You've had fun with me, haven't you?DharmaHelper wrote:Honestly whatever. I'm fine with getting lynched in this game. My Hedge thing was not an attempt to get any attention anywhere.
If anything recent days just proves what I already thought. Mafia is no longer fun for me.
I guess.Long Con wrote:You've had fun with me, haven't you?DharmaHelper wrote:Honestly whatever. I'm fine with getting lynched in this game. My Hedge thing was not an attempt to get any attention anywhere.
If anything recent days just proves what I already thought. Mafia is no longer fun for me.
On some other site I think "scum" is synonymous with "mafia."Snow Dog wrote:it's you get when you call me scummy.Roxy wrote:Voted. nothing will change my mind. His reply to me only served to prove he is bad. Now I am a bitch - well thanks Snow! I think you are quite peachy! <3
Yeah. "He's scummy." "He's a baddie". "He's totally evil"zeek wrote:On some other site I think "scum" is synonymous with "mafia."Snow Dog wrote:it's you get when you call me scummy.Roxy wrote:Voted. nothing will change my mind. His reply to me only served to prove he is bad. Now I am a bitch - well thanks Snow! I think you are quite peachy! <3
"He's Long Con"Long Con wrote:Yeah. "He's scummy." "He's a baddie". "He's totally evil"zeek wrote:On some other site I think "scum" is synonymous with "mafia."Snow Dog wrote:it's you get when you call me scummy.Roxy wrote:Voted. nothing will change my mind. His reply to me only served to prove he is bad. Now I am a bitch - well thanks Snow! I think you are quite peachy! <3
Synonymous. No offense should be taken, I consider these regular game terms.
DharmaHelper wrote:"He's Long Con"Long Con wrote:Yeah. "He's scummy." "He's a baddie". "He's totally evil"
Synonymous. No offense should be taken, I consider these regular game terms.
This is probably the best case I've read so far.timmer wrote:Here's one for those of you thinking DH is bad.
The Day 1 lynch ended up tied. DH had 7 votes. MetalMarsh had 7 votes. The poll closed at 6:53pm Epig's time.
If we assume DH is bad for a minute, then likely he would have a teammate or two helping him out. And with the knowledge that votes could be changed, help could come at any time.
Well, lookie here.
Snow Dog posted this:
at 6:53, meaning he voted one minute before the end of the poll.Snow Dog wrote:vOTED BOOMSLANG IN THE END.
But then reversed and posted this two minutes later:
That was posted two minutes after the poll closed, meaning Snowie voted at literally the last possible second. But he REALLY didn't want to be seen as helping DH, did he? This post reads as the MM vote was a mistake, and golly gee the time expired. Well he KNEW the time was expiring, he has posts talking about how time was running out and he had to make a decision. I don't buy that he swung from Boomslang to MM to llama all in the space of 90 seconds, but oh darn his vote got stuck halfway through the thought process. this reads like a panicked help vote for DH.Snow Dog wrote:i CHANGED to MM. Thought better of it and decided to vote Llama. I'm all over the place. Unfortunately the time was up and my vote is still on MM.
Sorry MM.
Day 2, Snow Dog spends most of the day saying he thinks he'll vote thellama.
Then posts this:
But then 20 minutes before the end of the poll:Snow Dog wrote:Ok Llama. i think I am satisfied for now.
Made still not sure about. damn. Made is so easy to suspect but that don't make him bad.
The only other post he made that mentioned Made was this:Snow Dog wrote:Ok before times runs out. I am trusting Made but I am going back to Llama. He just seems wrong to me. Not super confident with this vote but it's the best I got at the ppresent.
Votes LLama
But that night when MP mentioned Snowy and Made, Snowy replied:Snow Dog wrote:
Made always looks bad. I know this from the Cars game.
He didn't really?Snow Dog wrote:addedndum. I said plenty about Made, MP. don't go making things up now.
Day 3 he says he thinks DH seems civvie (DH: "But what i read sounds believable")
Day 4 he voted fairly early on for Boomslang, as did DH later. Neither voted for DF.
Day 5, the Bass vs Dom lynch. Both Snowy and DH voted for Dom instead of Bass. So they avoided voting for DF (a suit) and both chose to vote Dom (a Sorcerer) over Bass (a Suit).
So there is a fairly strong correlation between Snowy and DH, and Snowy's last second voting antics on Day 1 suggest a panicked save of DH as well.
Sorry, I know I'm hopping into this conversation late. I'm mostly familiar with the books, but can a horcrux be a spell? I thought they were objects.S~V~S wrote:So do you think Reys curse or similar posting effects could have been a horcrux? Or just normal night powers that last one day?juliets wrote:The role description for Voldemort says his horcruxes must be used each night and die out after use.S~V~S wrote:I don't understand why disappearing after one day makes a difference. Could you explain this?juliets wrote:I missed SVS's post about Lily being an avatar of light. Forget what I said in my last post.
I don't like it. It's not what i signed up for.Long Con wrote:Yeah. "He's scummy." "He's a baddie". "He's totally evil"zeek wrote:On some other site I think "scum" is synonymous with "mafia."Snow Dog wrote:it's you get when you call me scummy.Roxy wrote:Voted. nothing will change my mind. His reply to me only served to prove he is bad. Now I am a bitch - well thanks Snow! I think you are quite peachy! <3
Synonymous. No offense should be taken, I consider these regular game terms.
Yeah, I don't like it either; I always preferred the term baddie or mafia.S~V~S wrote:Tbh I absolutely hate the term scum. I dislike seeing it, but I get that it is the norm for some sites.
Who? He's playing?MovingPictures07 wrote:And what do people think of Russtifinko this game?
He just posted on the last page.DharmaHelper wrote:Who? He's playing?MovingPictures07 wrote:And what do people think of Russtifinko this game?
27 posts. My point being he's like smoke he's so blendy. No real read one way or the other. Whereas there are a number of players I know for a fact are involved, and I have opinions on.MovingPictures07 wrote:He just posted on the last page.DharmaHelper wrote:Who? He's playing?MovingPictures07 wrote:And what do people think of Russtifinko this game?
He can't have THAT many posts. I might even reread them myself.
I was originally going to ask, when you say other team, what do you mean? Not your team?S~V~S wrote:I am not Doms teammate; I adore him & I adore Bass, and that's how it is. I hated yesterdays poll, and that is why I kept saying it. I was tortured and unhappy, and wanted everyone to know it, especially the Host. I was not bad, not am I. Dom is gonna get lynched without me, so i am gonna vote for Daisy. I think she is on the other team, Voldys team. I am gonna vote now, and leave while my dignity is still intact. Do you not believe this?
And am mad as hell that it is Day 5 and i was not recruited *tears* ?
Linki, right about SVS?? I just fucking outed myself lol.
Solid points.MovingPictures07 wrote:So looking over Russ's posts:
- Thinks DH is sketchy on D1
- Thinks the case on Made is good on D2, misses the vote
- Says he suspects people who say "I'm a civ" and similar on D3
- Voted Boomslang on D3, saying that Made is cleared and is inclined to "give DH more time"
- He says the case on DF is "no stronger than the one on Boomslang" D3
- He even clarified and said they are "equally weak" but his "gut" leans Boomslang when I was asking him about it
- Got pinged by Dom on D4 but expressed he didn't want to vote for either player.... BUT THEN votes Bass on D4
- Isn't sure about me since I got outed, votes Dom even though he hates voting for outed players D5
- Then there's his post on the last page...
votes Russtifinko
Honestly, I'd lean that way too, but I can't get past how he had multiple posts on D3 when I was questioning him saying that he suspected Boomslang and DF the same (thought they were equally weak), but kept arguing with me about DF and then voted Boomslang because his "gut" felt it more.zeek wrote:I dunno, his vote for Bass when the lynch wasn't done and dusted makes me think Sorceror.
I'm tempted to vote Russ too now. Really want to lynch a Sorceror to get a bit of fucking civ cred.
No idea. I'll wait to better answer once I know how Russ flips, assuming he even does.zeek wrote:Yeah well I've lynched a Suit in a tight 1-on-1 lynch, a lynched Sorceror might help quell doubts about me. Usually circumstances convince everyone of my civvieness by now. No luck this game!
If Russ is Suit, who do you think the final one is then?
I wanna hear from Made. Suspects, thoughts, anything.
I'm really tempted. I should now I've said it or I'll be accused of a going back on it...MovingPictures07 wrote:Are you going to vote for him then?
as I read through as much Russi could. Didn't see anything. But just read your views above and yeah, you could be right I guess. Problem is I'm dead beat right now. I don't think I can make a sensible vote. I just want to sleep at the moment.MovingPictures07 wrote:No idea. I'll wait to better answer once I know how Russ flips, assuming he even does.zeek wrote:Yeah well I've lynched a Suit in a tight 1-on-1 lynch, a lynched Sorceror might help quell doubts about me. Usually circumstances convince everyone of my civvieness by now. No luck this game!
If Russ is Suit, who do you think the final one is then?
I wanna hear from Made. Suspects, thoughts, anything.
Are you going to vote for him then?
Interesting way to respond to the discussion. Just a way a teammate should, IMO.zeek wrote:Woah, Russ does just have 27 posts. Guess he's quoted such big posts it tricks you into thinking he's said more than he has.
Odd that he says Sorcerer.zeek wrote:I dunno, his vote for Bass when the lynch wasn't done and dusted makes me think Sorceror.
I'm tempted to vote Russ too now. Really want to lynch a Sorceror to get a bit of fucking civ cred.
Really weird question to ask. Especially since:zeek wrote:Yeah well I've lynched a Suit in a tight 1-on-1 lynch, a lynched Sorceror might help quell doubts about me. Usually circumstances convince everyone of my civvieness by now. No luck this game!
If Russ is Suit, who do you think the final one is then?
I wanna hear from Made. Suspects, thoughts, anything.
He asks DH who he thinks the Suits are here as well. Why does he care so much if he wants to nab a Sorcerer?zeek wrote:I'm really tempted. I should now I've said it or I'll be accused of a going back on it...MovingPictures07 wrote:Are you going to vote for him then?
I'm torn.
DH, who do you think the Suits are?
Long Con wrote:Also, even if Hedgeowl is the Mad Hatter... why would we lynch her? It's not in anyone's win condition to kill the Mad Hatter, barring some secret. I'm especially surprised at MP for voting an Indy, for obvious reasons. What's up MP, is this a trolly jab of some sort? The Mad Hatter also hasn't killed anyone or really done any harm, beyond some forcing-curses or whatever.
What is this tea party and why wasn't I invited? Would announcing my interaction with hattie removed me from the guest list?DharmaHelper wrote:Hold on, mind-blowing theory time.
We know there are a crazy amount of MIA people. We also know that at least two of them (Made and Rey) vanished after either posting oddly or in Mades case outright being targeted by the Hatter.
What if *some* of these players are not inactive at all? What if they are otherwise engaged? At a tea party perhaps?
But that leaves one question, who could be the Mad Hatter?
The one person to have absolutely zero contact in-thread (and therefore the longest time spent at the Tea Party)
Patient Zero, Mad Hatter. Hedgeowl.
speaking of which, would the narrator know they are the narrator, or do they just kinda exist in a similar fashion to Concord in presumably this game and Monty python?zeek wrote:Oh look, thread evidence.zeek wrote:MP's 99% claim makes me think he chose her as the Narrator and, thus, knows her role.timmer wrote:As to SpaceDaisy. MP, I would like you to go into DETAIL about why you are thinking civ here. Obviously you have an agenda, and the fact that you are outed and playing an ostensibly pro-civ game doesn't change that. You DO have an agenda to see your recruits survive. So when I see you defend someone as civ at this point in the game, if you want me to listen to you, you will need to DEMONSTRATE your reasons. I don't think anyone, outside of your recruits, will just simply trust you. At least, they shouldn't. So I'm willing to listen, how is SD civ?
While the player choice is definitely odd imo, we all have people this game who we kinda trust a bit right? If a player attacks a player that you trust, wouldn't that make you suspicious of both, or does Mongoose think this is civ vs civ?MovingPictures07 wrote:Mongoose wrote:I'll vote for Hedgeowl now because I don't really wanna vote LC or DH and I'm about to take Theraflu, which will basically make me seem like I'm on a serious acid trip.
If you notice someone talked in another thread, or in irc or something, would it be improper to mention it in this game?timmer wrote:And sable is posting in the film directors game as we speak, which kind of pisses me off.
DharmaHelper wrote:27 posts. My point being he's like smoke he's so blendy.
I just knew when I defended DH today that someone would bring up my vote on Day 1. IT WAS DAY 1!!! I'm learning never to change opinions on anything. And come on, EVERYONE expressed they didn't want to vote for either player on Day 4. That's nothing special. S~V~S is STILL expressing it. And lo and behold, 2 baddies.MovingPictures07 wrote:So looking over Russ's posts:
- Thinks DH is sketchy on D1
- Thinks the case on Made is good on D2, misses the vote
- Says he suspects people who say "I'm a civ" and similar on D3
- Voted Boomslang on D3, saying that Made is cleared and is inclined to "give DH more time"
- He says the case on DF is "no stronger than the one on Boomslang" D3
- He even clarified and said they are "equally weak" but his "gut" leans Boomslang when I was asking him about it
- Got pinged by Dom on D4 but expressed he didn't want to vote for either player.... BUT THEN votes Bass on D4
- Isn't sure about me since I got outed, votes Dom even though he hates voting for outed players D5
- Then there's his post on the last page...
votes Russtifinko
Yeah could be . You've been sure before though.MovingPictures07 wrote:That said, I won't put too much cart before horse, but I really think Russ is a better way to go over DH and Snowy right now.
Snowy, consider the points I've illustrated. Don't you find it weird the way Russ voted Boomslang if he thought the cases on him and DF were "equally weak"? Don't you find it weird that he voted for Bass over Dom if he was pinged by Dom and not Bass? Don't you find it weird that he thought DH was pretty sketchy on D1, but gradually backed off "giving him more time", and now finds him "very genuine" and thinks it doesn't make sense to act the way he is if he's bad?
I tell you what, I think Russ is bad. I really do.
zeek wrote:LOL MP
I asked you who you think the final Suit is because I didn't agree Russ is likely one. I asked DH because I wanted to see his answer, as I suspect he is a Suit. Trying to work through the possibilities.
But whatever, vote for me. I dare you :P
Holy shit, you're definitely bad. Sorry man, but your response here vindicates me. But I'll respond to your response nonetheless.Russtifinko wrote:DharmaHelper wrote:27 posts. My point being he's like smoke he's so blendy.
I just knew when I defended DH today that someone would bring up my vote on Day 1. IT WAS DAY 1!!! I'm learning never to change opinions on anything. And come on, EVERYONE expressed they didn't want to vote for either player on Day 4. That's nothing special. S~V~S is STILL expressing it. And lo and behold, 2 baddies.MovingPictures07 wrote:So looking over Russ's posts:
- Thinks DH is sketchy on D1
- Thinks the case on Made is good on D2, misses the vote
- Says he suspects people who say "I'm a civ" and similar on D3
- Voted Boomslang on D3, saying that Made is cleared and is inclined to "give DH more time"
- He says the case on DF is "no stronger than the one on Boomslang" D3
- He even clarified and said they are "equally weak" but his "gut" leans Boomslang when I was asking him about it
- Got pinged by Dom on D4 but expressed he didn't want to vote for either player.... BUT THEN votes Bass on D4
- Isn't sure about me since I got outed, votes Dom even though he hates voting for outed players D5
- Then there's his post on the last page...
votes Russtifinko
You can be mad I didn't follow your case on Day 3, I guess. But please be honest with yourself and tell me the DF case was stronger than the Boomslang one. You can't, because it wasn't.
As for few posts and blendiness, guilty. I've been having trouble getting into the game for whatever reason, which I realize kinda sucks for our terrific host and the other players. So I haven't been reading or posting as much as I should, and haven't formed as strong opinions as I usually do. I'll try to pick it up if I stay alive.
Lots o' linki
Like I said, cart before horse. Who knows if I'm even right about Russ? I'm just really feeling the case since I think there's evidence for him to be on either team.zeek wrote:LOL MP
I asked you who you think the final Suit is because I didn't agree Russ is likely one. I asked DH because I wanted to see his answer, as I suspect he is a Suit. Trying to work through the possibilities.
But whatever, vote for me. I dare you :P
