Who Framed Roger Rabbit? [Day 10]

[thellama73]

Lynch me, then

I can't. It's night. But tomorrow, she is a'comin'!

[Long Con]

Sophie, I personally think you're civ, but I don't think jumping incredulously down the throats of anyone who suspects you is doing you or, more importantly, the civs any favours right now. The baddies are obviously attempting to sow chaos and dissension, and we need to stick together to prevent that. The way to do so is by watching, waiting, seeing what happens, and discussing ALL possibilities and being willing to change our minds to stick with the people we trust. Indignant outbursts don't help civ unity, especially when they're directed at people (eloh) who are very likely civs themselves.
This kind of reactionary in-fighting is exactly what the baddies are hoping happens, because it's the only way they'll survive. If we stick together and keep our heads on straight, we will eliminate them all, in time.

Sensible talk. I have to go to work soon, so I'll just say this now. There's a few people in this thread that I trust, namely Elohcin, Llama, Zomberella, Canuck, fingersplints, and MP. There's people I don't trust: Sophie and rabbit8. The rest, there's some I have a feeling about, but nothing too sure. Lynching me tomorrow would be a mistake.

[rabbit8]

So, if I suspect someone who has had someone suspect them before in the game, I'm "riding everyone's coattails". That's a pretty dumb reason to suspect someone. I think it's telling how you have barely touched upon Bass setup of me, and you're going with an accusation that's basically meaningless even while a bunch of others think they have found a baddie from a stupid mistake. LOL, in a way, you're the one riding Bass' coattails on this one.

It's really hard to figure out which ones are the baddies, and which ones are actually just gullible Civvies, but the fact that you're staying as far away as you can from the "Bass' slip" theory is very telling. If it was your idea, then I'm impressed, it's fucking brilliant.

For the Civvies out there who want to be led the wrong way by some upset baddies ... I promise that if you lynch me, I'll do my best to make it clear who was most involved in the setup. I have some very good ideas about who it is. You don't need me in order to win, but at least you can use this to get a Civvie win. We have lots of time until the Day 5 lynch is over.

Give me a break. It's not a dumb reason. I've seen it dumb and used many times, buddy. I don't need to touch upon a Bass setup, I already think you're bad. The supposed set up only confirms my suspicions. If Zomba would open her eyes she would see it is you at the center of this big evil baddie badass play. You know it, I know it. And it looks like you're about to get away with it with your silver tongue.

Some upset baddies, nice way to paint me as bad there LC. Everyone knows when I post it comes off as mad. But I ever am. IT CLEAR YOU ARE INVOLVED IN THIS SETUP OF YOURSELF.

Now lets discuss tactics. One I've employed myself a time or two. The way to obvious to be a baddie tactic. The one you're trying to get away with here. The one I've pulled off on you a few times for the win in the past. Why you think you can get away with that?

Civvies don't you need you to win, you're right, because you're bad. I don't care you bamboozled in BTSC. Like you're the only person to get a civ to believe you're a civ when you're not. NUB.

[rabbit8]

Sophie, I personally think you're civ, but I don't think jumping incredulously down the throats of anyone who suspects you is doing you or, more importantly, the civs any favours right now. The baddies are obviously attempting to sow chaos and dissension, and we need to stick together to prevent that. The way to do so is by watching, waiting, seeing what happens, and discussing ALL possibilities and being willing to change our minds to stick with the people we trust. Indignant outbursts don't help civ unity, especially when they're directed at people (eloh) who are very likely civs themselves.
This kind of reactionary in-fighting is exactly what the baddies are hoping happens, because it's the only way they'll survive. If we stick together and keep our heads on straight, we will eliminate them all, in time.

Sensible talk. I have to go to work soon, so I'll just say this now. There's a few people in this thread that I trust, namely Elohcin, Llama, Zomberella, Canuck, fingersplints, and MP. There's people I don't trust: Sophie and rabbit8. The rest, there's some I have a feeling about, but nothing too sure. Lynching me tomorrow would be a mistake.

You're a fucking riot. I do love when we're on opposite sides in a game LC. Makes it much more interesting.

[Long Con]

So, if I suspect someone who has had someone suspect them before in the game, I'm "riding everyone's coattails". That's a pretty dumb reason to suspect someone. I think it's telling how you have barely touched upon Bass setup of me, and you're going with an accusation that's basically meaningless even while a bunch of others think they have found a baddie from a stupid mistake. LOL, in a way, you're the one riding Bass' coattails on this one.

It's really hard to figure out which ones are the baddies, and which ones are actually just gullible Civvies, but the fact that you're staying as far away as you can from the "Bass' slip" theory is very telling. If it was your idea, then I'm impressed, it's fucking brilliant.

For the Civvies out there who want to be led the wrong way by some upset baddies ... I promise that if you lynch me, I'll do my best to make it clear who was most involved in the setup. I have some very good ideas about who it is. You don't need me in order to win, but at least you can use this to get a Civvie win. We have lots of time until the Day 5 lynch is over.

Give me a break. It's not a dumb reason. I've seen it dumb and used many times, buddy. I don't need to touch upon a Bass setup, I already think you're bad. The supposed set up only confirms my suspicions. If Zomba would open her eyes she would see it is you at the center of this big evil baddie badass play. You know it, I know it. And it looks like you're about to get away with it with your silver tongue.

Some upset baddies, nice way to paint me as bad there LC. Everyone knows when I post it comes off as mad. But I ever am. IT CLEAR YOU ARE INVOLVED IN THIS SETUP OF YOURSELF.

Now lets discuss tactics. One I've employed myself a time or two. The way to obvious to be a baddie tactic. The one you're trying to get away with here. The one I've pulled off on you a few times for the win in the past. Why you think you can get away with that?

Civvies don't you need you to win, you're right, because you're bad. I don't care you bamboozled in BTSC. Like you're the only person to get a civ to believe you're a civ when you're not. NUB.

You lost me somewhere in the middle there. Nice to see CAPITAL MAN is back in town though. Anyways, see you after the night is over, gotta go to work.

[fingersplints]

Sophie, I personally think you're civ, but I don't think jumping incredulously down the throats of anyone who suspects you is doing you or, more importantly, the civs any favours right now. The baddies are obviously attempting to sow chaos and dissension, and we need to stick together to prevent that. The way to do so is by watching, waiting, seeing what happens, and discussing ALL possibilities and being willing to change our minds to stick with the people we trust. Indignant outbursts don't help civ unity, especially when they're directed at people (eloh) who are very likely civs themselves.
This kind of reactionary in-fighting is exactly what the baddies are hoping happens, because it's the only way they'll survive. If we stick together and keep our heads on straight, we will eliminate them all, in time.

Sensible talk. I have to go to work soon, so I'll just say this now. There's a few people in this thread that I trust, namely Elohcin, Llama, Zomberella, Canuck, fingersplints, and MP. There's people I don't trust: Sophie and rabbit8. The rest, there's some I have a feeling about, but nothing too sure. Lynching me tomorrow would be a mistake.

Hmmm very interesting list here.

[Elohcin]

Prove it Elo. If what you say is true, there is one very obvious way you can make me believe you

I was thinking between you and one other.

Elo how do you feel about llama?

Yeah, how do you feel about me? Be honest.

I believe I can trust you llama And I have to say, I think I have had more fun with you this game than any other.

And Zomb....I forgot all about lite brite. I loved it so much!!!

Sophie, I personally think you're civ, but I don't think jumping incredulously down the throats of anyone who suspects you is doing you or, more importantly, the civs any favours right now. The baddies are obviously attempting to sow chaos and dissension, and we need to stick together to prevent that. The way to do so is by watching, waiting, seeing what happens, and discussing ALL possibilities and being willing to change our minds to stick with the people we trust. Indignant outbursts don't help civ unity, especially when they're directed at people (eloh) who are very likely civs themselves.
This kind of reactionary in-fighting is exactly what the baddies are hoping happens, because it's the only way they'll survive. If we stick together and keep our heads on straight, we will eliminate them all, in time.

I like this post, but not if you're bad.

Are you bad?

I would so love to be a fly on the wall of the baddie chatzy these days. Just for shiggles you know....I can't imagine what they are talking about.

I trust LC, llama, Zomb, canuck, BR, Splints, possibly MP I am wary of Sophie and Rabbit. Others I am just unsure of...they are quieter of course.

[Canucklehead]

Prove it Elo. If what you say is true, there is one very obvious way you can make me believe you

I was thinking between you and one other.

Not to step on fs' toes, but I just want to say that I think there could be some real mutual and reciprocal benefit if you decide on me.

[fingersplints]

I feel strongest bf is a civvie. I'm a little surprised he hasn't made either of your lists. next is Canuck and llama, except I'm getting a little paranoid about llama, but not ready to abandon my trust yet.

Linki - you don't even know how much benefit there is in choosing me I feel like I am campaigning now lol.
fingersplints 2015

[Elohcin]

Prove it Elo. If what you say is true, there is one very obvious way you can make me believe you

I was thinking between you and one other.

Not to step on fs' toes, but I just want to say that I think there could be some real mutual and reciprocal benefit if you decide on me.

but you trust me already. And I need more trust not surer trust

[Elohcin]

okay, time to work out. I skipped yesterday b/c I was low on time. I'd love to stay and just mafia...but I can't skip two days in a row. See y'all in about an hour and 20.

[Canucklehead]

Prove it Elo. If what you say is true, there is one very obvious way you can make me believe you

I was thinking between you and one other.

Not to step on fs' toes, but I just want to say that I think there could be some real mutual and reciprocal benefit if you decide on me.

but you trust me already. And I need more trust not surer trust

Yeah, but it's not just about trusting you! Being able to speak freely would be super useful.
Super.
Useful.

[Tangrowth]

I'm thoroughly confused. Lol.

[rabbit8]

I'm thoroughly confused. Lol.

About? The BTSC talk? It's funny actually.

[Tangrowth]

I'm thoroughly confused. Lol.

About? The BTSC talk? It's funny actually.

Well, about the stuff with Elo. I can only think of one explanation that would explain what she's been saying, but if it is true, IMO it is incredibly unwise for her to be this brazen about it and it also seems like blatant info dumping to me.

I don't understand how it fits in with LC either. I still think LC is likely bad, but I'm just confused by the last page or so, and what it all means.

[rabbit8]

So, if I suspect someone who has had someone suspect them before in the game, I'm "riding everyone's coattails". That's a pretty dumb reason to suspect someone. I think it's telling how you have barely touched upon Bass setup of me, and you're going with an accusation that's basically meaningless even while a bunch of others think they have found a baddie from a stupid mistake. LOL, in a way, you're the one riding Bass' coattails on this one.

It's really hard to figure out which ones are the baddies, and which ones are actually just gullible Civvies, but the fact that you're staying as far away as you can from the "Bass' slip" theory is very telling. If it was your idea, then I'm impressed, it's fucking brilliant.

For the Civvies out there who want to be led the wrong way by some upset baddies ... I promise that if you lynch me, I'll do my best to make it clear who was most involved in the setup. I have some very good ideas about who it is. You don't need me in order to win, but at least you can use this to get a Civvie win. We have lots of time until the Day 5 lynch is over.

Give me a break. It's not a dumb reason. I've seen it dumb and used many times, buddy. I don't need to touch upon a Bass setup, I already think you're bad. The supposed set up only confirms my suspicions. If Zomba would open her eyes she would see it is you at the center of this big evil baddie badass play. You know it, I know it. And it looks like you're about to get away with it with your silver tongue.

Some upset baddies, nice way to paint me as bad there LC. Everyone knows when I post it comes off as mad. But I ever am. IT CLEAR YOU ARE INVOLVED IN THIS SETUP OF YOURSELF.

Now lets discuss tactics. One I've employed myself a time or two. The way to obvious to be a baddie tactic. The one you're trying to get away with here. The one I've pulled off on you a few times for the win in the past. Why you think you can get away with that?

Civvies don't you need you to win, you're right, because you're bad. I don't care you bamboozled in BTSC. Like you're the only person to get a civ to believe you're a civ when you're not. NUB.

You lost me somewhere in the middle there. Nice to see CAPITAL MAN is back in town though. Anyways, see you after the night is over, gotta go to work.

YES SIR. Now go hide from the thread. LOL. Just kidding.

[thellama73]

voting aces, just arrived home with 1 minute to vote, dont wanna miss it

Followed immediately by:

have been reading thread while in law houses and found myself agreeing with golden case, didnt have time to either respond or read very carefully, ill do it now and brb

So she voted for someone BEFORE reading the case on them, then went back to rationalize the vote. Sure, Aces flipped mafia, but he did not have the most votes, MM did, so it would have been a safe vote for a teammate.

NextL

At this point i think one of the baddies have to be one of the quiet ones. I mean, what a better strategy for a baddie than lie low while other people take the spotlight. And, if im not mistaken, there have been people that barely posted. Dom, Canuck, come to mind, but there are probably other. The game already started a couple of days ago and some people didnt either contribute or posted. Suspicion behaviour if you ask me . Gonna go check who are the quiet ones and brb

Sophie is one of the most vocal players in the game. Nice subtle way of deflecting suspicion off herself by saying the baddies must be quiet. Aces was not very quiet.
But the low posters angle is a problem, because Bass is a low poster, so she has to get out of this. She starts by naming three people, Bass, Dom and Canucklehead.

dom, canuck and bass the clever

have they posted at all? i see dom didnt even vote and canuck and bass voted mm
if they did post (dont remember) have they voiced their suspition?
ill go read what those players have posted

She then follows up by rereading the posts of all three. Of the three, her analysis of Bass is the least accusatory.

Then she accuses Canucklehead for being bad for doing the exact same thing she just did:

well, canucklehead posted more than the other 2, specially in day 0, but after posting a bit that day, she just posted the cartoon and dissapeared. No opinion whatsoever on aces lynching and on her suspects.

Also she said low posters should be looked at and its easy to be one when you are a baddie, weird thing, considering she is being a low poster here

Dom is then killed, leaving her with Canuck and Bass.

But then she abruptly drops her low poster suspicions, claiming she only wanted tgo stimulate conversation, posts this wishy washy suspect list:

After reading rabbit vs lc today im not sure i see either of them as mafia, so i dont know there

Im unsure still about elo or mp. Also, a post of canuck pinged me a bit but i gotta go reread

Then she votes for MP without an explanation.

Im votin mp, no time to ellaborate rn, but imo theres still smthing fishy there

Now she is all friends with Canuck. Why? No reason.

Not again!!! Can't we lynch anyone!?

i think in this case is better that canuck didnt die

maybe we should try to lynch MP tomorrow again and see if the baddies still have one of those lynch switches

What happens next is super shady.

all i gotta say about me is im civvie, it might sounded that i contradicted mtself, but i just made a mistake i cant explain in the thread, im just saying the civvies will sufer a lot if i die, but, then again, it could help the case cause then civvies will know who to lynch next. im ok to being killed, i dont think i will be offendidly (thats probably isnt even a word) defeinding myself on the thread or pulling quotes and posts. Im civvie but if you dont wanna believe me its fine. I trust it will be ok in the end and the civvies left will do whats gotta be done

She hints she has info, says it will be really bad for the civvies if she dies, then says she doesn't mind dying. Why does she not mind if it would be so bad for the civvies?

What happens next is very interesting. This is Sophie's first comments suspecting Bass since her early suspicion of low posters.

I know right. I can't believe all the heat im taking for that vote. LC what should I do?

Slip??????? Wasnt that a PM????

Followed at once by:

So lc and bass are baddie teammates? Nice

Now, to me, it is obvious that Bass's comment was not a slip, but deliberate. It also comes after a large number of people had already basically declared their intent to vote for Bass. What I think happened was that Bass and Sophie agreed that he was doomed, and concocted a plan to take LC down with him, by laying in a fake "slip" and having Sophie respond to it. Sophie was the first person to vote for Bass, awfully eager for someone who hadn't actually suspected him in several days. I don't know Sophie's play style well, but she seems the kind of daring and outrageous player who would attempt such a thing.

I also think her constant taunting of the baddies (thanks for keeping me alive!, etc.) rings hollow and insincere. I expect to vote for Sophie tomorrow.

[thellama73]

EBWOP: I was going to type an introduction to that explaning that these are the reasons I suspect Sophie, but I forgot

[rabbit8]

I'm thoroughly confused. Lol.

About? The BTSC talk? It's funny actually.

Well, about the stuff with Elo. I can only think of one explanation that would explain what she's been saying, but if it is true, IMO it is incredibly unwise for her to be this brazen about it and it also seems like blatant info dumping to me.

I don't understand how it fits in with LC either. I still think LC is likely bad, but I'm just confused by the last page or so, and what it all means.

You know what it means. You know what FS and Canuck are vying for, right?

[rabbit8]

EBWOP: I was going to type an introduction to that explaning that these are the reasons I suspect Sophie, but I forgot

Who you going to NK tonight?

[rabbit8]

EBWOP: I was going to type an introduction to that explaning that these are the reasons I suspect Sophie, but I forgot

It's funny, all the reason you suspect Sophie are all the same reason I don't.

[Canucklehead]

EBWOP: I was going to type an introduction to that explaning that these are the reasons I suspect Sophie, but I forgot

It's funny, all the reason you suspect Sophie are all the same reason I don't.

[Tangrowth]

I'm thoroughly confused. Lol.

About? The BTSC talk? It's funny actually.

Well, about the stuff with Elo. I can only think of one explanation that would explain what she's been saying, but if it is true, IMO it is incredibly unwise for her to be this brazen about it and it also seems like blatant info dumping to me.

I don't understand how it fits in with LC either. I still think LC is likely bad, but I'm just confused by the last page or so, and what it all means.

You know what it means. You know what FS and Canuck are vying for, right?

I would assume I do, yes, but it doesn't necessarily make either of them civilian, nor does it make anyone that Elo has been defending civilian either. I'm not saying I don't know what the possibility means or how it works; I'm saying I don't understand why the hell Elo would be this brazen about it, why those two particular players are fighting for it, and why Elo is even taking suggestions from the thread.

Let's just say that if Occam's Razor is correct, I would NEVER play this role like Elo has. Surely she will be NKed now, if she is being truthful.

[Canucklehead]

I don't think anyone is claiming that anyone involved in this convo is necessarily or even probably civillian. There could be any number of hidden intentions, manipulations, and wahtnot going on (including an attempt to provoke precisely the sort of reaction you just gave, or an attempt by any one of the parties involved to appear civillian when they are not). I also don't think that anyone is naive enough to assume otherwise. I also think Eloh is free to play her role, whatever it might be, however she chooses. If she crosses the line, I'm sure the host will deal with it.

[thellama73]

EBWOP: I was going to type an introduction to that explaning that these are the reasons I suspect Sophie, but I forgot

Who you going to NK tonight?

You, if you're not careful.

[Tangrowth]

I don't think anyone is claiming that anyone involved in this convo is necessarily or even probably civillian. There could be any number of hidden intentions, manipulations, and wahtnot going on (including an attempt to provoke precisely the sort of reaction you just gave, or an attempt by any one of the parties involved to appear civillian when they are not). I also don't think that anyone is naive enough to assume otherwise. I also think Eloh is free to play her role, whatever it might be, however she chooses. If she crosses the line, I'm sure the host will deal with it.

I don't think people are understanding me. I'm not saying anyone is claiming that, except for maybe Elo.

And I'm not trying to tell her how to play her role, but I am shocked that, if it is truthful, she is playing it this way.

[blindfaeth]

I'll also note that there would have been no way for bass to guarantee LC would be there when he posted unless they were teammates.

I was the third-last post above Bass, I was obviously there. Why would you say this when you can just look at the thread and see how it went down? Unless you mean that, in the nine minutes between my post and his, he's supposed to be unable to figure out that I was there.

You mean kind of like how my post was only 7 minutes before this post and two above it and yet I'm not responding for hours? :P

Linki w/ MP.

[blindfaeth]

I feel strongest bf is a civvie. I'm a little surprised he hasn't made either of your lists. next is Canuck and llama, except I'm getting a little paranoid about llama, but not ready to abandon my trust yet.

Linki - you don't even know how much benefit there is in choosing me I feel like I am campaigning now lol.
fingersplints 2015

I'm surprised too, but at least I'm not on the baddie list.

FWIW as of this moment I'm trusting FS, rabbit.
I want to trust/leaning civ: MP, Sophie
No read: Llama
Worried about: bea, BR, nijuu
Suspect: LC, Zomb, Elo

[blindfaeth]

Sorry I neglected to add Canuck to the list, because I was working off the poll, and she had been removed from it yesterday.

I'm trusting Canuck

[Canucklehead]

I feel strongest bf is a civvie. I'm a little surprised he hasn't made either of your lists. next is Canuck and llama, except I'm getting a little paranoid about llama, but not ready to abandon my trust yet.

Linki - you don't even know how much benefit there is in choosing me I feel like I am campaigning now lol.
fingersplints 2015

I'm surprised too, but at least I'm not on the baddie list.

FWIW as of this moment I'm trusting FS, rabbit.
I want to trust/leaning civ: MP, Sophie
No read: Llama
Worried about: bea, BR, nijuu
Suspect: LC, Zomb, Elo

What am I, chopped liver?

[blindfaeth]

I'm thoroughly confused. Lol.

About? The BTSC talk? It's funny actually.

Well, about the stuff with Elo. I can only think of one explanation that would explain what she's been saying, but if it is true, IMO it is incredibly unwise for her to be this brazen about it and it also seems like blatant info dumping to me.

I don't understand how it fits in with LC either. I still think LC is likely bad, but I'm just confused by the last page or so, and what it all means.

I've read that front page a dozen times and it still makes no sense.

The real problem is how many roles have secrets.

[blindfaeth]

I feel strongest bf is a civvie. I'm a little surprised he hasn't made either of your lists. next is Canuck and llama, except I'm getting a little paranoid about llama, but not ready to abandon my trust yet.

Linki - you don't even know how much benefit there is in choosing me I feel like I am campaigning now lol.
fingersplints 2015

I'm surprised too, but at least I'm not on the baddie list.

FWIW as of this moment I'm trusting FS, rabbit.
I want to trust/leaning civ: MP, Sophie
No read: Llama
Worried about: bea, BR, nijuu
Suspect: LC, Zomb, Elo

What am I, chopped liver?

Lol! See add-on post. I'm sorry you felt left out :P

[rabbit8]

I'm thoroughly confused. Lol.

About? The BTSC talk? It's funny actually.

Well, about the stuff with Elo. I can only think of one explanation that would explain what she's been saying, but if it is true, IMO it is incredibly unwise for her to be this brazen about it and it also seems like blatant info dumping to me.

I don't understand how it fits in with LC either. I still think LC is likely bad, but I'm just confused by the last page or so, and what it all means.

You know what it means. You know what FS and Canuck are vying for, right?

I would assume I do, yes, but it doesn't necessarily make either of them civilian, nor does it make anyone that Elo has been defending civilian either. I'm not saying I don't know what the possibility means or how it works; I'm saying I don't understand why the hell Elo would be this brazen about it, why those two particular players are fighting for it, and why Elo is even taking suggestions from the thread.

Let's just say that if Occam's Razor is correct, I would NEVER play this role like Elo has. Surely she will be NKed now, if she is being truthful.

You're working off the assumptions the baddies do not have the same ability as Jessica.

I did that in a couple games. Gave the civvies a BTSC role. Then gave the baddies the same ability, only secret. Mass confusion, sir. It makes for a better game. This host seems to like evil shit, I like him for that and think this is a possibility.

[Tangrowth]

I'm thoroughly confused. Lol.

About? The BTSC talk? It's funny actually.

Well, about the stuff with Elo. I can only think of one explanation that would explain what she's been saying, but if it is true, IMO it is incredibly unwise for her to be this brazen about it and it also seems like blatant info dumping to me.

I don't understand how it fits in with LC either. I still think LC is likely bad, but I'm just confused by the last page or so, and what it all means.

You know what it means. You know what FS and Canuck are vying for, right?

I would assume I do, yes, but it doesn't necessarily make either of them civilian, nor does it make anyone that Elo has been defending civilian either. I'm not saying I don't know what the possibility means or how it works; I'm saying I don't understand why the hell Elo would be this brazen about it, why those two particular players are fighting for it, and why Elo is even taking suggestions from the thread.

Let's just say that if Occam's Razor is correct, I would NEVER play this role like Elo has. Surely she will be NKed now, if she is being truthful.

You're working off the assumptions the baddies do not have the same ability as Jessica.

I did that in a couple games. Gave the civvies a BTSC role. Then gave the baddies the same ability, only secret. Mass confusion, sir. It makes for a better game. This host seems to like evil shit, I like him for that and think this is a possibility.

That's a good point.

[rabbit8]

EBWOP: I was going to type an introduction to that explaning that these are the reasons I suspect Sophie, but I forgot

Who you going to NK tonight?

You, if you're not careful.

But I was offering beer.....You don't like beer? What do you like? Harder stuff?

[blindfaeth]

Who dropped a piano on the chief of police?

Poll ended at Wed Mar 04, 2015 9:47 pm

AceofSpaces
5
blindfaeth (9), Golden (10), Black Rock (19), bea (20), Sophie (23)
22%

blindfaeth
1
MovingPictures07 (14)
4%

juliets
1
rabbit8 (22)
4%

Metalmarsh89
8
Metalmarsh89 (5), AceofSpaces (6), juliets (7), Bass_the_Clever (11), nijuukyugou (13), Zomberella12 (16), Long Con (17), Canucklehead (21)
35%

thellama73
1
Elohcin (12)
4%

Zomberella12
2
thellama73 (4), fingersplints (15)
9%

Day 1 vote for reference, two baddies already on the MM lynch train.

Linki w/ rabbit - thanks, this is the kind of point I was trying to make. With so many secrets, its very possible people are having the wool pulled over their eyes.

I'm not going to assert that's the case by a longshot, but-

Linki again ~.~

[fingersplints]

I'm thoroughly confused. Lol.

About? The BTSC talk? It's funny actually.

Well, about the stuff with Elo. I can only think of one explanation that would explain what she's been saying, but if it is true, IMO it is incredibly unwise for her to be this brazen about it and it also seems like blatant info dumping to me.

I don't understand how it fits in with LC either. I still think LC is likely bad, but I'm just confused by the last page or so, and what it all means.

You know what it means. You know what FS and Canuck are vying for, right?

I would assume I do, yes, but it doesn't necessarily make either of them civilian, nor does it make anyone that Elo has been defending civilian either. I'm not saying I don't know what the possibility means or how it works; I'm saying I don't understand why the hell Elo would be this brazen about it, why those two particular players are fighting for it, and why Elo is even taking suggestions from the thread.

Let's just say that if Occam's Razor is correct, I would NEVER play this role like Elo has. Surely she will be NKed now, if she is being truthful.

You're working off the assumptions the baddies do not have the same ability as Jessica.

I did that in a couple games. Gave the civvies a BTSC role. Then gave the baddies the same ability, only secret. Mass confusion, sir. It makes for a better game. This host seems to like evil shit, I like him for that and think this is a possibility.

I don't know if I am remembering Epis secrets from other game correctly, but for some reason I have the mentality he is like this too (giving baddies and civvies same abilities for confusion) your similarities are scary

[Elohcin]

@MP, about everything you've said...
The only thing I said was that we all needed to read the roles. That was it. Anyone can make whatever they want of what they read in the roles. And, suggestions in the thread? suggestions for what, MP? Splints asked me to prove my civvieness and said I knew how to do so.

[thellama73]

MovingPictures07, I demand you respond to my Sophie case. I demand it!

[Black Rock]

Oh my, Bass really put this thread in an uproar.

I was starting suspect Llama but he has talked me out of that before I even mentioned it. I believe Eloh to be a civvie. She has really stuck her neck out on this one, she certainly would not have if she was a baddie. I really don't see how she is making any suspect list at this point.

[thellama73]

Oh my, Bass really put this thread in an uproar.

I was starting suspect Llama but he has talked me out of that before I even mentioned it. I believe Eloh to be a civvie. She has really stuck her neck out on this one, she certainly would not have if she was a baddie. I really don't see how she is making any suspect list at this point.

Thank you, Black Rock. I regard you as a lady of utmost grace and character.

[nijuukyugou]

Damn all of you and your nighttime talkativeness! Just kidding - I love you all dearly and you keep me somewhat sane

I don't understand all of this trusting and these trusty posts happening without much substance. We had the first lynch we could actually understand what happened, this game is full of shenanigans (I just love that word, so I will use it profusely), and yet we apparently trust each other. But no one trusts the same people. It bothers me when people these things, and a lot of these lists aren't really supported with anything but "I trust so-and-so." Trust in mafia is horribly dangerous. But I suppose that's like saying "the sky is blue" or "oatmeal raisin cookies are pretty delicious."

That's my two cents on that subject. And while I still have a little bit of free time, more thoughts while I remember them. I think llama's look at Sophie is worth considering; I haven't really looked at her, but I think he makes good points with what he found. I think what people are saying about Bass' "slip" (about it not being a slip) has some merit, especially about the PM vs. BTSC business, but I'm in the slip camp, simply because it seems to be the simplest explanation. I like simple. Simply simple simpliness. Is Eloh role-hinting? And why? Perhaps I didn't read thoroughly enough, or it's just banter, so correct me if I'm off base. I know I say this a lot, but I think I had more to say but forgot. I'm willing to discuss other things (or these more thoroughly) while/if I have some time tonight (I miss bantering in real time )

And now, for the greatest toy in the history of toys:


(Mine's broken. After decades, it died. So sad.)

[rabbit8]

Oh my, Bass really put this thread in an uproar.

I was starting suspect Llama but he has talked me out of that before I even mentioned it. I believe Eloh to be a civvie. She has really stuck her neck out on this one, she certainly would not have if she was a baddie. I really don't see how she is making any suspect list at this point.

Bullshit. Baddies stick their necks out all the time from what I remember. Maybe the new crop of baddies don't?

Or at least the baddies who know how to play the game. To dismiss sticking your neck out is absurd.

[Black Rock]

Oh my, Bass really put this thread in an uproar.

I was starting suspect Llama but he has talked me out of that before I even mentioned it. I believe Eloh to be a civvie. She has really stuck her neck out on this one, she certainly would not have if she was a baddie. I really don't see how she is making any suspect list at this point.

Bullshit. Baddies stick their necks out all the time from what I remember. Maybe the new crop of baddies don't?

Or at least the baddies who know how to play the game. To dismiss sticking your neck out is absurd.

Sure they do, but at this level? I doubt it.

[Epignosis]

Night 4: The Acme Factory

The Acme Factory was the source of many of the Toons’ greatest gags- from portable holes to anvils that could smash someone’s skull into a thousand bloody pieces- the chance for laughs was endless.

“Slip and Slide. Sounds like a cure for constipation, huh?”

“What do you make of this thing? It looks like a flashlight, but I ain’t never seen anything what looks like the end piece before in my life.”

A rumble of sniggering came.

“Shoes with a single row of wheels? Hell no. I’d put these on and do myself a mischief.”

An anvil came whirling down from above. It made contact and shot back up, tearing a hole through the roof.

“Ah, springs!”

No one has been killed. It is now Day 5. You have 24 hours to lynch someone.

[Elohcin]

Love the post Love even more that no one died

[rabbit8]

Oh my, Bass really put this thread in an uproar.

I was starting suspect Llama but he has talked me out of that before I even mentioned it. I believe Eloh to be a civvie. She has really stuck her neck out on this one, she certainly would not have if she was a baddie. I really don't see how she is making any suspect list at this point.

Bullshit. Baddies stick their necks out all the time from what I remember. Maybe the new crop of baddies don't?

Or at least the baddies who know how to play the game. To dismiss sticking your neck out is absurd.

Sure they do, but at this level? I doubt it.

Come on, this is me you're talking to. You remember some games we have played together, yes?

Now, your assessment is that Eloh would not do this? I would trust your word on this, I think.


Link: Nice no one died.

[Black Rock]

Oh my, Bass really put this thread in an uproar.

I was starting suspect Llama but he has talked me out of that before I even mentioned it. I believe Eloh to be a civvie. She has really stuck her neck out on this one, she certainly would not have if she was a baddie. I really don't see how she is making any suspect list at this point.

Bullshit. Baddies stick their necks out all the time from what I remember. Maybe the new crop of baddies don't?

Or at least the baddies who know how to play the game. To dismiss sticking your neck out is absurd.

Sure they do, but at this level? I doubt it.

Come on, this is me you're talking to. You remember some games we have played together, yes?

Now, your assessment is that Eloh would not do this? I would trust your word on this, I think.


Link: Nice no one died.

It's also who SHE is. I don't believe Elohcin herself would do this without good reasoning.

[rabbit8]

What do you mean by ho she is? Her role, or her the poster?

Good reasoning with what in mind? I'm not sure I follow.

[rabbit8]

What do you mean by ho she is? Her role, or her the poster?

Good reasoning with what in mind? I'm not sure I follow.

Who she is, sorry eloh, I would not presume to think you're a ho.