Linki - MP, has anyone ever told you that you say "duly noted" a lot?

in case you haven't noticed Benny took you off the poll
Moderator: Community Team
Okay, nevermind, I see at least one civilian possibility. :P Not sure why I didn't put two and two together there.fingersplints wrote:There are civvie possibilities for her to know that. I have figured out most of those things MP, but unfortunately I am unable to figure out how bass knew LC was the judge. maybe it's just a damn lucky guess. unless there is something in the baddie secrets. a role check or something idk
Yes, but because I have doubt about that (and doubt about his Judge-ness), I think Ninja is a much better bet. LC isn't going anywhere, and there is a LOT more uncertainty surrounding him. I think the prudent thing to do is lynch a weasel, and wait to see what people like Eloh have to offer about LC as the day goes on.MovingPictures07 wrote:Duly noted, splints, I'll go check the roles again. Admittedly I don't have them all memorized.
What do you mean? Not sure I follow.Canucklehead wrote:I don't understand why your uncertainty about LC being the Judge and zomba's and the baddies knowledge or lack thereof acctually makes you want to vote LC more?? Shouldn't that put doubt in your mind and make you want to vote him less.....or at least tomorrow??MovingPictures07 wrote:Wow, Canuck, that's astute. I hadn't been pinged at all by Blooper but when you present her posts like that, I don't understand how I wasn't. Very good detective work.
Here's where I'm at right now:
Blooper: Solid candidate for Toon Patrol, possibility for Judge (though no reason to believe it's true, IMO), possibility for civilian (seems doubtful about Canuck's points, but still a possibility)
LC: Solid candidate for Toon Patrol, solid candidate for Judge (though I still don't understand why Zomba is acting like she KNOWS LC is Judge), practically no possibility for civilian (I suppose it's possible but I don't see it)
I see the point regarding if LC is the Judge, then what's the point in lynching him today? It's a very good counterargument, and I otherwise would be leaning Blooper, but there are two questions I have that I just don't understand:
1) How would Zomba know that LC is the Judge?
2) How would a baddie team know that LC is the Judge and devise a plan for Bass to slip up, on purpose? In this case, both the baddie team would have to either know LC is the Judge OR have gotten lucky, AND the slip up had to be purposeful, which frankly I still don't believe is the case.
I could see why a vote for either candidate would be prudent today, but I personally am still leaning LC.
I still think there's a solid possibility that LC is Toon Patrol, don't you?
That's a good point, hadn't thought of that. That said, I still tend to think the first two lynches were straight-up switches, but that's just a theory.fingersplints wrote:my only worry about saving LC for tomorrow is the lynch shenanigans. That it would somehow not go through tomorrow and then he would have the opportunity to kill again. however, I feel like the judge already has NK protection, so it's unlikely that role has any lynch protection.
Linki - MP, has anyone ever told you that you say "duly noted" a lot?I have read the roles a surprising amount of times. I'm too invested in this game now haha
in case you haven't noticed Benny took you off the poll
Fair enough. I still stand by my feelings on the matter, but I can see where you're coming from, and your perspective probably makes more logical sense.Canucklehead wrote:Yes, but because I have doubt about that (and doubt about his Judge-ness), I think Ninja is a much better bet. LC isn't going anywhere, and there is a LOT more uncertainty surrounding him. I think the prudent thing to do is lynch a weasel, and wait to see what people like Eloh have to offer about LC as the day goes on.MovingPictures07 wrote:Duly noted, splints, I'll go check the roles again. Admittedly I don't have them all memorized.
What do you mean? Not sure I follow.Canucklehead wrote:I don't understand why your uncertainty about LC being the Judge and zomba's and the baddies knowledge or lack thereof acctually makes you want to vote LC more?? Shouldn't that put doubt in your mind and make you want to vote him less.....or at least tomorrow??MovingPictures07 wrote:Wow, Canuck, that's astute. I hadn't been pinged at all by Blooper but when you present her posts like that, I don't understand how I wasn't. Very good detective work.
Here's where I'm at right now:
Blooper: Solid candidate for Toon Patrol, possibility for Judge (though no reason to believe it's true, IMO), possibility for civilian (seems doubtful about Canuck's points, but still a possibility)
LC: Solid candidate for Toon Patrol, solid candidate for Judge (though I still don't understand why Zomba is acting like she KNOWS LC is Judge), practically no possibility for civilian (I suppose it's possible but I don't see it)
I see the point regarding if LC is the Judge, then what's the point in lynching him today? It's a very good counterargument, and I otherwise would be leaning Blooper, but there are two questions I have that I just don't understand:
1) How would Zomba know that LC is the Judge?
2) How would a baddie team know that LC is the Judge and devise a plan for Bass to slip up, on purpose? In this case, both the baddie team would have to either know LC is the Judge OR have gotten lucky, AND the slip up had to be purposeful, which frankly I still don't believe is the case.
I could see why a vote for either candidate would be prudent today, but I personally am still leaning LC.
I still think there's a solid possibility that LC is Toon Patrol, don't you?
I understand why you have me as a solid Toon Patrol candidate, because of the Bass thing.MovingPictures07 wrote:LC: Solid candidate for Toon Patrol, solid candidate for Judge (though I still don't understand why Zomba is acting like she KNOWS LC is Judge), practically no possibility for civilian (I suppose it's possible but I don't see it)
I am opposite. I feel much much much more confident about LC but stand by my doubts whether or not we need to lynch him today.Canucklehead wrote:My one reservation about LC being the judge, is that I think he would use the power more strategically, and would use forced votes to be the basis of building cases and getting civ cred in order to stay alive longer...but he hasn't really done any case building at all that I can see. Maybe I've missed it (because I haven't done a close read of LC), but I dunno. I'm seeing an LC who is kind of disengaged (save for his feud with rabbit) which is not how I imagine an indy LC... But I could be wrong about thatMaybe I overestimate how devious LC would be, or maybe he's just doing his machinations behind the scenes and staying neutral in the thread, but I just imagine an indy LC as a more energetic/engaged LC. And then there's Eloh's vouch, which is obviously not iron clad, but it is another item in the mix.
So those are my doubts.
They're tenuous, but they're much stronger than my Ninja doubts.
You guys can see how great my desire to actually study is.Long Con wrote:I understand why you have me as a solid Toon Patrol candidate, because of the Bass thing.MovingPictures07 wrote:LC: Solid candidate for Toon Patrol, solid candidate for Judge (though I still don't understand why Zomba is acting like she KNOWS LC is Judge), practically no possibility for civilian (I suppose it's possible but I don't see it)
Why do you have me as a solid candidate for Judge? And why do you say there's practically no possibility for me to be Civ?
I don't know where either of those two statements are coming from. I can understand the Toon Patrol accusation, and I can argue against it, but it's frustrating to see you say the other two things, because I am a Civ.
I don't believe I ever said you weren't trying, LC, I think you must be thinking of someone else. The only thoughts I had of you pre-Bassgate (I think we should call it this now) were that you were not seeming "overly civilian" and I had you in my ???? list roughly a cycle ago.Long Con wrote:I disagree that I haven't been trying in the thread, and I really don't see how it compares negatively to past games. You've played lots of games with me, MP, and I don't know what you expect. I mean, look at Film Directors. That's my Civ game, how does it compare to my playstyle now?
I've been looking back on Zomberella some more since her Judge accusation of me, and though I thought I had her down for a role, I think she has intentionally deceived. Look at this lynch.
Who's the baddie, Zomberella or Llama? Unless The Judge predicted that Bass would get ALL the votes, and stuck a baddie there with solid prescience.
Zomb is a baddie, and she's just trying to continue the setup that Bass started.
Well, you're allowed to read my posts even if they're responding to MP.fingersplints wrote:have you given up on trying to convince me LC?
Fair enough, I may be mixing up the various vague accusations that my playstyle isn't "overly Civilian" or that I'm not "genuine". There's been a couple of accusations like that, each as impossible to defend against as the last, so I guess I grouped them together in my mind.MovingPictures07 wrote:I don't believe I ever said you weren't trying, LC, I think you must be thinking of someone else. The only thoughts I had of you pre-Bassgate (I think we should call it this now) were that you were not seeming "overly civilian" and I had you in my ???? list roughly a cycle ago.
I did have reason to believe that. It's actually very similar to my reason for believing Llama. There were some doubts about Z though, and given her phony attack on me, and her weirdo vote ("OH, I accidentally clicked on MP... oopsie daisy!"), I'm pretty convinced she's bad now.fingersplints wrote:I thought you also had reason to believe that Zomba was a civvie
What is "civ behaviour"?Canucklehead wrote:Why do you think llama is civ? I haven't seen much resembling civ behaviour from him.
Epignosis wrote:If llama is good, it means we exist in a universe in which multitasking llama can call out the first of two mafia while simultaneously calling out two civilians.
I don't want to live in that universe.
I skimmed it, to be honest. Right now I'm more focused on me, because it won't matter one way or another if Canuck is right or not if I'm dead. I haven't analysed the validity of Canuck's accusations yet, but I do trust that they come from an honest place.fingersplints wrote:how do you feel about Canucks case on nijuu? do you think there is merit there?
Epignosis wrote:If llama is good, it means we exist in a universe in which multitasking llama can call out the first of two mafia while simultaneously calling out two civilians.
I don't want to live in that universe.
Your case against me is that i vote for a baddie on day 1, mention other baddie after that, before anyone have mentiobed him, and then thought that bass post was a slip?? Lol, no wonder why anyones talking about it, except 2 people who said your ""case"" only proved i was civviethellama73 wrote:No one is talking about Sophie, and that is a problem.
Voting for baddies like Bass, for one.thellama73 wrote:What is "civ behaviour"?Canucklehead wrote:Why do you think llama is civ? I haven't seen much resembling civ behaviour from him.
Elohcin wrote:@MP. If Niju is toon patrol, then I don't think LC could be toon patrol. She was adamant about voting for LC over Bass on the day Bass was lynched.
I agree with LC that he has been trying in the thread. He has been trying real hard to win this game IMO.
Werent you sure lc was a civ? Didnt you have info on him????
Now....I feel this is safe for me to say in the thread. And, I know this is going to cause crazy reactions b/c of everything I said yesterday. However, I do NOT trust LC anymore. I do not believe he is toon patrol. I believe he has to be the Judge. LC...I love you man, but I WILL be voting for you tomorrow. As for today I think Canuck's case on Niju is very convincing. I believe she is toon patrol and I will be voting her today. Now, I have come forth against LC and I am hoping that b/c of this, you all will vote with me tomorrow for LC. If not, I know I am a gonner.
Linki: If t helps, I am 99.999999% that zomb is civ.
linki: llama, I think Sophie may be a good way to go too, but I think the case on niju is better. Sophie could have just been an overzealous civ in her reaction to the Bass "slip".
Why were you gullable?Elohcin wrote:Oh, sophie....I was so gullable. SOOOO gullable. Please forgive me. Doesn't mean I still don't have my eye on you. But.....you are not on the top of my list. Niju today, LC tomorrow before he can kill me for learning the truth.
Good, then vote for Sophie like I did and we will all be together.Elohcin wrote:Llama, listen...I am pretty certain we should stick together on lynches and not spread things out too much.
Epignosis wrote:If llama is good, it means we exist in a universe in which multitasking llama can call out the first of two mafia while simultaneously calling out two civilians.
I don't want to live in that universe.
I've told you why. Your reaction to Bass' "slip" made me feel like you were trying to emphasize it and reiterate it. Like you are on Bass' team and trying to MAKE SURE everyone saw the "slip".Sophie wrote:Why were you gullable?Elohcin wrote:Oh, sophie....I was so gullable. SOOOO gullable. Please forgive me. Doesn't mean I still don't have my eye on you. But.....you are not on the top of my list. Niju today, LC tomorrow before he can kill me for learning the truth.
Why do u have your eye on me?
Nope, I vote of my own free will.Sophie wrote:Your case against me is that i vote for a baddie on day 1, mention other baddie after that, before anyone have mentiobed him, and then thought that bass post was a slip?? Lol, no wonder why anyones talking about it, except 2 people who said your ""case"" only proved i was civviethellama73 wrote:No one is talking about Sophie, and that is a problem.
I just take it as if your vote have been directed
Epignosis wrote:If llama is good, it means we exist in a universe in which multitasking llama can call out the first of two mafia while simultaneously calling out two civilians.
I don't want to live in that universe.
Well, then don't lecture me about keeping our votes together when you're the one who didn't do that thing.Elohcin wrote: @llama - I already voted niju, sorry. I am just still on the fence with Sophi as you can see. Too much LC in my head to go after her atm.
Epignosis wrote:If llama is good, it means we exist in a universe in which multitasking llama can call out the first of two mafia while simultaneously calling out two civilians.
I don't want to live in that universe.
Okay, fine....if you don't care to know what I think about things, I'll stop telling youthellama73 wrote:Well, then don't lecture me about keeping our votes together when you're the one who didn't do that thing.Elohcin wrote: @llama - I already voted niju, sorry. I am just still on the fence with Sophi as you can see. Too much LC in my head to go after her atm.
Then you either are on drugs or are a baddie, cause your case only proves im civvie and on the thread there are a lot of people who we have a geniune reason to lynch and you are just hurting our chances with your votethellama73 wrote:Nope, I vote of my own free will.Sophie wrote:Your case against me is that i vote for a baddie on day 1, mention other baddie after that, before anyone have mentiobed him, and then thought that bass post was a slip?? Lol, no wonder why anyones talking about it, except 2 people who said your ""case"" only proved i was civviethellama73 wrote:No one is talking about Sophie, and that is a problem.
I just take it as if your vote have been directed
I was definetely on the top of your list cause you said that I was bass teammate instead of lc, you were pretty sure. Im on my phone and is too hard to quoteand everything on it, but your posts about me being bad are there for anyone else to see.Elohcin wrote:Okay, fine....if you don't care to know what I think about things, I'll stop telling youthellama73 wrote:Well, then don't lecture me about keeping our votes together when you're the one who didn't do that thing.Elohcin wrote: @llama - I already voted niju, sorry. I am just still on the fence with Sophi as you can see. Too much LC in my head to go after her atm.![]()
![]()
![]()
linki: Sophie - your reaction was WAY over the top in my opinion. And it pinged me. I never said it put you at the top of my suspect list.
I'm sorry, I didn't realize "we should keep our votes together" meant "vote for who I tell you to instead of who you think is bad."fingersplints wrote:why didn't you wait for us llama
Epignosis wrote:If llama is good, it means we exist in a universe in which multitasking llama can call out the first of two mafia while simultaneously calling out two civilians.
I don't want to live in that universe.
Exactly. Glad we clarified that. :Pthellama73 wrote:I'm sorry, I didn't realize "we should keep our votes together" meant "vote for who I tell you to instead of who you think is bad."fingersplints wrote:why didn't you wait for us llama
I like you, Splintsy. You're a stand up dame.fingersplints wrote:Exactly. Glad we clarified that. :Pthellama73 wrote:I'm sorry, I didn't realize "we should keep our votes together" meant "vote for who I tell you to instead of who you think is bad."fingersplints wrote:why didn't you wait for us llama
I have to read some stuff on Sophie. will respond later
Epignosis wrote:If llama is good, it means we exist in a universe in which multitasking llama can call out the first of two mafia while simultaneously calling out two civilians.
I don't want to live in that universe.
Elohcin, you're a sweet lady. Thanks for believing in me. I really did appreciate your support during Bass' genius setup move, and I don't feel like that support was mistaken, since it WAS a dirty setup. Even if I were The Judge, I would never kill you, unless you and I were the last two alive... you've been the one thing I could count on for a glimmer of hope.Elohcin wrote:Oh, sophie....I was so gullable. SOOOO gullable. Please forgive me. Doesn't mean I still don't have my eye on you. But.....you are not on the top of my list. Niju today, LC tomorrow before he can kill me for learning the truth.
Hey now! I've glimmered a little too, haven't I?Long Con wrote:Elohcin, you're a sweet lady. Thanks for believing in me. I really did appreciate your support during Bass' genius setup move, and I don't feel like that support was mistaken, since it WAS a dirty setup. Even if I were The Judge, I would never kill you, unless you and I were the last two alive... you've been the one thing I could count on for a glimmer of hope.Elohcin wrote:Oh, sophie....I was so gullable. SOOOO gullable. Please forgive me. Doesn't mean I still don't have my eye on you. But.....you are not on the top of my list. Niju today, LC tomorrow before he can kill me for learning the truth.
Epignosis wrote:Bitch, my identity is my identity theft protection!