The Syndicate

The current course of this game does not appear to be directed towards your lynch this phase, splints. What do you make of MP's reversal on you?

it comes to my attention that i am not going to have much time at all during this day phase. expect me to be largely absent (at least by the standards of my activity level so far) all the way through the lynch deadline. i'll do my best to keep up with the thread and place an educated vote, but i ca...

MP, could you talk about the things that concern you about Turnip, your second most suspicious rainbowman? i am asking for a lot of perspectives on him because i think his team is likely to win the game (no matter which team it is) if he isn't sorted out very soon.

Roxy is going to blow up this thread when she next pays it a visit.

i could dig a full reads list from DDL especially.

that's a very surprising position for DDL, MP. what makes him your top town read at this point? I think he's the real deal. :srsnod: Of course, since I know no one's alignment with certainty, my lists are subject to change, but it's really just that I'm starting to question the green reads more, an...

Notice too that Rox defended Golden 1.0 hard and she's defended splints hard before. I think it's because she KNOWS they're civilians. Roxy also defended Bubbles hard on Day 2. valid points. What I'm afraid of is one of my green or higher is mafia, and I'm actually starting to wonder if it's Jay. I...

that's a very surprising position for DDL, MP. what makes him your top town read at this point?

I just got the sense of conviction that this is genuine and NOT forced. If she were a mafia, anyway, she wouldn't advocate that we lynch her first, and I felt that she really meant it here. understandable perspective, even if a bit WIFOM. you know splints better than i do. if anyone disagrees with ...

btw, i DO use blue in my rainbows... but only for confirmed townies. which nobody in this game will ever be.

Golden, could you describe in either briefly or verbosely what concerns you about Turnip?

most likely to be town G-Man sanmateo MovingPictures07 Bass_the_Clever swing players upon whom the game will likely be decided Turnip Head birdwithteeth11/Golden if he's mafia it is going to be a problem Vompatti strong defenses, but the case against is ever-growing Dragon D. Luffy most likely to y...

you're the first person to actually do a correct color scheme for a rainbow.

Golden wrote:JJ, could you repeat that in words I understand?

Do you mean, lets post our rainbows and compare them?

essentially yes. they don't have to be rainbows though.

i think we have a good opportunity now to bring our full reads spectrums together as a group, because if there's enough overlap then process of elimination will be a very reasonable objective.

question to everyone: how did you personally feel about splints' passionate outbursts during Night 3? MP seemingly has reversed his perspective which surprises me. i pose this question to everybody regardless of how much experience you have playing with her. my initial reaction was to trust her less...

when i try to compile potential scum teams, Roxy appears in essentially all of them at this point.

I'm terrible at coming up with questions, so here's some more music and music ranking questions: - Worst 5 albums you've ever heard and why Crazy Frog - Crazy Frog - honestly i just listened to this so i could fill the minimum rating slot on my RYM page DragonForce - Inhuman Rampage - when i ask my...

RIP Bubbles, thanks for playing with us. :) hope to play again, and you're certainly welcome to join us on RYM too if you ever care to. my immediate reaction to the current discussion re: Adam Smith is that it is too reliant upon the unknown to serve as the primary basis for a lynch. but i welcome t...

If there is only one mafia between splints and MP and i am asked to pick based only on THIS conversation, it'd be splints. Her candor seems exaggerrated.

Dead players can win this game. If my reads "paint targets" for the mafia, then i am literally dictating their kills for them. A wonderful strategic advantage.

But i don't think any targets are being painted.

Separately re: aether and the past game post i referenced. Yes i know she was town -- i was calling her suspicious for espousing the opposite perspective in this game. It's a highly specific meta and it may have contextual barriers to be examined (open setup vs closed -- in the game i referenced nob...

And JJJ, could you describe your method for looking for interactions (I mean technically speaking, because it seems like a big trawl)? I would like to do one of those of BR/you. I'm not particularly expecting to see anything, but I think it is not appropriate that you get a pass from the analysis b...

interactive analyses CLIFF NOTES players ranked from least suspicious to most suspicious purely for how i think their interactions with BR reflect on them G-Man Turnip Head MovingPictures07 sanmateo birdwithteeth11/Golden Vompatti Epignosis Roxy TinyBubbles Dragon D. Luffy fingersplints still plenty...

Meaningful interactions between/about Black Rock and Epignosis as recommended by Golden, to get a better idea of whether he was mafia or town. In case no one sees it, 3J thinks I smell like shit. To be fair, you often do. :grin: playful and probably meaningless affirmation of fecal stench. ;) I can'...

Meaningful interactions between/about Black Rock and Vompatti neither of them has mentioned the other once. BR didn't acknowledge Dom either. Vompatti has been busy fulfilling his enigmatic reputation so this isn't surprising. i won't give him a free pass for goofing around though. he has commented ...

Meaningful interactions between/about Black Rock and Turnip Head *Note: CTRL+F for "TH" is a nightmare. i'm calling him Turnip from now on. I want to hear more from BR. Did I miss something you asked? Nope. Does your opinion need to be solicited for you to share it? I feel like you're only...

IN NO PARTICULAR ORDER OTHER THAN ALPHABETICAL, HERE IS THE LONG AWAITED AETHER RAINBOW Bass_the_Clever G-Man JaggedJimmyJay MovingPictures07 sanmateo Vompatti birdwithteeth11 / Golden Dragon D. Luffy Roxy TinyBubbles fingersplints Turnip Head I have a personal preference for blue over green :beer:...

Meaningful interactions between/about Black Rock and TinyBubbles You got what you wanted TH, you put me back in the game and made me do work. I'm going to go ahead and vote TinyBubbles . :ponder: What? Sure, TinyBubbles was working on flawed logic but instead of questioning it you just jump right on...

Meaningful interactions between/about Black Rock and sanmateo BR had nothing to say to/about sanmateo. between fingersplints and black rock i would probably vote for the latter, because splints said she'd had bstc with turnip head but theyre not my main suspects unless i'm missing something somewher...

Meaningful interactions between/about Black Rock and Roxy BR didn't have anything to say to or about Roxy. BR - I did think she was defending MP AND throwing a small suspicion Elo's way. I do trust splkints read of her but I would like to give her a chance to get better and respond before I lay a vo...

Meaningful interactions between/about Black Rock and MovingPictures07 Just catching up here. You guys have been busy today. This post is where I'm at. I see that DDL thinks all those who've been posting tonight look like town. I disagree, but not only that, I highly doubt that none of the mafia are ...

JJ - I hate to be the bludger that suggests you do all the work, but I think a BR/Epi comparison could also be useful to help us figure if we have two or three baddies left alive. very good call. i'd have not considered that. i might not have enough time in the night phase to cover everyone. if not...

feeling pretty sure about mp now. i was gonna say i was sure about jay too but i looked thru his history and apparently he said early in the day My most likely vote as of now is aether. was it th's case what convinced you? still i think he's most likely town i'm just being fickle and that bothered ...

Im going to go ahead a vote BR I think she is bad news. of the people who voted for br, bass is the only one who i think could be scum, only because he does the "yeah good points *votes*" what significance do you think there is in the fact that Bass's vote broke a 3-3 tie with aether to g...

Meaningful interactions between/about Black Rock and G-Man i'm going to actually analyze this man. he shouldn't be left out anymore! he is trying to be a part of the game! but it's going to involve lots of spoilers. How is Gman cursed already? hey look! there's a BR post about a player i am analyzin...

Meaningful interactions between/about Black Rock and fingersplints this is a huge post so i've enclosed it within numerous spoilers. BR was involved with splints more than any other player in her post history. so all of the important bits will be covered by default when i look at splints. if anyone ...

you're my boy G-Man. you should check out this new spoiler feature, it could really suit you in this game.

Meaningful interactions between/about Black Rock and Dragon D. Luffy guess what! BR said nothing to or about DDL. :| Black Rock: not much useful activity, but she seems to be the player who likes to comment on little contradictions and say useful things now and then. Not a very productive playstyle,...

Meaningful interactions between/about Black Rock and birdwithteeth11/Golden 2.0 BR had nothing to say to or about BWT11. this is becoming a frustrating trend, but productive for any members of the mafia team. So I'm a bit torn on MP. I think that the thing that bothers me the most is actually that I...

First things first, I probably would have gone after TH today, but I think the poll is looking pretty good for him, and a couple of others as well. I'll probably do a lynch analysis as part of my catch up (except that I dare say JJJ will beat me to it :p ) maybe. :p but as long as we disagree about...

oh sure, let's leave JJJ out of the singing contest. :P

to be honest i was [pleasantly] surprised when sanmateo voted BR. i thought he would go with aether.

interesting thoughts re: splints DDL. i'll see how i feel about her in light of the BR mafia flip once i get to her in these interactive analyses i am doing. but i would caution anyone out there who is anywhere near "certain" bussing occurred. i think on the surface it's a valid concern, b...

Meaningful interactions between/about Black Rock and Bass_the_Clever BR never said anything to or about Bass in any post. Bass didn't acknowledge BR until the gun-to-head reads exercise, in which he named her as town: nope. shrinking it. http://oi57.tinypic.com/o1bmf.jpg it is noteworthy perhaps tha...

Meaningful interactions between/about Black Rock and acrosstheaether Well I voted for acrosstheaether, nothing else I could do at this point. When I flip civ I hope you guys gain the info you are looking for on other players. this was the only post in which Black Rock acknowledged the existence of a...

Neat.

Now i can really play my game. Prepare to be analyzed everyone.

When i get home at least

Have to vote now. BR.

I like it TH. Black Rock will probably be my vote.

There is some precedent at least for aether playing this way as town. When you are able to, could you elaborate on that? Since aether can't defend herself to save her life it seems others will have to do that for her. She has run into trouble in some recent games for low effort and apathetic play. ...

Search found 36916 matches