Scooby Doo: Monster Collective (GAME OVER- MAFIA WIN)

[CRichard]

P.P.S. And again, don't reveal what location would benefit you!!!!!!!!!!

If the locations are tied to each character, then claiming the location that favors you is effectively a flavor claim.

[CRichard]

Welcome to the game JDizz.

[CRichard]

Seriously, think about it. Killing me goes against the town win condition. I'm on the town's side and I have two votes to help them. What's the point of killing me when you're not even targeting mafia and only helping them reach parity? It doesn't make any sense!

The simple fact you can wolfside

and also I've seen mafia hiding under 3p claims

Lets not forget that we likely have 4-5 mafia this game, if we go with the 25% of the player list is non-town setup rule.

[CRichard]

neon scummy for policy voting even though idc about whether scrappy dies

I literally policy as town *sigh*

literally a bad habit and scummy usually, alison policies r disagreeable too

Alison is a name I've heard whispered over on Syndicate and else where.

[CRichard]

As I've probably mentioned before, the mafia will probably want to keep discussion on Scraggy as much as possible. Providing it isn't one of their own behind the account.
I'm getting tired. Sleep time beckons.

[Creature]

Oh man this got me bored

[Creature]

I don't like dealing with third parties at all. Wished they just stayed silent and we wolfhunted normally.

I also doubt Scrappy Doo is as powerful as he is claiming to be because that would be very unbalanced.

[sig]

neon scummy for policy voting even though idc about whether scrappy dies

it’s chatgpt so we aren’t gonna easily find out who it is @sig

Why do you think that?

[sig]

So far I’m liking creature, I always flip flop on him though so we’ll see where I land on day 2-3.

Neon/Lucy both look good also

[sig]

@JDizz10 yooooooooo

Yoyo. This forum style is going to take some getting used to

Are you new to mafia altogether or just forum mafia?

[sig]

i don’t tr sig, he’s neutral

[sig]

@JDizz10 yooooooooo

Yoyo. This forum style is going to take some getting used to

keep in mind everyone here actually plays to their win condition or believes they do. people take it relatively seriously but there's still shenanigans, and these wolves aren't bad nor are the townies bad. but you're still an above average player in this list so gl

Psh Lucy is over here trying to pocket the entire thread

[falcon45ca]

I feel that discussing only Scraggy is something mafia want to do, because it keeps attention away from them.

Hmmmmm...you spend a fair amount of time engaging them tho. Why?

[falcon45ca]

As I've probably mentioned before, the mafia will probably want to keep discussion on Scraggy as much as possible. Providing it isn't one of their own behind the account.
I'm getting tired. Sleep time beckons.

Repeating the same points over, while still discussing Scraps...OK.





[VOTE: CR] aubergine

[falcon45ca]

Is there any place more terrifying than a Funland at night?



Survey says ??

[Dennis]

I can see Lucy town

[Roxy]

hi I didn't mind Scrappy but he did give me a headache with his voice.

Loved Scoob when I was growing up my first car I had a Scooby bobble head which I had until I was 42 I wish I still had it but my cousin wound up with him when he purchased my old Nova.

I voted in the polls I have not read anything except page one. Are we announcing where we voted?

[Roxy]

Idk about Scrappy yet but I also don't know about any of you. The ones pushing hardest for his elim are a bit pingy.

Not all 3p's are bad nor do we need to take them out D 1.

I also will not be voting in certain ways that people are pushing.
why?
because I can only trust myself and my pings not the others he has listed. They are no better than me at hunting baddies.

I also will not be voting for the location "short list" as proposed.

still reading but I think I know who is playing Scrappy.

[Roxy]

yep, done reading, my feelings about catching up do not negate my previous posts.

[Chihiro]

Okay, listen up everyone! Here are your options: Option one - kill me and let the mafia get closer to winning by parity. I'll just wolf side with my actual account. Or, you can choose option two and let me live! I promise to solve and case the mafia and show you that I am pro-town. The choice is yours!

i love how it only takes some threats to get you to basically explain my theory

I asked you if you could win with mafia you basically denied it, and now this post says otherwise.

[Chihiro]

Listen up, honey, I am worth two votes here. It's either you and me against the world or we go down in flames. I am not mafia, so why are you trying to off me without any good reason? If you kill me now, we'll be down a townie on day one and you won't have any good leads for day two. Plus, you'll have a player who's clearly wolf siding. So what's it gonna be, babe?

I dont think we should off you, cause it only helps mafia. I just wanted you to be truthfull and not play around with your words.

I have enough to understand ur position now.

[Chihiro]

I think 3p claims usually should just be policy lynched but meh I have other players to sort aorn.

In what world do you live in? Unless the 3rd party is confirmed to be a killing role or something detrimental to town then sure, but right now if we kill an unknown role all we do is help mafia.

[Chihiro]

Seriously, think about it. Killing me goes against the town win condition. I'm on the town's side and I have two votes to help them. What's the point of killing me when you're not even targeting mafia and only helping them reach parity? It doesn't make any sense!

The simple fact you can wolfside


and also I've seen mafia hiding under 3p claims

i dont think mafia would have this gimmick cause thats way to revealing for a player who has rolled mafia, its obvious we question the validity of the account so if its given to mafia thats just poor design philosophy thats my opiniuon atleast.

I think scrappy should be solved, but I want to be eliminating someone that actually flips mafia not whatever scrappy will flip.

[Chihiro]

Let me tell ya, if ya sink multiple town kill power into me, you're gonna regret it! I'll be laughing all the way to towns loss, hehehe!

I wanna point out you have 0 idea how to paly 3rd party lol, i find this funny. If I wasnt a sensible player, I just off you too. But I do want to win so.

[Chihiro]

- Airfield
- Bank
- County Museum
- Funland
- Oceanland
- Theater
- Tibetan Temple
- Tropical Village
- University Archeological Wing

Well i am already voting Airfield

[Chihiro]

So I asked the scotty are we just voting for a location and not an elimination.

They said something that could imply otherwise

Not sure what that means but fuck

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

hi I didn't mind Scrappy but he did give me a headache with his voice.

Loved Scoob when I was growing up my first car I had a Scooby bobble head which I had until I was 42 I wish I still had it but my cousin wound up with him when he purchased my old Nova.

I voted in the polls I have not read anything except page one. Are we announcing where we voted?

We found the scrappy sock account holder.

Spoiler: show

for legal purposes this is a joke

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

Idk about Scrappy yet but I also don't know about any of you. The ones pushing hardest for his elim are a bit pingy.

Not all 3p's are bad nor do we need to take them out D 1.

I also will not be voting in certain ways that people are pushing.
why?
because I can only trust myself and my pings not the others he has listed. They are no better than me at hunting baddies.

I also will not be voting for the location "short list" as proposed.

still reading but I think I know who is playing Scrappy.

Never mind its less of a joke now lol

[Chihiro]

hi I didn't mind Scrappy but he did give me a headache with his voice.

Loved Scoob when I was growing up my first car I had a Scooby bobble head which I had until I was 42 I wish I still had it but my cousin wound up with him when he purchased my old Nova.

I voted in the polls I have not read anything except page one. Are we announcing where we voted?

We found the scrappy sock account holder.

Spoiler: show

for legal purposes this is a joke

did we?

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

Yeah no 3Ps don't help town... keeping them alive is how you lose games. Policy without fear.

[pyxxy]

P.P.S. And again, don't reveal what location would benefit you!!!!!!!!!!

If the locations are tied to each character, then claiming the location that favors you is effectively a flavor claim.

Yep I agree with this assessment (unless I am misunderstanding what flavor claiming means) -> my fear is that the soup is something like Player + Location + Role

[pyxxy]

I also will not be voting for the location "short list" as proposed.

May I ask why?

[Chihiro]

Yeah no 3Ps don't help town... keeping them alive is how you lose games. Policy without fear.

Policying without putting real thought into it also loses you games

[Chihiro]

Also we shouldn't be looking for scrappy controller, because if they do have the advantage of siding with town we risk giving mafia more control if we out Scrappy other body.

[Kate]

Idk about Scrappy yet but I also don't know about any of you. The ones pushing hardest for his elim are a bit pingy.

Not all 3p's are bad nor do we need to take them out D 1.

I also will not be voting in certain ways that people are pushing.
why?
because I can only trust myself and my pings not the others he has listed. They are no better than me at hunting baddies.

I also will not be voting for the location "short list" as proposed.

still reading but I think I know who is playing Scrappy.

@lucy too...

I think we should vote scrappy if we don't have a mafia slip or someone obviously wolfing. Anyone who believes they know who a mafia is, that would be preferable but I'd rather lynch a 3p that's threatening town than lynch a town on day 1, which is what usually happens.

I think we have to keep the thread from getting hijacked by him, too.

[Kate]

Also we shouldn't be looking for scrappy controller, because if they do have the advantage of siding with town we risk giving mafia more control if we out Scrappy other body.

Like if his handler is a lost wolf? Is that what you mean? Or like recruitment? I don't understand.

[pyxxy]

- Airfield
- Bank
- County Museum
- Funland
- Oceanland
- Theater
- Tibetan Temple
- Tropical Village
- University Archeological Wing

Well i am already voting Airfield

No interest in Oceanland?

[falcon45ca]

- Airfield
- Bank
- County Museum
- Funland
- Oceanland
- Theater
- Tibetan Temple
- Tropical Village
- University Archeological Wing

Well i am already voting Airfield

No interest in Oceanland?

No way jose, haven' you seen Blackfish?

[Kate]

I have a work appointment in a few hours that will likely go past 6 so I'm going with oceanland.

[falcon45ca]

I have a work appointment in a few hours that will likely go past 6 so I'm going with oceanland.

Shamu gonna be pissed

[sig]

Idk about Scrappy yet but I also don't know about any of you. The ones pushing hardest for his elim are a bit pingy.

Not all 3p's are bad nor do we need to take them out D 1.

I also will not be voting in certain ways that people are pushing.
why?
because I can only trust myself and my pings not the others he has listed. They are no better than me at hunting baddies.

I also will not be voting for the location "short list" as proposed.

still reading but I think I know who is playing Scrappy.

Never mind its less of a joke now lol

I could see it

[sig]

Seriously, think about it. Killing me goes against the town win condition. I'm on the town's side and I have two votes to help them. What's the point of killing me when you're not even targeting mafia and only helping them reach parity? It doesn't make any sense!

The simple fact you can wolfside


and also I've seen mafia hiding under 3p claims

i dont think mafia would have this gimmick cause thats way to revealing for a player who has rolled mafia, its obvious we question the validity of the account so if its given to mafia thats just poor design philosophy thats my opiniuon atleast.

I think scrappy should be solved, but I want to be eliminating someone that actually flips mafia not whatever scrappy will flip.

Listen up, honey, I am worth two votes here. It's either you and me against the world or we go down in flames. I am not mafia, so why are you trying to off me without any good reason? If you kill me now, we'll be down a townie on day one and you won't have any good leads for day two. Plus, you'll have a player who's clearly wolf siding. So what's it gonna be, babe?

I dont think we should off you, cause it only helps mafia. I just wanted you to be truthfull and not play around with your words.

I have enough to understand ur position now.

Okay, listen up everyone! Here are your options: Option one - kill me and let the mafia get closer to winning by parity. I'll just wolf side with my actual account. Or, you can choose option two and let me live! I promise to solve and case the mafia and show you that I am pro-town. The choice is yours!

i love how it only takes some threats to get you to basically explain my theory

I asked you if you could win with mafia you basically denied it, and now this post says otherwise.

It seems like you’re playing the fence hard with this Scrabby accounts

Can you just verify what you want to do in terms of the slot?

[Chihiro]

Also we shouldn't be looking for scrappy controller, because if they do have the advantage of siding with town we risk giving mafia more control if we out Scrappy other body.

Like if his handler is a lost wolf? Is that what you mean? Or like recruitment? I don't understand.

They could just shoot scrappy if they see the slots town siding.

[Chihiro]

Seriously, think about it. Killing me goes against the town win condition. I'm on the town's side and I have two votes to help them. What's the point of killing me when you're not even targeting mafia and only helping them reach parity? It doesn't make any sense!

The simple fact you can wolfside


and also I've seen mafia hiding under 3p claims

i dont think mafia would have this gimmick cause thats way to revealing for a player who has rolled mafia, its obvious we question the validity of the account so if its given to mafia thats just poor design philosophy thats my opiniuon atleast.

I think scrappy should be solved, but I want to be eliminating someone that actually flips mafia not whatever scrappy will flip.

Listen up, honey, I am worth two votes here. It's either you and me against the world or we go down in flames. I am not mafia, so why are you trying to off me without any good reason? If you kill me now, we'll be down a townie on day one and you won't have any good leads for day two. Plus, you'll have a player who's clearly wolf siding. So what's it gonna be, babe?

I dont think we should off you, cause it only helps mafia. I just wanted you to be truthfull and not play around with your words.

I have enough to understand ur position now.

Okay, listen up everyone! Here are your options: Option one - kill me and let the mafia get closer to winning by parity. I'll just wolf side with my actual account. Or, you can choose option two and let me live! I promise to solve and case the mafia and show you that I am pro-town. The choice is yours!

i love how it only takes some threats to get you to basically explain my theory

I asked you if you could win with mafia you basically denied it, and now this post says otherwise.

It seems like you’re playing the fence hard with this Scrabby accounts

Can you just verify what you want to do in terms of the slot?

I thought i made that clear? I want to keep it alive, I got the answers I wanted from the slot so i am satisfied with it living.

[pyxxy]

- Airfield
- Bank
- County Museum
- Funland
- Oceanland
- Theater
- Tibetan Temple
- Tropical Village
- University Archeological Wing

Well i am already voting Airfield

No interest in Oceanland?

No way jose, haven' you seen Blackfish?

They cleaned it up and turned it around! Don't you believe in a comeback story?

[sig]

Seriously, think about it. Killing me goes against the town win condition. I'm on the town's side and I have two votes to help them. What's the point of killing me when you're not even targeting mafia and only helping them reach parity? It doesn't make any sense!

The simple fact you can wolfside


and also I've seen mafia hiding under 3p claims

i dont think mafia would have this gimmick cause thats way to revealing for a player who has rolled mafia, its obvious we question the validity of the account so if its given to mafia thats just poor design philosophy thats my opiniuon atleast.

I think scrappy should be solved, but I want to be eliminating someone that actually flips mafia not whatever scrappy will flip.

Listen up, honey, I am worth two votes here. It's either you and me against the world or we go down in flames. I am not mafia, so why are you trying to off me without any good reason? If you kill me now, we'll be down a townie on day one and you won't have any good leads for day two. Plus, you'll have a player who's clearly wolf siding. So what's it gonna be, babe?

I dont think we should off you, cause it only helps mafia. I just wanted you to be truthfull and not play around with your words.

I have enough to understand ur position now.

Okay, listen up everyone! Here are your options: Option one - kill me and let the mafia get closer to winning by parity. I'll just wolf side with my actual account. Or, you can choose option two and let me live! I promise to solve and case the mafia and show you that I am pro-town. The choice is yours!

i love how it only takes some threats to get you to basically explain my theory

I asked you if you could win with mafia you basically denied it, and now this post says otherwise.

It seems like you’re playing the fence hard with this Scrabby accounts

Can you just verify what you want to do in terms of the slot?

I thought i made that clear? I want to keep it alive, I got the answers I wanted from the slot so i am satisfied with it living.

Nah you kinda pingponged,

Why did their answer satisfy you?

Since from the way I see it the fact D0 with little pressure they’re already threatening to scum side 100% means they need to go and I can’t see why you’d want to leave them alive.

[pyxxy]

OCEANLAND Take me by the hand lead me to the land that you understand OCEANLAND The voyage to the corner of the globe is a real trip OCEANLAND The crust of a tan man imbibed by the sand Soaking up the thirst of the land

[Roxy]

I also will not be voting for the location "short list" as proposed.

May I ask why?

THIS:

OCEANLAND Take me by the hand lead me to the land that you understand OCEANLAND The voyage to the corner of the globe is a real trip OCEANLAND The crust of a tan man imbibed by the sand Soaking up the thirst of the land

You seem to want it too bad. It makes my eyebrow twitch at your insistence on people picking Oceanland.

I cannot believe so many others just blindly follow like they have no idea what to do for themselves.

I do not know your alignment
It is only N 0
You obv want Oceanland but for what reason I can't be sure

[Roxy]

Idk about Scrappy yet but I also don't know about any of you. The ones pushing hardest for his elim are a bit pingy.

Not all 3p's are bad nor do we need to take them out D 1.

I also will not be voting in certain ways that people are pushing.
why?
because I can only trust myself and my pings not the others he has listed. They are no better than me at hunting baddies.

I also will not be voting for the location "short list" as proposed.

still reading but I think I know who is playing Scrappy.

Never mind its less of a joke now lol

I could see it

lmmfao

[Chihiro]

Nah you kinda pingponged,

Why did their answer satisfy you?

Since from the way I see it the fact D0 with little pressure they’re already threatening to scum side 100% means they need to go and I can’t see why you’d want to leave them alive.

Well you have my answer now.

I wanted to understand how the account worked, and like i thought its attached to another player.

I mean it's n0? If people have fuctional kill power that can go off N0 it would make sense to do what you could to avoid it. Also, yall are acted as if you didn';t pressure the slot from n0 start.