The Flash: Battle for the Gem Cities (Day 12)

#1651

I don't want to go for low posters, either. I was just wondering why DH picked one out as the place to start his hunt.

#1652

I don't recognize half the players in the lynch poll. Man how the heck long have I been gone?!

(Just a drive-by hello from your friendly neighborhood mongoose)

#1653

It's been a very busy day. What the heck is going on with the names on the poll, the reverse stuff and all of that? Can someone explain it?

I don't know what to think of all of this. I still want to know if you all think this is the doing of a civvie or a baddie.

After reading what Roxy said about Aces and realizing it's not forbidden, I think I should tell you that I had BTSC with Sonjei. He answered one question about his suspicions by saying he posted his reads on the thread. Since the reads were before Bass' lynch, I asked what about after the lynch, but he stopped replying from there on. I even wrote that I'm going to think he's bad if he doesn't reply, and it didn't help. Then, I went to the Championship game where TH is playing, and I saw he's barely there as well, so I figured there's nothing much I can learn from this. I don't know if it matters to anyone, but I thought I'd share.

So did everyone just decide SD is legit after what happened? It's like all the suspicions that were there 48 hours ago have gone away.
To be honest, I have no idea who to vote for this day. Sadly, we have nothing concrete.

#1654

I have reason to believe we've been Flashpoint Paradoxed.

#1655

What does that mean?

#1656

FZ. wrote:It's been a very busy day. What the heck is going on with the names on the poll, the reverse stuff and all of that? Can someone explain it?

I don't know what to think of all of this. I still want to know if you all think this is the doing of a civvie or a baddie

I was wondering if it had something to do with Prof. Zoom who looks and reminds me of the Reverse Flash. What do you think about that FZ?

Thanks for sharing inre: Soneji

DH - Flashpoint Paradox? Can you explainit in a way that I could understand?

#1657

Whoa. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justice_Le ... nt_Paradox

That's a crazy storyline.

#1658

Roxy wrote:
FZ. wrote:It's been a very busy day. What the heck is going on with the names on the poll, the reverse stuff and all of that? Can someone explain it?

I don't know what to think of all of this. I still want to know if you all think this is the doing of a civvie or a baddie

I was wondering if it had something to do with Prof. Zoom who looks and reminds me of the Reverse Flash. What do you think about that FZ?

Thanks for sharing inre: Soneji

DH - Flashpoint Paradox? Can you explainit in a way that I could understand?

If it's Zoom related, did it have something to do with SD, or was it just a coincidence? The thing is, if it's Zoom, I'd expect something really bad to happen. But this does look like something that could be connected to the R-flash.
I keep wondering what it is that the Trickster can do. This is like a funny result, so maybe it has something to do with him. No idea.

Long Con wrote:Whoa. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justice_Le ... nt_Paradox

That's a crazy storyline.

You can say that again. But how does it relate to what just happened?

#1659

I actually feel a lot better about how Roxy played yesterday now knowing that her BTSC buddy was Aces. If Roxy wanted to she could have hopped on the Ace wagon early and fueled it further with her story about BTSC but yet she showed restraint. Roxy earned a few civvie points in my book for that move.

What does everyone think of BF atm? I feel like he's been coming in here and voting for Bullzeye repeatedly and not contributing much other than that, other than to chastise us for who we've lynched be they bad or good. I'm interested in hearing Llama's opinion of BF.

#1660

Turnip Head wrote:I actually feel a lot better about how Roxy played yesterday now knowing that her BTSC buddy was Aces. If Roxy wanted to she could have hopped on the Ace wagon early and fueled it further with her story about BTSC but yet she showed restraint. Roxy earned a few civvie points in my book for that move.

What does everyone think of BF atm? I feel like he's been coming in here and voting for Bullzeye repeatedly and not contributing much other than that, other than to chastise us for who we've lynched be they bad or good. I'm interested in hearing Llama's opinion of BF.

He did say he was voting for someone else this day. I think it's DH

#1661

By the way, how's the other game going? I stopped following because it's crazy. It's like those people have no life whatsoever....and I consider myself obsessed with mafia

#1662

FZ. wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:I actually feel a lot better about how Roxy played yesterday now knowing that her BTSC buddy was Aces. If Roxy wanted to she could have hopped on the Ace wagon early and fueled it further with her story about BTSC but yet she showed restraint. Roxy earned a few civvie points in my book for that move.

What does everyone think of BF atm? I feel like he's been coming in here and voting for Bullzeye repeatedly and not contributing much other than that, other than to chastise us for who we've lynched be they bad or good. I'm interested in hearing Llama's opinion of BF.
He did say he was voting for someone else this day. I think it's DH

Oh okay thanks I missed that. I'm feeling pretty good about DH, what do you think of him?

#1663

And I PM'ed you about the OT so as to not derail this thread

#1664

Here is the Wiki article as well, from the original comics.

FZ, I don't understand what happened either, there's nothing I can tell you. It appears that Aces was going to be lynched, but instead the day reset, with this weird alternate stuff going on. I can see the similarity to the Flashpoint thing. I wonder, if we restore the timeline, will Llama be dead again?

I think it will likely just be a normal lynch, and then Night 3 and Day 4 and so on normally. And I don't think Llama will die, I think it's more likely that someone resurrected the obvious choice somehow.

Metalmarsh: I saw in Roxy's quote when you said "maybe Llama will get rezzed too" in reference to the "dark irony" of the similarity to Llama's X-Men game. I can't believe it actually happened! Just wonderful. I wonder if someone, for the sake of continued monitoring, could share what fate befell Llama next in X-Men?

As for the whole Roxy-Aces situation, and the suspicions of DH, Bullzeye, Metalmarsh, S~V~S, I'm a little at a loss. I've read it all once only, and I think it will take another read-through to get my bearings on the current scene. Wow, and I just looked, and the lynch ends in 5 hours. I guess it seems very sudden to me since I was not around for a good chunk of Reverse-Day-3.

Ok, I'll try to relate how I feel about people. BF, I have a bit of suspicion about, but I'm waiting to see if a certain thing happens regarding him. I'm seeing a couple of possible Civ-BTSC connections between some people, but obviously I don't want to share who... and I might be getting vibes from map-BTSC and confusing it. Roxy is pinging me a little bit, but I feel like she has had some bold play and I don't know if a baddie Roxy would act that way.

I really don't know what to think of the Aces-Roxy map-BTSC thing most of all. There were a lot of reactions to it, and some of those seemed confident that Roxy and Aces were Civ, if I recall correctly. I don't know why, maybe someone can reiterate that point of view. I mean, Aces was going to be lynched, and Roxy was trying to save him, right? I think it's a bit suspicious. I think I saw Aces pulling a little No U on me back there somewhere, which didn't make me feel better about him. I may end up voting for him again, or Roxy.

I feel sort of sympathetic toward Bullzeye, he really has been under suspicion from the get-go, and I never really shared that suspicion. BF and MM are very confident in it though, so

maybe they're right. I just don't have a feel on Bullz yet.

Who else is out there? Timmer, I feel pretty good about, Turnip Head too. DH could be bad.

I realize that I'm a little wishy-washy on some opinions on current events, I really need to do a reread. But the lynch ends too soon, I'm going to my mom's for a BBQ very soon, so the reread will have to wait.

#1665

Just got home. Going to be reading the thread today, YAY!

#1666

Turnip Head wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:I actually feel a lot better about how Roxy played yesterday now knowing that her BTSC buddy was Aces. If Roxy wanted to she could have hopped on the Ace wagon early and fueled it further with her story about BTSC but yet she showed restraint. Roxy earned a few civvie points in my book for that move.

What does everyone think of BF atm? I feel like he's been coming in here and voting for Bullzeye repeatedly and not contributing much other than that, other than to chastise us for who we've lynched be they bad or good. I'm interested in hearing Llama's opinion of BF.
He did say he was voting for someone else this day. I think it's DH
Oh okay thanks I missed that. I'm feeling pretty good about DH, what do you think of him?

I'm feeling okay about DH, but there are moments that I wonder if he's just fooling me.

Long Con wrote:Here is the Wiki article as well, from the original comics.

FZ, I don't understand what happened either, there's nothing I can tell you. It appears that Aces was going to be lynched, but instead the day reset, with this weird alternate stuff going on. I can see the similarity to the Flashpoint thing. I wonder, if we restore the timeline, will Llama be dead again? I think it will likely just be a normal lynch, and then Night 3 and Day 4 and so on normally. And I don't think Llama will die, I think it's more likely that someone resurrected the obvious choice somehow.

Metalmarsh: I saw in Roxy's quote when you said "maybe Llama will get rezzed too" in reference to the "dark irony" of the similarity to Llama's X-Men game. I can't believe it actually happened! Just wonderful. I wonder if someone, for the sake of continued monitoring, could share what fate befell Llama next in X-Men?

As for the whole Roxy-Aces situation, and the suspicions of DH, Bullzeye, Metalmarsh, S~V~S, I'm a little at a loss. I've read it all once only, and I think it will take another read-through to get my bearings on the current scene. Wow, and I just looked, and the lynch ends in 5 hours. I guess it seems very sudden to me since I was not around for a good chunk of Reverse-Day-3.

Ok, I'll try to relate how I feel about people. BF, I have a bit of suspicion about, but I'm waiting to see if a certain thing happens regarding him. I'm seeing a couple of possible Civ-BTSC connections between some people, but obviously I don't want to share who... and I might be getting vibes from map-BTSC and confusing it. Roxy is pinging me a little bit, but I feel like she has had some bold play and I don't know if a baddie Roxy would act that way.

I really don't know what to think of the Aces-Roxy map-BTSC thing most of all. There were a lot of reactions to it, and some of those seemed confident that Roxy and Aces were Civ, if I recall correctly. I don't know why, maybe someone can reiterate that point of view. I mean, Aces was going to be lynched, and Roxy was trying to save him, right? I think it's a bit suspicious. I think I saw Aces pulling a little No U on me back there somewhere, which didn't make me feel better about him. I may end up voting for him again, or Roxy.

I feel sort of sympathetic toward Bullzeye, he really has been under suspicion from the get-go, and I never really shared that suspicion. BF and MM are very confident in it though, so maybe they're right. I just don't have a feel on Bullz yet.

Who else is out there? Timmer, I feel pretty good about, Turnip Head too. DH could be bad.

I realize that I'm a little wishy-washy on some opinions on current events, I really need to do a reread. But the lynch ends too soon, I'm going to my mom's for a BBQ very soon, so the reread will have to wait.

I was under the impression that it was SD that was going to be lynched, not Aces. Are you sure about that? By the way, you didn't say how you feel about her.

Did you notice that llama isn't posting anything? Is there a reason for that.
I think I share most of your opinions on the people you mentioned.
I didn't think Bullz was bad either, and I hope he doesn't take it the wrong way, but I feel that when I am bad, I let real life become an issue more than I do when I'm a civ. I don't do it on purpose, but it's like I allow myself to be less active because I'm busy, whereas when I'm a civ, I can't help myself and I am engaged no matter what. I don't know if that's the case with him, but it seems as though him not feeling well has made him absent. I hope it's just that.

By the way, can't you give BR your phone for a few minutes so she can come on and say something. It's getting very hard to decide who is scum when at least 5 players are non existent

#1667

I see my husband was playing online when we got home from the banquet. I totally passed out instead.

I like DH's theory on Made being a missing killer, but that only works if he's right about the kill. i guess I just assumed the baddies killer, I don't know a whole lot about this universe. I just got introduced to Flash in the new tv series.

I'm going to be putting my vote there for now. I'm not sure if I'll be home in time and we were supposed to leave 5 mins ago.

I'm going to think more on the Roxt/DH thing while I'm out.

Linki: I'm just saying something quick now FZ.

#1668

Thanks BR, I appreciate you trying.

Does anyone know who was supposed to be lynched had the day not ended?

Where is everyone? Is there another game keeping everyone away?

#1669

Daisy had a few more votes than Aces, iirc.

#1670

FZ. wrote: I didn't think Bullz was bad either, and I hope he doesn't take it the wrong way, but I feel that when I am bad, I let real life become an issue more than I do when I'm a civ. I don't do it on purpose, but it's like I allow myself to be less active because I'm busy, whereas when I'm a civ, I can't help myself and I am engaged no matter what. I don't know if that's the case with him, but it seems as though him not feeling well has made him absent. I hope it's just that.

Catching up but wanted to respond to this first. I'm always far more engaged as a baddie, I don't really like being civ and would rarely be one if I had the choice. That's not to say it ruins games or anything, some of my favourite roles have been civ ones, and some of my favourite games have been where I was a civ, but I find it harder to get into a game if I'm not bad or at least if I don't have a team of some kind. I'm more likely to allow myself to be inactive as a civ tbh. Being ill during the week did make me a bit absent but as I've said I'm generally feeling burnt out by this game and being constantly on the defense. I don't particularly want to die, especially not at night, but at this point I also really want to see certain people proved wrong about me - more than I want anything else in this game. I'm sick of defending basically and don't want to do it any more.

#1671

I thought I knew what had happened during the last lynch right when it did, but it quickly became clear that I was incorrect. So I have no idea who did it, but it wasn't me. And the way the host wrote it makes it pretty clear that it is focused on Aces rather than me. I even talked to him about it just to be sure he realized the votes piled on me at the end. I don't know what happened but it was not because of me.

#1672

Bullz, for what it's worth, I think most people here don't necessarily view you as a baddie, so I wouldn't worry.

I agree that a lot of what I think about BF is riding on what llama says about him, so I hope he stops by soon, because I'm really tired and want to go to sleep. I don't really get BF's vote, nor do I get MM.

Between Roxy and Aces , I think I'd rather go for Aces, but I'm not convinced he's bad either.

#1673

I'm quite busy at work today, I've been skimming as best I can, but I'm not really available to post a ton.

Here's the thing that bugs me about DH's Made suspicion today.

If you look back to DH's first post about Made today, it mentions that DH thought that Made was off the poll. Once others pointed out that he was actually there, DH ran with that knowledge, but I cannot get over that

a) there are clearly multiple players missing, not just Made. Even if you can't remember all of them, there are enough names on the poll who aren't posting that I find it hard to believe DH missed it and thought it was only Made.

b) it's a comment about a player DH thought was off of the poll. That means he was bringing up stuff that he thought would have no bearing on today's lynch. With all of the chaos yesterday, cases against Daisy, Roxy, Aces, older cases still against Bullz, some against SVS (his own, that one), BF, DH brings up a point about someone who he thought wasn't even relevant to today.

c) I won't go check, but I believe there is a protecting role, and likely a blocking role. Whether someone kills on odd nights or even nights, they'd have only had one chance so far to kill since instead of a night 3 we got day 3.1. So I don't even see how there is enough evidence yet about missed kills for Made to be a suspect anyway.

and lastly, d) I find it is more often baddies than goodies who bring up lynching low posters/absent players.

All of this means I am not liking DH's output today.

#1674

FZ. wrote:Bullz, for what it's worth, I think most people here don't necessarily view you as a baddie, so I wouldn't worry.

I agree that a lot of what I think about BF is riding on what llama says about him, so I hope he stops by soon, because I'm really tired and want to go to sleep. I don't really get BF's vote, nor do I get MM.

Between Roxy and Aces , I think I'd rather go for Aces, but I'm not convinced he's bad either.

I think if BF were a detective, I'd be dead. I don't think he's on team Llama.

#1675

Interesting points about DH, timmer-prime. I don't think it's DH's baddie-MO to go after low posters, I think he's more conniving than that when he's bad, but I'd like to know why he singled Made out from the other people that aren't playing.

I gave the tildes a once-over looking for things like "reverse" "stop" "mirror" and couldn't really find anything. Then it occurred to look for "alternate" so I'ma do that now and also "lightning strike".

Also Zoom's role has a bunch of ??????'s after the tildes and no other role has that, so there may be secret secrets. Also why are there two arch-villains named Zoom

#1676

timmer wrote:I'm quite busy at work today, I've been skimming as best I can, but I'm not really available to post a ton.

Here's the thing that bugs me about DH's Made suspicion today.

If you look back to DH's first post about Made today, it mentions that DH thought that Made was off the poll. Once others pointed out that he was actually there, DH ran with that knowledge, but I cannot get over that

a) there are clearly multiple players missing, not just Made. Even if you can't remember all of them, there are enough names on the poll who aren't posting that I find it hard to believe DH missed it and thought it was only Made.

b) it's a comment about a player DH thought was off of the poll. That means he was bringing up stuff that he thought would have no bearing on today's lynch. With all of the chaos yesterday, cases against Daisy, Roxy, Aces, older cases still against Bullz, some against SVS (his own, that one), BF, DH brings up a point about someone who he thought wasn't even relevant to today.

c) I won't go check, but I believe there is a protecting role, and likely a blocking role. Whether someone kills on odd nights or even nights, they'd have only had one chance so far to kill since instead of a night 3 we got day 3.1. So I don't even see how there is enough evidence yet about missed kills for Made to be a suspect anyway.

and lastly, d) I find it is more often baddies than goodies who bring up lynching low posters/absent players.

All of this means I am not liking DH's output today.

I don't know his reasons, and maybe you do have a point there, but to your last point, I just want to say that as a civ, I'm tempted to vote for the low posters because it's getting on my nerves. If you don't want to play, don't join. I'm sick of players doing that....Had to get it off my chest. That said, I know low posters can easily be civvies and lynching them does nothing for the civvie cause. Still, I sometimes feel like I'd rather give a potential baddie, who's trying to be here and post, the benefit of the doubt, and lynch a low poster who's not even trying

#1677

Abra Kadabra – He is a stage magician who uses futuristic technology to put on the greatest show on Earth. As such, he has a bevy of powers at his disposal. Once each, he can: ~~s~~~~~, ~~~~~-s~~~~~, r~~~ ~~~~~, ~~~~r s~~~~, s~~~~~~, s~r~~~~ ~ ~~~~, s~r~~~~ ~ ~~~~~, ~r r~s~rr~~~ ~~~~~~r ~~~~~r.

Abra Kadabra – He is a stage magician who uses futuristic technology to put on the greatest show on Earth. As such, he has a bevy of powers at his disposal. Once each, he can: ~~s~~~~~, ~~~~~-s~~~~~, r~~~ ~~~~~, ~~~~r s~~~~, s~~~~~~, survive a kill, survive a lynch, or resurrect another player.

#1678

Bullzeye wrote:
FZ. wrote:Bullz, for what it's worth, I think most people here don't necessarily view you as a baddie, so I wouldn't worry.

I agree that a lot of what I think about BF is riding on what llama says about him, so I hope he stops by soon, because I'm really tired and want to go to sleep. I don't really get BF's vote, nor do I get MM.

Between Roxy and Aces , I think I'd rather go for Aces, but I'm not convinced he's bad either.
I think if BF were a detective, I'd be dead. I don't think he's on team Llama.

I thought about it, but that would make it very obvious that he is a detective. Do we always learn who was responsible for a NK?

Turnip Head wrote:Interesting points about DH, timmer-prime. I don't think it's DH's baddie-MO to go after low posters, I think he's more conniving than that when he's bad, but I'd like to know why he singled Made out from the other people that aren't playing.

I gave the tildes a once-over looking for things like "reverse" "stop" "mirror" and couldn't really find anything. Then it occurred to look for "alternate" so I'ma do that now and also "lightning strike".

Also Zoom's role has a bunch of ??????'s after the tildes and no other role has that, so there may be secret secrets. Also why are there two arch-villains named Zoom

I was trying to do the same thing (without the mirror) and came up with nothing. There's also Secret secrets, and maybe Plunder who's from the mirror universe?

linki: If it's him, it gives us nothing

#1679

FZ. wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
FZ. wrote:Bullz, for what it's worth, I think most people here don't necessarily view you as a baddie, so I wouldn't worry.

I agree that a lot of what I think about BF is riding on what llama says about him, so I hope he stops by soon, because I'm really tired and want to go to sleep. I don't really get BF's vote, nor do I get MM.

Between Roxy and Aces , I think I'd rather go for Aces, but I'm not convinced he's bad either.
I think if BF were a detective, I'd be dead. I don't think he's on team Llama.
I thought about it, but that would make it very obvious that he is a detective. Do we always learn who was responsible for a NK?

As far as I know we do. BF is really determined to see me dead, and seemed really smug at the thought of the ninja killing me N1. I can't imagine he'd have passed up on that opportunity. It would be better for him too tbh, if I'm lynched he and MM lose their credibility.

#1680

You know, I was willing to drop my suspicion of Bullz for a while. He sounded authentic in the wake of my lynch. But the constant whining about an impending NK is starting to feel forced. I'm not quite sure what to make of it, but it is starting to swing me back in the "suspicious of Bullz" direction.

#1681

thellama73 wrote:You know, I was willing to drop my suspicion of Bullz for a while. He sounded authentic in the wake of my lynch. But the constant whining about an impending NK is starting to feel forced. I'm not quite sure what to make of it, but it is starting to swing me back in the "suspicious of Bullz" direction.

What do you think of BF?

#1682

Turnip Head wrote:
Abra Kadabra – He is a stage magician who uses futuristic technology to put on the greatest show on Earth. As such, he has a bevy of powers at his disposal. Once each, he can: ~~s~~~~~, ~~~~~-s~~~~~, r~~~ ~~~~~, ~~~~r s~~~~, s~~~~~~, s~r~~~~ ~ ~~~~, s~r~~~~ ~ ~~~~~, ~r r~s~rr~~~ ~~~~~~r ~~~~~r.
Abra Kadabra – He is a stage magician who uses futuristic technology to put on the greatest show on Earth. As such, he has a bevy of powers at his disposal. Once each, he can: ~~s~~~~~, ~~~~~-s~~~~~, r~~~ ~~~~~, ~~~~r s~~~~, s~~~~~~, survive a kill, survive a lynch, or resurrect another player.

I'm pretty sure there is also "insanify", "lynch switch", "role check" (or block), "power steal", "silence".

#1683

thellama73 wrote:You know, I was willing to drop my suspicion of Bullz for a while. He sounded authentic in the wake of my lynch. But the constant whining about an impending NK is starting to feel forced. I'm not quite sure what to make of it, but it is starting to swing me back in the "suspicious of Bullz" direction.

Am I talking about an impending NK? No. I'm talking about one that would have happened in a certain circumstance. Don't twist my words.

#1684

timmer wrote:I'm quite busy at work today, I've been skimming as best I can, but I'm not really available to post a ton.

Here's the thing that bugs me about DH's Made suspicion today.

If you look back to DH's first post about Made today, it mentions that DH thought that Made was off the poll. Once others pointed out that he was actually there, DH ran with that knowledge, but I cannot get over that

a) there are clearly multiple players missing, not just Made. Even if you can't remember all of them, there are enough names on the poll who aren't posting that I find it hard to believe DH missed it and thought it was only Made.

b) it's a comment about a player DH thought was off of the poll. That means he was bringing up stuff that he thought would have no bearing on today's lynch. With all of the chaos yesterday, cases against Daisy, Roxy, Aces, older cases still against Bullz, some against SVS (his own, that one), BF, DH brings up a point about someone who he thought wasn't even relevant to today.

c) I won't go check, but I believe there is a protecting role, and likely a blocking role. Whether someone kills on odd nights or even nights, they'd have only had one chance so far to kill since instead of a night 3 we got day 3.1. So I don't even see how there is enough evidence yet about missed kills for Made to be a suspect anyway.

and lastly, d) I find it is more often baddies than goodies who bring up lynching low posters/absent players.

All of this means I am not liking DH's output today.

#1685

What about Sophie? Bass?

#1686

DharmaHelper wrote:

Really? I mean, its not exactly 100% concrete, but thats not the reply I was expecting, man.

#1687

rabbit8 wrote:Just got home. Going to be reading the thread today, YAY!

Input would be nice! What do you think of DH? I need help there. And related, what do you think of low posters? Any pings there?

#1688

timmer wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Really? I mean, its not exactly 100% concrete, but thats not the reply I was expecting, man.

What were you expecting? Did it make you feel better or worse about him?

#1689

DharmaHelper wrote:
timmer wrote:I'm quite busy at work today, I've been skimming as best I can, but I'm not really available to post a ton.

Here's the thing that bugs me about DH's Made suspicion today.

If you look back to DH's first post about Made today, it mentions that DH thought that Made was off the poll. Once others pointed out that he was actually there, DH ran with that knowledge, but I cannot get over that

a) there are clearly multiple players missing, not just Made. Even if you can't remember all of them, there are enough names on the poll who aren't posting that I find it hard to believe DH missed it and thought it was only Made.

I didn't think it was only Made, I just had Made on the mind.

b) it's a comment about a player DH thought was off of the poll. That means he was bringing up stuff that he thought would have no bearing on today's lynch. With all of the chaos yesterday, cases against Daisy, Roxy, Aces, older cases still against Bullz, some against SVS (his own, that one), BF, DH brings up a point about someone who he thought wasn't even relevant to today.

We established Made was on the poll before I brought up anything.

c) I won't go check, but I believe there is a protecting role, and likely a blocking role. Whether someone kills on odd nights or even nights, they'd have only had one chance so far to kill since instead of a night 3 we got day 3.1. So I don't even see how there is enough evidence yet about missed kills for Made to be a suspect anyway.

This is actually a valid point. I'm not saying my Made suspicion is bulletproof, clearly it is not. I would have voted for him already if I was 100% certain.

and lastly, d) I find it is more often baddies than goodies who bring up lynching low posters/absent players.

Difficult to defend against this, but I can assure you I almost always bring up lynching low/absent players regardless of alignment.

All of this means I am not liking DH's output today.

#1690

There's your response Timmer.

To whomever asked: Flashpoint Paradox comment was meant to postulate that we are not in our normal timeline

#1691

Timmer what do you think of BF?

#1692

DharmaHelper wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:DH what do you think of Roxy?
I don't feel great about her waiting so long on the Aces thing.
Thanks. Who are you thinking about voting today?
I'm mulling some things over. If Made were on the poll I might have voted for him.

Thanks for the reply, DH, but I think you are twisting things a bit. This^^ is from what I can tell, your first mention of Made today. Thus, it had NOT been established that he was on the poll yet. Right?

#1693

FZ. wrote:
timmer wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Really? I mean, its not exactly 100% concrete, but thats not the reply I was expecting, man.
What were you expecting? Did it make you feel better or worse about him?

I was expecting an actual reply, lol, which he's now given.

#1694

Turnip Head wrote:Timmer what do you think of BF?

Why isn't llama answering this? There's a chance I'm going to vote for BF. His suspicions seem too easy, and have you noticed that he focuses on one player per day? It's like he doesn't need to bother himself with commenting on all the rest because he already has a suspect. In my opinion, that's usually more a baddie tell than a civvie one

#1695

I think I'm just going to vote for BF. I really need to go to sleep, and I can't wait anymore. The only thing keeping me from voting BF is llama, but since he's not answering, I might as well vote and get out of here

#1696

I'm out of here. Falling asleep on my screen. Bye.

#1697

FZ. wrote:I think I'm just going to vote for BF. I really need to go to sleep, and I can't wait anymore. The only thing keeping me from voting BF is llama, but since he's not answering, I might as well vote and get out of here

I agree, I think I brought it up earlier. BF's focus has been much narrower than I would have expected from him this far into the game. I asked for Llama's take but like you said he hasn't provided one yet.

#1698

I meant to quote FZ's other post where she talked about how BF only really discusses one player per lynch.

#1699

FZ. wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:Timmer what do you think of BF?
Why isn't llama answering this? There's a chance I'm going to vote for BF. His suspicions seem too easy, and have you noticed that he focuses on one player per day? It's like he doesn't need to bother himself with commenting on all the rest because he already has a suspect. In my opinion, that's usually more a baddie tell than a civvie one

I just did a complete reread of BF.

About the only really ping-y thing i could see was his "wtf?" reaction to how the Bass 1.0 lynch went down. For the rest, I've got an alignment in mind for him, and he seems to be pursuing leads as he sees them. I'm not sure I could say he's bad, but I don't think he's an Old Rogue, either. I won't vote for him, but won't really be going out of my way to defend him, if that makes sense?

#1700

Bullzeye wrote:
thellama73 wrote:You know, I was willing to drop my suspicion of Bullz for a while. He sounded authentic in the wake of my lynch. But the constant whining about an impending NK is starting to feel forced. I'm not quite sure what to make of it, but it is starting to swing me back in the "suspicious of Bullz" direction.
Am I talking about an impending NK? No. I'm talking about one that would have happened in a certain circumstance. Don't twist my words.

I am hunting scum. what are you doing?

srsly, rvs, sus(s)

FZ. wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:Timmer what do you think of BF?
Why isn't llama answering this? There's a chance I'm going to vote for BF. His suspicions seem too easy, and have you noticed that he focuses on one player per day? It's like he doesn't need to bother himself with commenting on all the rest because he already has a suspect. In my opinion, that's usually more a baddie tell than a civvie one

BF's defense of me was odd and unexpected, but I do not read him as bad. I don't think baddies stick their necks out like that.

Can Someone Finally Die?