The Syndicate

c4e5g3d5 wrote: ↑Thu Apr 01, 2021 1:56 pm Never seen so much postgame theory discussion around one wrong read.

More discussion than on the final day that’s for sure.

Really good game @Sloonei and @juliets! Thanks for hosting

@BoKnows Your team helped set you up in the beginning, but I think you deserved the win most of all. It was fun after I died and learning you were the last, watching how you subtly push and steer the thread. So many right moves! Well done!

Good game to all the bees as well. We were just outplayed. Remember it’s just a game

Seanzie wrote: ↑Wed Mar 24, 2021 5:57 pm Okay, well good luck tomorrow everyone.

Legacy:
1. Nook should be next.
2. I'll ask everyone to give TS Account another look, and consider them over Kyle if the reasons why people were clearing TS don't hold up to the second look.
3. Alison is probably just town and y'all should act accordingly, but I'mma be so pissed if eventually we find out that wasn't the case.

I second number two in case the game isn’t over and I’m nk

BoKnows wrote: ↑Wed Mar 24, 2021 5:45 pm Ah man I don't know what to think about this lynch. Sean doesn't come off as scum to me, but so does no one. I guess it comes down to who is more towny than who... I wish we had another day to hash everything over.

I agree with the first bit about no one really coming off as scum at this point, but I’m not sure another day would help. Personally I have a feeling I would feel as unsure tomorrow, and that only a reveal of some sorts will move us forward.
Just hoping for the best at this point.

Kylemii wrote: ↑Wed Mar 24, 2021 5:28 pm what happened to ratrug

Lynched day 2

Yea, I just looked back and Quin had 3 votes already when you voted for ratrug Seanzie, so why are you focusing on nanooks vote there when you also had a vote for ratrug that could have been to save Quin?

Seanzie wrote: ↑Wed Mar 24, 2021 5:15 pm What do people think about Nook's Ratrug vote with the context that Quin was the competing wagon to Ratrug?

It is one of the points against.

But didn’t you vote ratrug too?

BoKnows wrote: ↑Wed Mar 24, 2021 2:35 pm This is going to sound dumb as hell but who's Mikey?

Ts account

I had to ask earlier

Alison is just a feeling based on thread behaviour plus quin vote.

When I’m speaking of clearing here it is of course as cleared as one can be without the host telling you for sure

@BoKnows Esooa is cleared to me for voting only mafia so far

Plus I want to stick with my other bees Esooa and Alison. Hive mentality and what not

I’m switching to Seanzie. Got to go with gut at this point and nanook feels better and more helpful

[VOTE: vote Seanzie] aubergine

A lot of my thoughts and reason for my vote for nanook over Seanzie was the theory that it wasn’t likely a mafia team would all vote for the same person day 1 to save a teammate. But it’s entirely possible, so @Alison you know Seanzie better? Does that fit with playstyle? Because if I throw out that theory, Seanzie’s votes are worse of the two, plus worse thread activity.

Alison wrote: ↑Wed Mar 24, 2021 9:32 am I'm mostly just waiting for seanzie to check in. If he stays radio silent I'm going to assume he's scum who's given up and just vote him out.

I definitely feel out of the past days activity of the top lynch contenders (I forgot what PoE means, but I think PoE is applicable here) his looks the worst. Nanook has been around and helpful. Kyle has been around and helping as much as personal life will allow. Both their responses just look better.

Now I also take this with a grain of salt because Quin was around and posting a lot at the end too, but maybe that’s why Quin seemed so frustrated.

Alison wrote: ↑Wed Mar 24, 2021 9:31 am
fingersplints wrote: ↑Wed Mar 24, 2021 9:27 am
BoKnows wrote: ↑Wed Mar 24, 2021 9:24 am How's everyone feeling?
For me this is the toughest lynch. All the other lynches I felt there were more clear candidates, whereas this one I feel like there are two or three people who it could be but have all also seemed town a lot. So it’s a guess really.
Add on top of that, there is only one mafia left, so the game could be over with a right guess, but with a wrong one I’m almost certainly getting night killed tonight and I lose.
you win even if you're dead now

Technically, yes. Personally, no. It’ll be hard for me to ever consider it a real win if I don’t make it to the end.

There is a lot of pressure. Tbh when I saw the beesparado PM, I just assumed I was going to shoot wrong and it was game over for me. But then I survived that, and got a little taste of victory and I want to win it all. I almost never win.

BoKnows wrote: ↑Wed Mar 24, 2021 9:24 am How's everyone feeling?

For me this is the toughest lynch. All the other lynches I felt there were more clear candidates, whereas this one I feel like there are two or three people who it could be but have all also seemed town a lot. So it’s a guess really.
Add on top of that, there is only one mafia left, so the game could be over with a right guess, but with a wrong one I’m almost certainly getting night killed tonight and I lose.

fingersplints wrote: ↑Wed Mar 24, 2021 9:18 am @ts account what are you thinking about the two lynch candidates?

Or kyle for that matter

@ts account what are you thinking about the two lynch candidates?

Alison wrote: ↑Tue Mar 23, 2021 8:01 pm As a note for future games I think dayvigs should be flipped at EOD (which I thought was the case this game, actually), because like if the dayvig submits their shot at 12pm and EOD is at 6pm, then the host resolving the shot at 12pm on time is very different from if the host is out for lunch and comes back at 4pm and resolves the shot then.

I don’t want to get in trouble from speaking too much about bts host stuff but this wasn’t an issue. They did a great job. I knew it would go through right away. They were very available, accommodating, and quick in their responses. Maybe this kind of set up wouldn’t work in every game, especially in one with only one host so less availability, but there were no problems in this one.

LC is dead

I think nanook’s votes look worst, and they were really pushing Alison to get the shot.

[VOTE: vote nanook] aubergine

fingersplints wrote: ↑Tue Mar 23, 2021 12:09 pm Seanzie voted Bo with Falcon and Quin day 1. I have a hard time believing any mafia team would ever think “hey, here’s a good strategy. Let’s all vote for the same person day 1” lol

They also voted ratrug day 2. So possible if improbable still not a great look

Seanzie voted Bo with Falcon and Quin day 1. I have a hard time believing any mafia team would ever think “hey, here’s a good strategy. Let’s all vote for the same person day 1” lol

Esooa wrote: ↑Tue Mar 23, 2021 12:05 pm
MartinGG99 wrote: ↑Tue Mar 23, 2021 12:01 pm Okay, Quin was mafia.

I presume Esooa is more tunneled on me.
I'm willing to move

But you're gonna have to try to convince me who of Alison/Nanook/Kyle is mafia if not you

I don’t think an Alison and Quin team makes much sense. The in thread comments and vote yesterday is just too much to make me believe distancing

Nanook voted esooa day 1, ratrug day 2. Definitely not a good look
Ts voted Falcon day 1 (I still think this vote is suspicious) and ratrug day 2 - not a great look, but admittedly still not the worst.

Looking at polls still.

Esooa voted mafia day 1 and 2. Good look. Confirms my thoughts there.

Martin voted falcon day 1 and I believe was 3rd which was an important vote though not deciding. Participated in ratrug lynch, so possible but not likely IMO

Kyle voted quin day 1 when there was absolutely no way quin was getting lynched. Voted Seanzie day 2. Not a good look

Quin and Falcon both voted for Bo day 1. Probably not team

Haha ok you did really have me doubting at the end there Quin

I’m sorry if we’re wrong, and if we’re right you almost got me there at the end lol

I’m around, just doing stuff too. I see you appeals and it’s giving me pause, but I think it might be too late for me to change tactic now. And mafia can make appeals too.
It’s making my head hurt, for a game that is likely over for me.

Also happy birthday

At some point it might just be worth revisiting your “lock towns” is all I’m saying. Don’t get distracted by the couple main suspects out there. Mafia love that

Ok well I was hoping for more input. If it goes badly, don’t just focus on Alison vs Seanzie. Look at some of those people not being discussed a lot. BoK and Kyle are worth a second look

Kylemii wrote: ↑Tue Mar 23, 2021 1:26 amoh jesus

Just keep asking til you get an answer

Quin wrote: ↑Tue Mar 23, 2021 1:19 am
fingersplints wrote: ↑Mon Mar 22, 2021 8:08 pm @ts account no one is cleared in my books because they say they wouldn’t do something. I get that other people have said it’s unlikely too, but you aren’t confirmed by all means.
And you can say “we can worry about this later.” But I might not have that option.
Part of me thinks I should shoot Quin as that is the biggest suspect, but the other part of me thinks I should shoot someone else while you all lynch Quin today anyway. I could get a mafia or worst case scenario clear someone not with some suspicion. Thinking nanook? Dunno
or maybe we can not kill quin at all. i'd like that a lot.

i get that you want to be diplomatic or whatever but this road is only going to net you a dead civilian. the only question is whether it's you via shooting me or me via lynch.

gth i'm immune, whos on your shooting shortlist?

I mentioned I was previously considering someone on my “middle suspicion” list such as nanook.

Hosts aren’t around now it doesn’t seem, and I’m going to sleep so I guess the shooting will happen tomorrow. That’ll give @MartinGG99 some time to chime in.
Probably just assume discussion should center around a lynch target who is not quin at this point

Well that’s probably where we are at

Well as I’ve posted you as my most trusted, it would be nonsensical to shoot you, because if I am right I die, then as you said you will get nightkilled. I’m really not going to entertain that option.

Alison wrote: ↑Tue Mar 23, 2021 12:26 am
fingersplints wrote: ↑Mon Mar 22, 2021 6:34 pm So I’m thinking if the mafia chose me that means I’m likely wrong about a couple things lol not to figure out what.
I suspect mafia chose you because you're the most obvious town. There's too much WIFOM to just choose the person with the worse reads, plus they'll likely out and ask the town to vote on their shot choice anyway.

The group is saying all different people and at the end of the day I have to make the decision. That is where my personal suspicions would come into play.

Alison wrote: ↑Tue Mar 23, 2021 12:37 am
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Tue Mar 23, 2021 12:06 am Either it hits mafia or it confirms her and pseudo confirms martin which is two clears for the price of one

Yeah I'd probably shoot her atp
I'm ok with this, just give me time to get my legacy in order. I'm pretty sure I want Quin dead, still trying to sort out Seanzie and you (leaning town on him atm but unclear, because he veers between townie mindset and heavily scumsiding; as for you you've been like POE since yesterday and nothing has changed that)

Why is everyone ok with my shooting them? If you are town, I die, so I really don’t understand the “let me get my legacy in order” posts.

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Mon Mar 22, 2021 9:17 pm If you want to shoot me that's fine, just give me a couple hours to leave a legacy

I pretty strongly believe the shot should be someone in the poe to try and clear it quicker

why would you need a couple hours? If you were town and shot, you would survive.

Kylemii wrote: ↑Mon Mar 22, 2021 8:34 pm fingersplints i lov e your for saying "beesperado"

I wish I could take credit for it, but it’s not I you love

our hosts are clever little bee keepers

I don’t want the shot to monopolise the thread. You guys still have a lynch. So it might be better sooner, rather then later. But I was hoping to get a few more opinions first.

Oh I wrote some of that weird. Well hope you all get the gist. I’m multitasking

@ts account no one is cleared in my books because they say they wouldn’t do something. I get that other people have said it’s unlikely too, but you aren’t confirmed by all means.
And you can say “we can worry about this later.” But I might not have that option.
Part of me thinks I should shoot Quin as that is the biggest suspect, but the other part of me thinks I should shoot someone else while you all lynch Quin today anyway. I could get a mafia or worst case scenario clear someone not with some suspicion. Thinking nanook? Dunno

ts account wrote: ↑Mon Mar 22, 2021 7:52 pm safest shot is quin, just cleans up yesterday's wagons and gives us a better idea of the movement

I disagree. I voted for Quin. Why would they give me a shot, when the most likely person I would shoot is them? I think I got to go for one of the more mid suspicious people

@Seanzie i love it. If I die in this game today, I will still be happy because this game gave me glow text lol If I could write all my posts in glow, I would.

Where is Alison when I need her
Hope she feels like playing today. I need guidance

I don’t think ratrug was “so obviously townie” but at the same time I do think it’s suspicious how many votes they got and last minute too. I wouldn’t be surprised if mafia voted there, but to go for someone “so obviously townie” as you say, there would have had to been a reason. Who were the others in danger? Was it quin and Seanzie? Was the ratrug push a save

Search found 106 matches