Return to “Rocky and Bullwinkle - The Legend of Frostbite Falls [Day 8]”
S~V~S wrote:
We have better drinks & snackzzz in dead land anyhow Sorsha
indiglo wrote:S~V~S wrote:
QFT
Sorry Sorsha.
Golden wrote:RIP Sorsha
Scotty wrote:bwahahahaha
So you think I forced you to vote svs?bea wrote:Wilgy, given the fact that I was reprimanded privately and what the host said publicly, forgive me for not talking more about my force vote. It's there if you go back and look.
I'm going to vote sorsha. I've had better I've read blooper as civ all game.
And so what..... It makes him bad? Or you can't vote with him because you don't like how he's playing? Does him voting me and changing his mind and switching make you think that he and I are Mafia together? I'm not understanding how you're making your decisions here wilgy. There are only two Mafia in the game.DrWilgy wrote:sprityo wrote:what did i miss? scotty is nell?It's comments like these and your non commitment towards anyone else that makes me not want to vote with you.sprityo wrote:Oh, hur dur I can't read.
Okay, I can just believe people vote fornscotty just for being Scotty
I think they have bts but is it baddie? I've been more suspicious of blooper than of Eloh but I think they are the same, regardless. I wish LC would give some thoughts about someone other than wilgy.a2thezebra wrote:Yup, Eloh/niju officially seems more likely to me than Eloh/Sorsha.Elohcin wrote:Those voting records are good enough for me. Sorsha it is.
Thats funny. Go ahead BullwinkleDrWilgy wrote:Oh trustworthy Moose roleblocker, hear my plea. Please block Sorsha tonight for me!
Anyone have any thoughts about my Sorsha theory now?
So does this mean he's role claiming narrator? Otherwise I still don't get it?DrWilgy wrote:Duh :PSorsha wrote:Was this post discussed yet?DrWilgy wrote:EverySloonei wrote:has the narrator targeted you every day?DrWilgy wrote:Lol, compare it to my previous votesSloonei wrote:Wilgy's vote has the appearance of maybe being forced by the narrator/Natasha. I don't recall him every expressing any suspicion against me.
Single
Day
There's a no double targeting rule so I'm not sure how wilgy could have been targeted so many times consecutively by the same role.
so you're killing me? 
Was this post discussed yet?DrWilgy wrote:EverySloonei wrote:has the narrator targeted you every day?DrWilgy wrote:Lol, compare it to my previous votesSloonei wrote:Wilgy's vote has the appearance of maybe being forced by the narrator/Natasha. I don't recall him every expressing any suspicion against me.
Single
Day
I don't like bloopers vote on there tbh. And bea is implying she was forced. You, me and eloh have at least expressed suspicion on her.Sloonei wrote:But whoa, I see SVS is suddenly in the lead. I'll have to think about how that makes me feel. I might pass out and not wake up until right around the deadline soon so I'm not sure how much I can get done the rest of this phase.
Was there much doubt to Scottys alignment? Or if there was doubt no one cared, he was either fearless leader or Nell.DrWilgy wrote:My suspicion on Sorsha goes back to this. I feel like this attack was preemptive. Starting before we even knew Scotty's alignment. Planning on following up after Scotty's flip, Sorsha set SVS up for an easy lynch following Scotty's fall.DrWilgy wrote:Wait, this implicates SVS while Scotty is still unconfirmed?Sorsha wrote:Check out SVS's iso, from yesterday in particular. She defended Scotty near lynch time which is the basis for my vote on her today.
At the end of the day if Scotty is the one lynched I'll be happy, but I don't want to waste the day by not talking about other suspects.
Sorsha, you are bad.
Even looking at Scotty's and Sorsha's interaction from previous. Hindsight, It was almost as if she was wanting to blow off Scotty's lynching until later, even though she supposedly knew SVS was bad based on her interactions with the not yet confirmed Scotty.
A point that I don't like is "This player was killed because of ___" it's easy for a baddie to use the kill and then false case build off it. It can give a baddie total control of the flow of a game if we base our lynchings on Mafia NK's.
She did the same thing in AWR with Juliets, who was her Mafia teammate.a2thezebra wrote:I suspect S~V~S often for a number of reasons, but soft defenses isn't one of them. Is that really what has earned her five votes or is there more to it?
I'm reading this as genuine S~V~S.
Whether you are good or bad I'm looking at LC & wilgy next. Atm, gut feels have me thinking wilgy is the good one and LC is pulling something but I really need to review everything they have both said on this Natasha and forced votes thing first. I don't think wilgy is bad if you are. I'd think more you & LC as a team.S~V~S wrote:The forced vote on me doesn't help tbh.
Your opinions on Sloonei, LC and Wilgy?
S~V~S wrote:Of the people with votes, I think Scotty DOES have a baddie game. I am not sure I am seeing it here. I don't think Eloh is bad either. A reread of her knowing what we know now did me a world of good there. I recommend it, Zebra & Wilgy.
Wilgy on the other hand is giving me heeebies, maybe even jeebies. I should be finished catching up and able to vote over my AM coffee at work.
The above quote is I why I think Epi got killed. I think Epi was on to the Scotty/SVS connection as well. So the pink is her once again softly defending him based on past meta reasons. Then the blue is leaving herself a way out when she is wrong.S~V~S wrote:It is hard to explain; he just *feels* jabbier to me when he's bad, not unlike how I view LC when he's bad; he makes little one liner pokes at people for reasons I don't fathom. Which isn't to say *I* have to fathom everyone elses thoughts. But in LOST Again I read Scottys posts with my forehead scrinched up and one eyebrow almost in my hairline. In LOST Again, I could pretty much pull him out of a hat after a few posts. I am not seeing it as much here. He danced around it a bit more, IMO. Here he is pretty much sticking to his guns. He looks totally different to me than he looked in that game, and more like he does in the games I have seen him mislynched.Epignosis wrote:Can you elaborate?S~V~S wrote:Of the people with votes, I think Scotty DOES have a baddie game. I am not sure I am seeing it here.
BUT God knows I could be wrong, though; see the last 2 lynches. My civ game always goes off the rails when I have to defend before I get a chance to settle in to the thread.
@Bea, yeah I kinda agree. But even if Llama were to allow votes for Matt (and in the past he has not cut replacements slack iirc) I would feel better letting him settle in. Replacing into a role taking suspish is not easy.
Which reminds me, I don't know about anyone else, but I thought Suspish-Gate in GOC was hilarious.
Again with the soft defense followed by the "but" she could point at later... not sure how many no-shows we had that lynch (i know bea missed it) but I think this last post was for the sake of them to get any last minute straggler voters to push over to WIlgy instead of Scotty.S~V~S wrote:Scotty is not in the house. I hope you guys are right. He looks very different to me than he did in LOST Again, but that is my only basis for comparison.
Because they will just kill me tonight. Or try to lynch me tomorrow. Either way it's fine, I'm a civ.Scotty wrote:SVS why not place your vote on her thenS~V~S wrote:Sorsha wrote:If Scotty is or isn't the fearless leader I'd think they would want to lynch him, especially if he is FL and they were able to convey to him somehow their identities. Keeping him alive runs the risk of him slipping up and revealing them or being hesitant to vote for one of them in a close lynch or any number of ways of outing them by accident. Plus, if he isn't FL of course they would just play along that he is to get a civ lynched.
I think if he is Nell he will die tonight by snidely whiplashes hand (unless that's not possible if Dudley is still alive) otherwise he is FL.
.....and he didn't die via snidely. So I'm willing to bet he is FL.
My main suspect for Boris or Natasha happens to be SVS so I'll put my vote there.
Actually your reaction to what I said makes me think you are Boris or Natasha. What you said up there would count for any bad team not just a split one, anyone can give anyone away at any time. The fact that your reaction to what I said was basically,so what's your point, makes me think I hit a nail on the head.
Voting Scotty.
You're not bothered that this is almost a complete waste of a day then? We are not learning anything about who Boris or Natasha are.a2thezebra wrote:I am bothered that she makes it clear that she'll be happy if Scotty is lynched...but isn't pushing for Scotty's lynch.DrWilgy wrote:Wait, this implicates SVS while Scotty is still unconfirmed?Sorsha wrote:Check out SVS's iso, from yesterday in particular. She defended Scotty near lynch time which is the basis for my vote on her today.
At the end of the day if Scotty is the one lynched I'll be happy, but I don't want to waste the day by not talking about other suspects.
Sorsha, you are bad.
Yes but you were casting doubt on a Scotty lynch yesterday, saying you didn't think this was his baddie game. Now you vote for him even though you think I'm Boris or Natasha?S~V~S wrote:Sorsha wrote:If Scotty is or isn't the fearless leader I'd think they would want to lynch him, especially if he is FL and they were able to convey to him somehow their identities. Keeping him alive runs the risk of him slipping up and revealing them or being hesitant to vote for one of them in a close lynch or any number of ways of outing them by accident. Plus, if he isn't FL of course they would just play along that he is to get a civ lynched.
I think if he is Nell he will die tonight by snidely whiplashes hand (unless that's not possible if Dudley is still alive) otherwise he is FL.
.....and he didn't die via snidely. So I'm willing to bet he is FL.
My main suspect for Boris or Natasha happens to be SVS so I'll put my vote there.
Actually your reaction to what I said makes me think you are Boris or Natasha. What you said up there would count for any bad team not just a split one, anyone can give anyone away at any time. The fact that your reaction to what I said was basically,so what's your point, makes me think I hit a nail on the head.
Voting Scotty.
Yeah, he said that's why he moved his vote off indiglo and on to epi day 2.Sloonei wrote:Didn't Mp claim to be seduced earlier?
Sorry I'm not getting why it matters that they know who he is?S~V~S wrote:True. But now they have gotten a few fearless leader messages,and likely know who he is. So we need to keep that in mind.Sorsha wrote:I vote for Boris & Natasha hunting, otherwise we're just going to have a bandwagon day that gives us no new info.Epignosis wrote:Bottom line is that Scotty is 50% likely to be bad, but without BTSC.
Do you want to lynch him straight off tomorrow, or do you want to leave him alone and hunt the BTSC mafia? You know, the ones with the kills?
I vote for Boris & Natasha hunting, otherwise we're just going to have a bandwagon day that gives us no new info.Epignosis wrote:Bottom line is that Scotty is 50% likely to be bad, but without BTSC.
Do you want to lynch him straight off tomorrow, or do you want to leave him alone and hunt the BTSC mafia? You know, the ones with the kills?
Why does being lost and uncertain not inspire good feelings to you? The Mafia are the ones who know who is civ and who isn't, the civs are the ones who start out the most lost and uncertain in any game.Sloonei wrote:I should apologize for being so singularly focused on Scotty right now, but I don't really have time to develop other cases in depth at the moment. The town reads I expressed yesterday were MP, SVS, and Elohcin. All three of those still stand. Sorsha has been invisible and while I've only played a couple games with her so far, I've already come to expect her to be more of a presence in the thread. I should understand more than anyone right now the limitations that real life can put on Mafia activity, but she hasn't offered up any explanation other than feeling lost and being uncertain, which doesn't inspire me to read her as good at all. Plus her reaction to MP's fire drill both during and after the fact raise a few alarms. She was a willing participant, and then seemed to blame MP when the result turned bad, while also sayinn she herself should not be blamed because she's "just one vote". Seems a bit blindly hypocritical, unless I'm misunderstanding her stance on MP.
I will need to dig further if I'm going to come up with a third suspect. Everything else I've got is little more than unsubstantiated hunch-based suspicion, and that's not worth sharing.
Sorry bub. You lead that and I fell for it hook, line and sinker. As soon as indi had enough votes you bailed. I suggest everyone take what you say with a grain of salt. In fact you'd be my number one choice to lynch tomorrow, just so we can see what your true intentions were today. I think you were trying to save one of the players who had votes.MovingPictures07 wrote:Not willing to take responsibility for your own vote?Sorsha wrote:Gets civ lynched.MovingPictures07 wrote:Guess I'll have to start reevaluation process. Better give my work attention now though. See you all for d3.
Peace out homies.
Consider my eye on you much more heavily going into d3.
Why not?Long Con wrote:Sorsha is also on my suspect list. Just had a look at her posts this game, and it's pretty lean, and yet she was Cheers-ing the CFD idea. Why, Sorsha?Sorsha wrote:MovingPictures07 wrote:Who wants a CFD?
Let's CFD Epi, indiglo, or Long Con please.
I didn't have anyone I suspected enough to put a vote on. MP comes in like a madman with a plan. The way i was looking at his posts was like GTH reads. He was catching up/reading the thread quickly and giving his reads as he went. Don't blame me for all this, I was just one vote.Gets civ lynched.MovingPictures07 wrote:Guess I'll have to start reevaluation process. Better give my work attention now though. See you all for d3.
Sorry indiglo
MovingPictures07 wrote:Who wants a CFD?
Let's CFD Epi, indiglo, or Long Con please.
If you're trying to save Sloonei why didn't you vote for eloh, who has more votes than you & tied with Sloonei, rather than yourself?MovingPictures07 wrote:STOP VOTING FOR SLOONEI
Vote for me instead.
Votes MP
My post about her earlier was highlighting how she first said she didn't know if it spoke to SVS's alignment to SVS's reaction being a definite civ tell. 20 minutes apart with no addition input from svs on the matter.Sloonei wrote:Zebra's approach there, and the general strategy of the maligned "RVS" is to put pressure on a player to see how they react. I think that is what you are observing in Zebra here.Sorsha wrote:I put my vote on zebra. See my previous post on her, I think she was trying to get something going on svs but backed off when no one was going for it. Then she turned to eloh.
However, I am in no position to defend zebra's townstripes, having just been sufficiently crushed by her in an RYM game last week.
