Don't Starve Mafia [ENDGAME]

[Lime Coke]

If I had a reads list it would look somewhat like...

Townread:
Scotty
Tutuu
JJJ
Zenon
Sean

Townlean:
SVS
Die_meat

[Seanzie]

If I had a reads list it would look somewhat like...

Townread:
Scotty
Tutuu
JJJ
Zenon
Sean

Townlean:
SVS
Die_meat

Why did I get moved to forest green? Just because I asked?

[Lime Coke]

Oh wait I did like SVS's thing with looking at past Porscha games, like while it could be total BS and SVS could just say as maf to make it seem like they're doing something. They at least somewhat had details about both instances of Porscha being maf and compared it to here and put a read there.

So yeah SVS is probably just town.

[Lime Coke]

If I had a reads list it would look somewhat like...

Townread:
Scotty
Tutuu
JJJ
Zenon
Sean

Townlean:
SVS
Die_meat

Why did I get moved to forest green? Just because I asked?

Yes.

[Seanzie]

If I had a reads list it would look somewhat like...

Townread:
Scotty
Tutuu
JJJ
Zenon
Sean

Townlean:
SVS
Die_meat

Why did I get moved to forest green? Just because I asked?

Yes.

I feel like you're being very people-pleasy.

[Lime Coke]

If I had a reads list it would look somewhat like...

Townread:
Scotty
Tutuu
JJJ
Zenon
Sean

Townlean:
SVS
Die_meat

Why did I get moved to forest green? Just because I asked?

Yes.

I feel like you're being very people-pleasy.

Onion ring.

[tutuu]

Sorry I was working long yesterday and didn't had any energy to write here. Also that I am just writing on the phone because I can't log in on my fucking PC and this piss me of. My Screen on the Phone is ripped and so it takes fucking nervs do write with this thing
@tutuu
I played 2 games before and never did somebody have a ego like yours and annoyed me this fucking much. You literally just piss me of with no fucking reason.... I sorry that I didn't have time to spam the thread with bs like you.

i always admire honesty. You are not trying to butter up the highest poster who has kinda overwhelmed the thread a bit, in your first game here. That reads pretty well for you.

@tutuu I went back and skimmed Cartomancy and Hot Dog Fingers, the two games I recalled bad Porscha. She seemed a bit different from each other in both, but neither of them looked much like here, particularly for a day one from a person who I generally get the impression is a slow starter. Especially since she came back to address suspicions, she felt sincere to me.

How do I look?

I asked you a direct question last night, and you ignored me

I think you sounded sincere last night. Your original reaction to Jay playing sounded VERY sincere. So i don't think bad Rondo brings that case against Jay, I think you only do that if you believe me.

@Vivax, as i said, I was replying to a direct question from Scotty. My meaning there was that I'm not being manipulative when i say that. I'm just talking.

U admire her personally attacking me because u disagree with my logic, u found it silly, and me making 200 posts in 36 hours is so much that it justifies antagonizing me. Gotcha SVS will keep in mind

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[S~V~S]

@tutuu that was in no way personal. I think DMBs honesty makes her more likely town. I’m townreading her, not endorsing her actions.

I didn’t say I agreed with her or thought she was right. I think a baddie wouldn’t have gotten in your face.

I’m surprised to see you take that personally. It most def wasn’t meant that way.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Seanzie’s arrival to the game kind of mirrors Creature’s, and I like it in both cases.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[VOTE: DrWilgy] aubergine

[JaggedJimmyJay]

baby_meatdie’s outrage looks pretty angry-new-player-contending-with-incorrect-suspicion. I’ll temper that with no knowledge of the player or their personality.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

POE seems somewhat restrictive at the moment. I’m at approximately:

[Wilgy, falcon, motobot, Porscha, Vivax, Belzy]

I could likely add more if I graded tougher, but I feel decent about it as a starting point. Given the low activity skew of that pile, I doubt it’s perfect. I’ll try to rainbow it up later when I get through my afternoon business.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I need to take a closer look at Lime Coke when I get a chance. Reminder to self.

[Belzy]

Tutuu is leading wagon, but also a (top) town read by many - how did this happen?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Schrödinger’s tutuu.

[Ricochet]

Tutuu is leading wagon, but also a (top) town read by many - how did this happen?

The wolf team probably said YOLO.

[Lime Coke]

Tutuu is leading wagon, but also a (top) town read by many - how did this happen?

Not sure and I'm not a fan of it.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

tutuu’s current wagon seems to feature two loud retaliatory votes (meatbaby and Porscha) and one inscrutable vote (motobot). Hard to do much with that, but regardless it doesn’t inspire confidence.

[Seanzie]

Seanzie’s arrival to the game kind of mirrors Creature’s, and I like it in both cases.

You're going to have to elaborate on this. Creature's ISO looks like they've just been complaining about being suspected for not being in the game early, and then naked voting people and pushing me for not being in the game early, and then dipping for the entire second half of the day.

How does this mirror me at all?

[Seanzie]

POE seems somewhat restrictive at the moment. I’m at approximately:

[Wilgy, falcon, motobot, Porscha, Vivax, Belzy]

I could likely add more if I graded tougher, but I feel decent about it as a starting point. Given the low activity skew of that pile, I doubt it’s perfect. I’ll try to rainbow it up later when I get through my afternoon business.

What do you think of Rico?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Seanzie’s arrival to the game kind of mirrors Creature’s, and I like it in both cases.

You're going to have to elaborate on this. Creature's ISO looks like they've just been complaining about being suspected for not being in the game early, and then naked voting people and pushing me for not being in the game early, and then dipping for the entire second half of the day.

How does this mirror me at all?

Clearly you two have different personalities. The parallel I refer to is arriving after a long delay and immediately settling into form (your different respective forms).

[Ricochet]

[VOTE: DrWilgy] aubergine

Anything to gain from shooting in that patch of total dark?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

POE seems somewhat restrictive at the moment. I’m at approximately:

[Wilgy, falcon, motobot, Porscha, Vivax, Belzy]

I could likely add more if I graded tougher, but I feel decent about it as a starting point. Given the low activity skew of that pile, I doubt it’s perfect. I’ll try to rainbow it up later when I get through my afternoon business.

What do you think of Rico?

I have him as most likely town. I got the impression that he believed in his grievances with Scotty and tutuu in particular. I saw that you had gripes; I haven’t had the time yet to fully absorb and consider them.

[Seanzie]

Seanzie’s arrival to the game kind of mirrors Creature’s, and I like it in both cases.

You're going to have to elaborate on this. Creature's ISO looks like they've just been complaining about being suspected for not being in the game early, and then naked voting people and pushing me for not being in the game early, and then dipping for the entire second half of the day.

How does this mirror me at all?

Clearly you two have different personalities. The parallel I refer to is arriving after a long delay and immediately settling into form (your different respective forms).

Town!Creature is usually either almost completely disengaged, or they're very engaged and alternating between very nuanced takes and slightly-out-there takes. Here it looks like he is trying to be engaged, but not giving that off-the-wall juicy content that town!Creature can. I don't think I'd call this "settling into form".

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[VOTE: DrWilgy] aubergine

Anything to gain from shooting in that patch of total dark?

Ideally a dead member of the mafia team. If nothing else at this precise time, maybe a response or six that illuminate his alignment.

[Creature]

Oh right right man

Damn I couldn't play this game with its due respect

[Creature]

Seanzie’s arrival to the game kind of mirrors Creature’s, and I like it in both cases.

You're going to have to elaborate on this. Creature's ISO looks like they've just been complaining about being suspected for not being in the game early, and then naked voting people and pushing me for not being in the game early, and then dipping for the entire second half of the day.

How does this mirror me at all?

Is this worth townreading Seanzie for? Or can he fake that as wolf?

[Ricochet]

Case on Scotty not playing it genuine

SVS shade, based on mechtalk, feels like a scramble to come up with some less-good to paint someone out of it (whilst there was no true, general trend to sus anyone out of that talk, save for SVS v. tutuu). The reasoning that SVS would have played it carefully doesn't feel cooked in campfire at all.

Later spins it, I feel, in a sketchy / paranoid angle of SVS being smooth killah and stuff, which feels either too early (and insubstantial) to paint such a picture or just bluff

+

Vivax suss feels like a piggyback onto JJJ's reasoning. Made me also think it's a second time he's melding with someone else (though he did the same wrt tutuu on SVS, but that is likely just a coincidental timing). Then proceeds to strengthen it in serious critical tone. Again, I feel a true Scot could / would have come out of the gates himself with that.

+

Upon re-read, most of his other pushes are flat.
Splash votes (Rondo, Wilgy, Lime).
Soft jab at JJJ for some weak (meta) apologetics.
Creates wolf team with two inactives (at that time)

+

Deflecting shades and suspicions on votes on himself with jokes, banter and haha can obviously come from either side, but coming from a mostly suss perspective, it doesn't better the read.

[Ricochet]

[VOTE: Scotty] aubergine

[tutuu]

@tutuu that was in no way personal. I think DMBs honesty makes her more likely town. I’m townreading her, not endorsing her actions.

I didn’t say I agreed with her or thought she was right. I think a baddie wouldn’t have gotten in your face.

I’m surprised to see you take that personally. It most def wasn’t meant that way.

Shes been calling me names, calling me annoying stupid egocentrical. U come in and are like "i admire ur bravery, ur so valid queen ". Multiple ppl reacted a tad more appropriately to her antics. Rondo laughed her off, rico reminded her of the rules, others acknowledged her being outlandish. What do u do? Hype her up "i admire ur honesty, u dont take no shit from nobody, hell yea baby girl ". Then u quote her asking me bout wilgy and me ignoring her. U say "ikr, i also get frustrated when my questions are ignored, just answer directly like duh obviously!!". Didnt occur to u that im ignoring the person insulting me post after post? That something unreasonable?
Was disappointed to see u being so tone deaf and not reading thread temperature as an admin

[Ricochet]

Might we perhaps not recap things and poke some more at every step? Reach out to host and mod, even regarding others who might have been inconsiderate as side-talkers.

[S~V~S]

“UR so valid Queen ” is a bit hyperbole.

Again I am sorry if I have brought offense, it was definitely not my intention, tutuu.

I tend to townread ballsiness, and that’s the case here. I am sorry if your feelings are hurt most def not intentional.

[Seanzie]

Seanzie’s arrival to the game kind of mirrors Creature’s, and I like it in both cases.

You're going to have to elaborate on this. Creature's ISO looks like they've just been complaining about being suspected for not being in the game early, and then naked voting people and pushing me for not being in the game early, and then dipping for the entire second half of the day.

How does this mirror me at all?

Is this worth townreading Seanzie for? Or can he fake that as wolf?

Pretty sure he could fake it.

Do you feel like our enterances are similar?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Tutuu is leading wagon, but also a (top) town read by many - how did this happen?

Hey Belzy, about how much of the thread have you read so far?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

falcon seems to have no suspects beyond a lone barely-explained Creature vote. I am perturbed.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Case on Scotty not playing it genuine

SVS shade, based on mechtalk, feels like a scramble to come up with some less-good to paint someone out of it (whilst there was no true, general trend to sus anyone out of that talk, save for SVS v. tutuu). The reasoning that SVS would have played it carefully doesn't feel cooked in campfire at all.

Later spins it, I feel, in a sketchy / paranoid angle of SVS being smooth killah and stuff, which feels either too early (and insubstantial) to paint such a picture or just bluff

This portion is fair, and it occurs to me that I don't have the clearest understanding of what Scotty's discomforts with S~V~S are in this game. I have an impression that Scotty is worried about S~V~S, but it seems to be more about the concept of S~V~S than about posts she made in the game thread (e.g., she's "tricksy" or "careful"). Scotty could stand to clarify this stuff.

[DrWilgy]

Good morning. Haven't read shit. Why are we yeeting JJJ and Tutuu?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Spoiler: show

JJJ is town

JJJ is town

eagle falcon eye over here

Why

The last game I played with JJJ he was scum, and had different tone.



I accused him of Revelations 3:15-18, and I'm not seeing that here

[VOTE: Creature] aubergine

Because creature hates playing as scum

I've seen this before, tis true

Lol why arent you actually combating my point?

which points? why im scumreading u and sean? u said it urself. ur polarized. ur not being towny. so i have to think ur maf

Tell me about me.

u werent posting so i thought ur maf

I didn't even know about the game until I saw your @ this morning, and then didn't get a rolecard until this afternoon, and then I took some mushrooms and ended up getting lost in a sunflower maze and ate brussels sprout pecan tacos. I have not had time to post.

You had me at hello.



This totally vibes with my own experience this game, except I took different drugs and ate different food...and I didn't get lost, BUT! The rest is the same.



TR Sean

Cuz I'm town, and it mirrors my own experience. Whether it's AI or not, I find it towny

I don't recall seeing this version of falcon before. To my [admittedly dated] memory, he isn't the "hand out town reads" type in general, and he can be an accusatory/interrogative firecracker kinda like Seanzie. This material is bland and frivolous. To be fair to falcon, I don't think he generally has looked like this as mafia, so maybe it isn't "scummy". I don't find it "towny" either. Maybe someone with more recent experience with him can share their view.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Good morning. Haven't read shit. Why are we yeeting JJJ and Tutuu?

You tell me.

[DrWilgy]

Good morning. Haven't read shit. Why are we yeeting JJJ and Tutuu?

You tell me.

I'm just jelly of your looks tbh

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Good morning. Haven't read shit. Why are we yeeting JJJ and Tutuu?

You tell me.

I'm just jelly of your looks tbh

You know, Mafia threads need more posts like this one right here.

[DrWilgy]

ISO'd Falcon and I'm underwhelmed.

Falcon, hurry up and townspew.

[falcon45ca]

falcon seems to have no suspects beyond a lone barely-explained Creature vote. I am perturbed.

I am suffering from some form of malaise, of whose origins I know not

[falcon45ca]

ISO'd Falcon and I'm underwhelmed.

Falcon, hurry up and townspew.

Ugh, do I have to?




I'll do it later, I promise. I just need to slank for a bit

[DrWilgy]

Please don't mislynch me for just not posting

Just skimmed creature and have decided to mislynch them for just not posting.

[DrWilgy]

ISO'd Falcon and I'm underwhelmed.

Falcon, hurry up and townspew.

Ugh, do I have to?




I'll do it later, I promise. I just need to slank for a bit

ty boss.

So far I'm at:
T Falcon.
T Creature.

This game is easy.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

falcon seems to have no suspects beyond a lone barely-explained Creature vote. I am perturbed.

I am suffering from some form of malaise, of whose origins I know not

I hope you feel better soon and that you discover the origins of your ailment for vengeance.

Are you content to push Creature?

[falcon45ca]

falcon seems to have no suspects beyond a lone barely-explained Creature vote. I am perturbed.

I am suffering from some form of malaise, of whose origins I know not

I hope you feel better soon and that you discover the origins of your ailment for vengeance.

Are you content to push Creature?

I just want him to get involved, I'm not committed to his wagon by any stretch

[falcon45ca]

falcon seems to have no suspects beyond a lone barely-explained Creature vote. I am perturbed.

I am suffering from some form of malaise, of whose origins I know not

I hope you feel better soon and that you discover the origins of your ailment for vengeance.

Are you content to push Creature?

Fear not, Al Swearengen is my mentor