Also, I updated my sig at the start of the game for 2 purposes:
A) just to brag...
B) As a wink to my role without blatantly saying it.

All-in-all, I had a blast playing....and now it's back to mafia retirment for me...PEACE OUT!
Fine. Guess I'm getting lynched guys...I won't be threatened. I'm good letting things play out.Elohcin wrote:But, if your vote stays, so does mine.
To take Epi's approach from earlier today, I could but I won't. I've gone over everything at my disposal and it all points to Epi being a baddie role and INH not being a cop or Yin. I have no firm grasp.on you, BWT (who I don't believe has posted in the past 24-48 hrs., which is disheartening) or Russ. I'm either right or I'm wrong. Admittedly, I'm quite frustrated at this point but it's only a game (which while I've enjoyed playing serves as a reminder why I don't play mafia anymore) and not worth giving myself an ulcer over any longer. Here's to hoping my logic has added up, but if not, congrats to all those who've outplayed me.Elohcin wrote:Can you elaborate? B/c I think he looks pretty bad when he tries to defend himself against accusations.BigDamnHero wrote:I don't think INH is a cop nor is he yin.
goddam linkitis BULLSPIT!!!!....BigDamnHero wrote:and FUCK ME....did I miss the post where Russ changed his vote to ME?!?!?!!? Or even an explanation why??? Suddenly I am well aware of how a mexican stand-off feels...why don't we all just vote a different person and leave it a whatever-way-tie..SHEESH!!!
There was an earlier post where Epi stated the fact that there's no way to keep Yin from killing....then INH quetioned if this was a role claim (which he then later stated he didn't buy it). But either way, this makes no sense!!! Why the hell would anybody claimed to be the last member of a baddie team during a lynch phase??? It wuold serve no purpose other than to pain a target on themself and stand to gain nothing in return.Russtifinko wrote:BigDamnHero wrote:So obviously Epi got whammied by an item or else he wouldn't install vote one person and then recommend several other vote another. I'm gonna take time towhich one of you other bastards I can trust. ATM, I'm leaning Russ, but that could very easily change.
To my civ counterpart, don't give up hope. I had previously thought that our victory was already squashed, but we've got a Hail Mary shot at taking the baddie teams out.Soooo, I'm the one you can trust most, but then Epi says "You should vote Russ." and you vote Russ? Are you that easily swayed? Color me perplexed, at best, and a little frustrated.
Keep in mind, this is the same Epi who's been wrong 4 times in a row, and who has been so convinced I'm bad he's come up with 3 different baddie teammates for me, 2 of whom are now dead civs.
I earlier thought this was signs of him being yang, but I think there's another role that could explain his cavalier attitude here...
I got some small validation with that timmer death, so I'm now 1/2 on calling baddies. I think you can do the math here.
so basically your record is a coin flip...and that's somehow supposed to give you civ cred?
BDH, to answer your question, Elo is definitely bad in my book right now. She voted me yesterday, reread us, and decided to vote DF. Then she voted me again today as soon as Epi said jump. Which, honestly, is the same you did, but circumstances being what they are, I don't really buy that you're bad regardless. I figure her for a probable Cop.
if Elo is definitely bad then in your book why didn't you just vote her right away? ESPECIALLY because of your next statement...
I think BWT is likely bad as well. Between Epi and INH I'm really torn on the final baddie; my vote for Epi yesterday was admittedly reactive and somewhat emotionally-driven, and INH has been agreeing with me a lot, which is making him harder for me to judge. So I am actually open to changing my vote, no matter what Epi says. (Preferably to Elo or BWT, but to INH if I feel there's a compelling-enough case against him.)
And speaking of pretending to be willing to change your vote, this strikes me as funny in hindsight:
Epignosis wrote:Of course not. I was always voting Russ.Elohcin wrote:B/c of DF's last post?Epignosis wrote:Voted Russ again.
I kinda figured you weretimmer wrote:Wait, I was bad? Wattttt?
...only if one of the items is a bag of magic beans leading to a castle in the sky where a giant lives that can squash both baddie teams in one fell swoop.Elohcin wrote:I can't wait to read end game and see the ins and outs of all the items. It had to be an item in the hands of a baddie, or I guess possibly a misguided civ.Russtifinko wrote:Geez, so it was 2 civs on that poll...brutal.
BDH, who do you most feel like spoiling? haha
Now, b/c we are still playing, that must mean that civs still have a chance, right?
Does my vote even matter at this point? It's already 5-2 against you. Plus, if you are a civ and I am, that just leaves one other....presumably Epi. But that would mean both other baddie teams have organized...and I don't see that. Part of me is now thinking you and Epi have been a baddie duo all along and using my gullibility as your pawn. Epics most recent quote to me "Don't get cute." stark a strange tone with me...it sounded like a threat than advice...it dunno...I go to work in a few hours so I'll vote before then. Again, I feel the civs have already lost and we are basically deciding which baddie team gets the W.DFaraday wrote:![]()
BDH, I promise you, I am one of the last remaining civs, and it seems you are as well. I don't know what Russ is, but I strongly believe he is Yin/Yang. If we lose this lynch the game is basically over for us. I'm imploring you, you can't vote me today. We will lose. Please trust me this one time.
Like the Temptations, I ain't too proud to beg.
I could potentially be for that...I'm increasingly feeling a knife being twisted in my back...and he was quick to jump onto my BWT lynch...I suddenly lyrics feel like I'm the puppet to his master...the pawn to his...uhhhmmmm....chess guy?insertnamehere wrote:Russ, assuming you make it out of Day and Night 7, would you want to lynch Epignosis?
@Everyone who is not Epignosis: Would you be open to considering Epignosis for a Day 8 lynch, and if not, why?
After talking to the host, I feel I need to proceed with caution and discretion. Sufficed to say, BWT's explaination of things 100% satisfies my conflict towards him effectively going for Defcon 1 all the way back down to Defcon 5. Unfortunately, without further violating the rules, I can't really answer your question. Now let me be clear that this in NO WAY confirms/clarifies his allignment in any way. There's a lot of baddies out there and we haven't scored so much as a whiff of one during our lynches.birdwithteeth11 wrote:BDH, I know how you think you got info on me. The item I was holding at the time was the necklace. It was an item that was auto-activated based on you using your ability on me. I did not actively choose to use the item at that time, so it wasn't like I was holding it for some strategical moment to happen and then me use the item because it benefited me in a certain scenario.
Based on what information you received, what specific part of it makes you believe I am bad?
Larger explaination later but I had to switch my vote from BWT quick and didn't wanna go with eloh or Scotty (both of whom I posted about earlier today)Russtifinko wrote:NOW YOU WANT TO????BigDamnHero wrote:I'm in b the middle of a football game...BWT explaination satisfies my quarries. Changing my vote to timmer...I'll post a longer explaination later...if I'm still around. Apologies for any part I may have played in the current situations.
AUGH!
RIP Scotty. Now you guys can clearly see there was nothing going on between me and him. So, can we PLEASE:
1) Stop listening to Epi
2) Lynch timmer
3) In all honesty, probably lynch Epi at this point. Let's be real, he's led like 3 bad lynches and shown no sign of letting up.
insertnamehere wrote: Blink twice if I'm right.
You're right...there's nothing you really can say...not do I expect you to...but at the same time, I'm not taking up a call to arms and rallying everybody to vote the same way either.birdwithteeth11 wrote: So because you know something you can't publicly reveal, you have to vote for me?
I mean, I'm not really sure what I can say to defend myself against that. And there's nothing in-thread that you can point to that has made you come to this conclusion?
We'll that's the trick, isn't it...IF I received any info or Intel, I couldn't says so as it would be in violation of the rules. As it stands, I received NO INFO WHATSOEVER on you...of this were a 5 question pop quiz, I got ZERO. And that's why I'm concerned...and that's why I think your role has secrets. And your avoidance, while neither confirming nor denying the claimed role secrets does not instill confidence in my of your civiness. I think I have to vote you this round...birdwithteeth11 wrote:What makes you think my role has secrets? I'd prefer to hear your thought process on this, because right now there's NOTHING I can say to any of this.BigDamnHero wrote:Epignosis wrote:If you want to go in that direction, I will support you. I went through (half of) bwt and gave my opinion, but if you feel differently, I'm willing to back you up.
Plus it'd be a relief for someone else to get shit if you're wrong.
FUck it...I'm just throwin' it out there: I have a STRONG indication that BWT is a role with secrets attached to him...it's the ONLY explaination I can come up with. That leaves me to believe thag if he's not civ, then he's a crooked cop or Despereaux (who may or may not be able to assist the civs). The problem is all the damn secrets and we don't know what we don't know...
I mean, if you really do think I'm bad, I'd at least prefer to hear why before you stick a vote on me.
Epignosis wrote:If you want to go in that direction, I will support you. I went through (half of) bwt and gave my opinion, but if you feel differently, I'm willing to back you up.
Plus it'd be a relief for someone else to get shit if you're wrong.
as for part 2 of that...eeewwww...Scotty wrote:I don't understand your relationship with Epi but both of you seem to have a little secret and I hate not knowing secrets.BigDamnHero wrote:If my trust in Epi has been misplaced in this game, then I am well and truly BONED because I'm fairly certain he has deduced my identity. That being said, I do believe I may have been one of the ?????? failed NK attempts. I received no notification/confirmation that I was , but if so, I have NO IDEA how I would have survived it.
My aunt is named Chatty Kathy for two reasons: her name is Kathy, and she loves to talk. LOVES it. Which is great when I need to know how many cousins I have this year, and not great when the discussion focuses on her girlfriends' menstrual cycle syncing.
I don't know why I brought that up.
This makes me think we should bring a lynch against Scotty to a SCREECHING hault...there's SOOOOO much truth in here it's not even funny. The reason I know this FOR A FACT is because I gifted rabbit something before Scotty took over. Last night, I got that EXACT item sent back to me...what possible reason would a baddie have to send out an item to someone rather than give it or hoard it amongst his baddie teammates? Even more, what reaason would he then have to openly admit to having gifted it not knowing where/who it came from to begin with...Scotty wrote:I'm not questioning your gift exchange. Hell, I gifted you an item last night (this isn't breaking rules afaik) so if anyone wants an item, it's me, should I still be alive.
Rabbit had Multiple items in his possession when I inherited the role. None of them benefited me so I gifted them our to who I thought were civs. Hope y'all use it to your advantage.![]()
And what about Elo strikes you as a certain civ role? Do you think she's Shawn?
I would go with BWT too...not because Of Eloh saying it, but because earlier this day phase I brought up concerns I had with him.Elohcin wrote:BWTinsertnamehere wrote:
@BDH, Elo, and BWT, name one person you suspect that Epignosis didn't influence you towards.
Do you thing Epi could be a silver-tongued baddie leading us astray, Scotty? If so, who would you have me vote for instead? The "evidence" presented against you does look bad, but as always in mafia, it's purely circumstantial...so can you explain away those circumstances?Scotty wrote:Just look at those votes pile up.
Eerily reminiscent of early game, ain't it?
No one finds that suspicious that I'm having no resistance, once again? Timmer got resistance.
I mean, you can't all be bad, but apparently you can be lazy.
I'm done putting up a resistance. Once again, I'm trying too hard in the game and it's making me irritable. Next time I replace in, I'm just gonna pop in every now and then and say "hey, I agree with the majority, that person is bad". Sounds like a winning strategy.
No, I'm not gonna talk to the mods. I've got it out in my past life and over the past day. It's just a game, I know, but it just sucks. Someone just tell me who to vote, I'm over making cases right now, it's just not worth it.
I sent my PM to the hosts after we agreed to the trade.Elohcin wrote:Yeah, I had forgotten about it too until I reread the rules the other day. BDH has offered to trade/gift me his item while I gift him mine, but I haven't heard from him since. I'm a little afraid he will forget and then I will have given him my item for nothing in return.
BDH, please confirm with me about our agreement as we get closer to EoD.
That last part was more metaphorical, than literal...cuz I really haven't asked you anything directly. I just read through your posts and can't infer/decipher/pick-up-on anything. You just read as a complete blank to me and I've never realy had that happen before. I usually get SOME glimpse (whether correctly or incorrectly) about something. And I should make it clear, this is more about ME reading you than anything directed at you/your actions. But since we are having this discourse, what are your thoughts about our inability to seek out baddies in this game? Are we being manipulated?...Do we just suck at it?...Are the civs just more active making it harder to find the mafia crews?birdwithteeth11 wrote:What feelers have you sent out? If you have questions, I will answer them.BigDamnHero wrote:Epi, what is your take on BWT? I can't seem to get a read on him. It's like I send feelers out and get NO RESPONSE back...
I'll take you up on this offer...Elohcin wrote:Now....anyone willing to gift me their item and I will gift you mine?