The Syndicate

You guys are a bunch of asses.

Oh, Chris. Thanks for trusting in me. I have no idea why you did but thank you. I thought I was playing real civvie like and it felt nice to be trusted.

linki: I guess my gut got me killed.

Linki 2: I wouldn't have checked you because I was sure your role wasn't able to be recruited. I was so wrong about that.

LET ME POST!!!!!!!!!!!!!

To my lovely hosts, I had so much fun this game. No matter any of the conflicts or what not. Nothing took away from my fun. I loved my role. So many nights I had to stay up late to find something to check, which meant I had to have some drinks. I thank you for that. Some much of my fun was trying to find something. I did set up SVS because I wanted to check her out. Roxy I caught because I couldn't check her statement to get a real result. I only did check Enrique because of page 19 (I think it was page 19). I would have suspected him for that even if I hadn't checked him.

I can't believe I was right about Dom, it was just a complete gut feeling. He was playing such a good game I figured he was protecting a role like that. Dom left nothing to check that I could find.

As my first time as a LD (that I can remember), the role works, it works well, it works tricky like. It was awesome.

I'm sorry that civvies didn't win, they played hard this game. The game was fun, that's a win for me.

bea wrote:

keys56000000000 wrote:Balls! I gotta ask, is this the first time you've been killed as a couple in a mafia game, LC & BR? RIP guys. RIP.

I'm gonna go ahead and vote Bass.

I'm not gonna lie, I was curious about that myself. Part of why it took me so long to write it was because I thought it might have been the first time they both died the same night. I wanted to make it special.

It's how I want to go in RL. Husband has my back and we go out fighting!

Epignosis wrote:

Black Rock wrote:I voted for Woman Wept.

You're singing it wrong.

It's, "No Woman, No Cry."

My mistake, I'll do better next time.

I voted for Woman Wept.

I voted for Bass. I am suspicious of DFaraday but somethings and given me pause on him so I am going to revisit that tomorrow.

Chris wrote:

zeek wrote:

S~V~S wrote:Your paranoia is blinding you, my friend.

I have to agree with this.

Chris, set out your Cyber team, recruited team and the remaining civs for me. I'm trying to follow this but it seems a mess.

zeek, I have. To be honest, I'm wary of you as well, since MP helped get you rezzed.

But, here you go:

CyberController - Epig
Role blocker - Bass
Cyber Head - Snow Dog

recruiter - SVS
recruited - keys and MP.

I think there's a chance that keys is The Master.


I'm moving my vote to SVS. I think if the recruiter dies, the recruited go back to normal, and I for one want a non-recruited civvie MP back.

*votes SVS*

SVS can't be the recruiter.

Epignosis wrote:

Chris wrote:I don't like the thought of a DF lynch at all.

You don't?

Cool.

You boys

Turnip Head wrote:BR, if it helps any re: DF, I think that some if not all of last night's targets were redirected.

Awwww... that does help a lot.

Turnip Head wrote:BR who are your top suspects and why?

I suspect DFaraday. Something weird happened last night that I can't find how it would happen so I am still unsure about him. I also suspect Epig and Dom. Dom is actually my main suspect for The Master. I just can't pull anything together to support my gut feel on that.

Turnip Head wrote:What does everyone think of SVS so far? I've not seen her take any heat yet but I also don't see anyone vouching for her or trusting her. It feels like something is missing from her game but I can't quite place my finger on it. Less conducive to open discussion? Her posts seem to go down carefully mapped avenues of thought, unlike those of a freewheeling baddie hunter.

I'm probably voting for Bass but that seems like yesterday's news already. Bass hasn't said or done anything to make me doubt the evidence against him. I brought up a point about Bass saying he went back and read old games of Made's and Enrique's in order to figure out they were bad. It sounded like bulloney to me and he never responded to it. I think he got rolechecker info on one or both of them and dressed it up as his own research. Especially considering Bass doesn't have many contributions to the discussion this game, that point really sticks out.

I have said several times that I think she is civvie and trust her. Unless the recruiter is civvie she is not the recruiter. She may have been recruited but we still don't know how many can be recruited. It could have been only one.

Chris wrote:LC, if I were to ask you to vote for MP tonight, and leave it there for it to count, would you?

This would be under the understanding that I don't want to lynch him at all, and if someone were to add a vote to him, you could immediately remove your own.

The reason I'd ask you to do this is to chase a lead.

Would you be willing to do this?


Black Rock, I'd like to know your answer to the above scenario as well...

Chase a lead? I don't know how this would be helpful.

Chris wrote:

Black Rock wrote:

Chris wrote:LC, I just wanted to point out about Epig's point of Sabie the role checker voting for me twice.

First, since when does anyone trust a baddie?

A baddie pointed my way to Sabie and that's the main reason I voted for Sabie. I feel like that statement isn't entirely correct.

I meant more along the lines of why would you trust an accusation from a known baddie? I mean, is it unheard of for a baddie to try to take a civ down with them?

It could happen, but they are more likely to take down a baddie.

Chris wrote:There's a big difference in Roxy saying something that caused me to look into two players and find baddie evidence, and Epig discerning that a baddie Sabie must have role checked me and started voting for me because I'm The Master.

ok, I see what you are saying.

Linki: Hehehe

Chris wrote:LC, I just wanted to point out about Epig's point of Sabie the role checker voting for me twice.

First, since when does anyone trust a baddie?

A baddie pointed my way to Sabie and that's the main reason I voted for Sabie. I feel like that statement isn't entirely correct.

Snow Dog wrote:

Black Rock wrote:

Snow Dog wrote:

S~V~S wrote:

Dom wrote:

Snow Dog wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:I do think you might be onto something, Chris. Honestly, I was starting to wonder about Snow Dog as D8 developed and I was dead, because he is vastly different from earlier, civvie Snow Dog 1.0 who was very unsure of himself -- and then, together with Bass, was trying to push Hedge being the recruiter, and I don't think I saw any real reason other than the obvious Rox-Hedge connection which doesn't make sense to me. This would have been maybe to keep heat off of their teammate, Sabie?

I am still unsure. My worry is that Chris is Amy Pond. My bigger worry is that he is the Master. As for Hedge....well it's a hunch. Not absolutely sure of it but what can one do? I've been told i follow other people leads. Well i've been doing that since Snow dog 1.0 and look what happene
d to me there. If I don't have any ideas myself of course i follow other peoples suspicions. Always have. always will.

SD 1 found it hard to get in the game. Big cast, new personalities, I had not played a while and i was rusty. i got lynched for that.
Now there are fewer here and i've warmed up.

I do not understand your conjecture that Chris is Amy Pond given that no one died in place of him. My understanding is that Rory would have died instead.

Also don't get why Chris would role hint one of two civvies if he was a third civvie. That would make him look very suspish to the real Sarah Jane & Cap'n Jack, for no real gain.

Linki~ good point.

I presume because he wouldn't be allowed to say who he was? So if he was Amy, he couldn't say so, but he wanted ppl to know he was civ so he offered to roles that he was not with similsr reason for surviving.

but maybe you are right and he wouldn't do that and he is indeed the Master.

Hosts Is it allowed for a player to say "I am either A or B"?

Really? Game play is game play and you shouldn't ask the hosts to play the game for you.

I find myself unsure of the rules of mafia. i simply want it clarified whether this is role dropping or not. But if you like i withdraw the question and invite players opinions on the matter.

I guess everyone has their own opinion on this. Role claiming can be true or false and it's up to the individual player to believe it or not. One team had a dead role checker which would help them false role claim knowing what civvies were dead or not.

Snow Dog wrote:

S~V~S wrote:

Dom wrote:

Snow Dog wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:I do think you might be onto something, Chris. Honestly, I was starting to wonder about Snow Dog as D8 developed and I was dead, because he is vastly different from earlier, civvie Snow Dog 1.0 who was very unsure of himself -- and then, together with Bass, was trying to push Hedge being the recruiter, and I don't think I saw any real reason other than the obvious Rox-Hedge connection which doesn't make sense to me. This would have been maybe to keep heat off of their teammate, Sabie?

I am still unsure. My worry is that Chris is Amy Pond. My bigger worry is that he is the Master. As for Hedge....well it's a hunch. Not absolutely sure of it but what can one do? I've been told i follow other people leads. Well i've been doing that since Snow dog 1.0 and look what happene
d to me there. If I don't have any ideas myself of course i follow other peoples suspicions. Always have. always will.

SD 1 found it hard to get in the game. Big cast, new personalities, I had not played a while and i was rusty. i got lynched for that.
Now there are fewer here and i've warmed up.

I do not understand your conjecture that Chris is Amy Pond given that no one died in place of him. My understanding is that Rory would have died instead.

Also don't get why Chris would role hint one of two civvies if he was a third civvie. That would make him look very suspish to the real Sarah Jane & Cap'n Jack, for no real gain.

Linki~ good point.

I presume because he wouldn't be allowed to say who he was? So if he was Amy, he couldn't say so, but he wanted ppl to know he was civ so he offered to roles that he was not with similsr reason for surviving.

but maybe you are right and he wouldn't do that and he is indeed the Master.

Hosts Is it allowed for a player to say "I am either A or B"?

Really? Game play is game play and you shouldn't ask the hosts to play the game for you.

Chris wrote:

Black Rock wrote:

Chris wrote:BR, did you say you felt very confident of Elo being a civ?

Can you elaborate?


LINKI @ TH: Good point. I agree Bass is likely Cyber. We just need to come together on who that last one is...

Unless she's recruited I am confidant that she is a civvie. It's hard to elaborate as it's hard to explain ones beliefs. When she was targeted for a kill she was a civvie. I don't know what's going on with these recruitments, I don't know if it was just one recruitment or unlimited. For now I trust her.

I trust you in this game BR.

In doing some research, I've uncovered a scenario that could show Elo to possibly be The Master. It's a touch thin, but there's some meat too... Vote evidence type shit.

But if you're pretty certain, I'll put that one away.


How do you feel about Dana then? MP has vouched really heavily for her. And she's been MIA for days and days. Do you have reason to trust MP's assessment of her. And shit, while we're at it, MP is also saying Daisy was 100% civ. Do you agree with that?

If she's the Master I have been completely snowed. I don't think she is.

What do you think about Dom?

Chris wrote:BR, did you say you felt very confident of Elo being a civ?

Can you elaborate?


LINKI @ TH: Good point. I agree Bass is likely Cyber. We just need to come together on who that last one is...

Unless she's recruited I am confidant that she is a civvie. It's hard to elaborate as it's hard to explain ones beliefs. When she was targeted for a kill she was a civvie. I don't know what's going on with these recruitments, I don't know if it was just one recruitment or unlimited. For now I trust her.

Long Con wrote:I think that panoplied Master Black Rock Lucy Saxon thing could very well be indecorous a "recruit".

I reword target believe overhaul the Cyberman Body scherif a secret gymnosophist.

Excuse me?

Fantastic! Glad to have you back MP!

Hedgeowl wrote:

Dom wrote:

Chris wrote:

Dom wrote:

Turnip Head wrote:How does Chris's case make sense for Sabie being a Dalek? I don't see that angle.

The Daleks would have wanted to delay Made's lynch, no? They would have wanted to keep that under wraps so Made wouldn't be NK'd, right?

I think the Daleks would have wanted to delay it, yes. But I think that if the Cybers knew that they couldn't kill Made with a lynch, they knew they could kill Rico. So they all switched to Rico. If they had managed to lynch Rico the day Made was lynched, then we tried to lynch Made the next day, Strax wouldn't be able to NK him, and we'd waste another lynch on Made.

Or, like I said before, they could have just wanted to lynch someone who can die...

WHY?
Why wouldn't the Cybermen want to leave the thread mired in useless Made lynches?
This is the part that I am not following at all?

I think the important point is that Roxy a dalek voted for. Made over enri because he would survive. If sabie is a cyber and knew made AND enri's role then she would vote Enri necause he would actaully get lynched and have a role reveal, then the evidence would point to made again who had been defending him. Thats the theory that makes some sense to me. I am not totally convinced Epi might be a cyber, because of his initial suspicion of enri as epi. 1.0. I feel better about a sabie vote at this pojnt.

Linki i am wondering the same. Why not just want to lynch epi chris?

I feel the same way.

I voted for Sabie. I believe that Chris' role hint (slap in the face) was truthful. The only way he is baddie would be if he's recruited and I not willing to lynch him based on that. I also believe that Sabie is bad so I'm ok with braking the tie.

I can't get it to work, figure I missed it.

Epignosis wrote:

Black Rock wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

Long Con wrote:Epignosis, Mafia are your thoughts on Sabie? Have you given them harrowing blocking past?

sabie tricked me once in Felt Mafia. I was bad, but hers was a priority role (civilian BTSC that could be recruited by the SK). I went the entire time not believing that she had BTSC. She's been quiet here, but she was quiet in Felt (41 posts in 8 Days there). At this stage I do not suspect her.

I can never read you, I think you like it that way. Are you bad?

In tennis? Yes.
In the kitchen? No.
In Fantasy Football? Yes, yes, no and no.
In business? Terribly so.
In bed? Sample size too small.
In Dr. Who Mafia? No and no. I don't have a bad role, and I think I've done a good job voting and paying attention. So much so that the biggest accusation against me is that I'm a role checker or on a team with a role checker. It reminds me of the semester I got called into a professor's office because she was convinced I had plagiarized my essay.

nothing is ever simple with you. I think the same thing happened to LC, maybe it was a poem... I can't remember.

Epignosis wrote:

Long Con wrote:Epignosis, Mafia are your thoughts on Sabie? Have you given them harrowing blocking past?

sabie tricked me once in Felt Mafia. I was bad, but hers was a priority role (civilian BTSC that could be recruited by the SK). I went the entire time not believing that she had BTSC. She's been quiet here, but she was quiet in Felt (41 posts in 8 Days there). At this stage I do not suspect her.

I can never read you, I think you like it that way. Are you bad?

Black Rock wrote:I think LC is saying he knows exactly what happened and it's in the roles.

Who survived NK's?
MP - Very good civvie - prize
Elo - Civvie by proof
Me - Civvie, survived by block
LC - Civvie, survived by something he knows
Chris - Civvie, role

Did I miss something? I do believe they all could be civvies and the baddies are playing low key and off the radar.

I believe all the people above are civvies. I am also confidant that SVS is good and I believe MP was very confidant that Dana is a civvie. Also Chris being civvie is truthful.

I am likely voting Sabie today and if she is indeed the baddie I think she is then I will be looking at Epig.

I think this post was misunderstood. I was saying they are civvie because of why they survived. I was saying I think they are civvie and the reason they survived. I also updated it better.

Chris wrote:

Black Rock wrote:I think LC is saying he knows exactly what happened and it's in the roles.

Who survived NK's?
MP - Very good civvie
Elo - Civvie by proof
Me - Civvie, survived by block
LC - Civvie, survived by something he knows

Did I miss something? I do believe they all could be civvies and the baddies are playing low key and off the radar.

I believe all the people above are civvies. I am also confidant that SVS is good and I believe MP was very confidant that Dana is a civvie. Also Chris being civvie is truthful.

I am likely voting Sabie today and if she is indeed the baddie I think she is then I will be looking at Epig.

2 things BR.

You left me off, and I know I survived for a very civ reason.

Elo surviving Strax's kill attempt doesn''t automatically make her a civ, in my opinion. She could have been any of the baddie roles with a NK protection, and she would have survived Strax's kill just the same as if she was civ.

I missed this post. I did leave you out. I totally forgot you did survive and most recently. I do believe you survived for civvie reasons as well. I have a different reason for believing Elo is a civvie on top of her survive.

Chris wrote:Also, I know you're biased, but you include yourself in there in a way that suggests that all of those kill survivals you listed were survived in a way that makes them civvie.

You listed yourself in there.

How does a killer being blocked show you are civ?

It doesn't. Surviving a kill doesn't make you baddie either. So it's up to you to believe I am a civvie or not. I am a civvie, that's the truth.

Turnip Head wrote:Interesting BR. I may have missed your reasoning on Sabie and how you're connecting her to Epi. Can you quickly summarize it for me?

I don't think Roxy was lying when she connected them.

I think LC is saying he knows exactly what happened and it's in the roles.

Who survived NK's?
MP - Very good civvie
Elo - Civvie by proof
Me - Civvie, survived by block
LC - Civvie, survived by something he knows

Did I miss something? I do believe they all could be civvies and the baddies are playing low key and off the radar.

I believe all the people above are civvies. I am also confidant that SVS is good and I believe MP was very confidant that Dana is a civvie. Also Chris being civvie is truthful.

I am likely voting Sabie today and if she is indeed the baddie I think she is then I will be looking at Epig.

Not a surprising night. I mean, MP and LC were both targeted.

RIP MP.

I am very interested to hear from Sabie, I really think Roxy did know some things and was throwing it out there before she died. What do you think about that Epig? It's hard for me to mistrust you right now but I have no reason to trust you either.

Chris wrote:The MM lynch was the one that ended early.

If Epig is with MP, that lynch could have been a choice of picking the lesser of the two evils with MP. Or it could have just been a matter of it ending early and screwing up any possible plans.

I highly suggest you all re-read MP with the mind that he could be The Master, and that Roxy and MM were both recruited.

It starts to look very interesting.

Then remember the people vouching for MP or intereacting with MP a lot. LC, Epig, SVS... all people I'd recruit if I was a recruiting Indy killer.

I'm not making a case that he is The Master. I need someone else's view on the possibility. Someone who is not LC, Epig, SVS, or Hedgie please.

I think, in order for MP to be a civ, he can only be one role. And it doesn't make much sense that people would be saying they think he's a civ based on anything role related.

Black Rock, you were targeted. What do you think of the possibility that MP is The Master?

I just saw this on a reread. I am very confidant that MP is a civvie and I even have him pegged as a role. I don't think he is the Master.

sabie12 wrote:Yay! We got all the Daleks! I was wary of Roxy for awhile there. I am voting salad because I'm trying to eat healthier and I'm craving a delicious salad right now. Still unsure about Chris and how he survived those two attempts on his life. I guess we shall see how things go.

What do you think of Roxy's accusations against you?

Long Con wrote:I don't know if an Indy whose win condition includes killing all Civvies would pass an "I am not a baddie" lie detect, since that's, like, THE definition of a baddie's goal.

Ok, for some reason I thought you were saying the opposite.

Black Rock wrote:

Long Con wrote:Roxy was a really nice two-for-one. Took out the last Dalek, and diminished this Mystery Recruiter's team by one at the same time. Very good lynch! I think we have to assume that this recruiter is a "baddie"... which applies to an Indy who needs the Civvies dead to win. Though I don't know if the distinction would matter to a Lie Detector... Ideally, it's an Indy recruiter who is just a Last Man Standing kind of deal, but it's probably best to assume the worst.

So where's this phantom Insanifier? Is Jackie Tyler finally dead?

What do you mean?

Well that bold didn't stick out enough...

Long Con wrote:Roxy was a really nice two-for-one. Took out the last Dalek, and diminished this Mystery Recruiter's team by one at the same time. Very good lynch! I think we have to assume that this recruiter is a "baddie"... which applies to an Indy who needs the Civvies dead to win. Though I don't know if the distinction would matter to a Lie Detector... Ideally, it's an Indy recruiter who is just a Last Man Standing kind of deal, but it's probably best to assume the worst.

So where's this phantom Insanifier? Is Jackie Tyler finally dead?

What do you mean?

bea wrote:[b
Roxy has been Lynched. She was Dalek 2. She was Recruited. You have 24 hours to do what you need to do.
The Daleks have been Exterminated. [/b]

Roxy you were a naughty girl, you tried to kill me? That hurt.

What is this recruited thing? Is it the Master or a secret role?

Chris wrote:

Black Rock wrote:*glares at Chris*

Chris wrote:Jesus keys, don't vote for me.

I don't want to quit. There are so many players who just aren't even playing. Why take out an actual participating player? Is that what this game has come to? Participators are killed, and non posters live?

That's not a fun game. I want to live and hunt baddies. That's a fun game.

I just don't want her to feel like she should be lynched because she didn't participate in a way that someone else would find an acceptable level for this day phase. It brings up a whole different issue I have, you got the brunt of it because it was the latest insulting post I had read.

Elohcin wrote:I voted for Roxy. Sorry I didn't contribute anything today.

You don't need to apologize, you play the way you need to play. *glares at Chris*

S~V~S wrote:

Black Rock wrote:

S~V~S wrote:Knowing which role you hinted at would go far for me, Chris. But I can't find it, I suck at in your face role hints, semi hints are beyond me.

I won't vote for Roxy, I at least suspect you. I am not getting the Roxy votes from people who don't seem to suspect her, and never mentioned her previously, like Ninjajujube. Snowy is being consistent in his Roxy suspish, but not sure where Ninjube is coming from.

I'm not completely convinced on the Roxy vote either. I somewhat suspect her for her Non-LD statement that she claimed was solid. Not completely though. Do you have any better ideas for me to look at? I respect your opinion here.

You did mention her previously; no did Snowy~ I am not understanding Ninjas vote mostly, I guess. I also know she has a really good reason not to be here defending, and people are lynching her anyhow. But that is my personal feelings talking. She does not "feel" bad to me, and i think i read her pretty well, she has this sinister thing going on when shes bad, that i just don't see here.

I suspect Epi, as i have, and i suspect Chris. I guess my thoughts on Chris have a lot to do with LC~ he feels civ to me, and I think he is a pretty astute civ. What are your thoughts on LC?

Linki~ O...K.... you know, I noticed that when you posted it, but forgot it. I had to go back and look at a role to check.

OK, Chris. I will buy what you are selling. But I am gonna vote for Epi, not Roxy. I HATE lynching people who can't defend. I got lynched once on the day of a good friends funeral, coming home to that was like the rancid cherry on top of the poisoned ice cream sundae that was my day that day.

I believe LC is a civvie this game. I try not to let his opinion sway me in Mafia as we so easily do it in RL. LC can be really good at catching baddies but I'm usually better! All joking aside, sometimes he can let one thing cloud his judgement and I'm not sure if we're seeing that here. I'm not completely confidant here, Chris could just be snowing me and I could be wrong about Roxy. If she is a civ, then she shouldn't have been dishonest about a LD statement that really had no business being a topic or being used in a case. I feel really strongly about it, and the way she worded hers while building a case on Epig about his usage. Something is just off about that.

Chris wrote:

S~V~S wrote:Knowing which role you hinted at would go far for me, Chris. But I can't find it, I suck at in your face role hints, semi hints are beyond me.

I won't vote for Roxy, I at least suspect you. I am not getting the Roxy votes from people who don't seem to suspect her, and never mentioned her previously, like Ninjajujube. Snowy is being consistent in his Roxy suspish, but not sure where Ninjube is coming from.

I posted this day 6.

http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 543#p90543



As for Roxy, I have to wonder how she knew Rico was bad. She seems to know Made was bad too, whom we all suspect was also a Dalek. She voted Made with a very made up reason. She accused the hell outta Epig as being the role checker... maybe she's the role checker. How else did she pinpoint to Dalek players? And she's barely been involved. Involved enough to paint them, but not much else.

That's why I can vote for her without worry. I think there's a chance she's a baddie.

Interesting. Is there a good point to read and see all of that? I know about Epig, but the other two I must have missed. I mean we all were pretty sure about Enrique and Made. Was there something specific that seemed like she knew more?

S~V~S wrote:Knowing which role you hinted at would go far for me, Chris. But I can't find it, I suck at in your face role hints, semi hints are beyond me.

I won't vote for Roxy, I at least suspect you. I am not getting the Roxy votes from people who don't seem to suspect her, and never mentioned her previously, like Ninjajujube. Snowy is being consistent in his Roxy suspish, but not sure where Ninjube is coming from.

I'm not completely convinced on the Roxy vote either. I somewhat suspect her for her Non-LD statement that she claimed was solid. Not completely though. Do you have any better ideas for me to look at? I respect your opinion here.

I'm still deciding who I'm going to vote for. It's tempting to vote Chris just for some of the crap he's been posting. I think there is a chance that he might be one of the roles that he has role claimed so I won't. It's a time I wish I could be on the other side and not care.

Between the two lead vote getters at this point I think we have a better chance of Roxy flipping bad so I am likely voting her and not wasting my vote. Hell, I just talked myself into it so I can make sure I don't miss the vote this time. *votes*

Dom wrote:

Black Rock wrote:

Roxy wrote:Epi - what do you think of sabie saying she needs to read through things but knows enough to know that we are discussing lie detectors?
They would not waste 8 nights if they just check the one that says I am a good girl.

Actually, good girl is not a checkable statement. This type of behaviour is suspect to me. You were all over Epig for his statement, and yet you do the same type and want to be "Look, I'm a civvie. I have been ever so cooperative with a LD statement."

Epignosis wrote:Yes, I'm sure the lie detector would like to spend 8 Nights checking those.

This is a valid statement Roxy.

I know I'm a little late to the press on this one, but I don't understand how Roxy can have a valid argument when her statements suck just as much as Epigs.

BR I can't remember but did you agree with Roxys cSe on Epig? I'm on my phone and screwing up my multiquoted posts so I don't really wanna check for that

I looked over her case, but I have my own theory on Epig Vs Enrique. My theory leaves Epig as neutral to me. He could be bad or good, I can't be sure.

Crap, I thought this posted an hour ago. Now I will catch up.

Roxy wrote:Epi - what do you think of sabie saying she needs to read through things but knows enough to know that we are discussing lie detectors?
They would not waste 8 nights if they just check the one that says I am a good girl.

Actually, good girl is not a checkable statement. This type of behaviour is suspect to me. You were all over Epig for his statement, and yet you do the same type and want to be "Look, I'm a civvie. I have been ever so cooperative with a LD statement."

Epignosis wrote:Yes, I'm sure the lie detector would like to spend 8 Nights checking those.

This is a valid statement Roxy.

I know I'm a little late to the press on this one, but I don't understand how Roxy can have a valid argument when her statements suck just as much as Epigs.

Interesting. So I'm pretty sure LC and MP are both civvies, so I'm not liking Chris' lynch list atm.

I'm not sure who I am going to vote yet but there are at least four people I won't be voting for.

Long Con wrote:

Black Rock wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:Now, to clarify, I'm not advocating that I think BR is bad necessarily, nor that we should vote people who survive NKs. But I do think it is necessary to keep in mind those who survive kills and say they don't know how, ESPECIALLY if they survive 2+ NKs. That's when it starts becoming noteworthy.

I'm suspicious because I didn't know why I survived? I would think it should be if I did.

Well, Jack Harkness and Sarah Jane would both know why they survived, and not be suspicious because of it... whereas the invincible baddies are another story. It's a pretty good balance, really, makes it harder for players to simply pigeonhole a survivor into one or the other.

Fair enough.

I think the target was blocked and that's how I survived. When I thought through the night post. I didn't have super powers and walked through a wall. They were literally blocked by a brick wall. That's my theory anyways.

MovingPictures07 wrote:Now, to clarify, I'm not advocating that I think BR is bad necessarily, nor that we should vote people who survive NKs. But I do think it is necessary to keep in mind those who survive kills and say they don't know how, ESPECIALLY if they survive 2+ NKs. That's when it starts becoming noteworthy.

I'm suspicious because I didn't know why I survived? I would think it should be if I did.