Who Framed Roger Rabbit? [Day 10]

#901

Well this sucks. Golden was the only person I trusted. See you in the next game Golden. I had fun playing with you again.

Linki: I had to ask but I really didn't think it was you. Your reaction seemed genuine.

#902

RIP Golden. Even when cursed, you were a helpful civ. I will miss you.

If MP had a switch, why did he need to vote Rabbit to save himself? This result makes me think that the baddies are experienced (and possibly sadistic) players. Having Aces flip bad, made Golden look good. Now having Golden flip good, makes MP look bad. Maybe there's more than one lynch switch power. This is too much thinking for a Friday night.

Here is my sexy song.
http://youtu.be/5Il1ivUR-2E

#903

Elohcin wrote:I hate lynch manipulations. I feel like....why even try?

No kidding!

#904

Black Rock wrote:Well this sucks. Golden was the only person I trusted. See you in the next game Golden. I had fun playing with you again.

Linki: I had to ask but I really didn't think it was you. Your reaction seemed genuine.

Ditto to all of this that BR just said.

#905

good luck everyone. Ill be watching.

#906

MovingPictures07 wrote:And I'm absolutely convinced you're bad now, juliets, I can't believe you of all people railroaded me like that, without much of any warning, because I "threatened" people, which I didn't at all. I was giving you the BOTD, but the way you acted towards me this lynch even though we both were in almost the exact same seat re: connection to Aces makes me positive that you aren't civilian or you would have considered how I felt.

You arent hearing the part where I said it was my opinion. There was something about the tone of that post that sounded like you reacted in anger because people were paying attention to what Goldne said instead of you. So, you just threatened to vote us. That's MY INTERPRETATION. Also, you are not taking into account what BF said. I was just adding onto his thoughts. I don't know why you're saying you think I'm bad because of this. It sounds more like your feelings are hurt because I didn't think about you being in the same position as me. Perhaps I didn't, and perhaps thats not fair IF you gave me the botd. Maybe I can give you the botd now that it was not you or your teammates that switched the lynch off of you onto Golden. All depends on what happens from here but your pleas about not being lynched again did sound genuine.

linkis will read after

#907

Epignosis wrote:The gumshoes explored Maroon Cartoons.

In one of the back rooms they found a filing cabinet filled with pitches. One was about a bored but brilliant teenager named Lightbulb who finds a notebook, and using it, can kill anyone whose name he writes. He becomes acquainted with a god of death named Ree-Yuck, who eats apples a lot but throws them up, hence his name. Lightbulb engages in a cat-and-mouse scenario with his nemesis, a great detective named “L” (placeholder). “L” sits on his feet because it helps him think, or so everyone believes, when in fact he suffers from atrocious hemorrhoids due in part to his unhealthy diet of macaroons, cake, and sugar.

“What a stupid ass cartoon.”

“Nobody will ever watch something like this.”

“It needs work.”

“Work? It needs to be written down in the death notebook so that it dies a quick and painless death.”

“A notebook like this?”

Everyone gasped. Wedged in the files was a thin black notebook.

“We have to destroy it. Right now.”

Golden stopped them.

“Hey, wait a minute. That’s a guestbook, not a death notebook! What are you guys, crazy? I’ll just write my name in here like this, and then everyone will know who I am! See?”

Golden has been lynched. He was Roger Rabbit.
It is now Night 2. You have 23 hours to submit your PMs.

I LOVE this Death Note tribute! So perfect!

#908

Lightbulb, LOL

#909

Golden

that really sucks
sorry I missed the vote. I lost track of time. I'm not sure what to make of these lynches honestly.

#910

#911

The Dead may participate in all contests!

I didn't mention that before, did I?

#912

#913

#914

RIP Golden

Um, this is the sexiest of sexy songs, and my opinion will not be swayed:

Cheers, everyone

#915

@ Aces - Okay - that song is really good.

#916

Wtf???

#917

nijuukyugou wrote:RIP Golden

Um, this is the sexiest of sexy songs, and my opinion will not be swayed:

Cheers, everyone

That is about death. It literally has a woman emulating African grievers in it. Did I need to define "sexy?" Or do I need to contact the authorities regarding your proclivities?

#918

Epignosis wrote:
nijuukyugou wrote:RIP Golden

Um, this is the sexiest of sexy songs, and my opinion will not be swayed:

Cheers, everyone
That is about death. It literally has a woman emulating African grievers in it. Did I need to define "sexy?" Or do I need to contact the authorities regarding your proclivities?

#919

Well, I guess the baddies got their revenge for the Day One lynch switch. Somehow. How many secret secrets are out there? Two lynch switches and a curse, any other things anyone has noticed?

MP07, first I'd like to say that my suspicion of you was NOT based on "Golden suspects MP so I do" as a few people apparently did. Second, I'd like to say I no longer suspect you. I believe your reactions were genuine, and that you are a Civvie.

Next, I'd like to suggest that these lynches are something we'll have to figure out. Maybe there will always be some wacky factor involved that we can figure out, and predict and control. This is two lynches in a row... one got a baddie, one got a Civvie. Maybe this isn't two separate secret lynch switches, maybe in Toon Town we have to deal with some other factor. A quick look showed me that it's not the same number of players away from the most-lynch-votes person, and you don't move the lynch up by how many votes the leader got. Those are just a couple of things I thought of off the top of my head, maybe someone else can see a pattern.

#920

Someone will pay for Goldens death

Too bad the weasels can't kill on even nights, because that gives me an extra day to terrorize them

Occams razor, the lynch switch was used up and a civvie did not do it. Wasting a lynch switch to save a civvie did not happen. IMO

#921

Epi, are you going to give us a lynch poll thread?

#922

juliets wrote:Epi, are you going to give us a lynch poll thread?

He's been posting them in the game thread.

#923

juliets wrote:Epi, are you going to give us a lynch poll thread?

No. The polls are in this thread. Just search my "In Topic" if you need to find one.

#924

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
juliets wrote:Epi, are you going to give us a lynch poll thread?
He's been posting them in the game thread.

Yeah, I just wanted to know if he was going to give us a way to find them but as he just pointed out we can find them under his topic. Thanks Epi.

#925

I wonder... If Goldens apparent overnight switch in thinking was because Jessica rabbit found him. Something to think about.

#926

#927

Not bad, Black Rock. But how about this:

#928

Long Con wrote:Well, I guess the baddies got their revenge for the Day One lynch switch. Somehow. How many secret secrets are out there? Two lynch switches and a curse, any other things anyone has noticed?

MP07, first I'd like to say that my suspicion of you was NOT based on "Golden suspects MP so I do" as a few people apparently did. Second, I'd like to say I no longer suspect you. I believe your reactions were genuine, and that you are a Civvie.

Next, I'd like to suggest that these lynches are something we'll have to figure out. Maybe there will always be some wacky factor involved that we can figure out, and predict and control. This is two lynches in a row... one got a baddie, one got a Civvie. Maybe this isn't two separate secret lynch switches, maybe in Toon Town we have to deal with some other factor. A quick look showed me that it's not the same number of players away from the most-lynch-votes person, and you don't move the lynch up by how many votes the leader got. Those are just a couple of things I thought of off the top of my head, maybe someone else can see a pattern.

If there is any truth to that I might hang myself.

#929

#930

This is fcked up

Im kinda shxoked that no one except bf thinks baddies did this
I think that happened
What other explanation there is?
Maybe mp being a civvue with a lynch switxh?

Mp do u know how you survived?

#931

And why golden? He didnt even had votes

#932

Why people say they "no longer suspect mp"? Whats going on?

Pff bb tomorrow i feel really bad and am in my bfa gouse

Perdon typos im in phone

#933

Sophie wrote:Why people say they "no longer suspect mp"? Whats going on?

Pff bb tomorrow i feel really bad and am in my bfa gouse

Perdon typos im in phone

i no longer suspect MP because I thought his reaction to his impending death was honest. He really sounded like a pissed off civ.

#934

#935

Ok. So. A lot of shit happened.

I am VERY conflicted about MP. I think if I hadn't been attempting to vote while rather drunk, and while walking my dog wearing those stupid gloves with the metal threads in te fingers that are supposed to let you use your phone with them on (News Flash: they're really damned frustrating! Especially when your fingers are all wonkajeeby from the booze)....if those factos hadn't played in, I might have held off on my vote a little, and not been so hasty...but honestly, I probably still would've coted MP. Yes, I thought there was merit to Golden's case. Im not sure why agreeing with Golden and bf makes people unsure about me? I'm pretty sure agreeing with or disagreeing with wht other people say is part of this game...since I was in no position to do a more thorough read through and make my own case, and since i agreed that there was some plausibility to MP being an Aces teammate, I voted based on the limited knowledge I had at the time.

Now, MPs angry rants make me wary of voting him again, since they could be genuine civ reactions...but, of course, they could also be frustrate baddie reactions. Regardless, they were pretty off putting and I'm glad MP realized tht and apologized (

), but I dont know what o make of them.

The lynch switch doesn't look great for MP, but LC's idea is an interesting (if terrifying) one.

Black Rock: now that I'm here and sober, is there anything you want me to address? Or is your suspicion of me based on things you're not likely to be talked out of?

Oi. What a loony game.

#936

I agree maybe they aren't lynch switches. I was also wondering if it's possible we are dealing with a baddie role that others die before he is lynched.

#937

Watch out for all this sexiness .

#938

fingersplints wrote:I agree maybe they aren't lynch switches. I was also wondering if it's possible we are dealing with a baddie role that others die before he is lynched.

Yeah, it's possible...but that would only explain one of the lynch "switches", since different people were leading the lunch both times. Day 1, the person withh e second most votes bit the dust, and Day 2 someone with no votes croaked. Based purely on previous game mechanics (which obviously might mean nothing here), I think MM's save reads more like a built in lynch survival (he is essentially removed from the tally of votes, thus leaving Aces with the highest tally), while MP's read more like a switch (where whoever is doing the switching chose to change it to Golden). The switcher may or may not have actually been MP/MPs teammate in that scenario. I can imagine arguments for both.

But that's all speculation.

LCs theory is just as plausible at this point I think.

#939

yes, I didn't mean that would account for both. I was looking for possible explanations for one. like maybe MM is the head of the baddies, and he can't die until his team is dead, so Aces died instead. or he is a civvie who survived for a similar reason. Idk I just find it highly unlikely both are civcie related, and I am just trying to figure out which of the two guys I am most suspicious of. yesterday I would have said MP hands down, but I'm not sure if he would fake that much of a pissed off response.

#940

I've seen too many people fight to the very bitter end to be fooled by something like this. Dex, BLL, someone else whose name I can't recall but she was on that one website that we all abandoned stv? Anyway I think a don't like this is a lot easier to pull off if you know you're surviving.

#941

Anyway I think this is a lot easier EBWOP

#942

fingersplints wrote:yes, I didn't mean that would account for both. I was looking for possible explanations for one. like maybe MM is the head of the baddies, and he can't die until his team is dead, so Aces died instead. or he is a civvie who survived for a similar reason. Idk I just find it highly unlikely both are civcie related, and I am just trying to figure out which of the two guys I am most suspicious of. yesterday I would have said MP hands down, but I'm not sure if he would fake that much of a pissed off response.

Gotcha. And I agree.

#943

Canucklehead wrote:Ok. So. A lot of shit happened.

I am VERY conflicted about MP. I think if I hadn't been attempting to vote while rather drunk, and while walking my dog wearing those stupid gloves with the metal threads in te fingers that are supposed to let you use your phone with them on (News Flash: they're really damned frustrating! Especially when your fingers are all wonkajeeby from the booze)....if those factos hadn't played in, I might have held off on my vote a little, and not been so hasty...but honestly, I probably still would've coted MP. Yes, I thought there was merit to Golden's case. Im not sure why agreeing with Golden and bf makes people unsure about me? I'm pretty sure agreeing with or disagreeing with wht other people say is part of this game...since I was in no position to do a more thorough read through and make my own case, and since i agreed that there was some plausibility to MP being an Aces teammate, I voted based on the limited knowledge I had at the time.

Now, MPs angry rants make me wary of voting him again, since they could be genuine civ reactions...but, of course, they could also be frustrate baddie reactions. Regardless, they were pretty off putting and I'm glad MP realized tht and apologized ( ), but I dont know what o make of them.

The lynch switch doesn't look great for MP, but LC's idea is an interesting (if terrifying) one.

Black Rock: now that I'm here and sober, is there anything you want me to address? Or is your suspicion of me based on things you're not likely to be talked out of?

Oi. What a loony game.

lol, you know me so well. I'll address this later in the day. Feeling too crappy to go back and look.

fingersplints wrote:I agree maybe they aren't lynch switches. I was also wondering if it's possible we are dealing with a baddie role that others die before he is lynched.

Two different people were up for lynch, I doubt two people have such an awesome role.

Epig? Is there something zany going on with the lynches that's maybe not role related?

#944

I'll never tell.

#945

Epignosis wrote:I'll never tell.

#946

Not a big Elvis fan at all, but this version of this song is sex on toast

#947

Sophie, I was the first one right off the bat to say I suspect a baddie lynch switch. Why are you neglecting that information? BF is NOT the only one saying the baddies did it; I don't understand how you received that impression.

To answer your question though, Sophie, I have absolutely no idea how I survived. I was definitely posting under the impression I was a dead man, and I think my posts reflect that.

And to give you a question, Sophie, why the heck did you vote for me? You said you didn't have time to elaborate before, but you don't know either. You didn't appear to be leaning that way AT ALL, and you still haven't satisfactorily explained it, IMO. Seriously, I went back and skimmed through your posts and your vote for me was definitely opportunistic.

-----------------------

BF, I understand and agree that a civilian did not switch the lynch. That doesn't make any sense to me. You seemed to imply something else in your posts, however, or maybe I'm wrong. Did you?

Also, why would you say Golden's change was due to Jessica? I understand your point, but there are two problems with that, from my perspective:
1) From what I recall, Golden did not backpedal off of anyone he suspected yesterday completely. Wouldn't he have if the reason for his change of heart was due to Jessica?
2) Why would you point this out in thread, if it were true? Wouldn't it possibly help the baddies narrow down who Jessica is?

I will admit I also am confounded by Golden's change of heart, especially since I and others asked him, and he sort of vaguely answered it. To you and others who know him better, was this kind of behavior normal for him? It's not like he completely shifted his thoughts, but reevaluated his suspects and shuffled them around. Yet rabbit said he gets tunnel vision. So is this characteristic or not?

And what are you trying to say by "this" is easier to pull off? I don't understand. Are you trying to implicate me without talking about me directly? If you think I've faked this, come out and say it.

-----------------------

Canuck, you literally said nothing about me except what was in your post; can you not see how insanely opportunistic that was?

----------------------

juliets, I'm really sorry if you felt like I was threatening you or anyone else or that I was mad at you in particular. Yes, I did have my feelings hurt, and it's far from being just your fault -- I just was absolutely floored that only a few players who actually suspected me this game (Golden, BF, rabbit, mainly, in that order of most explanation to least of the three) have elaborated on why they think so, but that so many others seem to just hop onto Golden's case against me when I defended against it IMO really well (which I felt Golden even recognized, since he said I sounded civilian, even if it appeared the evidence looked bad for me).

Here's the problem, as I've said over and over, and that's that the evidence is wrong, because I would never openly issue a non-opinion on a teammate and steer the thread singlehandedly at such a critical point in the game. That would be suicidal. And now that Golden was lynched instead of me, and he had no votes, I'm certain this was a baddie lynch switch designed to make me look bad. But I swear it wasn't me.

And I just got really frustrated that I kept asking people to actually elaborate on why they saw me as bad but I didn't really get much out of people, and I kept getting ignored. Not just once but multiple times. (Again, a few players didn't ignore me, but you, Sophie, and Canuck voted for me practically out of nowhere).

I hope that makes sense. It doesn't excuse my behavior for getting really mad, so I really apologize to you and everyone else for that. Sorry folks. I should have counted to five. I just figured I was going to die and had very limited time to get all my thoughts out, and I was super frustrated that I'd been railroaded.

Now I never got to finish my re-read yesterday, but I think this past lynch illuminates a lot of possible avenues for catching baddies tomorrow. I will pursue these with what free time I get today and tomorrow.

And Epi, I just had to read your host post a second time. Too funny.

#948

And regarding the two lynches thus far, I think Occam's Razor suggests one of the following two possibilities:
1) Aces was lynched by a civilian lynch switch and Golden was lynched by a baddie lynch switch
2) Aces was lynched due to vote manipulation (since it was 8-5) and Golden was lynched by a baddie lynch switch (since he would have needed 6 votes to even die)

If 2) is accurate, that means there likely is a decent amount of vote manipulation, but that it was civilian vote manipulation that caused Aces's death.

OR, the baddie team pulled a stunt like Bass, S~V~S, and I did in WWE where we switched the lynch to me, lynching me, and sending all of the thread on a wild goose chase for my teammates. Somehow I really doubt that. But I suppose it's possible. Does anyone think Aces would want to sacrifice himself on purpose on D1?

#949

I do not necessarily think that there is the existence of a role that splints is talking about, unless I suppose that role is MM, and the baddies knew it would get the second highest vote getter lynched (Aces), and they didn't care as much since not many players would believe the top two vote receivers were baddie.

Actually, thinking on this, this is a third possibility, but IMO still the most unlikely.

I've seen D1 lynches with two baddies taking the blunt of the heat before, and the one not lynched getting cleared for some time. Pretty rare though.

#950

BF, Sophie, and Canuck are pinging me something hard at the moment. Sophie and Canuck opportunistically voted for me so insanely, and Sophie's really confused response and Canuck's follow-up do not convince me they had the best intentions at heart. Can either of you explain to me why you think I'm bad and actually address my meta concern that I do NOT non-suspicion my baddie teammates on Day 1?

And BF's vague statements saying "I've seen too many people fight to the very bitter end to be fooled by something like this." and similar sentiments over and over without actually saying that he believes I am bad and switched the lynch ping me HARD. Come on, BF. Stop being vague. If you suspect me, say it. Or at least explain what you're talking about.

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

How About Now?