my initial gut.
Epi, a big part of your suspicion of Simon was based on the fact that when you asked him if he was on Sig's team, he said he thought so. You interpreted that as him forgetting he wasn't supposed to say who his team was, and then it all snowballed from there. I know I asked you before the day ended, but knowing he didn't make that mistake when saying he thinks they are on the same team, does it change your perception of him?
Thanks DDL!Dragon D. Luffy wrote:@Matt: I've been kind of suspicious of Glorfindel the entire game, but haven't really decided why. Could you help, and say why exactly you suspect him?
I promise that at least I won't ignore you
Been there done that. I make up huge cases, they subsequently get ignored.Spacedaisy wrote:I didn't ask you to repeat yourself I asked you to explain it. I am willing to listen to any case, and if there is some logic there I might be swayed, but simply saying if this person is bad and this person is civ then this other person must be bad. I need to understand what you used to draw these conclusions. Because Glorfindel did not vote Simon?Matt wrote:Yes. 2+2=4 therefore since sig is civ, and if Simon is bad, then Glorfindel needs to go.Spacedaisy wrote:Can you please explain the reasoning there?
But I'm also cool with skipping straight to lynching Glorfindel if everyone else is up for it.
Also, Enrique, what do you think of Boomslang's "I'm not down for lynching Simon...yet" Ha!
Yes. 2+2=4 therefore since sig is civ, and if Simon is bad, then Glorfindel needs to go.Spacedaisy wrote:Can you please explain the reasoning there?
Don't worry, I don't think anyone really wants to play haha.DrWilgy wrote:A GTH this early? I'd rather play the, If I attempted night kills game last night, I would have killed blank and blank, etc.
Of course everyone wants a winged pikmin, Scotty, what was I thinking?You wouldn't want a blue or winged pikmin?Scotty wrote:And for Wilgy- if I were a protagonist, I would currently have a randomly chosen pikmin out of 7 possible choices.
Am I doing that right?
I think if sig is civ and Simon is bad, then Glorfindel is def baddie.DrWilgy wrote:Civ, but his posts seem to be jumbly mumbo butts.
Are you not down for my game Matt?
Lol. Nice.DrWilgy wrote:I got an excersize for everyone to partake in. If I were a protagonist, I would currently have _____.
I will start:
If I were a protagonist, I would currently have a Purple pikmin.
I would like everyone to copy this format.
By this I assume you had Zeebs as a Protagonist role? Why?Glorfindel wrote:I'll say this again - based on her behaviour and the tone of her posts so far this game, I cannot conclude that she has an alignment to the Mafia. Further, I think eliminating her to be a mistake and if I'm correct, one that we may ultimately regret.
Your vote is on Epi. Forced?DrWilgy wrote:Sig is scum
Hi Floyd!TheFloyd73 wrote:Hello.
I exist.
That is all.
Thanks MP, I totally forgot to send in my kill.MovingPictures07 wrote:Also, if you have Night actions, you have just a little over 6 hours to send them into me. So please do so if you haven't already!
If you have questions about your Night action or aren't sure whether you have one, PM me and I'd be happy to help.
No sir, I am not! I am a confirmed cute, innocent Pikmin.Metalmarsh89 wrote:I'm still catching up myself as well.
Are you a member of mafia Matt?
Cool. Did they play Starlight? That's my faves.Metalmarsh89 wrote:I missed the party. Bye zebra.
On the other hand, I saw Muse last night in Portland. They were brilliant.
Oh my bad, basically Enrique, Boomslang, and I rocked the house as Mafia in MP's super awesome Pet Sounds game. You can see the imaginary winner's banner in my signature, but anywho, inviting Boomslang to vote with me and Enrique was a nod to that classic game, nothing more. Voting for Boomslang was also for funsies, although I think it was either FZ or k4J who said "Peeps better be voting for real reasons". But like, Day 1 so whatevs.Glorfindel wrote:Four posts in almost 48 hours and the justification for his vote on me is "For the fun of it"? This was followed by Matt inviting Boomslang to join in on a vote on me and after being challenged by Spacedaisy, Matt changes his vote TO Boomslang. I don't like what I'm seeing here and I'm wondering if this exchange was an indication of something more sinister? I may change my vote later but for now, I'm prepared to vote for Enrique. I think that if he should turn out to be Mafia, it may give us something more to work with.Enrique wrote:For the fun of it.FZ. wrote:I love that Matt has all the mafia figured out.
I always wanted to play a game where everyone names who they think the mafia members are on the first day, based on gut feeling of day 0 or day 1, and then we look at the list at the end of the game and see who's intuition we should rely on in the future.
Glorfindel
Matt
sig
