The Syndicate

Sloonei wrote:hey soneji why shouldn't I shoot you?

Because I'm town.

I saw Nutella cleared JJJ, though I'm not sure I exactly trust that. Nutella had been being buddy-buddy with JJJ early on and I don't care for JJJ's vote history. Nutella's push was maybe the biggest reason the Marmot lynch gained traction, so what's not to trust about it? If JJJ ever ends up scum,...

I saw Nutella cleared JJJ, though I'm not sure I exactly trust that. Nutella had been being buddy-buddy with JJJ early on and I don't care for JJJ's vote history. Nutella's push was maybe the biggest reason the Marmot lynch gained traction, so what's not to trust about it? If JJJ ever ends up scum,...

So I've been both busy IRL and with running my own game on NF, disheartened with how far behind I've become in this game. I have tried just reading the last couple pages and looking into my suspects from before, along with vote counts from the first two lynches. The thing that stood out to me most w...

@Jay in regards to the sig lynch: I would say Syndicate regulars with their familiarity with sig mislynches come off looking the worst in general, yourself and Golden in particular as starters of that wagon. I can't really agree that "Are there any good reasons not to lynch sig" is a good ...

I will switch to Wilgy if Fredwood doesn't take off. Sig hasn't struck me as anything more than a slight scumread. His talk of the map came off well as him being relaxed enough to be silly and I've liked his interactions past that. Wilgy hasn't provided any contributions despite the very long day ph...

Out of all the people I've had some suspicion on today, this one is the strongest. I had some doubts about culture clash but the more I see from Silver Lantern and JoH, the less his posts are excusable. They both have been in the thick of things, not using their unfamiliarity with the posters/style...

The silly argument is that saying the amount of towncred that might be achievable with what Dys pulled is worth the high possibility of getting lynched, especially when hammer rules are in play. I haven't seen a single person give actual town cred to Dys. Several people are still voting for Dys bas...

That latter post of Soneji is not something I like. It's shutting down opposition to something that by all rights should be discussed until everyone's sick of talking about it. Says the queen of tinfoil. i do not know what relevance tinfoil as a concept has to my post, so this just feels like you'r...

Given you had read the thread through this far and should know that I'd explained at least part of my rationale for why I hadn't voted yet - how do you come to a legitimate vote for me later? I have no real excuse. The first post was part of a quick 12-page skim, the second was a post just looking ...

Given you had read the thread through this far and should know that I'd explained at least part of my rationale for why I hadn't voted yet - how do you come to a legitimate vote for me later? I have no real excuse. The first post was part of a quick 12-page skim, the second was a post just looking ...

That latter post of Soneji is not something I like. It's shutting down opposition to something that by all rights should be discussed until everyone's sick of talking about it. Says the queen of tinfoil. i do not know what relevance tinfoil as a concept has to my post, so this just feels like you'r...

Quin wrote:That latter post of Soneji is not something I like. It's shutting down opposition to something that by all rights should be discussed until everyone's sick of talking about it.

Says the queen of tinfoil.

It wouldn't be a brilliant scum play as there is no true benefit for Dys in doing it, while it had a strong chance of getting them lynched with the hammer vote in place. Let's be clear that Dys is not getting town cred for his fake slip, proving that it was just that only removes him from the obvio...

It wouldn't be a brilliant scum play as there is no true benefit for Dys in doing it, while it had a strong chance of getting them lynched with the hammer vote in place. Let's be clear that Dys is not getting town cred for his fake slip, proving that it was just that only removes him from the obviou...

Polls are usually kept in a separate thread Silver Lantern. That may not be the case here, so you could ask Spirityo if you're allowed to screenshot them. You said mafia don't have much reason to vote together here though, which is true but altogether an unhelpful statement that could only serve to...

Not only does Dys link show him making the exact same play but it happened just last month. There might be room to be skeptical if he had to dig up something from years ago but as is there is nothing to contest.

Polls are usually kept in a separate thread Silver Lantern. That may not be the case here, so you could ask Spirityo if you're allowed to screenshot them. You said mafia don't have much reason to vote together here though, which is true but altogether an unhelpful statement that could only serve to ...

I don't take issue with Silver Lantern's defensiveness in response to Quin given that it was a misunderstanding anyway, and I also just generally think "defensiveness" isn't a very interesting tell in the first place. I feel like I see that accusation hurled constantly in Mafia and that i...

Hi everyone. Apologies for dumb questions ahead of time, I will be asking them all game and for games to come too. DO NOT GIVE ME THE MAP, I REPEAT, DO NOT GIVE ME THE MAP. Alright, now that I got the reverse psychology argument out of the way, should we try to coordinate the poll votes, or would t...

So this marks the second time a CFD is run on me when I leave for awhile. Sigh.

thellama73 wrote:
Soneji wrote:Do you think that I specifically forget to mention my teammates as mafia, Llama?
Yeah.

Would you like to display your research to the class?

Do you think that I specifically forget to mention my teammates as mafia, Llama?

ebwop, I also want to do a hard reread of Epi if we get the other thread back. I found him to be an unexpected kill since it would have been fairly easy to drum suspicion on him. When I made the post I made about how he should not be ruled out as bussing Mac, it was becasue I was having a hard time...

Not sure why people think my meta comment had to do with Mac when it was in response to the suggestion of finding out who the sock puppets were so they could be meta read. Nor was it saying that we shouldn't be using meta, just that we shouldn't devote too much of our resources on just that one tool...

Meta is a crutch as it means you can't catch said person in any kind of slip or make a convincing case that their behavior is scummy on its own. It is a tool that can be used to scumhunt but I'd never rely on it. You would agree that it was successful in this instance though, yes? Since Mac flipped...

Meta is a crutch as it means you can't catch said person in any kind of slip or make a convincing case that their behavior is scummy on its own. It is a tool that can be used to scumhunt but I'd never rely on it. You would agree that it was successful in this instance though, yes? Since Mac flipped...

The only suspect of mine from D1 in here is Made, though I can't remember what exactly pinged me. Probably something similar to Made's post in here about speculating whose getting lynched in the other thread when it is irrelevant to who gets lynched here. As for my meta comments, it was in regards t...

I can only imagine a 40 player game in which everyone is highly invested. :scared: Such a thing is not possible. Even at the 70 player game we had last year, there were like 25 highly invested players, another 25 mildly invested ones, and maybe 20 inactives. It would be a nightmare. How am I suppos...

The lesson here is that different mindsets for scumhunting will always get me suspected on this site. My reasoning was sound and I was right in that Zebra was a baddie trying to push lynches on false pretenses, yet Golden found my logic suspicious. And I also thought your sprit vote looked like a b...

LOL Soneji. Recruitment Mafia 4. *drops mic* I checked it over and while it is complex in its own way, its not on the level of NF role madness. It is not really a competition though, as I have enjoyed the more global mechanics and event focused games on here. My Majora's Mask game has been influenc...

This is the closest I've seen on this site to the level of role madness I'm accustomed to. Will be interesting to see how those here handle it. What do you mean by "role madness"? Also, I signed up, forgot to earlier. What Spirityo referrred to as a clusterfuck, a game type where the majo...

My latest experiments have been playing around with generic roles in otherwise role madness games. My Zootopia game was a low level role madness game and I included a Mammal Initiative mechanic which allowed the generics to pick a different standard role type each cycle(vig, doctor, roleblocker, cop...

The lesson here is that different mindsets for scumhunting will always get me suspected on this site. My reasoning was sound and I was right in that Zebra was a baddie trying to push lynches on false pretenses, yet Golden found my logic suspicious.

Its funny how Golden's main reason of suspicion on me was for my suspicion on a member of the opposing mafia team

Pretty much just got unlucky that the one person who had a weird hang-up with me was a situational vig. The roll of the dice got me in this one, along with doing work on Clash of the Hosts.

Hey guys. Wilgy, Golden, Marco, MP, Zebra, Sorsha Imo, the vig should target those people first. In whatever order they prefer. Nothing personal guys, but I doubt more than two of you will manage to catch up before the game is over. 3 baddies, 1 cult leader and only 2 civs. :mafia: Lol, and I was s...

This is the closest I've seen on this site to the level of role madness I'm accustomed to. Will be interesting to see how those here handle it. What do you mean by "role madness"? Also, I signed up, forgot to earlier. What Spirityo referrred to as a clusterfuck, a game type where the majo...

This is the closest I've seen on this site to the level of role madness I'm accustomed to. Will be interesting to see how those here handle it.

What happens when you gather seven of the best hosts on the site and give them free reign on what roles they can submit? You get Clash of the Hosts:

https://forums.hero-academia.com/thread ... s.1091093/

Going to do a few ISO's as catching up normally at this time when I'm preparing to put up sign-ups for a big game on NF is just too much right now. As always, remember that I do not have town reads, just varying levels of scumreads. MP : Not a whole lot of content to work off of as hes perpetually i...

This will sound naturally suspicious coming from someone like me ( :grin: ) but I say there is a large number of people ruled out for this phase. Rather than focus on sprityo's team, I would like to have a crack at the other. That's a good deal harder than finding teammates. So there's where my foc...

This will sound naturally suspicious coming from someone like me ( :grin: ) but I say there is a large number of people ruled out for this phase. Rather than focus on sprityo's team, I would like to have a crack at the other. That's a good deal harder than finding teammates. So there's where my foc...

Thank you LC. General consensus. Do we think more baddies are openly discussing or hiding in the background? People always ask that for some reason and the most likely answer is always "both". There are 7 baddies in this game, I expect some of both kinds. But there is almost certainly a b...

insertnamehere wrote:I'd extend the same query to Sig and Soneji

I already gave my thoughts on LC. spirityo is voting for self preservation, which doesn't indicate much to me.

THE CASE AGAINST LONG CON I am willing to vote sprityo, LC, or DDL of those three names. DDL is, let's say, a kind of incendiary guy. I agree with the initial idea behind DDL's case against LC. LC has latched onto a few things DDL said that admittedly don't make complete sense, but are just used to...

DrWilgy wrote:Thank you LC.

General consensus. Do we think more baddies are openly discussing or hiding in the background?

The majority of votes at the moment are on active players with strong opinions, that would indicate the former. That its the middle of the holidays muddies the waters.

THE CASE AGAINST LONG CON I am willing to vote sprityo, LC, or DDL of those three names. DDL is, let's say, a kind of incendiary guy. I agree with the initial idea behind DDL's case against LC. LC has latched onto a few things DDL said that admittedly don't make complete sense, but are just used to...

What is a GTH and a CFD? Gun to head read. "If I had a gun to your head would you say this player is good or bad?" Chinese Fire Drill. The act of quickly forming a wagon on someone near EOD that results in their lynching. An example of a GTH would be that GTH, I would say Epi is scum as h...

Vote spread is consistent and bueno. What are the cases for DDL, LC, Sprityo and Sig? Also didn't we already off Sprit? What did New Sprityo do to warrant lynch 2? I'd like to say, for the record, that there IS no case against me. You're certainly the best person to ask when it comes to the validit...

Search found 572 matches