The Donner Party - Day 7

#851

Black Rock wrote:
Zomberella12 wrote:I'm thinking that Rico just killed Llama, or someone else did it to frame him. If Rico did it, he is a bad civvie. Does that exist?
No, but civvies make mistakes all the time.

So, a civvie was just killed and the vote is split between two likely civvies (imo).

I'm voting for Bass as well, unless someone can tell me why I shouldn't.

I don't get the Bass votes instead of Russ. What exactly has Bass said that was considered suspicious by anyone so far? This is coming out of the blue, when Russ is only telling us why what we think isn't right, and has not given anything other than that.

I would consider voting for Ty

#852

FZ. wrote:
Black Rock wrote:
Zomberella12 wrote:I'm thinking that Rico just killed Llama, or someone else did it to frame him. If Rico did it, he is a bad civvie. Does that exist?
No, but civvies make mistakes all the time.

So, a civvie was just killed and the vote is split between two likely civvies (imo).

I'm voting for Bass as well, unless someone can tell me why I shouldn't.
I don't get the Bass votes instead of Russ. What exactly has Bass said that was considered suspicious by anyone so far? This is coming out of the blue, when Russ is only telling us why what we think isn't right, and has not given anything other than that.

I would consider voting for Ty

Well I'm open to options, just not the leading two.

#853

Also I voted Bass because he had a vote and Ty did not.

#854

Black Rock wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Black Rock wrote:
Zomberella12 wrote:I'm thinking that Rico just killed Llama, or someone else did it to frame him. If Rico did it, he is a bad civvie. Does that exist?
No, but civvies make mistakes all the time.

So, a civvie was just killed and the vote is split between two likely civvies (imo).

I'm voting for Bass as well, unless someone can tell me why I shouldn't.
I don't get the Bass votes instead of Russ. What exactly has Bass said that was considered suspicious by anyone so far? This is coming out of the blue, when Russ is only telling us why what we think isn't right, and has not given anything other than that.

I would consider voting for Ty
Well I'm open to options, just not the leading two.

I'm with FZ on this. There is no evidence against Bass and lots of evidence against Russ and LC.

#855

I just went over the list of players and over who people are defending. It seems like it's impossible to not hint in this game. The minute you say you think someone is okay, it makes people assume you're on their team. And if I'm getting it right, and LC and BR are legit, then it makes Russ legit as well.
This leaves me with Trice, TY, Blooper and Splints. Am I missing anyone? I think the baddies are laying low until we lynch someone. They can't defend anyone and are just hoping to skate by until they change roles

linki: would you consider voting for Russ?

linki: Splints, what do you think about my theory? :P

#856

Black Rock wrote:Also I voted Bass because he had a vote and Ty did not.

Ty is new, that might account for his lack of votes.

I would consider switching my vote to Russ. Trice didn't have a good reason for voting for LC. You could be right about him being bad.

#857

I changed my vote to Ty right now.

#858

Black Rock wrote:I changed my vote to Ty right now.

LOL, I just switched to Trice. Thought it better to lynch a veteran and give the newbie a chance to get more experience

#859

Let's all decide on one person, so LC and Rico don't get lynched

#860

FZ. wrote:Let's all decide on one person, so LC and Rico don't get lynched

Well I'm going to put my trust in you and switch now.

#861

Does my vote still count?

#862

If it were up to me, I'd rather you guys would stay at or lynch LC from the two of us.

#863

Ricochet wrote:If it were up to me, I'd rather you guys would stay at or lynch LC from the two of us.

I imagine that would be your opinion.

#864

How about you both move it, LC and Rico?

#865

FZ. wrote:
Long Con wrote:
FZ. wrote:Could LC just be a jester? Or is he acting like that to make us think he is, so we don't lynch him?
No one wants to lynch a jester! But no, I'm just a regular Civvie dude, I don't know who's bad or anything. I'll try to find a new place for my vote now.
No, but I don't find him suspicious for now, and I think the votes are spread enough. What do you think about Russ? Zomb and Splints were considering him as well, so we can all vote there

that is not true

#866

thellama73 wrote:Does my vote still count?

#867

fingersplints wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Long Con wrote:
FZ. wrote:Could LC just be a jester? Or is he acting like that to make us think he is, so we don't lynch him?
No one wants to lynch a jester! But no, I'm just a regular Civvie dude, I don't know who's bad or anything. I'll try to find a new place for my vote now.
No, but I don't find him suspicious for now, and I think the votes are spread enough. What do you think about Russ? Zomb and Splints were considering him as well, so we can all vote there
that is not true

What isn't? You weren't considering voting Russ?

#868

FZ. wrote:How about you both move it, LC and Rico?

I said earlier LC's dodgy manners probably wouldn't change my D1 vote for him. So I'm fine.

#869

Ricochet wrote:
FZ. wrote:How about you both move it, LC and Rico?
I said earlier LC's dodgy manners probably wouldn't change my D1 vote for him. So I'm fine.

Clearly, you're not going to listen to those defending him

#870

thellama73 wrote:Does my vote still count?

Yes. I suppose Murphy can probably just use his kill at any time of a day/night, not necessarily at the end of them.

#871

FZ. wrote:
fingersplints wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Long Con wrote:
FZ. wrote:Could LC just be a jester? Or is he acting like that to make us think he is, so we don't lynch him?
No one wants to lynch a jester! But no, I'm just a regular Civvie dude, I don't know who's bad or anything. I'll try to find a new place for my vote now.
No, but I don't find him suspicious for now, and I think the votes are spread enough. What do you think about Russ? Zomb and Splints were considering him as well, so we can all vote there
that is not true
What isn't? You weren't considering voting Russ?

That is correct. I will not be voting russ

I'm ok with voting bass or Ty based on low posting reasons since Rico seems to be civ now maybe

Also rip llama. Random game

#872

FZ. wrote:
Ricochet wrote:
FZ. wrote:How about you both move it, LC and Rico?
I said earlier LC's dodgy manners probably wouldn't change my D1 vote for him. So I'm fine.
Clearly, you're not going to listen to those defending him

I'm afraid of defending him, in case he flips bad.

On a more serious note: if he's just a jester, just like Epignosis was, i.e. he is Wasatch or a protected civ, then the outcome of today's lynch doesn't matter. Wait, it does. I'll be lunched, then. So I'll add self-preservation on my reasons, too, at least right now.

#873

For now I am leaving my vote where it is I may change when I get home from work. He ignored thread evidence and multiple opinions and killed Llama, so I will do him the same courtesy and ignore his "signal".

Like I said I will probably get over myself and do the civ thing when I get home, but I am #%&%$# angry.

#874

I'm voting Ty now actually. post more and I will move it off of you!

#875

Okay, I'm out for tonight. Going to bed. I'd suggest changing your votes, but why listen to me?

@linki: SVS, I get why you're upset, but doing that will just cause us another civ, and if we change roles, we might really need that role later on. There is still one kill in his arsenal.

@linki: Splints, what's the point in voting another person who has no votes? You just said you were considering voting Trice (who has 2 votes) as well, yet chose Ty who has no votes. Scummy much? Why don't you give your vote to Trice?

#876

thellama73 wrote:Does my vote still count?

I tried to save you. Don't lunch llama I said.

#877

Why points you to Murphy having only one kill left, FZ.?

#878

when did I say I was considering voting trice?

#879

Zomberella12 wrote:
Long Con wrote:
fingersplints wrote:And I just realized that Metalmarsh was Tamsen Donner. That really really sucks for the Civvies, Tamsen could have been the key to winning the game.
Here is more of my evidence against LC - "That really sucks for THE CIVVIES!?" Don't you mean - "That really sucks for us?"

Ok, I was on the fence between Rico and and LC. Rico sounds genuinely resigned as a doomed civvie, and LC sounds like a baddie provocateur who isn't scared of getting eaten.

I'm changing my vote. Long Con is on the menu!

#880

and FZ, the point of voting him even though he only has one vote is to encourage him to post more. I will move if another better case presents itself but for now I'll vote there.

#881

fingersplints wrote:when did I say I was considering voting trice?

Sorry, I checked and you said Bass or Ty, not Trice or Ty. I still think you're bad.

Is there something I'm missing? I don't get all the votes on LC. I really don't.
Good night

@linki: I don't buy it Splints. I think you and Trice are on the same team, and it's not a good team

#882

Well RIP llama that was pretty crazy. I don't think I'm going to keep my vote on rico. I not sure where I'm going to move it. Its probably between LC and Trice.

#883

I switched to LC.

#884

Zomberella12 wrote:
Black Rock wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Black Rock wrote:
Zomberella12 wrote:I'm thinking that Rico just killed Llama, or someone else did it to frame him. If Rico did it, he is a bad civvie. Does that exist?
No, but civvies make mistakes all the time.

So, a civvie was just killed and the vote is split between two likely civvies (imo).

I'm voting for Bass as well, unless someone can tell me why I shouldn't.
I don't get the Bass votes instead of Russ. What exactly has Bass said that was considered suspicious by anyone so far? This is coming out of the blue, when Russ is only telling us why what we think isn't right, and has not given anything other than that.

I would consider voting for Ty
Well I'm open to options, just not the leading two.
I'm with FZ on this. There is no evidence against Bass and lots of evidence against Russ and LC.

I agree

#885

That was...an unexpected turn of events. RIP llama!

I was pretty set for Rico, but it looks like it could be a set-up, as others said. From my reading, it looks like lots of people are voting LC because he's "playing the jester" and not giving a crap (I mean that in the way that you're not caring what others think, rather than saying you're not caring about the game). I don't want to vote for him because of that, and that's all I see as reasoning.

My second choice was Russ from the pings from last night, and I see others are toeing that suspicion, yet not sure whether to go for it. I believe I'll go there and see what happens.
And now, time for some fancy birthday victuals (AKA probably Taco Bell, because I'm a classy lady

)

#886

Oh, I see others changed their minds. Well hot dang. Oh well.

#887

I am going to trust BR and FZ

#888

I have wanted to lunch LC the whole game but FZ pointed out that he did have Russ and Black Rock defend him. That's not to say that they aren't all three bad, but defending other baddies would be a bad baddie strategy (say that five times fast)! Keeping my vote on Russ, taking a good look at Tricer.

#889

I notice the vote on Trice is getting momentum and I can't see what the charges on him for D2 are, besides that he suspects LC for not backing up his suspicions and for acting nonchalantly, which to me reads like a pretty genuine, two-day long suspicion on LC. I can understand LC voting him for that, I can understand both BR and FZ defend LC's behaviour as not that much of a deal, but otherwise... what else is there? This screams late lynch train to me and I'm not on board with it.

#890

So Zomba, you moved your vote to Russ thus almost guaranteeing an LC lynch?

Linki, well you were hoping to lead one on me I am sure had Llama come up bad.

#891

I don't understand what you mean. I asked for people's reasoning for which Trice would be bad, other than their obvious discontent with him gunning LC hard.

#892

S~V~S wrote:So Zomba, you moved your vote to Russ thus almost guaranteeing an LC lynch?

Linki, well you were hoping to lead one on me I am sure had Llama come up bad.

The whole day I've been looking at LC and Russ. I've never considered Tricer. I don't want LC to get lunched any more but I can't in good conscience vote for Trice without anything to back it up. Are you saying that you don't think Russ is bad?

#893

Come on snowman, switch your vote.

#894

Zomberella12 wrote:Come on snowman, switch your vote.

You're not the boss of me.

#895

Trice has a more possible connection to Epi and defended him HARD, and he was the one I thought I'd end up voting today when the day began. Thinking about it, I also think his suspicion of LC is a bit opportunistic.

I know LC's antics are weird, and I can't make heads or tails of it, but he read genuine to me earlier. Only reason I switched to LC was given I didn't want to lynch Rico and wasn't sure I'd be back in time.

Switching to Trice

#896

MovingPictures07 wrote:Trice has a more possible connection to Epi and defended him HARD, and he was the one I thought I'd end up voting today when the day began. Thinking about it, I also think his suspicion of LC is a bit opportunistic.

I know LC's antics are weird, and I can't make heads or tails of it, but he read genuine to me earlier. Only reason I switched to LC was given I didn't want to lynch Rico and wasn't sure I'd be back in time.

Switching to Trice

I still think my vote for Russ is a good vote. I hope you're not wrong about Tricer.

#897

Snowman wrote:
Zomberella12 wrote:Come on snowman, switch your vote.
You're not the boss of me.

Apparently I am.

#898

MovingPictures07 wrote:Trice has a more possible connection to Epi and defended him HARD, and he was the one I thought I'd end up voting today when the day began. Thinking about it, I also think his suspicion of LC is a bit opportunistic.

I know LC's antics are weird, and I can't make heads or tails of it, but he read genuine to me earlier. Only reason I switched to LC was given I didn't want to lynch Rico and wasn't sure I'd be back in time.

Switching to Trice

Hmmmmm....

#899

Zomberella12 wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Trice has a more possible connection to Epi and defended him HARD, and he was the one I thought I'd end up voting today when the day began. Thinking about it, I also think his suspicion of LC is a bit opportunistic.

I know LC's antics are weird, and I can't make heads or tails of it, but he read genuine to me earlier. Only reason I switched to LC was given I didn't want to lynch Rico and wasn't sure I'd be back in time.

Switching to Trice
I still think my vote for Russ is a good vote. I hope you're not wrong about Tricer.

I honestly have not much of a clue if Trice is bad, but going into today the players I thought I trusted least and seemed perhaps most connected to Epi were Rico, Russ, and Trice, so it's OK with me. I do feel bad he isn't around to defend himself though.

#900

And time!

Here is the poll:

We have been here before