LinearPoint wrote: ↑Wed Aug 23, 2023 2:21 pm
cat wrote: ↑Wed Aug 23, 2023 12:56 pm
Guillotine wrote: ↑Wed Aug 23, 2023 10:27 am
Actually Michelle is wolfing
[VOTE:
Michelle] aubergine
I dont believe you question how 3 wolves would be unbalanced in a game with 10 players
This does not sit well with me. The moment this guy is called out for passivity he amps up the agression and votes the person pushing him? Plus the logic doesn't make sense to me, but that part is just personal preference.
Sus on Guillotine
cat wrote: ↑Wed Aug 23, 2023 1:05 pm
LinearPoint wrote: ↑Wed Aug 23, 2023 10:51 am
Guillotine wrote: ↑Wed Aug 23, 2023 10:46 am
How about we stop speculating about mafia:town ratios?
It gives scum the opportunity to hide under the guise of creating content by talking about it.
I for one think it's productive as it's likely to draw in wolves to the discussion and open them up for slipping.
Plus it's not like there is anything else we can realistically do at the very start of day 1. There's no mechanical info to go off of so we need people to talk, associate, and take positions.
No slips will happen, but i think it's more likely wolves will feel awkward discussing it since it is really not much value, triggering their self-awareness. It's an easy stance to take and it looks good on face value. Once again Guillotine looks bad here
If you're really worried about wolves hiding inbetween the cracks then look for them instead of trying to prevent discussion
@Guillotine Is this Town or Wolf?
Ok
1) in the first quote she is scum reading my aggression, which i can understand from someone that does not know that im naturally aggressive, it is normal to happen.
2) Also in the first quote, It depends on whether she knows Michelle like i do, Michelle has played a lot and has hosted game too, it is unbelievable that she'd question why in a 10-player game, 3 scum would be unbalanced, because she should know better and also looked like a question a wolf would make to look like she is trying to solve hiding mechanical talk.
So if Cat does not know Michelle then i guess it is fair Cat does not understand the logic, now if cat is experienced and knows Michelle then that is sus.
3) In the second quote, the comment about no slips will happen, i agree, wolves cannot be caught slipping speculating about mechanics unless they mention a role we dont know it exists with certainty. I disagree that wolves would feel awkward talking about mechanics, literally that is what wolves love to do instead of pushing players, they could do it all they if they were allowed.
4) “ If you're really worried about wolves hiding inbetween the cracks then look for them instead of trying to prevent discussion”, what does she think im doing now then?
I cant say if she is a wolf or town based on this but thanks for bringing it up, will keep a close eye.