The Syndicate

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:DIINY

DRWILGY

ELOHCIN

EPIGNOSIS

GOOD

BAD

GOOD

GOOD

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:BCORNETT24

BLACK ROCK

BULLZEYE

CHOUTAS

BAD

BAD

GOOD

GOOD

F me J3. I neeeeeed it.

I'd suggest you focus on scumhunting and only respond to major points. Logical scumhunting could not only dissuade us from lynching you for minor reasons, but in the case that you're town it is information that would be very useful.

Matt you're saying that motel is bad for pushing Strawhenge to save Mac but then turning around and saying they're both scum. If they're both scum why would they risk that open conversation if Strawhenge wasn't going to change his vote regardless?

My bad Wilgy, I do indeed have short term memory. Mac moved to you as a possible self-preservation wagon and commented that I'm town and you're scum before moving off to Diiny.

I replaced Reywas.

I want to see Wilgy burn today, slightly more so after Mac had nothing to say on the topic.

Matt by those criteria I should be on that list as well. I've stated reasons, though they're illogical, but I could be lying.

Now I know why games are weird here. I'm not automatically on the table to be lynched at all times.

You wound me, Epi. You're a very good [Power Rangers villain fused with Shao Kahn?] though.

Who is "keej/mojiki?" motel? J3 I'm not exactly one to talk, I ramble at times, but being succinct can also convey a different tone. Saying something in five words can have a bigger impact than saying something in five sentences. Still want Wilgy's blood, but Mac's flip combined with his &...

See, motel, one of two things is going to happen regarding me and J3. One of us is going to be killed, and the other is going to be proven either Light or Near. The impostor, or the successor. I'm assuming J3 will be killed before I will be, since I've decreased my credibility this phase in any situ...

Wilgy you, as a Mafia player who understands the game, are aware of something. Information is king. Suspicions, reads, inklings, any game-relevant information helps town (barring extremes like knowing who Medic/UC are), and every civilian should aim to increase the total knowledge base of the town b...

Pushing for a lynch is different than having your vote on him for a few hours at the beginning of the day, Metalmarsh. What you've done does not qualify as pushing for a lynch. I know why you don't want Wilgy lynched today, but that's selfish behavior and we can't afford to waste time. Scum will be ...

For the purposes of this explanation let's assume that neutral refers to 50%, absolute town and scum are 0% and 100% respectively. When I say that a player is hard to get lynched, that at most adds 3%. The opposite is also true, if the wagon on a player forms very quickly then that's 3% deducted at ...

Ah, the deadline is in four hours, my mistake. I understand that you've put a lot of work into getting the lynch wagon on Mac going, and I respect the effort, but let me put it a different way. I think Wilgy is dirtier than Mac. My preference would be to lynch the player I am most confident in being...

Actually, that could work.

Anybody up for a CFD? I nominate Wilgy.

I'm sad that there's no self-voting in this game.

Roughly two and a half hours, if nothing changes. And that seems unlikely, barring any Chinese firemen entering the thread.

Because he is obvscum. Bullzeye is scum. Fuzz is scum. Look to the throwaway votes imo. You got me excited that you actually thought I was scum, but then you don't list me in your next post. I feel neglected. I also feel annoyed that you asked me to put in work on post analysis and then call the re...

Mac I can see the arguments against him, but with the current trend of mislynching I'm unsure about him and need to think on it some What is this supposed to mean? Why aren't I asking Floyd questions or trying to involve him? I don't have questions that I would learn anything from asking. The occas...

Floyd looks bad, no two ways about it. I'm aware that he's had a horrible situation and that's why his contribution is so low, but even the posts he has made have been borderline scumslips. "Do you mean the in-thread text" being the prime example, to me. Despite that, I'm not going to lync...

MM, my logic is as follows. If Wilgy was town and I was wrongly pushing him, Mafia would want to help me push his mislynch, and there would be at least some mention of him. However, the opposite applies, it's very hard to get the ball rolling to lynch Mafia because a portion of the game is actively ...

The main reason to lynch Mac, for me, is because he wanted to lynch Sorsha to get information either way, as Rico said. However, he never actually said what kind of information he would get from the lynch. His reactions to Matt's SK accusation read town to me. That's enough for me to hesitate. In th...

With the information that I believe you're trying to tell me with that, Wilgy, I don't see how that changes my conclusion. I don't have anything to work off of here, so rather than assume some hidden shenanigans I have to base my conclusions off of what I can see. You're not making me feel better by...

If you've got a lot on your plate, MM, don't worry about making a case against me. Someone will eventually do it, even if it's only because I've been alive for a long time. I say this non-sarcastically.

just because i can't explain it, doesn't mean it isn't well thought out and solid You're not entirely wrong, but if you can't coherently explain what your theory is how do you expect people to look at it and form their own conclusions? We're not going to take your word that this theory you can't pr...

It's really annoying being seen as generally town-neutral but not town or dirty enough to get a fun color in everybody's fun-filled rainbow lists.

Wilgy talk coming up shortly.

Choutas not really sure what you're asking.

TGG I don't like sauce and I don't like hot or spicy things, so I'd prefer neither.

MM I thought you were my friend.

I speak to you all as someone who plays via mobile occasionally. For the love of god use spoilers. Open your phone to this page and imagine Rico's post being quoted ten times, in addition to actual new content under it that would then get quoted and replied to in turn. I can't imagine a world where ...

I asked both J3 and Wilgy questions about each other. J3 responded while Wilgy did not. My best guess as for Wilgy's reaction if he was scum with J3 would be to coordinate responses. It's an extremely minor thing, and can honestly be interpreted either way, but I find it interesting nonetheless. J3,...

J3 - You understand why I can't trust you anymore. I asked you the "name three people that won't stab you in the back" question to see what order your list the names in. Mac should've been first, and I thought there was a good possibility I was there, but since you were so adamant on Mac h...

The reversed question also applies to Wilgy. Ignoring the possibility of J3 being lynched, what night phase do you think he will get killed?

J3 I'm aware you're out at the moment, but I want your opinion on something.

Ignoring the possibility of being lynched, what night phase do you think Wilgy will get killed?

Thanks for the clarification Bullzeye.

Is that last part a typo or do you suspect people that you already trust bringing up valid cases?

Would you mind listing what you disagree with me on?

And it's likely a wording or definition issue, but it irks me to see that you haven't suspected me. You should be suspecting everybody, especially the players you think are right.

Bullzeye, if you're still here, how have my posts in the last hour changed your opinion of me? Feel free to do a simple before and after analysis instead of a short answer. I'll read it.

It's always fun to see people who are apparently convinced they'll be killed at night.

Ah, I misinterpreted your frustrations. He asked you to do something you believed to be against the rules. I thought you were upset at Matt seemingly trying to use modkills to his advantage as a player.

You scold Matt for "trying to get people modkilled," but J3's actions had been interpreted similarly. Asking the mods to clarify espers' status the moment he goes over 72 hours without posting could be seen as a more tactful way to achieve the same end.

Bullzeye what do you think of J3's questions to the mods regarding espers?

Martian was pretty good. Lots of the monologues felt appropriate, he would be creating a video log as opposed to just talking to himself, and the movie wasn't bogged down with crazy amounts of "I'm the only man on Mars dear god why" depression. A few characters were introduced by name for ...

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Do you drink your milk with tabasco?

No, that doesn't sound like a fun time.

Thanks MM, but there are flaws with that as well. I lack, as J3 has said, a sense of urgency. If I'm committing myself to remain calm then I have to deaden the importance of the situation, and controlled panic can be a good thing. Sorry about that earlier J3, I forgot to add the actual statement. If...

I'm glad that I'm a reassuring presence, MM. Somewhat confused as to how, but glad nonetheless.

Heads up J3.

I do. I assume that I know you better than anyone else here, and I don't want to make any false assumptions about you. I did make assumptions before day 3, and it was fun, but to be honest since then I've been hung up on day 2. I just noticed that you use the word conclusions. Why is this? Have you...

I'm exempt from your lists? That's a nice way of saying that you're intending to push me later without being held accountable for an opinion now. Thanks for the response. Lol, you got me! No, the player you subbed for just missed votes, so I don't have the intel to properly judge your actions and i...

I'm exempt from your lists? That's a nice way of saying that you're intending to push me later without being held accountable for an opinion now. Thanks for the response.

DrWilgy wrote:JJJ is probably scum. Only 55% sure though.

Probably scum? What does that make me? If he's probably scum, and he thinks I'm clean, explain the most likely outcome to me.

I'd be willing to shoot a vote his way, Wilgy. What do you think of J3? Scum, town, neutral, etc.

Fair enough splints. You do you. If you don't have faith that repeated asking gets answers I can fetch some examples from here, but it's a moot point.

Search found 372 matches